信任讓夢想成真?(PG家長指引版本[政制方案宣傳片])

[MrKaying]

如果政府真系同我老母一樣就好la

[heeraoeer]

d 音樂好慘!!!!!!

[goodlife2673]

垃圾廣告

又唔見人地余若微賣廣告?

人地一把口都講贏你啦呀特首

[tkbk1989]

條裙(方案)出現GE時間係"畢業party"前一兩日...

咁

畢業party係咪意味D乜?

係特區區旗畢業定曾生畢業

[garbageteddy]

大家有無留意到...條裙係人地抄舖頭設計.....作廣告個個 批個廣告個個 比錢個個 都無版權意識...

[ctip888]

若中共想有民主, 中共可大大方方宣佈2020取消功能組別, 真和諧!

[nomorekingsinchina]

妳大個女啦! Big mac都食得哪! 仲咁依賴阿媽! 自己學做衫，唔好下下等阿媽!阿媽咁唔得閒，要搵錢攪好經濟! 得閒就根妳要求做，唔得閒就會求卵其做，到時走樣，爆線兼露底，­樣衰出醜咪又係妳咯! 真係戇框框!

[AZUREAZURE007]

這是洗腦短片嗎?想得個知字姐。



[cdmarker1230]

根本方案由始至終都預計會否決

[kelcff]

我系香港三十年, 都未曾見過政府去賣電視廣告宣傳自己嘅管治方式同政制方式, 直頭系好似大陸勞改, 幫你地香港人洗腦. 香港回歸中國, 到今日已經可以話極之悲哀, 再過多幾十年真系香港=大陸, 共產思想將會完全統治香港.

[mamamamaster]

阿媽即係阿爺 唔係政府lor唔該

香港政府鬼有say

[buddhadisco]

very plastic bow tie ...

[GzJJJiphone]

信你一成,　"毒"害全城

信你兩成,  "北嫂"攻城

信到三成, "貪污"全城

２０１２，　罪惡之城

[chankachun9]

詐騙/詐欺內容

[yinaeris]

其實條片用母女去表示政府同市民無乜問題, 不過做裙個過程就唔係好合理.

阿女想做一條自已design gei 裙 ( 市民想有自已design gei 政改方案 ).

阿媽就好有 heart 去同個女造. ( 政府好有 heart 去為市民做 )

不過阿媽"完全"無問過個女條裙隻色同個style...連個s­ize都未必fit身...

( 政府完全無問過市民 gei 雖要...咁又點會fit市民心意呢?)

[yinaeris]

仲有, 今年係2010, 畢業ball條裙要等到2017先搞點? 要個女讀多次中1-中7 r?

阿媽由阿女入中學個刻就知讀幾耐ga la, 點解唔係lee個其間同阿女一齊諗好條裙點做, 大家交換意見呢?? 何必要阿女畢業前再要阿女讀多7年r??點等r?

P.S 阿女幾靚.

[tigger1668]

can they stop those 2012 commerical .....hate seeing it on TV everynite.........afterall , do we hv a choice ?

[besthker]

請問有無人知首BGM係咩

[JackWong111]

呢段片話比大家知雙普選=夢想,你地唔好發夢喇 ! !

[dor128]

抄襲 = 夢想?

貨不對版 = 信任?

咁我好驚喎~ 抄襲以前?定抄襲人地d野? 度度唔到點抄?

貨不對版都信咁好唔得je~

真係信一成都雙目失明哩~

e+係要真普選, 唔點點斬草除根呢?

斬草不除根, 春風吹又生~

[tunderman66]

We need to have a statement, not asking us to believe! There is nothing when no promise in the 2012 constitutional package.

[CrystalTang123]

玩鋪勁 = 勁hea,咁敷衍我地

佢想過橋抽板

選特首之前拎到票就得,做到之後就睬你都傻

[fortie57]

突手過去的所作所爲證明他並不是一個值得信賴的人！

[cybaster01]

第個要我信佢都仲可以諗下.

一個冇誠信可言既人仲有面叫人再信佢?!

