Jacky Cheung 張學友 - Ai Ru Ziao Zui 愛如潮水 [LIVE]

[JORE8889]

低key板

[littlerabbit12341]

@JORE8889 低key又如何？？

[JORE8889]

@littlerabbit12341



[blahblahblahsdafd]

@JORE8889

sounds manlier

[Kellicros]

ai ru chao shui

[a782551321]

呢個版本好聽好多

[xMZVKx]

I love his voice. Seriously didn't know his voice is this nice!

[a782551321]

你唔講 我以為佢原唱^^

[lucky2005sky]

小地比較喜歡張信哲唱的版本 !!

感覺像"海水"一樣，"快" .. 但是 .."柔"

[Mega5209]

學友好靚仔!



[4DTHINKER]

就这样张信哲开始情不自禁的县慕嫉妒恨起来。学友太不给面子了。­不过他是香港歌神所以它可以这么做。能压过他看来只有张雨生，孙­楠和刘欢了（个人意见）。

[ks4213]

KERKER



[martini0224]

幹! 真的是唱甚麼都好聽

[hakaihwa]

@martini0224 佢呢個演唱會唱咩歌都好聽過原唱^^

[yuzhiyueshen]

完全无法和张信哲比，尤其高潮部分简直玷污了这首歌。张真不适合­唱高音，没有那种空灵清澈的感觉，更让人失望的是他的演绎显得那­么随意，真的没投入恰当的感情，真是毁了这首经典。

[zk100yyy]

@yuzhiyueshen 这账号是你专门创建来找喷的么？

正不知道该怎么说你？不会飙高音？演绎不够恰当？笑话！找毛病也­要找得靠谱点吧~

[cleanmindedxd]

17个人一定太陶醉而按错了

[hakaihwa]

十卜十卜~

[littlerabbit12341]

好好聽^^

[hevin66531]

他根本是神

[shixin437]

借貼FB

[gulisanxiong]

good

[weijun940813]

是‘且‘还是’请‘?

[ShiML13]

无人可取代的歌神

[shenye100]

张学友有最好的声音， 许多年都没变。

[ozalice96]

Thank you Jacky for giving a new life to an old song.

Your unique style makes me fall in love with this song

all over again! I used to listen to Jeff's version in the past

but now I replace it with yours because you touched me

so much more. Love you, Jacky!

[flchang1]

唱工沒話說　但是另外一唱法　比較沒有原唱的深情呢　把這首歌變成充滿幸福的感覺　歲然是比較偏向爵士的感覺　所以見仁見智了　有的會喜歡　有的會有我這種感覺吧但是我不討厭　可是我絕得沒有原唱的味道

[Kent4w]

難唱=好聽?

諗清楚先啦!

[peebeelaa]

看学友那么随便唱还是好听

[Themydearful]

爲什麽一定要比較呢？ 每個人喜歡的感覺都不一樣， 比較不了啊～ 還是用心享受音樂吧！

[Sky55759]

原唱是張信哲

[Sky55759]

原唱是張信哲

[zuoen1]

@idunnoiii 原唱是谁？

[MrEriccheungxx]

@idunnoiii

我覺得就無話邊個好聽過邊個,2個唱出黎既意境都唔同,無得比較­既!!!

[15918021]

。。。。。Ai Ru Ziao Zui



[okitarebellion]

如果只能用兩個字形容...

歌神！

如果只能用一個字形容...

神！

[barbtylor]

Jacky great !!!!

[video78800]

張學友真是他媽太屌了 比原唱甚至是其他翻唱都好聽幾百倍 就連我這年代不同的都雞皮疙瘩

[video78800]

張學友真是他媽太屌了 比原唱甚至是其他翻唱都好聽幾百倍

[5tvxq2011]

Very different from Jeff's interpretation, yet 2 beautiful beautiful versions.

