Having seen Kyle Dean, I'm probably a bit more biased toward him but he really was unbelievably fantastic live. His singing was great but his acting was even better....so I'd say Kyle. Side note: I guess maybe he was better in person but based on recordings I've heard, I cannot say that I understand how Curt Hansen got the part. His singing is all over the place which really kills the vocals for any of Gabe's material. But, I digress.
My order of favorites is still Aaron Tveit, followed by Kyle Dean, then Curt Hansen, but I don't really judge based on these recordings, I am going off of live performances I have seen and other recordings mainly for my justification. They also have the youngest sounding voices, which best fit the role since he's supposed be a teenager. In my humble opinion of course.
This doesn't even sound like Curt Hansen to be honest. And I saw him while he was in SF. It does him too much justice. I'd say Kyle Dean Massey's was the best. I preferred Aaron over what I had heard from Curt.
I completely agree with ohmyusernameistaken...except timothy and perry needed to switch. 1. Kyle Dean Massey 2. Curt Hansen 3.Anthony Carillo 4.Aaron Tveit 5. Brian Justin Crum 6. Timothy Young 7. Perry Sherman 8. Gareth Keegan But Kyle Dean Massey all the way!!!
I LOVE hearing it end on a B!!! Kyle's was great, but a little Adam Lambert-y for my personal tastes. Brain's was KILLER. Curt sounded really great when I saw him in LA.
Kyle Dean Massey
kenmoremusiclover 4 days ago
Kyle Dean Massey owns that last note.
iou50bucks 1 week ago
Aaron Tevit followed by Anthony Carillo and Brian Crum. The others I really dont care for all that much
ddrew49 3 weeks ago
Aaron Tveit
next2gabe 3 weeks ago
Curt Hansen and then Anthony Carillo :D
eboyv 1 month ago
all of them are good but i think the best guy who played character is Tim Young
lukemizer1 1 month ago
Gareth and Anthony get my votes. Gareth mainly because his accent just made it sound cooler, and Anthony's riffing at the end sold it for me.
mahnamezmatteh 1 month ago
Kyle Dean Massey. always and forever
TmelodyA 2 months ago 2
aaron will always be gabe. no matter if anyone is better.
but perry is freaking amazing
eisnergurlzz58 2 months ago 2
Aaron rules as King, HOWEVER Mr. Crum takes the cake with the recordings presented in this video.
Long live N2N!!
gabegoodman09 2 months ago
Kyle then Brian, followed by Perry.
a1994r 2 months ago
1. Anthony Carillo
2. Aaron Tveit/Kyle Dean Massey
3. Brian Justin Crum
Then I really don't care.
phantomphan1992 2 months ago
Having seen Kyle Dean, I'm probably a bit more biased toward him but he really was unbelievably fantastic live. His singing was great but his acting was even better....so I'd say Kyle. Side note: I guess maybe he was better in person but based on recordings I've heard, I cannot say that I understand how Curt Hansen got the part. His singing is all over the place which really kills the vocals for any of Gabe's material. But, I digress.
filmcomposer1986 3 months ago
Do you have all full show?
gabrielcullen1 3 months ago
I have to say I like Perry the best.
dishonsmith 3 months ago
Kyle Dean Massey all the way!!!
jonovision21 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
My order of favorites is still Aaron Tveit, followed by Kyle Dean, then Curt Hansen, but I don't really judge based on these recordings, I am going off of live performances I have seen and other recordings mainly for my justification. They also have the youngest sounding voices, which best fit the role since he's supposed be a teenager. In my humble opinion of course.
russ2246 4 months ago
Comment removed
russ2246 4 months ago
I saw Brian perform the show and he was great. But Kyle is breathtaking.
sylarforreals 4 months ago
aaron has that intensity but kyle dean SMASHES it! brian is great too, i think.
Hannieexx01 4 months ago
Aaron's is definitely the strongest and most confident, but I like Curt's too. For some reason I don't like Kyle dean....
BroadwayBabe18360 4 months ago
Brian and Perry o.o
KyleKirbyy 4 months ago
kyle and aaron
codester00033 4 months ago
Aaron and Kyle definitely!
SweeneyTodd2095 4 months ago
Kyle, Aaron.
rafasuv 4 months ago
1) Kyle Dean
2) Aaron
3) Brian
4) Curt
HappyMadisonDude 5 months ago in playlist HappyMadisonDude's Favorited Videos
KYLE IS THE BESTT!!! tim is AMAZING curt wasnt so bad and anthony overdid the last im alive
trishaheartss 5 months ago
Anthony... that was a tranny mess. KYLE... HELLER!!!!!! You better sing
TheSimplyFabulous 5 months ago
seriously guys? aaron!!
swimstar66 6 months ago
Kyle Dean Massey for sure!!! Wonderful vocals!!!!!
TeddySherrod 6 months ago
Kyle de
TeddySherrod 6 months ago
is this even a question? aaron tveit obviouslyyyy
edidancer4life 6 months ago
Aaron Tveit for SHOW!
EmbleyHouse 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
aaron hands down for me :)
imwickedthruandthru 6 months ago
This doesn't even sound like Curt Hansen to be honest. And I saw him while he was in SF. It does him too much justice. I'd say Kyle Dean Massey's was the best. I preferred Aaron over what I had heard from Curt.
yobsterrish 6 months ago
sweetnyangie2993 7 months ago
1/2. Kyle Dean Massey/Curt Hansen
3. Anthony Carillo
4. Aaron Tveit
5. Brian Justin Crum
6. Perry Sherman
7. Timothy Young
8. Gareth Keegan
ohmyusernameistaken 7 months ago
I LOVE hearing it end on a B!!! Kyle's was great, but a little Adam Lambert-y for my personal tastes. Brain's was KILLER. Curt sounded really great when I saw him in LA.
wickedphant0m 7 months ago
KYLE DEAN MASSEY!!!!!!! woooooooooooooh!!!!!!!!!! and WTF did curt hansen do at the end of his?? lolol!
vivalavieboheme14 7 months ago
Aaron just because I have so much respect on his work!
BUT KYLE DEAN MASSEY!!! OHMYBROADWAY! :)
jdthemindfreak 7 months ago
100% Kyle Dean Massey. Although i did enjoy Anthony Carillo's remake of it.
Yudanashi 7 months ago
to me anthony carillo is the best gabe :) i love him so
dancinggh10 7 months ago
Awesome! Do you have audios of the Dallas production and the Melbourne production?
WickedMusicalBuffalo 7 months ago
Based on these clips...
1. Kyle Dean Massey
2. Anthony Carillo
3. Brian Justin Crum
4. Curt Hansen
5. Timothy Young
6. Aaron Tveit
7. Perry Sherman/Gareth Keegan
WickedGlindax 7 months ago