@simisimi9 what an animal you are . I let you know something before you die ill faggot: Sutherland had a voice around two sizes bigger than cartoon witch Maria. Dame Joan is the soprano of the century aside that Dame Joan had more personality than the ugly Maria, who made always a ridiculuos stage game , her ridiculuos '56 Tosca telecast , '58 Paris Tosca second act and '64 London Tosca second act leaves her as one of the most dreadful and ridiculuos actresses ever seen on stage
I truely enjoyed this so much. This is a delight to my eyes and ears. To see this wonderful performance preserved here for all time with these great performers is a treat, indeed! Thank you so much Ms. Sue Ann Nevins for sharing this with us.
Dame Joan Sutherland luce hermosa tanto física como vocalmente. En este gran concertante de Donizetti Sutherland no solo demuestra quien es como soprano sino como actriz, como olvidar esta Lucia doliente, abandonada y desesperada... ella sin duda es la reina de todas las coloraturas....
ME HAN LLAMADO IGNORANTE......ME HAN DICHO DE TODO MENOS BONITO......Y YO JAMAS HE INSULTADO A NADIE.......QUE NO TENGO NI PUÑETERA IDEA.......PERO MI AMOR POR LA VIDA SOLO HA SIDO AMAR A MARIA CALLAS Y A JOAN SUTHERLAND...APARTE DE MIS COSAS PARTICULARES..A MI EDIT PIAF .Y A MI MIREILLE MATHIEU..A MI SHIRLEY BASSEY..Y MUCHOS ESTILOS MAS.....Y TODOS SIEMPRE ESTAN DISCUTIENDO DE QUIEN ES MEJOR QUE QUIEN..Y ESO ES UNA TONTERIA.....PERO LA SUPREMACIA ES UN SONIDO....ALGO MAS QUE LA INTELECTUALIDAD
PERO HAY QUE RECONOCER QUE JOAN SUTHERLAND ES ALGO MAS QUE UNA CANTANTE DE OPERA.....ES SUPERIOR......UN ANIMAL DEL CANTO......ABRID LOS OJOS DE UNA VEZ.....PARA QUE EL SIGLO VENIDERO SEA MEJOR.......PORQUE SI VAMOS ASI VAMOS BIEN MAL....YA LES VALE.......YO NO SOY MITOMANO......SOLO TENGO OIDOS.......Y QUIEN NO ESCUCHA A JOAN SUTHERLAND....ALGO LE FALTA........
lo que siento mucho en otros que han puesto videos es que anulen mis comentarios..en cuanto a callas y joan sutherland....creo qu emi libertad....es democratica...y mis gustos tambien...jamas permitire que nadie hable mejor de la callas que yo...pero jamas permitire...que se me anule cuando hablo de la mejor cantante de todos los tiempos..JOAN SUTHERLAND.....Y ALGUNOS EN ESTAS LIDES PARECE QUE SON FASCISTAS......Y YO SOLO SOY UN SER HUMANO QUE AMA...LO MEJOR....AMO A LA CALLAS COMO EL QUE MAS..
aparte de que su presencia en el escenario lo llena todo .............es......como.......si fuera de otro mundo......................su cara.su expresion...........su divismo sencillo........pero atronadorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr........sus facciones dedicadas al aria.....emotivas y sentidas a lo maximo.....y al mismo tiempo de manera facilll y elocuente..............es que me vuelve loco.........me chifla esta mujer..................ella cantaba y lo demas le importaba un pito..............eso es joa
@bellini7verdi Bravo bellini7verdi, pocas veces en youtube he escuchado tanta elocuencia de una manera tan sencillamente explanada. Bravo!!! Al fin alguien que dice las cosas como son... Ahhh Joanie... qué falta tan grande que me haces... especialmente en estos días de oscurantismo operístico lleno de vocecitas tan desoladoras...
esta mujer siempre tiene la tesitura adecuada..............entra y sale del aria como si ella la huviera diseñado...............es increibleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee..............................su oido es de lo mas exquisitoooooooooooo
I love love love this bit, but as with any choral song, it gets a bit muddy and hard to follow. I gave up trying to follow along with the libretto and now I just sit back and enjoy the artistry of 6 people singing 3 different songs with the same melody. It's EPIC!
