Chopin was so great. This piece sums up heroism itself, the overcoming - with each pass the melody approaches becoming more 'heroic' than the last and more complete... only at the end is it triumphant.
The uncertainty/overcoming of the hero at 632 - 636 is my favourite part, incredible what the composer could convey with just four or five strokes of the piano!
I really prefer this interpretation for Artur Rubistein`s one. Technical perfectionism may cause shortcomings in presentation on the other hand. IMHO, if it is allowed considering the pianist god...
If anyone is interested in understanding the intentions of the composer, please listen to the same piece performed by Artur Rubinstein. There are a number of posts on youtube.
This is still a good recording and how Horowitz plays it is unique to him. Without physically seeing either Horowitz or Rubenstein play I can hear the differences. To me, I find Horowitz' sharp notes to hard for me, and he plays that way for all the recordings i've heard. It is really to each his own and either way this is remarkable for 81 years old, I would be happy enough to be able to go to the bathroom on my own at 81!!!!
we are blessed to have this recording. Of course the quality is going to be inferior. Technology in the 80's blows compared to today. His legacy as well as Chopin's will last many, many years.
His playing really isn't about quality, is it? It's like he's not looking to be formal or gear his performance to make the audience feel a certain way, but instead he's just showing you what he thinks of the piece. There's a much more personal feeling to his playing than there is to the sound of most pianists nowadays, and it transcends labels like "bad" or "good." It's a whole different way of looking at music, but I think I prefer it, especially for solo music.
it is absolutely phenomenal that somebody can remember such difficult pieces and still be able to play them so perfectly and beautifully at that age. I don't play piano at the age of 17, but I think maybe I'll spend the rest of my life learning, so I can maybe play half as well when I'm 80 :D
bravo! excellent performance.. he lets his fingers do the talking. so many go overboard with body movements that are just nothing but show. this man is the real deal :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I feel that Chopin should be pushed and pulled more... and Im not talking about this specific song... i mean everything... this was probably the closest thing. the way he pauses a little bit before jumping to the next phrase... sometimes it feels a little to short though. and sometimes I hear something that doesn't fit. I wanna start studying Chopin more in depth to find out... I only started learning a few of his pieces.
Here is my response to the comment by "TheLovelyPiano" I have to say that this is NEVER the worst performance of this piece and i would also like to ask, Can u play like that when your 81? I would like to see you try, and fail.
While this is incredible!!!... I think I still prefer Rubenstein's interpretation. But the power Horowitz had [even at 80] is astonishing and lacking in Rubenstein's.
you clearly have an opinion from someone who doesn't know much about music. but it's still an opinion and it's yours. respected, although your tone is despicable. This man CAN PLAY.
It's just his style of playing I don't like. And by the way, I've been playing piano for 4 yrs. I think I know about music. I'm working on Chopin Scherzo no. 1. But it's not the music itself, it horowitz's style of playing that bugs me.
Wagner wrote about the concept of "Melos" which in musical terms corresponded to "Logos" as a representation not only of the word, but of reason. Noone understands the "Melos" of this composition better than Rubinstein, and for other interpreters of Chopin I would name Dinu Lipatti and Guiomar Novaes among my favorites. What Horowitz does here is nothing but butchery - was he not married to the daughter of that little Italian clockmaker Toscanini (Wanda?) here seen in the background. UGHHHH!
Man this is great! I think he is as good as Cortot on this, and that is praise indeed. I will not say he is better. As for Rubenstein, I did not think his rendition on youtube was as good as this. I still think that Rubenstein is great at Beethoven. For me, Cortot, Horowitz, Richter, Rubenstein and Barenboim are the big five. As an aside, I did see Horowitz as a child. He played on our home piano - Horowitz was travelling as an artist with the Vienna Boys Choir. Two were billeted at our house.
Well said. Rubinstein is the only one I can listen to besides Horowitz' version he did for CBS in the 60's who is my #1 of all times for THIS piece. By way of contrast I haven't got one single CD by and never hit it off with Pollini nor with any other of them others overly publicized guys.
