Added: 2 years ago
From: tribecafilm
Views: 58,123
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (213)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • el área y el territorio ha sido y será siempre de Palestina ,lo que ha hecho Israel se llama invasión . Verdaderos judios cobardes !!!respaldados  con la politica pero no les quedará mucho y Palestina ganará eso es una verdad afirmada .

  • You would judge them by a sparkly t-shirt or a microwave? these girls are considered very well off in palestine. There are much much much worst cases among them! They have no money their father is dead and everyday they live in fear of being shot by the israelis. In what twisted universe can you call this safety? Your comment proves you are very ignorant and know nothing about the subject so please do not judge them or make false statements!

  • I disagree, bklynz1. These kids live a tough life, but no different then the average disadvantaged american family in the city, living off food stamps, etc. The story itself didn't inspire, or show me something new. I don't see anywhere where the Israeli's were causing their problems, either. How did the father die? We don't know. All we can do is assume, and probably fit that to our own opinions on what we think happened. All in all, its an average story that really says nothing of substance.

  • I FEEL SORRY THAT U CANNOT UNDERSTAND SUBTLETY AND THAT'S WHY MY COMMENT IS IN CAPS LOCK, MAYBE U WILL UNDERSTAND THAT. haha!

    THIS STORY IS GENTLY EXPLORING THE PALESTINIAN TRAGEDY..IF U KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT IT U WOULD UNDERSTAND. please follow shofali's advice (it is a few comments below mine) and watch some DOCUMENTARIES, MAYBE READ A FEW AWARD-WINNING BOOKS like the one by Edward Said? hope the caps lock was good enough for your brain

  • Re your comment, the Palestinian tragedy - how is that unique - really?

    Considering every single country on earth has its own share of problems almost **identical to a T** to the ones in the aforementioned video. Is this profound? No, not really. Subtle? Hardly that, either. The CAPS LOCK is even ironic, considering Afridi doesn't understand how this entire movie could have been duplicated to the letter just replacing the actors and the scene with that of any other city of the world.

  • I never denied that this situation (girl losing her father, living in poverty, widowed wife, etc) couldn't have been "duplicated"..but the reason we all find it so subtle is because the situation seems normal, even to the end. But the Palestinian situation is unique in so many ways--you couldn't fathom the potency of this film unless you knew the full background. And clearly u don't

  • In its simplicity, the film gently shows how the Palestinians (I shouldn't pluralize: 1 family, i should say) is coping. Again, you wouldn't realize how intense their pain is unless you knew the background. Please watch that documentary that Shofali recommended in the comments. If only u knew what the Zionists have inflicted upon the M. East as a whole, and Palestine in particular. Just do it, before replying. Research, watch documentaries, DO something to educate yourself before replying.

  • Last point, and I'll shut up, because after all, this is Youtube we are not face-to-face or writing essays here: just because (as you say--though I disagree) this "movie could be duplicated...with that of any other city of the world" does NOT make the Palestinian situation any less important or negate it. It does not JUSTIFY what the Israelis have done. And I sincerely hope you, as I keep repeating because it will make all the difference in the world, truly educate yourself on the subject.

  • There are disadvantaged poor of every race, creed, and nationality - everywhere!, these arabs living on the outskirts of Israel are no different. They just have more support for their vocal cause in the UN, because their proponents (the other arab nations) have money *cough* I mean - oil.

  • Sorry dude, you fail. U didn't watch the thing I advised you to, ur comments show that. You can make up conspiracy theories till the cows come home, or twist facts, but the fact remains that: 1. Contrary to what your comment suggests, the UN barely takes action or issue with the situation. 2.Food supplies, charity aid, etc., are RARELY delivered to the Palestinians due to the Israeli blockade (look it up). 3.Palestinians have had every single human right listed by the UN denied.

  • "No different than the average disadvantaged american family" That is the whole subtlety of the film. You obviously don't have much background knowledge to go by, otherwise you would not judge the Palestinians only by this video. Does the average poor American get tortured, taken away randomly and tortured to death? Get denied running water for WEEKS at a tiime? Get bombs flying in their neighbourhood whenever the enemy feels like it? Get his/her house mowed down by tanks?

  • Fighting someone from stealing your land is the only case.

  • @moonstar i know.. but it's a total different meaning in egyption language. Anyway, yeah and i agee with @asdfghj56785678

  • But the origins come from the Kamites (ancient Egyptians).