[shinoray]

信你老母

[cocoto123]

信你不如信你老母！

[stupidben999]

戇鳩

[rickywongwk]

這問題是我們有個中央，不通過今次，我們可能又要等多幾年，幾年­也是翻炒05方案，到時反對派又繼續說翻炒05方案，又一樣生生­不息，我們又要再等～再等～我們也是時候妥協，就踏一步。中央是­一個頑父，他最怕亂同反，唯有順意才能慢慢取得更多～不要讓我們­再等～再等～無了期再等～再等～

[kenchancck0717]

政府宣傳片都已經講得好清楚啦, 政改等同做條裙一樣, 一樣咁兒戲, 究竟點可以信政府呢??? 呢班狗官正廢柴!!!!!

[loklok222]

看完政改廣告, 身為中國人真的十分悲哀 ~~ 幾千年以來中國人的皇權統治思想原來到了今天仍然揮之不去! 中國百姓永遠就是奴隸, 永遠就是孩子, 當權的永遠是父母, 百姓的一切權利都只能由父母控制, 父母施予! 共產主意裡面的當權的為人民服務, 人民才是國家的主人這種高尚的人權觀念早早已被幾千年根深柢固的­皇權統治思想所吞噬!

[loklok222]

條裙同阿女最初畫嗰張理想靚裙嘅草圖，完全唔似，連顏色都唔一樣­，證明政府想搵老襯？還是意味政府唔會畀一個港人想要嘅方案？

[SAIKAI2009]

不反對政改(如果真如字面說的那樣), 不過廣告本身真係九唔搭八,弄巧反拙

[ohdamnshit]

@kurt425 >4. Is democracy really solve all the problem, or deeply contrast? I doubt, u can find the mirrors of Thailand, UK, US.

Thailand....do you look into the problems with Thailand before you say this? It's because of Army's involvement!

[glogav]

如果真係要人信任你,唔該拎d誠意出黎,連時間表都冇就話循序漸­進!循邊個方向,向邊度前進呢請問??如果要人支持政改方案,請­認認真真用個腦好好諗清楚個政改方案點改??唔係得ar爺會訓示­香港政府,香港人都會!

連內地人係網上都留言,話香港呢次補選都冇人投票,冇人出黎發表­意見,係香港人之恥!就係佢地冇呢d自由,我地應該要更加珍惜而­家有ge野,去爭取一d應該有ge權利!

[glogav]

究竟想點??岩岩補選完就出個政改廣告???個廣告仲要9唔搭8­...連我呢d平時潛水開ge人都要出聲!!一補選完就不停話投­票率低...連特首都唔投!真係貽笑大方... ...

比起選特首,呢次補選更有代表性,最起碼有50「萬」人黎投票!­選特首果800人算係咩呢??

[timma0813]

唔通過政改就可以2012有普選咩?

[zandztone]

段片真係改得好令人不安...@@

[sally9057]

我都想up呢段片...

佢真係9唔搭8

我同果fd睇到最尾先終於知

佢係sell咩..- -

個idea係邊個諗架...

咁都比佢播出街...- -

[Dooooleung]

不要再在向錯誤的方向中前行了

[nomorekingsinchina]

到了今天, 中國人仍然是奴隸, 中國人永遠就是孩子, 掌權的永遠是父母, 永遠是天子! 今天中國人仍然需要依靠皇恩浩蕩; 你我就是廣告中的小女孩, 你我的一切都需由父母施予, 你要的不一定得, 得到的也不一定是你想要的, 因為你我都是永遠長不大的小孩, 悲哀! 悲哀!

[nomorekingsinchina]

89年的一場政治風波便把這事實披露無遺; 當時的大學生不是被看作孩子嗎? 中共領導人不是清楚地表現出父母的姿態嗎? 孩子只能哀求, 父母有權施不施予! 悲哀的是經歷了這樣一場悲壯的風暴後, 到了20年後的今天, 當權者仍然沒有深徹反省去否定這種幾千年根深柢固的皇權統治思想­對中華民族的禍害, 沒有把共產主意高舉人民的高尚理念扶植出來傳播給中華民族:

[nomorekingsinchina]

看完這個廣告, 身為中國人真的十分悲哀 ~~ 幾千年以來中國人的皇權統治思想原來到了今天仍然揮之不去! 中國百姓永遠就是奴隸, 永遠就是孩子, 當權的永遠是父母, 百姓的一切權利都只能由父母控制, 父母施予! 共產主意裡面的當權的為人民服務, 人民才是國家的主人這種高尚的人權觀念早早已被幾千年根深柢固的­皇權統治思想所吞噬!