[ji32ul3a87]

不要讓別的男人見識你的嫵媚

[ffffgvgh145]

迪克牛仔.張信哲.張學友 唱的都很棒

[stgf1080]

KEY 定這麼低.真的很容易唱..不覺的學友有多強.力宏曹格的歌都比­他難唱多了

[tdiddy0930]

@stgf1080 容易唱並不代表唱的好聽~ 容不容易唱不是重點, 有沒有人聽才是. 你不高興聽可以~ 但不要在這裡批評別人的意見, 每個人都可以有自己的想法.

[senti39348]

Which concert is this? I need to find the dvd. =)

[aerinya]

唯一翻唱比原唱還要好的歌者

無他人可比

謂之歌神是也...

[stgf1080]

@aerinya 最好比原唱好.KEY這麼低..差多了.還是張信哲好

[erinmomoyang]

@stgf1080

請理性!

[asd997isshin]

@stgf1080

最好是用KEY的高低來分好不好聽......

講的一點道理都沒有



[w071767]

12個腦殘

[suiteno1]

我想在婚礼上对着女友唱这首歌

[w071767]

學友哥你好帥!

[j26294042]

為神麼會有兩個買醉



[gergay35]

第1次聽時, 還以為這首歌原唱是張學友的

[MrEriccheungxx]

@gergay35 很難相信一位歌神會翻唱別人的歌曲對吧?

但歌神總是能唱出與眾不同的風格,充滿感情...也許是因洗歲月­的磨練吧,呵呵!

[TheCharlielielie]

@gergay35 me too@@

[chukonugame]

學友在這場演唱會翻唱過的歌我最喜歡這首！！很有感染力

[samleics]

拼音打錯左啊，

Ai Ru Chao Shui



[bikellkudos]

過之而無不及。

[siu20051777]

這是什麼演唱會??

[st09094238]

3:20 你該知道 唱成你該豬到 變成台灣國語了= =

[q224222]

嫵(音同五)媚才對......回到正題我投張信哲一票

[539953999]

主歌副歌起伏的很好,

像一開頭的"流眼淚"很深情,再到副歌就很激情,,,

我想問原唱哪裡有比學友唱的好???

[eunice12081]

@539953999 歌是被人享受的不是用來比的

我愛阿哲和張學友~~

[wenweichang]

张学友的音感，节奏感，跟技巧都是无懈可击的。只是可能情绪放错­地方，而且唱现场无法百分百的投入。

诠释一首歌的方式必须能够与旋律和歌词结合在一起，这样才能完整­地呈现想表达的意境。为了表现副歌的激动与澎湃，张学友把整首歌­的节奏加快，导致无法完整的唱出A,B段本该有的柔情，而且副歌­由于过度澎湃，也少了“这样会让我心碎”心痛的感觉，变成只是肺­活量的发泄。唱歌的口气（就像说话的语气）跟这首歌的意境没有完­全吻合，所以说有失水准。

[ccsj1ss]

@wenweichang 真的很像康康和小玲的評論。 真的替台灣歌壇擔心。

[boy6427]

@wenweichang 你好像对（音乐很有知识哦）将厉害你去唱啦！！！笨7

[Yagiang]

張學@wenweichang 你再說些什麼?沒有睡醒嗎?????????

[Jackeyku79]

各花入各眼....

[qiansu2001]

我到是觉得张信哲唱出了那种深夜独自对着电话等待的无力的感觉，­更加动人。。。这首歌曲我投张信哲一票。学友这首歌曲演绎得太雄­壮了。

[leeseungnin]

That is a better job to 张信哲; Fantastic ...

[lugia419]

張學友的fans們

別有反對意見就檢舉垃圾評論

他這首是確確實實比不上原唱

唱那麼快不知道是在趕什麼

感覺全沒了



[jasonw56k]

@lugia419 我很尊重任何人的意見，你不喜歡學友的版本沒問題。但請別說「確­確實實比不上原唱」、「感覺全沒了」。同樣地，這都是個人意見，­不是「確確實實」的事實。

我是先聽了學友唱才聽張信哲的版本，反而覺得學友唱得有力，張信­哲不夠他聲音渾厚且充滿靈魂。他聲裡流露著激動的感情，所以才唱­得快。每個歌手對每一首歌都有不同的見解，不同的演繹。

[pigboy6767]

@lugia419 他只是唱比較R&B的感覺好嗎?難道你聽不出來?

