Dear listeners, you'd understand this is a Ghazal and not a Karnataki Raaga based song. And that's why the difference came here from the original one sung by S. Janaki.
Ashaji is undoubtedly a good singer.... but in this song it is Janaki amma who stuns everyone.... she simply rox.... her expressions were beyond explanations... its sad dat she is yet to receive Padma awards....
this is a karnatic raga.. S janaki is a mastreo.. no wonder Ilya Raja prefers her most of the time.. Asha jee is good but handsdown , janaki jee is the winner.. i would listen to her songs any time of the day... i am Proud that she is TELUGU and from my home town :)...
Please hear " Kaatril enthan geetham" sung by Janaki. Then you will see the difference. Janaki is a singer who matched upto Lataji & Ashaji. As Bollywood is more famous, hindi singers are also famous
When I was studying in 12th in 1996, I saw this movie 'Aur Ek Prem kahani".I really liked this song and sing some lines of it yet, but did not find this song on youtube,on searching about Ilayaraja on wikipeddia, I read about this movie and my memories refreshed, I search this song here and got it.Thus I got my favourite song after 14 years.Thanks to uploader, youtube and wikipeddia.
A very rare video indeed. Thanks. Personally, the Janaki amma's original is so deeply ingrained in me that I am unable to shake it to welcome this version, even though this one is greatly sung by the living legend, Ashaji.
nice but nothing comes near tamil version. it simply the best. the tune it self ....the tamil version make you sleepless. the hindi not bad .....only the background music...downplayed.
I love both the versions, Hindi and Tamil. I actually first saw the Tamil version ( thanks to Halimali ) pictured on Sridevi, it was very powerful and it gave me shivers. Now seeing this version, I think it's very powerful and amazing as well. But maybe I prefer the Tamil one. Amazing song!
@nuetro78 : I agree that the intro by Janaki is like 10 times better than this one.... But the lyrics I like in this song (because I cant understand Tamil...else I am sure it is much more beauiful in Tamil version).. But we cant compare poetry in 2 languages... Each has its own merit..
Lovely song.thanks for posting. though the tamil one is better ;but the hindi one is stereo recording where as the tamil one was mono.janaki and sir illayaraja was at peak when it was composed in tamil.
Wonderful song. The initial Alap by Asha was just extraordinary. She did in her own style. And the orchestration!! it has been completely changed by the Maestro. There are very few musicians who does that depending on the mood of the song. Another one I notice is ARR. He reused "baba neeku mokutha" in Swadesh with completely different genre.
Tamil Nadu is really blessed with great directors and musicians!!
Nice singing. At least one to 1.5 notes lower than Janaki's original tamil version
murthy23 4 weeks ago
Dear listeners, you'd understand this is a Ghazal and not a Karnataki Raaga based song. And that's why the difference came here from the original one sung by S. Janaki.
worldofamor 1 month ago
Ashaji is undoubtedly a good singer.... but in this song it is Janaki amma who stuns everyone.... she simply rox.... her expressions were beyond explanations... its sad dat she is yet to receive Padma awards....
KumarNathable 1 month ago
this is a karnatic raga.. S janaki is a mastreo.. no wonder Ilya Raja prefers her most of the time.. Asha jee is good but handsdown , janaki jee is the winner.. i would listen to her songs any time of the day... i am Proud that she is TELUGU and from my home town :)...
snowfallonciders1 6 months ago
I always liked Asha more than Janaki. But in this Song, I dont know Why she sounds comparatively less interesting than Janaki's version.
martiantraveller 6 months ago
Excellent.
farzanaakhtarkhan 10 months ago
awsome song, listening to it after 10+ years........ thanks for uploading.........
bittuyx 1 year ago
This is such a beautiful song... ofcourse Janaki's version is better.. but I am from Delhi and dont understand the lyrics...
Thi smovie was premiered on TV (in Hindi) and this song stayed in mind forever since then.
Thanks for uploading this.
ramils 1 year ago
Ilayaraja is the best.