Jerome Hines is singing to the left of Sutherland. A cavernous bass, who did the first American Boris Godunov in Russia, I believe, and who was still singing at 80, in 2001. And yes, Gobbi sang flat on occasion- it was not his voice that thrilled but his PRESENCE and acting ability. I saw his Scarpia in Tosca in Chicago in '73 or '74 (so long ago) and his entrance sent chills down your spine. The singing? -Eh. The Normanno and the mezzo I cannot place. But WOW, to have seen this. Thanks!!!
El "standard" para mi, desde los años 50 de esta bellisima aria fue justamente estos seis cantantes que yo desconocia quienes eran . El aria se repetia casi todos los sabados por la Radio de la Universidad de Costa Rica ,junto con otras arias que se convirtieron-tambien-en mis standards para esas obras. Asi que cada vez que escucho a otros cantantes interpretandolas-inconscientemente- comparaciones que no son justas...
Thanks for your reply. In fact, as far as I know we don't have larks in Australia (tho I am no ornithologist). 'Lark' can be used in Eng to trivialise something, so I wanted to clarify that this wasn't your intention. Many thanks - we are on the same wavelength.
She nails the D, even sitting down! She used to sit during certain ensemble numbers to hide the fact of how tall she was. Once, when she came to Cincinnati, in the late 50s, she made all the chorus men parade before her, and demanded that any man shorter than her be replaced. It made a lot of people angry, but they did it. She was very self conscious about her height.
Fascinating bit of trivia. Thanks for sharing it. And thanks, too, to the poster for this gem. When I was a kid, The Telephone House was on Monday nights at 9, following the Firestone Hour. I repeatedly asked Mom why these programs were called HOURS since both aired only 30 minutes!
Sounds like you and I may date from the same appromate era, ha! I used to listen to the voice of Firestone on the Radio, and always lamented that it was only a half hour--7:00 to 7:30 if I remember right, back in about 1947. I originally heard it only because it preceded the Lone Ranger, but soon I was more hooked on the Voice of Firestone than I was on the Lone Ranger and Tonto. :)
thrilling rendition. for all the dated lack of sets, etc. the Bell Telephone Hour introduced me to many of the war horses such as this. Bravi Bell Telephone. Brava Ms. Nivens for the posting
@simisimi9 what an animal you are . I let you know something before you die ill faggot: Sutherland had a voice around two sizes bigger than cartoon witch Maria. Dame Joan is the soprano of the century aside that Dame Joan had more personality than the ugly Maria, who made always a ridiculuos stage game , her ridiculuos '56 Tosca telecast , '58 Paris Tosca second act and '64 London Tosca second act leaves her as one of the most dreadful and ridiculuos actresses ever seen on stage
neneorganico 2 months ago
@neneorganico Comentario Ridiculo!
avalokiteshivara 2 months ago
I truely enjoyed this so much. This is a delight to my eyes and ears. To see this wonderful performance preserved here for all time with these great performers is a treat, indeed! Thank you so much Ms. Sue Ann Nevins for sharing this with us.
masteroftheeouse 8 months ago
Dame Joan Sutherland luce hermosa tanto física como vocalmente. En este gran concertante de Donizetti Sutherland no solo demuestra quien es como soprano sino como actriz, como olvidar esta Lucia doliente, abandonada y desesperada... ella sin duda es la reina de todas las coloraturas....
franciscobarn 10 months ago
Joan Sutherland sings as if she has food in her mouth- can't understand a word she says- opera must communicate- it is not just music
PastaAndPavarotti 11 months ago
Tito Gobbi (in red wig) really did have a great stage presence, AND he was still in good voice.
Detectivefiction 11 months ago
not sure about the calibre of the male voices,,,,,,,,,
barneswriter 1 year ago
ME HAN LLAMADO IGNORANTE......ME HAN DICHO DE TODO MENOS BONITO......Y YO JAMAS HE INSULTADO A NADIE.......QUE NO TENGO NI PUÑETERA IDEA.......PERO MI AMOR POR LA VIDA SOLO HA SIDO AMAR A MARIA CALLAS Y A JOAN SUTHERLAND...APARTE DE MIS COSAS PARTICULARES..A MI EDIT PIAF .Y A MI MIREILLE MATHIEU..A MI SHIRLEY BASSEY..Y MUCHOS ESTILOS MAS.....Y TODOS SIEMPRE ESTAN DISCUTIENDO DE QUIEN ES MEJOR QUE QUIEN..Y ESO ES UNA TONTERIA.....PERO LA SUPREMACIA ES UN SONIDO....ALGO MAS QUE LA INTELECTUALIDAD
bellini7verdi 1 year ago
PERO HAY QUE RECONOCER QUE JOAN SUTHERLAND ES ALGO MAS QUE UNA CANTANTE DE OPERA.....ES SUPERIOR......UN ANIMAL DEL CANTO......ABRID LOS OJOS DE UNA VEZ.....PARA QUE EL SIGLO VENIDERO SEA MEJOR.......PORQUE SI VAMOS ASI VAMOS BIEN MAL....YA LES VALE.......YO NO SOY MITOMANO......SOLO TENGO OIDOS.......Y QUIEN NO ESCUCHA A JOAN SUTHERLAND....ALGO LE FALTA........