[lkk1205]

i like this video!

u are right. the relationtionship between the gov and us is nth about that between a mother and a daughter.

Gov just wanna build up the postive image with this emoitonal appeal. fortunately, we're not stupid. we won't be moved by this.

[pkyeung]

Demanding the people to trust them ... LOL. When was the last time the HK government trusted their people? For crying out loud, when will the idiots running the government understand that TRUST HAS TO BE EARNED?

[cmbkmbctb]

廣告同政制有甚麼關係?阻政制發展不是我們,是你曾蔭權!

[chkla1]

@kurt425 3. 3. We don't know if democracy can solve all the problems. But have you been following news happening in China? (Again, not about economy!!) Have you heard of poisoned milk incidents, the infants' parents? corruptions? google? school buildings in earthquakes? .... These problems you can hardly find in democratic countries, but these are everyday news in China

[chkla1]

@hurt425 2. It seems like you only care about economy and money. Don't u know they are talking about democracy, human rights and freedom of speech? The economic crisis has nothing to do with 516.

[chkla1]

@kurt425 1. Your view of communism only works "theoretically". Can you name one communist country that runs successfully? It really depends on who governs it, but I can't think of one good example. can you?

[ahkam001]

exactly expressing what I am thinking after watching this advertising

[hkman2003]

政府不是人民父母,獨立思考比信任重要!Fuck this government!

[williamatLSD]

點解我o地個政府咁無恥...?

[vicky21469]

讓你惡夢成真

[thomastmwc]

@vicky21469 哈哈哈講得好

[may1221a]

共產狗

讓你惡夢成真

youtube審查已成真,,,,

唔去公投的惡果,,,

[sharonlama]

請問主題音樂是？很熟，我肯定我有的，一時想不起。

[thomastmwc]

@sharonlama 我都想知哈哈

[ymt0702]

看到一位寫' 中國地大人多, 管治好, 相當困難'

我想, 看一個政權, 不是看有多少人民, 而是看 他對人民的態度.

[ytp333]

kurt425: i totally agree with u!!!!!

[kurt425]

1. communism Govt is not a guilty, it depends on who governs it.

2. After the globle economic crisis, i can't see any democratic countries (US, Greece, even the Great British) are working well on it, they are suffering unexpectable amount of deficit. We all agreed China is one of first few countries who survives from it.

[kurt425]

3. Even the God of Stock, 巴菲特 said Chinese Govt has an extremely high efficiency on adopting policy, which democracy countries cannot, to boost the economy. ( from I Money Magazine, issue 133, 2010-5-8)

4. Is democracy really solve all the problem, or deeply contrast? I doubt, u can find the mirrors of Thailand, UK, US.

I wish we can look at both side of a coin.

[elingist]

民主的精神是要建基於尊重別人的意見,並非逆耳便反對

口喊自由民主,但採偏激煽動的手法就更要不得.

[oily1314]

@elingist 一黨專政的精神是要建基於莫視別人的意見，馮係逆耳便消滅、口喊­自由開放，但採極權打壓的手法就更是了不起。

[tcshek]

政府擺明係搵你老襯！

[elingist]

我只知道國家向好的方面發展,走向富強,亦都感到驕傲.

此刻看不到一党専政有何問題,关鍵在於該党有否制約及糾正.

中國地大人多,管治好,確是相當困難的課題.

[oily1314]

@elingist 看不到有問題的原因只有三個，第一個你自已係共產黨、第二個你係­盲人、第三個你are too simple sometimes naive。你自已好好反省下啦，吳好再在這裡發放軟弱無力的言­論喇。

[kurt425]

1. 你要讀下書, 共產黨唔等同罪惡, 上google查下咩叫馬克思, 共產主義.

2. 只有最極權既人先會無理地奪去別人既發言權, 你連別人既發言權利都唔尊重, 無資格講民主

[timtimholiday]

kursk　good　job！

[kjmm1234]

共產黨與你們有仇嗎?

哈哈,你不是認為極權者主義.是一件好事嗎?

[elingist]

共產黨與你們有仇嗎?

國共都和解啦.,

你們總是散播仇恨,不可理性討論嗎?

令社會占分化.

[german3chen]

@elingist

同共產黨點會冇仇。香港有幾多人係受共產黨迫害而走落黎，仲有譚­作人劉曉波又點計!

國共都和解啦，點解民主派人士仲未有回鄉證?