I did not know he gave music to Hindi songs as well1
chandrashekharjain 1 year ago
Who is this actress ???
macanusa 1 year ago
@macanusa Heera
sunitha805 5 months ago
thnaks for upload.. a gr8 movie...
mohsinali 1 year ago
JANKI is inspired BY the greatest AASHA JI plz do not DISGRACE her by camparing her with JANKI i am PAKISTANI
nawabshaukat 1 year ago
Please hear " Kaatril enthan geetham" sung by Janaki. Then you will see the difference. Janaki is a singer who matched upto Lataji & Ashaji. As Bollywood is more famous, hindi singers are also famous
inder19852000 1 year ago
Appa...i think now atleast some people have understood that Asha or Lata are not the best just bcos they sung for bollywood...
AthmanAKS 1 year ago
When I was studying in 12th in 1996, I saw this movie 'Aur Ek Prem kahani".I really liked this song and sing some lines of it yet, but did not find this song on youtube,on searching about Ilayaraja on wikipeddia, I read about this movie and my memories refreshed, I search this song here and got it.Thus I got my favourite song after 14 years.Thanks to uploader, youtube and wikipeddia.
umeshmaslekar 1 year ago
I thought Asha couldn't do justice to it
Harivenur 1 year ago
Heera is so beautiful
kalirajkandasamy 2 years ago 2
Awesome..!!
Words are not enough to express my feelings for this song.. By Ashaji..!!
amitava1988 2 years ago
thanks a lot dude.....i was searching for this movie song forever........thanks again......can u plz upload the movie.....
vkzone 2 years ago
Thanks for uploading this song. I had heard the Tamil version growing up. I love Illayiraja's music and of Asha Bhonsle singing.
deepaliagashe 2 years ago 6
tamil version was really good compare to hindi
ngootha 2 years ago
Thanks a lot dude..I was dying to find this. My friend has the audio cassette of this album 12 years,,,but then he lost it...
I am very happy to find it in youtube..Thanks from bottom of my heart....
ForMusicVijeya 2 years ago
pls upload the sad version of ths song...i like it more thn ths
paaru098 2 years ago
A very rare video indeed. Thanks. Personally, the Janaki amma's original is so deeply ingrained in me that I am unable to shake it to welcome this version, even though this one is greatly sung by the living legend, Ashaji.
irthemes 2 years ago
nice but nothing comes near tamil version. it simply the best. the tune it self ....the tamil version make you sleepless. the hindi not bad .....only the background music...downplayed.
machakare 2 years ago 2
heera looks really cute in this movie
thanks for the upload
evadaitenakenti007 2 years ago
I love both the versions, Hindi and Tamil. I actually first saw the Tamil version ( thanks to Halimali ) pictured on Sridevi, it was very powerful and it gave me shivers. Now seeing this version, I think it's very powerful and amazing as well. But maybe I prefer the Tamil one. Amazing song!
Unknown090981999 2 years ago 2
-Asha has given her best but not even close to Janaki.....especially the intro. The tamil version is awesome.When did this movie release?.
nuetro78 2 years ago 12
@nuetro78 : I agree that the intro by Janaki is like 10 times better than this one.... But the lyrics I like in this song (because I cant understand Tamil...else I am sure it is much more beauiful in Tamil version).. But we cant compare poetry in 2 languages... Each has its own merit..
ramils 1 year ago 2
@nuetro78 it was in the year 1988
knrsattu 5 months ago
very very nice song
azizuzair 2 years ago
Good video. Nothing like the Tamil version but good nevertheless.
hildytnt 2 years ago
nice song...
amisha4u 2 years ago
Asha Bhosle is cool
beatiful video
5*
Fullmoongirl090 2 years ago
I love Asha Bhosle, but I prefer the original Tamil version in everything, singing, atmosphere , picturization and of course SRIDEVI!!!
halimali 2 years ago 2
wonderful song!!
hansaryan 2 years ago
Lovely song.thanks for posting. though the tamil one is better ;but the hindi one is stereo recording where as the tamil one was mono.janaki and sir illayaraja was at peak when it was composed in tamil.
RAJfromGOA 2 years ago
Wonderful song. The initial Alap by Asha was just extraordinary. She did in her own style. And the orchestration!! it has been completely changed by the Maestro. There are very few musicians who does that depending on the mood of the song. Another one I notice is ARR. He reused "baba neeku mokutha" in Swadesh with completely different genre.
Tamil Nadu is really blessed with great directors and musicians!!
sx42007 3 years ago 2