bellini7verdi 1 year ago
lo que siento mucho en otros que han puesto videos es que anulen mis comentarios..en cuanto a callas y joan sutherland....creo qu emi libertad....es democratica...y mis gustos tambien...jamas permitire que nadie hable mejor de la callas que yo...pero jamas permitire...que se me anule cuando hablo de la mejor cantante de todos los tiempos..JOAN SUTHERLAND.....Y ALGUNOS EN ESTAS LIDES PARECE QUE SON FASCISTAS......Y YO SOLO SOY UN SER HUMANO QUE AMA...LO MEJOR....AMO A LA CALLAS COMO EL QUE MAS..
bellini7verdi 1 year ago
I remember seeing this when it was first aired. Overall beautiful performances from all these great singers. Thanks for sharing it!
meltzerboy 1 year ago
@meltzerboy
G-r-e-a-t !!!!!
Many thanks to SueAnnNivens (love your handle!), and to Nate for sharing!
CurzonRoad 1 year ago
What a cast!!!!!!
LordMgls 1 year ago 2
RIP Joan Sutherland - an amazing singer who had a wonderful career.
kkkathykk 1 year ago
Freakin AWESOME!
novasafo 1 year ago 2
aparte de que su presencia en el escenario lo llena todo .............es......como.......si fuera de otro mundo......................su cara.su expresion...........su divismo sencillo........pero atronadorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr........sus facciones dedicadas al aria.....emotivas y sentidas a lo maximo.....y al mismo tiempo de manera facilll y elocuente..............es que me vuelve loco.........me chifla esta mujer..................ella cantaba y lo demas le importaba un pito..............eso es joa
bellini7verdi 1 year ago
@bellini7verdi Bravo bellini7verdi, pocas veces en youtube he escuchado tanta elocuencia de una manera tan sencillamente explanada. Bravo!!! Al fin alguien que dice las cosas como son... Ahhh Joanie... qué falta tan grande que me haces... especialmente en estos días de oscurantismo operístico lleno de vocecitas tan desoladoras...
luiscar89 1 year ago
esta mujer siempre tiene la tesitura adecuada..............entra y sale del aria como si ella la huviera diseñado...............es increibleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee..............................su oido es de lo mas exquisitoooooooooooo
bellini7verdi 1 year ago
History.... amazing, goosebumps, thanks for uploading this!
arnull40 1 year ago
I love love love this bit, but as with any choral song, it gets a bit muddy and hard to follow. I gave up trying to follow along with the libretto and now I just sit back and enjoy the artistry of 6 people singing 3 different songs with the same melody. It's EPIC!
swetergrl91 1 year ago
Thanks so much for posting this ! A wonderful glimpse back at the past!!
FrenchtownLassie 1 year ago
Jerome Hines is singing to the left of Sutherland. A cavernous bass, who did the first American Boris Godunov in Russia, I believe, and who was still singing at 80, in 2001. And yes, Gobbi sang flat on occasion- it was not his voice that thrilled but his PRESENCE and acting ability. I saw his Scarpia in Tosca in Chicago in '73 or '74 (so long ago) and his entrance sent chills down your spine. The singing? -Eh. The Normanno and the mezzo I cannot place. But WOW, to have seen this. Thanks!!!
jsmoir1 2 years ago
this is Gerome Himes?
OrpheuCe 2 years ago
Pretty darned sensational - thank you SueAnn :)
RobbieIPA 2 years ago
What treasures are on YouTube!!!!!!! GOLD! Thank you so much for posting this!
Mamasan41 2 years ago 7
Great.....Dame Joan at her very best....
1551Lente 2 years ago 2
Bravissimi soprattutto Tito Gobbi e Nicolai Gedda.