@stradavarius exactly !! One thing about NYC-- You never know who you're gonna hear playing or singing next door,below or above you-- Fabulous - Thanks for the video!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
With Horowitz , what can one say, it was all about the legend built up by one eyed critics like Schonberg, all fingers and nothing, but nothing, going on between the ears. almost juvenile playing here...........
while i certainly agree that this is not his best playing, it is still quite impressive since he was around 81 years old, on lots on anti-depressent medications, was having memory lapses and had a loss of physical control
Are you actually serious? Why are you here listening to and posting negative comments on this video? Horowitz is very most likely more of a legend than you or I ever shall be. Have some repect for genious
I apologize, this must have been in reply to someone else's comment, however it somehow failed to register as such. It's been so long, I'm actually not quite sure what I was replying to, forgive me for that.
This is from the video "The Last Romantic", which is an excellent piece on Mr. Horowitz (and Steinway pianos). The recording was released by Deutsche Grammophon in 1983 or 84? I remember it well because it was a new release and the 2nd CD I purchased after making the switch from vinyl. It's nice to see Wanda Toscanini in the video too. What a performer!
Yes. And it is nothing compared with old versions. He played that Polonaise in the 70's and one outsanding version in the 40's. If you can listen to both recordings, you'll be astonished :-)
Chopin was so great. This piece sums up heroism itself, the overcoming - with each pass the melody approaches becoming more 'heroic' than the last and more complete... only at the end is it triumphant.
The uncertainty/overcoming of the hero at 632 - 636 is my favourite part, incredible what the composer could convey with just four or five strokes of the piano!
Parasmunt 3 months ago
El sentir un torbellino de emociones en esta preciosa melodía.
Nemraciram2306 4 months ago
Bravo! The perfect performance of one of the greatest pianists!
Sewerynaable 5 months ago
Bravo! Perfect performance of this maestro of the piano!
Sewerynaable 5 months ago
i wanna play that way when im 81!
Yaniss 7 months ago 3
Listen to Olli Mustonen`s one if you get hold of it !
MrAmax60 7 months ago
Horowtiz is the greatest pianist. But this piece was easily one of many of chopins love letters
Haamidpianoman 7 months ago
I really prefer this interpretation for Artur Rubistein`s one. Technical perfectionism may cause shortcomings in presentation on the other hand. IMHO, if it is allowed considering the pianist god...
MrAmax60 8 months ago
If anyone is interested in understanding the intentions of the composer, please listen to the same piece performed by Artur Rubinstein. There are a number of posts on youtube.
VivaRenata 8 months ago
Dommage que la vidéo soit saccadée: à mon sens, la meilleure de toutes les versions existentes de cette oeuvre !
Volodia1977 9 months ago
the best version of all.. though argerich's and rubenstein's is good, this is absurd
vernaza11 9 months ago
jajaja the stare of his eyes to the camera at the end of the video is fun
apodots 9 months ago
beautifful--full of pathos and humanity. Take that techno computer generated "music" worshippers. Your machines will NEVER achieve this. NEVER
lavacap1 9 months ago
jajajajajaja 6:54, he have a excellent memory for that age o.o
Stebanick 11 months ago
I feel like only horowitz truly understands that strange transition section before the recap of the first theme. So wonderful!
bicsc7 1 year ago
Chess and Piano! A fantastic combination. I'm a pianist and chess player too :)
Horowitz was one of the best. This piece is simply amazing.
goldengab 1 year ago
@goldengab
me too jajjaja (y)
Stebanick 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
jesus christ, to all the people bitching about how they think he sucks here... he's 81. and he still plays better than you ever will.
rjgxjhs 1 year ago
he wears a suit in his own house
MrPneunomia 1 year ago 21
@MrPneunomia thats how much of a badass he is
louis621 1 year ago
@MrPneunomia He's that cool.
roshidon 1 year ago
@MrPneunomia i were a suit in my house all the time, i didnt know that i was special haha
nmbanana 1 year ago
@MrPneunomia кэп
Alexgolodenko 3 months ago
@MrPneunomia It's from the film "The Last Romantic".