  • Any person who sees this video, and starts making comments because the knowledge you have is from one source, a local t.v channel or a radio station, just do yourself a favor and give it ten minutes to seriously know sth about the case in Palestine/Israel from other sources online rather than what the media in your country feed you, or watch any of those two documentaries: "Occupation 101" or "Iron Wall" and then you can understand this video or any other comment or link.

  • the ending got to me. curse the state of israel for this pain they brought on my fathers land. they are a plague to the middle east. palestine has suffered from this illegitimate state for too long.

  • palestine is an illegitimate state. in the whole history there was never a independant country called palestine. but there was israel.

  • By someone else's law. By someone else's rules. What right did the British have to impose this set of laws upon the region? None. What right did the zionists have to massacre entire villages within months of arrival? None, but they covered it up and got away with it.

  • By the way, it's not like it was desert land with nobody living there. They had one leader. The land was cultivated by them. They had a system of government. They had villages, towns, politics, industry, families, everything.

  • I saw you youtube channel. Wow, how can you be so hard on Palestinians, when so many of your Gay/Jewish/Israeli colleagues, speak out against the Human Rights abuses, the Israeli State commits against innocent Palestinians. What kind of solidarity are you into? For argument sake. technically Kosovo shouldn't be a country but, it is now. East Timour, is another example. Nationhood is not determined by the past, it changes with time.

  • Because he/she has a double standard! And probably doesn't find Palestinians human enough to apply to the "human rights" category. Haha!

  • did you join youtube yesterday to tell me this? and in the whole history there has never been a independent democratic nation called israel? why? because they are the most dependent country in the world. nations are an invention, nothing but lines on maps. the area and territory has been palestine since before AD.

    maybe we should send you gays to an island.

  • she is lying to get some coins

  • haahahah ههههههههههه

    سبحان الله

  • so fake .. and amateur ,nothig s touching .begging & laying not a smart way to do so ...blek

  • haha the cake got pwnt

  • and your (pwnt) just got pwned check your speeling next time

  • Haha spelling, what a joke.

  • wut is this guy saying christian words?? know tha history oan origin before quoting that and also wut does it matter? there's a message being said in that short film so comment on that.

    dat story made me sad n i also thought that gunshot meant they were gonna die thx heavens they didn't or else dat woulda made me REALLY sad -_-

  • Too deep!

  • :'[

  • God, that's so sad! That was in Palestine, right? Half the time, I thought they were going to die!

  • omg..it is so sad...hay be ramalla right?! i like it. amazing :)

  • only heart

  • Whew, I thought they were going to get blown up...glad it worked out.

  • brought tears!!! dying to see single day of my life when i hear no violence, see no orphans,widows n the day when we truly learn to be humans . . . Allah bless this planet with peace for all the humans of different beliefs. Amen!!

  • @nilofar1188malik lmao... you pray to allah but use christian words such as amen?

  • "christian words"?...LOL

  • @hdeeplive lol yea ill admit i felt a bit stupider after i typed that out...

    I figure "amen" is a christian word... dunno what it meants but u always hear it after grace and shit

    fuk it, fuk religeon, bunch of idiots ;)

  • yeah you are right....everyone is fighting cuz of that one reason

  • amen is also an islamic word fyi

  • @comot17, Amen came fro the Kamites (ancient Egyptians). Amen-Ra

  • my tears are falling ya allah help all muslims ya allah !!

    everyone ALLAHU AKBAR!!

  • excuse me if you grew up in an environment getting bombed day in and day out, for decades on end, and NOBODY helps it stop guess what?

    you gotta stand up. even if it sounds wrong, it's totally understandable.

    and you know what

    look up the Israeli "new age" historians who don't cover up everything. read up on the subject. i have. i took it as a uni subject!

    you'll find out that the massacres started from the beginning, the killings were massive and unforgivable from the start.

  • buenooooooooooo

  • Stealing land is, stealing land.

  • :'( touching <3

  • my tears falling...

  • AMaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaazing really!!

    mashala 3alaik

    waiting to see more from your productions

  • VEEEEERY nice job man!

    GREAT video! No more.

    Congratulations.

  • we know what they've done

    we know what they are doing

    they've even got the friggin UN, keeping quiet about it though they should be charged with war crimes

    what are most people doing about it, to help our Muslim brothers and sisters?

    almost nothing.

  • woow .. that`s very sad .. i teared up .. my heart goes out for all the palestanians who are suffering these things ..

    Allah with you ..

    just have faith all the time ..

  • it ist money from israel?

  • Isreal is just like the Huns they kill everything in their wake, just like barbarians!!!