BassoAntico 2 years ago
Comment removed
LobsngDmchoi 2 years ago
Tito Gobbi out of tune????? is about 1,000 percxent better than the average bass!!!! Bravo Mr. Gobbi, we surely miss you!
Mamasan41 2 years ago
Joan.. ti amo.. love u so much Joan absolutely amazing.
dulcamara66 2 years ago
El "standard" para mi, desde los años 50 de esta bellisima aria fue justamente estos seis cantantes que yo desconocia quienes eran . El aria se repetia casi todos los sabados por la Radio de la Universidad de Costa Rica ,junto con otras arias que se convirtieron-tambien-en mis standards para esas obras. Asi que cada vez que escucho a otros cantantes interpretandolas-inconscientemente- comparaciones que no son justas...
JorPove 2 years ago
Who are the others? Guess Jerome Hines and Charles Anthony - but the Mezzo?
rigoletto97 3 years ago
Midred Miller.
VelikiKlek 2 years ago 2
actually, gedda sings "ella sta inaridita", which makes no sense, and gobbi doesnt even flinch or give him away in the lest bit....
consummate professionals all around...
eebooking 3 years ago
I remember seeing this at the original Met as a very young girl - they received 30 ! curtain calls-
egodimi 1 year ago
nicolai is singing the wrong words @.29 sec...instead of "ma qual rosa inaridita", he sings "ella sta fra morte e vita"...
good overall performances, though...
bravo...
and dame sutherland....what a lark...
eebooking 3 years ago
and dame sutherland... what a lark... what does that mean???
wattever333 2 years ago
Yep, I'd like to know what is meant by the lark reference to Joan, too.
jaedth 2 years ago
Have you ever heard a lark sing????? Glorious!
Mamasan41 2 years ago
Thanks for your reply. In fact, as far as I know we don't have larks in Australia (tho I am no ornithologist). 'Lark' can be used in Eng to trivialise something, so I wanted to clarify that this wasn't your intention. Many thanks - we are on the same wavelength.
jaedth 2 years ago
Glorious bird, the lark, one of the great singers in the meadow!!! Cheers!
Mamasan41 2 years ago
Thank you for posting this! It is just absolutely EXQUISITE. WOW....
PAMELACOLT 3 years ago 2
Thanks for excellent posting.
oegaziz43 3 years ago
Outstanding!
eisenburgh 3 years ago 2
Magnificent - Sutherland at her finest.
willb48 3 years ago 9
She nails the D, even sitting down! She used to sit during certain ensemble numbers to hide the fact of how tall she was. Once, when she came to Cincinnati, in the late 50s, she made all the chorus men parade before her, and demanded that any man shorter than her be replaced. It made a lot of people angry, but they did it. She was very self conscious about her height.
stefakamelpash 3 years ago
Fascinating bit of trivia. Thanks for sharing it. And thanks, too, to the poster for this gem. When I was a kid, The Telephone House was on Monday nights at 9, following the Firestone Hour. I repeatedly asked Mom why these programs were called HOURS since both aired only 30 minutes!
gmmix 3 years ago
Sounds like you and I may date from the same appromate era, ha! I used to listen to the voice of Firestone on the Radio, and always lamented that it was only a half hour--7:00 to 7:30 if I remember right, back in about 1947. I originally heard it only because it preceded the Lone Ranger, but soon I was more hooked on the Voice of Firestone than I was on the Lone Ranger and Tonto. :)
stefakamelpash 3 years ago
Dame Joan could hit a high D standing on her head! :-)
VirnAlfakyn 3 years ago 3
That's Joan reminding us that this opera is titled: Lucia ...
dpk242 2 years ago
Excellent! thanks!
Onegin65 3 years ago 2
How flat was the bass from 0:45 to 1:00??
EdgarColle 4 years ago
WAYY flat!
LaStupenda 4 years ago
Please don't forget Jerome Hines !
Great stuff !
Thanks for posting.
primobaritono 4 years ago
Well and Mildred Miller ;)
Jabe88 4 years ago
Thanks Sue Ann..... Dame Joan in her prime is always a treat.
Hako2004 4 years ago
thrilling rendition. for all the dated lack of sets, etc. the Bell Telephone Hour introduced me to many of the war horses such as this. Bravi Bell Telephone. Brava Ms. Nivens for the posting
operadm 4 years ago