AndStar100 1 month ago
This is still a good recording and how Horowitz plays it is unique to him. Without physically seeing either Horowitz or Rubenstein play I can hear the differences. To me, I find Horowitz' sharp notes to hard for me, and he plays that way for all the recordings i've heard. It is really to each his own and either way this is remarkable for 81 years old, I would be happy enough to be able to go to the bathroom on my own at 81!!!!
mystere485 1 year ago
Oh, he's 81. That explains it.
lllllllllllllll88 1 year ago
I hope I can love anything for as long as he loved piano.
jetfour07 1 year ago
I cant believe he can remember all that notes, but when you love it you die with it.
What a Legendary man
InSaNiTyRaNgE 1 year ago 2
@InSaNiTyRaNgE - Good point. I should have thought of that comment because this sounds like crap. But you put it in proper perspective. Thank Q
lllllllllllllll88 1 year ago
@lllllllllllllll88 np truly he is a legend on a piano
have u seen the movie The Pianist. i love it
InSaNiTyRaNgE 1 year ago
Horowitz- Polonaise Op. 53 "Heroic"
ac3761G 1 year ago
Yes he's old but he feels young when he plays this music :)
cesgarc 1 year ago
i don't know about music but my heart says this good :)
cesgarc 1 year ago
we are blessed to have this recording. Of course the quality is going to be inferior. Technology in the 80's blows compared to today. His legacy as well as Chopin's will last many, many years.
akagrin 1 year ago
This camera doesn't have the best mic. Nonetheless, I still hear the beauty!
JohnnyStricklett 1 year ago
His playing really isn't about quality, is it? It's like he's not looking to be formal or gear his performance to make the audience feel a certain way, but instead he's just showing you what he thinks of the piece. There's a much more personal feeling to his playing than there is to the sound of most pianists nowadays, and it transcends labels like "bad" or "good." It's a whole different way of looking at music, but I think I prefer it, especially for solo music.
BenMcCormack91 1 year ago
What piano is this?
1023george 1 year ago
@ScarletRonin idiot, dont spam at good music.
solow1991 1 year ago
one of the best pianist in the history of music.
coolasianbrian 1 year ago
it is absolutely phenomenal that somebody can remember such difficult pieces and still be able to play them so perfectly and beautifully at that age. I don't play piano at the age of 17, but I think maybe I'll spend the rest of my life learning, so I can maybe play half as well when I'm 80 :D
violent0heart 1 year ago
Dude most people cant even move their fingers at the age of 81 years old, let alone playing piano....
Desmonddd2002 1 year ago
horowitz se inmortalizo con su musica
PrisLN 2 years ago
Magnífico.
mkcrisolrm 2 years ago
maestro!!!!
asdlkfjghklawuieg 2 years ago
my family had the exact couch back in 1985!
thedrip 2 years ago 23
bravo! excellent performance.. he lets his fingers do the talking. so many go overboard with body movements that are just nothing but show. this man is the real deal :)
joe69rocket 2 years ago
Master
DanielMrtinzAngls 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I feel that Chopin should be pushed and pulled more... and Im not talking about this specific song... i mean everything... this was probably the closest thing. the way he pauses a little bit before jumping to the next phrase... sometimes it feels a little to short though. and sometimes I hear something that doesn't fit. I wanna start studying Chopin more in depth to find out... I only started learning a few of his pieces.
IxCloudxIx 2 years ago
que increible como maneja expresivamente la obra es increible!!! que gran pianista!!!! MAESTRO!!!!!!!
juanithor001 2 years ago 3
he should be able to play this piece in his sleep
callenishss 2 years ago 3
technique still within correctness. as long as all pressing motions come from the elbow joint not individual finger joints
callenishss 2 years ago
Here is my response to the comment by "TheLovelyPiano" I have to say that this is NEVER the worst performance of this piece and i would also like to ask, Can u play like that when your 81? I would like to see you try, and fail.
Horowitz is a genius
Horowitz never banged the piano
Even genius's make mistakes
MrVladimirHorowitz 2 years ago 3
@MrVladimirHorowitz Hear hear. By the way, why do you think "TheLovelyPiano" has such an unlovely way of talking about great pianists?
DeepPhilosopher5 2 years ago
incredible. is he really at eighty??
akihirori 2 years ago
no, 81
Sotox92 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This sux. Wrong notes, banging. This must be his worse performance of this piece, I hope. lol
I can't even listen any more. My ears!
