Paul Dunmall, Solo pipes, Cheltenham Jazz Fest 1.05.09

[lahirijl]

...just a humble "thank you" for posting... stunning... very sad to see so much ignorant, negative comments below.... sympomatic of our stupid species and its disfunctional relationship to music and its potential..........still......­..........!.

[madpipertn]

well it kinda has a nice sound to it when he's playing slowly, but when it sounds like he's trying to play while having seizures....eh... so not my cup of tea. That's kind of what I sound like when I'm full on plastered and trying to play.

[markh79sax]

@IC2720 I don't understand how you could reach that conclusion from seeing this- maybe you only heard the first 30 seconds?? Even so... have a look at one of the many clips of him playing the saxophone and see if that alters your opinion of him.

[IC2720]

I reach the conclusion by the fact that I play the pipes, smallpipes and great highland. This ain't piping, it's messing about. He's a good sax player and better off staying with that instrument. Cheers.

[brassexpert]

sound like an electric guitar?

[KeepDeltaMyDelta]

I believe this is called noise.

[9Geoff9]

I believe this is borderline music.

[fireislandcats]

Nice.

I am sometimes amazed by what Youtube thinks is related: "Chubby Personal Trainer" "Stuffed on April 23rd 2009" - I dont understand the logic.

[PSearPianist]

Thank you for uploading. I appreciate very much clips from events such as this which I would never be able to get to, and which would be unlikely to get airtime on Briitish national TV

[dbadagna]

I believe these are called "border pipes."