[jkhaer123]

太威了啦----超好聽還有爆發力

[jkhaer123]

太威了啦...推

[28luigi28]

meno male che ci sono i sottotitoli... altrimenti non riuscivo a capire niente... W Jacky.... sei il Gigi D'Alessio dell'estremo oriente!!!!!!

但學友翻唱別人的歌， 卻常令很多原唱者無地自容。(a fiducia!!!!!) :-)

[01Ubermensch]

@28luigi28 Did you use google translate for that? Or are you an Italian-Chinese? Not many Italians that I know of can speak/write mandarin.

[28luigi28]

meno male che ci sono i sottotitoli... altrimenti non riuscivo a capire niente... W Jacky.... sei il Gigi D'Alessio dell'estremo oriente!!!!!!

但學友翻唱別人的歌， 卻常令很多原唱者無地自容。(a fiducia!!!!!) :-)

[Piglet0123456789]

hair makes him way to cool, but i like the original more

[angiebhb]

Jacky sings so well better than the original singer.. he is just amazingly great...

[Suwandi]

Thanks for uploading!!

[jesse13797]

he sucks

[rosanayuyin]

聽了歌神唱的就再也無法聽其他人唱了，超感動的!

[539953999]

聽完學友唱,再走去聽原唱,

覺得學友才是真正的男人,張信哲只是半個男人

[kam420945]

各花入各眼....

[700gsteak]

Jackey Cheung- the master of singing chinese songs!!!!!!!!!!

[HanlinSG]

我喜欢学友，不过我觉得这首歌还真的不如张信哲

[jpctc2008]

这个发型确实不咋地。。

[nnhh4321]

一種感覺 學友給的比女友給的更爽

[monkeyleo333]

越老越帥!

[dds7788369]

張學友比起其他歌手的唱功未必真的厲害很多

歌神這個稱號完完全全是因為他唱歌帶有強烈豐富的感情還有投入感

這是其他好嗓子歌手完全比不上的....

[nethingkorean]

Both Jeff Chang and Jacky Cheung is great. Although I feel that Jeff has better control of the song, Jacky's voice is very powerful. I love both of them.....

[harvey61107]

讚!雞皮疙瘩都出來了

[gn6722hf]

@harvey61107 雞皮疙瘩+1

[minmone0728]

張學友唱的好好聽噢

這首歌元唱和張學友版本

都超好聽的

[acaftermath]

There isnt a song in this world jacky couldn't sing..truly god...

[alex1995119wang]

@kuzhy waaa, u really gonna say this?

[lht002004]

i wonder why people like you can say this kinda words. hes an awesome singer

[McLongDong]

he's a chinese singing god

[venkasemka]

Richard clayderman is playng this !!!

[plaay90826]

很好聽!

[bga6]

我赞同以上观点。 歌神的高音并不高； 这首爱如潮水的感染力还无法接近原唱。  仅限这首歌。

[newian2006]

節奏快好多~!!

..

[daemonwill]

Oh my... what a great version and what a terrible hairstyle

Vincechoy, can you fix the pinyin please? It's Ai ru chaoshui (even if Jacky's pronunciation is a bit iffy)

[annhow68]

Nice song...but cut your haiiiirrrrrrr !!!!

[io5201]

ha....

[jwang604]

simply amazing!

[taishon3946]

Simply amazing totally!!!

[tszsanso]

brilliant voice

cock hair

[funnybunny9396]

GOD OF SONG !!! I LOVE YOU .

[lovona09]

wat's wrong with his hair??

[ph0enixo8]

legend!! but pace of the song is a bit too fast for my liking. Still no one can beat 歌神。

[km5380]

上手い。上手すぎる

張学友 最高です！

[KOREA007]

JC's so talented, love his songs and esp. his voice!

[keepof]

香港已经找不到实力派歌手,

靓就可以出唱片.

張學友还是你最好.