TheLovelyPiano 2 years ago
It's amazing at 81.
anderwold1 2 years ago
There's a better recording of him playing this piece...
hellomate639 2 years ago 3
While this is incredible!!!... I think I still prefer Rubenstein's interpretation. But the power Horowitz had [even at 80] is astonishing and lacking in Rubenstein's.
Argh! They're both excellent!
isayhi72 2 years ago
wtf he got 14 fingers :D?
tibaninvio 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Horowitz sucks! I hate the way he plays. No, I'm not kidding! He's horrible!
fredericballade4 2 years ago
you clearly have an opinion from someone who doesn't know much about music. but it's still an opinion and it's yours. respected, although your tone is despicable. This man CAN PLAY.
anizato 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
It's just his style of playing I don't like. And by the way, I've been playing piano for 4 yrs. I think I know about music. I'm working on Chopin Scherzo no. 1. But it's not the music itself, it horowitz's style of playing that bugs me.
fredericballade4 2 years ago
@fredericballade4 i bet dynamics bug you to, oh and individualism as well
nmbanana 1 year ago
Wagner wrote about the concept of "Melos" which in musical terms corresponded to "Logos" as a representation not only of the word, but of reason. Noone understands the "Melos" of this composition better than Rubinstein, and for other interpreters of Chopin I would name Dinu Lipatti and Guiomar Novaes among my favorites. What Horowitz does here is nothing but butchery - was he not married to the daughter of that little Italian clockmaker Toscanini (Wanda?) here seen in the background. UGHHHH!
VivaRenata 2 years ago
@VivaRenata Love to see how you're doing at 81
Morfee 11 months ago
@Morfee Really intelligent posting! Many compliments.
VivaRenata 11 months ago
He is crazy but amazing pianist!
NEC02102Justin 2 years ago
Comment removed
feuip 2 years ago
It's very different from the other tenditions I've heard of this piece.... I liked it very much!!!! I hope someday I'll play it!!!
feuip 2 years ago 3
you wont.
Sotox92 2 years ago
yes, I will.... maybe not like him, but I will.... hahahahahah but thank you for the encouragement
feuip 2 years ago
It's playable, don't worry. It may take a couple months to learn if you have the time to put in enough time to actually practice.
fdsajklj 2 years ago 2
Incredible. It's restrained, poised, but full of gusto, and it's as if you hear the appreciation of a full life playing itself out.
Lukecash12 2 years ago 2
My idol, I hope I can still play Star Spangled Banner at his age.
killingangel707 2 years ago 5
this is not the best of him....but i like his interpretations
diegorzynski 2 years ago 2
Man this is great! I think he is as good as Cortot on this, and that is praise indeed. I will not say he is better. As for Rubenstein, I did not think his rendition on youtube was as good as this. I still think that Rubenstein is great at Beethoven. For me, Cortot, Horowitz, Richter, Rubenstein and Barenboim are the big five. As an aside, I did see Horowitz as a child. He played on our home piano - Horowitz was travelling as an artist with the Vienna Boys Choir. Two were billeted at our house.
swanningaround 2 years ago 2
I agree with your assessment, but you might want to consider adding Jorge Bolet and Emil Gilels to your list.
RandDguy 2 years ago
Rubinstein is very good, but Horowitz is better for a few ( and very few there are) reasons
1 no one is louder than Horowitz
2 he is more dot the dot cut the cut which makes him a little more expressive and
3 he is a little cleaner in transitions
btw it's not a trick piano
watch his other performances of this piece
Damonkeyboy123456789 2 years ago 3
Well said. Rubinstein is the only one I can listen to besides Horowitz' version he did for CBS in the 60's who is my #1 of all times for THIS piece. By way of contrast I haven't got one single CD by and never hit it off with Pollini nor with any other of them others overly publicized guys.
12rosebud12 2 years ago
horowitz IS better than rubinstein, but he's really not that great on this piece, argerich and rubinstein play it better for sure
FlyLikeASuperhero 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
demosj 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
me too giulygiuly22;)
rubinstein is perfect!!!
horowitz is good,he is a profesionist too,but rubinstein is better:)
musiclove237 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I prefer Rubinstein version...he's more fluent and passionate!!!