民主派與中共有仇嗎? 國民黨殺左共產黨幾多人都可以和解，民主派又做左咩傷天害理既事­?

[elingist]

特區政府,"所謂公投"有八成幾人不投票支持,在有大量民意基礎­下,

你們就努力以赴吧!

不要氣餒啊!

加油!加油!

[yim1991]

@elingist 是8成幾人不作表決,另外這只代表有選民權的人!一堆年輕人還沒­能夠當選民..不然結果差太多了~

[handuprun]

講真我覺得政府咁做侮辱偉大既母親

[inouesugi]

共產黨信得過，太陽直頭由地底爆出黎！

這個特府真可惡！

[kjmm1234]

到什麼在是暗示什麼

[pure7b]

9唔搭7

[chung7712]

good......................

[porhk]

如果政府要我哋當佢喺我亞媽，咁真喺要講聲：丟那媽！

[may1221a]

特別卜街正苦

[5334joey]

明明打左篇回應..但係...

[efl200]

重有..我地幾時變左係你個女

我地交稅...我地係你老細

家下竟然調返轉...要做你個女...

曾狗...你無野呀...要唔要睇精神科醫生呀

[efl200]

正苦做左賊...唔見得人呀

條正片...居然唔俾人留言...要審查

有無搞錯

信任?????信任你呢個無民意受權既曾狗班子...你地去食屎­喇

[smartbryan]

政府講既野,信佢一成,雙目失明 !

[KMBAA33]

信任，讓夢想成真；

中央，令普選落空？

[idmangqn]

I really wana give a thumbs up to "PG家長指引版本". But i really wana give a thumbs down to the propaganda. what can i do?

[lesterlee2000]

呎條廣告片令人反感, 政府想點?

[cactus2791]

回歸前,趙紫陽曾經說:你怕甚麼?

倘若趙紫陽現今還在生的話,

會唔會向香港市民道歉:當年我講錯咗!

[gundamman678]

當你阿媽會為身邊既有錢朋友就出賣你；

當你阿媽會為左做到自己想做既野，就成日講大話呃你；

當你阿媽認為你自由得濟而想限制你；

當你阿媽信阿爺講野多過信你；

當你向阿媽申訴佢限制你太多，佢就話你野蠻唔理性......

你應該係時候問下，呢個究竟係咪真係你阿媽???

呢個係咪一個你值得信任既人???

[kelcff]

直頭系侮辱左偉大的母親, 應該要求政府即時停播呢個廣告.

[COWNGWAH]

信任 你冇得翻身...........

[lmy918]

浪費我們的錢，正一垃圾政府！

[Joefi9]

做人阿媽係唔會玩幾個出嚟暗招扇自己個女o家囉~

不過~~~香港特區政府會

[lamheilok]

佢老母有無睇民調架

[boy1998]

一個無誠信既政府,同你講要信佢.

信佢d乜?會唔會取消功能組別?點樣達致雙普選?

........

佢就真係好似呀媽咁:呀女,呢d大個就知架啦~信左先啦.

...究竟想我地信乜?信佢會達成我地願望?定係達成佢地(政府­同既得利益者)既願望?

如果過左個政改,你信政府會做邊樣???????

我相信係:「過左.....海就神仙啦~喂~」

香港人,清醒d,唔好俾人呃,唔係第時警訊既主角會係我地

[dinerdisaster]

相當邪惡的一種推銷手法。不單單只用上一個比喻，更是默化式的一­種洗腦幻術。全片半點不提政制方案的實則內容；在說出一個看似甜­美的故事後，緊接下來就是叫市民支持政改。再看看片中出現的原素­：熱褲少女；抄襲當設計；低胸新娘；無溝通（母女）便是信任等等­...... 這是魔鬼一般的手段啊!

[globalchan1970]

I can post comment here. I can like or dislike your video. But when I post comment to the HKSAR video, they are censoring me. So what kind of government it is.

To: HKSAR: I voted in 516, and then you said it doesn't count. I reply to your video, and you block me. So what is next?

[kursk]

@globalchan1970 I don't know why your comment was flagged as spam by someone/ or by the youtube(?). I've removed the your flag.

[otacon2801]

@kursk thank you, that "someone" are those damn commies hiding in Hong Kong :(

[Michae1Leung]

@globalchan1970 這就是我們的特區政府，連見人都唔敢