What if I had never let you go

[MilaKaulitzTH]

Oh,MY GOD , I'm crying !!

The video is so beautiful...

I love the laughter of Kaulitz :)

[magneticmandy]

@MilaKaulitzTH That's very sweet! Thank you :)

[NonameNobodey]

A woman or a Man ???

Uhh.. Her name is Bill ?

[BeautifulgirlOo]

It's really a beautiful song!

And video is beautiful. Bill Beautiful! Ahahahahahah D:

Not really .... did you see looking at him?

Simply amazing with makeup, without makeup, what does it matter? Is perfect, who says that? Die! ♥ ♥ ♥

And they need to come to Israel, I'm from Israel, and they came only in 2007. I miss it!

: (: (: (: (

[SophixxTH]

Great clip & great song,you can even believe you was with Bill together.... ;)

[ajsh10]

lol I remember the first time I heard this song when bill was lip syncing to it

I laughed so hard

he is so georgeous

[aylabo]

yes me too...and i love it...

[marcoamokl]

shittt,,, omg

[SugarStar15]

hey,

he is a star but do you you know the real Bill?

.........

[magneticmandy]

@SugarStar15

'haha no. no no i don't.

[123456789charlotte33]

This is really good :]

[holz96xxx]

this is brilliant well done magneticmandy i absolutely love bill and this song is on his " party in genevea" it is such a bill song xx

[magneticmandy]

haha thanks. i sort of embarrassed. i could do so much better now.

[magneticmandy]

i am*

[SophixxTH]

@magneticmandy It's great, you couldn't done any better!!!! <3

[666IfOnly]

i used to be head over heels in love with him but shit happened now its just hard to listen to them, this brings back memories...

[CrazyLeacePeace123]

i hope i´ll never stop loving them...

it sounds so sad when you all say that you used to be fans and now...

well

i still love tokio hotel and that´s good...^^

And WOW

Such a beautiful song, video, and.....

WOW! :D

[magneticmandy]

haha thank you so much

[carolain2212]

geniales video =) ;)

[emopnk15]

he has the most beautifull smile and eyes lol im such a sucker for brown eyes :) good job on the vid

[emopnk15]

i lovvve this vid me and ma friend soraya watched it and thought that bill looks bare cute :)

[squeezebalah]

:D Bill Kaulitz made this song popular. XDD

[magneticmandy]

he sure did ;)

[pinkflowerme]

i love it! the best <3<3<3

[sortpunk]

I think this is a really beautiful video..

And I understand your thoughts..

Just really beautiful

[magneticmandy]

thaaaank you (':

[Liezzx]

This feels so weird... It's a beautiful video. But I used to be so in love with him, and now it's just, almost fading away. I think Tokio Hotel already had their best time. If they don't come back like who they used to be, I'm not longer a fan, I think. For the moment, I still like them, but not as much as I did a few years ago.

[rasmus1tokiohotel]

It's so sad. It reminds me of how I was with another band. I kinda forgot about them for Tokio Hotel. :'<

But I still really REALLY adore both the old band and Tokio Hotel. :]

I like the video much. ;)

[magneticmandy]

oh, that's good for you. what's the name of the other band you like? :)

thank you :D i'm glad you like it.

though i'm not into tokio hotel at all anymore. it's weird.

[rasmus1tokiohotel]

The band was The Rasmus. I still love both though. ;)

And dont' worry, it's normal to all of a sudden realize that you aren't a fan of something like you once were. I totally know the feeling. xD It is really weird though. But I'm sure there will always be a spot in your heart for Tokio Hotel. ;)

[magneticmandy]

i don't know "the rasmus", but maybe i should check 'em out sometime.

yeah, but it's just craaaz'aaayy how much they meant to me and how that feeling can like.. just disappear. but of course, they'll probably be something i will remember frm my childhood when i grow old or something :D

[jazzisievers]

im in a huge tokio hotel phase right now i mean my walls and celling and chair and deask r coverd in pictures

omg i hate being obsessede and i cant wait till the day comes when i go up to my walls and rip all the pics down

but for now im doomed

mein gott i love them so much

i need help xD

[UnderweightGoddes]

iknow what you mean! xD

[magneticmandy]

i've been there, my friend.

now i don't even remember what it felt like being a "fan".

i suck.

[Ashley23Domik]

fuj

[magneticmandy]

excuse me? :)

[erasmusisthebest]

:') wow! I feel totally the same! I had this Tokio Hotel period. It's over now, and I'm pretty happy 'bout that. I mean, c'mon, they DO look girlish! besides, no-one in my community even likes them... But sometimes I miss that fan-thing... That great feeling of belonging in a group of fans... when I listen to their songs now, I really feel like this indeed. They ARE hot anyway! omg I miss them...

[magneticmandy]

what a lovely long comment :)

i think we're pretty much in the same boots here. cause i never listen to their music anymore, and they have become some sort of. you know. more and more people find them detestable. not that i do too, i just don't like them anymore.

it's the sad truth.

[erasmusisthebest]

:D indeed!!! in the past, when I listend to their songs, i realy felt... well... touched? blabla, nearly crying. now i only feel sad, because of the missing. and jet... i don't realy like them so i don't want it back... :P it's weird. Love this to btw :D

[magneticmandy]

oh god, me too. i could easily cry when i listened to 'rette mich' or 'spring nicht' or 'heilig' or.. well 'an deiner seite'. whoa, mentioning all of these songs kind of makes me miss it a little bit too.

it is weird. but it's even more weird how much a band can actually mean to you, right?

and if you're talking about the video, then thank you so much :) !

[erasmusisthebest]

:P yes I am, nice pics and awsome song!

:'( Heilig & an deiner seite were my favorite ones to! And Ich bin nicht ich...