GiulyGiuly22 2 years ago
Estaba a punto de decir lo mismo, coincido en lo absoluto contigo, prefiero a Rubinstein, es la mejor en mi opinion.
zicekanelo 2 years ago
its actually full of boringness :D:D horowitz is unbeatble ... they are all geniuses dont get me wrong but Horowitz its untachable ! :)
fluence88 2 years ago 3
horowitch you are a good pianist. you likee
but you broken this piece
cescuuuu 2 years ago
bravo
tomkiel 2 years ago
The same. ²
suellio 3 years ago
lucky neighbours
stradavarius 3 years ago 113
@stradavarius exactly !! One thing about NYC-- You never know who you're gonna hear playing or singing next door,below or above you-- Fabulous - Thanks for the video!!
lpvcrcd 1 year ago
I wish I could have met this man and watched him play...
Polskapan 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
ryab55 "Is Horowitz still alive? No, but his trick piano is still around.
mikecaffey 3 years ago
what's a trick piano?
iPikee 3 years ago
id like to see you play this when you're 81
JWarwicksoccer 3 years ago
analxixen you have no clue what you're talking so you might as well just not post any comment..."juvinile" haha... what a joke!
JWarwicksoccer 3 years ago
is horrowitz still alive if he is he be like 90 years old right now.
ryab55 3 years ago
he is already dead
tempohyeah 3 years ago
He died in 1989 at age 86
John19182004 3 years ago
it´s my dream to have steinway at home...
hugotoxxxxx 3 years ago 32
This comment has received too many negative votes show
With Horowitz , what can one say, it was all about the legend built up by one eyed critics like Schonberg, all fingers and nothing, but nothing, going on between the ears. almost juvenile playing here...........
analxixen 3 years ago
while i certainly agree that this is not his best playing, it is still quite impressive since he was around 81 years old, on lots on anti-depressent medications, was having memory lapses and had a loss of physical control
bobmario511 3 years ago 6
bobmario511 - not actually, he was off the drink and drugs. he was regaining his strength here.
kasyapa 1 year ago
@bobmario511
You mean he was taking anti-depressants - AND HE COULD STILL PLAY THIS GREAT???
I need to hear him at his prime.
An astounding musician.
amoxtlacatl 1 year ago
@analxixen
Are you actually serious? Why are you here listening to and posting negative comments on this video? Horowitz is very most likely more of a legend than you or I ever shall be. Have some repect for genious
RichieCarvaliho 1 year ago
You're not alone, that's guaranteed.
Fnkyazn67 3 years ago
I apologize, this must have been in reply to someone else's comment, however it somehow failed to register as such. It's been so long, I'm actually not quite sure what I was replying to, forgive me for that.
Fnkyazn67 3 years ago
why not a junk whirlitzer grand
lukefenderrhodes 1 year ago
@hugotoxxxxx Mine is to house Horowitz (necessarily with his piano) at my home.
Kurremkarmerruk1 1 year ago
@hugotoxxxxx Mine too!
Kakarot21591 1 year ago
This is from the video "The Last Romantic", which is an excellent piece on Mr. Horowitz (and Steinway pianos). The recording was released by Deutsche Grammophon in 1983 or 84? I remember it well because it was a new release and the 2nd CD I purchased after making the switch from vinyl. It's nice to see Wanda Toscanini in the video too. What a performer!
EcuaScot1 4 years ago
Very refined - interesting to hear how he would play in his living room, as opposed to a concert hall.
fdartmouth 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
about as refined as being hit over the head by a mallett
analxixen 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Obnoxious
Polskapan 3 years ago
Outstanding, especially so close to his death. Such energetic left-hand octaves at around 4:23! Looks like him playing at his home, right?
Thanks for sharing this.
MrRobertZ 4 years ago
Yes. And it is nothing compared with old versions. He played that Polonaise in the 70's and one outsanding version in the 40's. If you can listen to both recordings, you'll be astonished :-)
lhiram23 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
outstandingly bad , at the very most
analxixen 3 years ago