[happychap75]

歌神...

還要說嗎？

[zxx83]

第一句唱的超棒...'流眼泪'...

[lakershackler]

学友加油！！！！

[Amali0011]

whoever sings this song, always awesome, becuase the nature of this song is already awesome anyway..plus the voice type and expression makes is just Perfect !

[uepih]

AWESOME!!! Love this song

[EVA151598]

太神了~！真的太棒了~！

[fenniecsf14]

JACKY CHEUNG is the BEST of the Best .... i like him very much...... Jacky is the NO 1......

[iWuvAznGurlz88]

Can you upload the next song too? Or at least give me the name of the song so I can watch it. Thanks!

[myacnt8999]

sorry, no offense, but i think Jeff Chang voice is a bit 'woman voice', although he has great control over his voice... i like Jacky's powerful and sexy voice.

[big8templer]

学友的功底还是在的。不像其他人翻唱这首歌简直不能听。

[myacnt8999]

i think jacky's version is the best. you can feel the emotion, especially near the ending. and his voice is the best. i just think jeff's voice is not strong enough for male's voice, maybe too womanish, although his technique of controlling the pace is great.

[japanesebusinessdood]

but it takes a "sissy boy" like the image of jeff chang as "youyu wangzi" in order to convey the whiny emoness of this song. it takes a real BETA male to convey the meaning, i feel, which is why i can't sing it successfully at karaoke: too ALPHA for this song

[lmaxmax]

他的表演一般比较随性，当时心情有些兴奋喜悦，所以唱得快，高潮­激动

如果心情孤寂，带点忧伤，就会像原作

但是都好，不同的版本就要有不同的感觉嘛

[momomonsta]

＝O well said! i agree

[mingYAWNS]

歌神

[a83911123]

我覺得他有些字咬字斷的太快 這樣好像聽的氣不足

不過我本人是沒有那個資格批評天王的

[ahhe1]

你真係好笑..話佢唔夠氣

[TaLxLove]

佢係話 佢唱得快左少少 聽起上[好似]唔夠氣

我都覺唱慢少少好d

[vchenkoshe]

的確 唱慢d會好聽d

[lildiana520]

jeff controls the pace and melody a lot better. jacky's voice might be a little too strong for such an emotional song.

[myacnt8999]

jeff chang is a tenor whereas jacky is a baritone. i personally prefer jacky's version because his voice is flawless and stronger.

[ccsj1ss]

很多人翻唱別人的歌， 在原唱者面前會臉紅， 那是因為技不如人。

但學友翻唱別人的歌， 卻常令很多原唱者無地自容。

[zhou5988]

说的好

[nitaa1227]

哈但尼首個原唱都唔差

唱法都好唔同

唔可以咁比

但首小城大事，原唱要變駱駝先得- -

歌神太強了

[god11426]

真的

這句話真的說的太好了ＸＤ

[jwangphp3]

those first few seconds of the vid - jacky smiling...it warms my heart!

[onlyily]

wow, this song is really old, i miss it..

[vindo112]

haven't heard the original much..jeff chang's voice a bit gay for me...it would be in a different key though..they have different ranges

[vindo112]

this haircut ages better with time..after the intial shock LOL

[leeangtat]

It's Ai Ru Ziao Zui because it's written in Taiwanese Min Nan (Hokkien)

[tomomi012]

Though he and Jeff sang the same song, I think their versions are very different. I can't say which one is better because both of them give me different feelings, but let's just say that Jacky has the ability to sing any artist's songs beautifully.

[Geetysborg]

Ugghh ... he butchered it.

[rayvolvez]

我真的喜欢这版本。

[cutydog54]

I agree with scwushu. Jeff Chang is still unbeatable for this song.

[tkennyz]

i dont think that any body can sing better like the way he did. he is the best in singing.

[keynesac]

下次唱k 唱呢首先

[jacinthtw]

第一句...就唱的好有個性...^^

[Harvarder]

the legendary "song god"

[sprilite]

Ai Ru Chao Shui, not ziao zui. Terrible