[katylovetom483]

great vid and the song is good too

[ToBillKaulitzHo]

great job! :D love bill<33333333

[KandJloveTOKIOHOTEL]

ISNT KATE WINSLET FROM TITANIC?

[magneticmandy]

sure, she is :]

[lovlygirl23]

yes

[farehgazrani]

This song reminds me of Bill too, because I saw a video with him, and he sang the song. Lovely song.

[superschalkerin]

i think the video great,but i can´t the band,sry

[superschalkerin]

ich hasse tokio-hotel,also sage ich nur:das arme Lied,das kann ja nix dafür !!!

[magneticmandy]

in english please

[lovlygirl23]

he or she said i hate tokio hotel i also think it's a waist of the song to put bill in it  :)

it's not my opinion i'm only the messeneger ;)

[magneticmandy]

thank you for telling me :)

waist of the song? well telling me how much he or she did NOT like my video sure isn't waist of time xD

[Happy7Happy7Me]

waste not waist ;D

sorryyyyyyyy im so anoyying.

[magneticmandy]

haha, oopsi.

that's ok. i know that 'waist' is a part of the body - i guess i didn't really think about it since lovlygirl23 misspelled it :)

english is not my native language anyway, you know.

[Happy7Happy7Me]

oh cool lol, sorry :)

i know, i live in Italy and so i have to try and speak italian (i hate my parentsfor moving me here) and if someone wrote something wrong i would just write it too lol

[toribabekit]

totally! everytime i hear this i think of bill und his fan xDD

this video und song is PERFECTION

[OrangeMg]

I LOVE this video! The song is perfect too!!

[1993alex1]

Reminds Me Of Our Nathan Owen... R.I.P Nathan

luv u and miss u

x x x

[ColbyTwentyOne]

Ha ha ha!!!!!! XD

Omg every time I hear this song now I think of Bill belting out this with the fan!

I like 2:01 when Bill is at the concert holding up his hand. That is in Oberhausen right? but which concert was it?

CAN ANYONE HELP? :3

[PiinQFaiRy]

*____*

love it <3

[magneticmandy]

thank you (':

[Stely95]

italian

[Stely95]

beautiful video!

[magneticmandy]

Oh thank you!

In which language? :]

[Stely95]

Stupendo!!!!!!

[magneticmandy]

What does it mean?

[flowerprincessxTH]

It's so beautiful...

I really love your vids :)

[Manda3307]

such a good videoooo!!

[mitchelsfan1yupps]

love it love it love it!!!!=)5 stars

[suxelyth]

Congratulations on the video! Wonderful!

[Joanneandbill]

it's weird cause he's actually singing this song on episode 36 tokio hotel tv :)) great video

[magneticmandy]

i know :'D didn't you see the part of my vid when the time's at 00:42? He's sooo adorable when he's "singing" that part =D

[xRWTYx]

beautiful video!

Videos like these make me loving him more.

[magneticmandy]

really? well i'm very honered then (':

[SamNik12]

bill bill bill <3 =D

he is the most amazinge boy in the world!

[o2amber]

Wauw.

Really it's so good !

Beautifull video

[BSProbine]

this is so amazing!

so lovely

good work!

kisses

[KHheartsbroken]

omg ammmaaazzzziiinggg so cute.

[mcflylovexoxo]

i love this video...!!

great job on it!! i love bill and the song fits in with it!!

[magneticmandy]

really, thank you soo so much (':

[Denezhka]

This vid is SO beautiful and funny, and touching... just perfect! I like it a lot!

Thanks so much for this piece of magic =)

[magneticmandy]

aww u' welcome : DD i'm glad you like it!

[diilovesbillsomuch]

The end <3

The laugh of my boy. <3

[xmanon96]

omg, a beautiful video! i really like it!

[monaguns]

la encontre!!!!

estoy tan tan feliz

[magneticmandy]

what does that mean?

[minbedstedreng]

It reminds me of my aunt.. I was visiting her and because of my boyfriend i went home 2 days before it was planned.. The day after i went home, she had a heartattack, and she died on the hospital because her boyfriends came home to late to safe her.. And i keep thinkin; If i didnt left 2 days before, she would still live.. So what if i had never let her go??

But i still love this song and i still love Bill.

[magneticmandy]

oh, i'm so sorry to here that, but please don't "blame" yourself like that..

but yeah. bill's the best. and this song's so great.

[minbedstedreng]

Yeah, i know. And all my friends keep saying "PLEASE stop putting the blame on yourself!" But still i keep thinking how it would have been if i didnt went home to early..

[amandaandallison]

its kinda how this song reminds u of bill because he was singing this in one of tokio hotel tv videos

[magneticmandy]

what are you talking about?

[amandaandallison]

oh sorry i said tht wrong like i dont no wht i was typing thts really off of wht i ment but nvm

[RoastedxPeanut]

b-e-a-utiful!

really, i love this vid!

good job!

[magneticmandy]

b-e-a-utiful? :'D I say that all the time. Don't know why you needed to know that.

But thank you so much! =D

[LoveTHLoveBill]

OMG!!! Very Beautiful Video!!!

[magneticmandy]

Ih thank yooou! I'm glad you like it.

[Billsjumbie]

Bill du bist meine Welt <3

I just love the song and the video

nice made !

[magneticmandy]

Thank you so much (:

Bill's the bestiiiiest :'D

[LoveDistrict]

Aaaaah sexy O_O

[ActiLemon]

Really good! Greate idea put that clip when he sing this same song too :D

[magneticmandy]

Thank you!

Yeah, that was actually that clip which gave me the idea for the video =D

[BillsRockMaus483]

Bill ich liebe dich so sehr 5*