  • Wow... Beautiful movie!!!! :D

    5* Stars!!! Incredibly touching too... What a surprise at the end... :( Also sad because of what the Israeli bastards have done to the Middle-east ever since they arrived. (RESEARCH IT and LOOK AT THE DIFFERENCE in the middle east since the formation of Israel or whatever shit country u gonna call it...) dont give a thumb down, just RESEARCH FIRST! I HAVE....Ull know the same!!!

  • this video burns me in the inside, my heart is filled with anger and sorrow

  • aww, how sad!! it has a great message of peace and innocence though.

    GREAT video! :]

  • :'( I dont no wat to say....

  • ...:[

  • this is so sad and great and nice...

  • superior potential just great.

  • great ...great...

  • es sorprendente lo q un niño puede hacer por amor a los suyos, el video es bonito y triste a la vez, pero deja una gran leccion de amor

  • this made me so sad. very touching

  • this is sad

  • any country any place children shouldn't wander like that, and the mom, should have searched for them, all she did was worry, the storyline could have been better

  • It happens all the time, even here where I live in Canada Ontario - that is, children wandering and parents not knowing where they are. Its extremely common place. Not to mention, in many other parts of the world, children become more independent at much younger ages - because they have to. The storyline was excellent, and quite touching.

  • In Canada there is an economy where young people can become independent from their parents. But there are places like in the middle east, where there isn't a good economy and grown people can't work either.

  • What are you talking about? I bet you're the one who gave me a thumbs down too. I'm not talking about living on one's own. I'm talking about young children having to do things on their own because their parents either are too busy, or need help.

    Like many children born in the country are better able to take care of themselves as younger ages than most city people, because they NEED to learn responsibilities earlier.

  • Sad...

  • wallah my eyes were filled with tears, i donno how both arabs and israelies and those who support them live knowing that they are responsible for destroying millions of lives all over. thats low

  • @basshus al because of some land

  • very heart warming

  • lol

  • yeah these is reality......

    in war there are no winners only losers.....

  • Does the money in Palestine money really look like that? It looks like the old French Franks.

  • it's Israeli Shekel's

  • very intriguing video...when i saw the synopsis, i thought how selfish "a girl's quest for a birthday cake" but that ending was quite a surprise, as tragic as it was. Though i must agree with another commentator, muslims do not steal or take advantage of charity, otherwise this was superb!

  • This short film was the best ever! Since i was little and learned about Palestinians i felt so sad and wanted to go up to Israel and tell them to stop this crime ! But i know that not all people from Israel are evil but i also know what is being done is for certain an evil crime! Children from both sides how are they to blame! I cant believe its been 5 decades and this nonsense is not over yet !

  • We should all look at it from a human perspective not Arab or Jew or anything. How could any human do this to their fellow human beings? HOPE is all I have for this people! I believe everyone should take a step forward to stom this big crime ! EVERY WAR IS A CRIME ! May God be with all those whom suffer (GOD which is the same as mighty ALLAH)

  • This is so sad :(

    i wonder how the Israelis sleep at night

    knowing tht they're the one causing all the suffrage of the palestinians.

  • Your comments are so uneducated & ignorant they're not even worth a reply.

    -__-

    Seriously, have you ever read up on the subject?

  • @Gameinggames, Israel was invented in 1947.

  • @moonstar7 lol take a history book and look farther back

  • Gameinggames, comments like yours prove that idiocy knows no bounds. Israel as a state=1947.

    I bet a million dollars you have never read up on this & are just commenting to piss people off.

  • Dude, I never said Palestine is a place anymore. It used to be, now it isn't. When did I deny that?

    I was saying that your comments illustrate your lack of knowledge about the subject.

  • How can European Jews claim ownership to what the ancient Hebrews wrote about? I think you need to get history straight.

  • sad

  • it was 2 sad =(

    and I agree with u MrHuStLa117

    and the Palestinians like the film introduce , they live a bad life and they live worse then that

    allah be with them

  • this was sad, but very interesting.

  • aww

  • so sad..

  • OMG that was toooo sad. :(

    Really, I wanna cry.

  • The plight of the Palestinians is a disgraceful black eye on the face of civilization.

  • that movie is great but...it's giving the muslims a bad look...muslims don't steal...don't lie... anddon't "happy birthday"...no offense (the movie is great)

  • Palistine forever!

  • wallahee!

    That is one fucked up ending!!!!

    How fucking sad!!!!!!!!!!!

    Palisine forever

  • ya 7imar, la tikoon nawari....

    el3alam lazim ye3arfoo inah el MUTASAKIFEEN

    mish nawar...

    la tiktoob comments mitil hay

  • gfhj

  • wow that was really omg i can´t write anything it was amazing !!!

  • waw thank u so much for this video. that shows the arab love toward family, even thought their dad passed away they still celebrate his birthday.

  • LMAO

  • that was too sad

  • MONEY IS THE ROOT OF ALL EVIL

  • you're right man

  • thats juz sad

  • that was sweet, it makes we want to cry D:

    Great Video!

  • thats what happening with muslims.

    even desiring the least of the lives.

    afraid of nothing even then by every thing!

    WHAT A VIDEO

    I LOVE IT

  • cool movie, it kept me watching and the story turned out to work great with the picture of it all........nice job.

  • Very tuching story wow Loved it great Job...

  • I couldn't stop crying at the end.

    I don't know why... i simply couldn't...

  • that was so sweet. this deserves like 15 stars, but i can only rate it 5.... i guess 5'll have to do ^^

    ~Snappy~

  • Simply amazing. Touching is an understatement. 5*

  • this is a really good story!! bravo!

  • wooow nice story .....

  • la ilaha ilallah.

  • amazing work nicely presented

  • This video illustrates the grief that DOES result from growing up under occupation.

  • touching video

  • There r so many ways for her to go bad, but she makes it right and 4 a touching reason. God, it just makes me cry!

  • Your video touched my heart.

    I accidentally clicked on it blindly from the front page, and I am glad I did.

    Very nicely done. I sure feel blessed to be where I am today.

  • alh yar7m man fa3la hada film inho jamil wa moatir merci xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

  • i lost of word to comment this video

  • Mar7aba Kifek, ktir shoukran ya sadiki !!!

    this video is beautiful as it´s human

    Rou7i, yalla keep doing well.

  • Comment removed

  • Hands down.. the best clip I ever watched about the cause, and I watched a lot. Thank you for the great quality and a performance next to non. Keep up the good work.

  • so sweet. We forget about the children and how they are processing what is happening. Amazing to see they are still "half full" after everything that has happened.

  • what a lovely sweet video all for her daddy who is in the other world.

  • i just don't understand those Arabs. Palestine is a muslim country and you too are muslims. But, you leave them being tortured by those israelis.

  • @stupiditiestloser It's not that simple. I wish it were. But it's true that Arab countries could be doing more than they are at the moment.

  • we want to help but there is nothing in our hand we cant fight if our goverments is not fighting and they stop evry revolution we make

    simply all of the goverments are controlled by israel and working for them

    hope to be free

  • you are the one who's stupid !! if you don't like it, leave your opinion to your self ! and respect the others who likes it !!

  • u r such idiot who has no felling

  • I LIKE PIE! :D

  • AHH..I am crying..that is so sad and a lot more worst is happening

    damn israel

    May Allah protect them and free all the Muslims

  • cool movie !! greets from:

    pacman . pt . vu

  • Very Interesting, i kept expecting something bad to happen to the family, but i guess something already did. Sad. :(

  • I thought that too

  • verry touching,,an sad.

  • for all Palestinians ,,me and all arabs and moslims and others we are sorry for our silence and ignorance about what the israely forces doing every day please accept our apolgy

  • Who are you to speak for all the arabs and muslims? Speak for yourself and apologize for yourself. I am like many other arabs are doing something and are not silent.

  • i want to cry....

  • I wish kids ran the world.

  • siktir lan

  • very nice

  • Verry Verry Good

  • Is the money the old French Franks?

  • no they are the new isrAeli shekels

  • why the hell would palestinians use old french franks?

  • She asks for shekels? Where'd you see francs?

  • i didnt

  • i was replying to sum who thought they were francs...

  • ISRAEL

  • can u try to be a little less retarded? or is that so hard to do?

  • Agree. Sad story of real life. Touching .

  • That little girl wasnt trying to in her own way keep her father alive...

    This conflict between Palestine & Israel, is bigger than an armies,terrorism whatever you would like to call it....its not a poltical issue , its a HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE...this film is amazing becuase it tries to show the forgotten vicitims of the conflict, in the US we are only shown one part of the story . May there one day be peace for Israelis AND Palestinians.we are all ONE human race...we r not all that different <3

  • That was beautiful. Really touching.

  • I am Palestinain

    I have been through this thousand of times and I really now how to feel like this when you can not buy thing that normal child would like

  • i love this video!

  • wow