Added: 3 years ago
From: ninofficial
Views: 110,112
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (272)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 2008 best year of my life!!

  • I love it! Damn Trent just keeps making great songs and even though his music evolves its always NIN..... 👽

  • What was that look he gave Robin at 0:22? o_O

  • @cyphr6 True love.

  • NIИ !!!

  • I'll trying dancing to this song... While my eyes closed...

  • this is one sexy video

  • The riff is fucking out of this world.

  • NO NINE INCH AFROS!!

  • God The Slip is so good

  • wow.is the DVD FROM SLIP,buying the cd/dvd package right now

  • where can i download some bootleg with all this AOL SESSION?

  • I WANT THAT drum machine!!!!

  • Yay! Im the first to actually like this video

  • badfuckingass!

  • Now ! I know that they served the devil ! Remember nine inch nails clip closer,the metronome with the all seeing eye.GO preach horus and the evil minions.Peace

    You are all deceivers !

  • Robin Finck...yeah...and love this version..

  • @RRyyNNee He's not. At least not playing.

  • Gives the guitarist such a dirty look at 0:25 lol

  • @toonooky its not an dirty look..

  • is lohner there?

  • O.O Trent's guitar is strung up lefthanded.

  • @kyletheenigma i don't think it is

  • What a way to play...

  • this songs a winner, as in it should win awards. Cuz its that fucking good.

  • How can I download this as an mp3? This version is wayyyy better than the album one.

  • @23house23 PM me your email address and I can send you the mp3 of this.

  • @Marc7665

    Thanks man, much appreciated.

  • @23house23 No problem bro! I sent it while ago. :)

  • Singing "Lalalala" has never been so sexy.

  • Trend Reznor is amazing. I grew up listenning to this guy and he is still great and inventive. Great song, great sounds. True talent doesn't fade away with time. Robert Finck rocks.

  • someone what the pickup in this Robin Finck guitar?

  • @danielhl22 Looks like the pickup has been removed and the hole covered up with gaffer tape to me.

  • Trent Reznor is *AWESOME*!!!!!!!!!!

  • @kmwerewolf That's a understatement

  • 2 people will never get to him in there

  • I love NIN and Trent's jacket!

  • the end of this is perfect.

  • I love it when Trent says; "now you just slowly fade away" and the camera gets out of focus. Nice touch!

  • I need that drum machine Josh has...

  • @mythkid1208 They sold it on eBay. :)

  • @mozzaman NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!! HOW DID I MISS IT?

  • @mythkid1208 I'm not sure - they ebay'd about 90% of their touring gear from 1989 - 2009 about a year ago

  • @mythkid1208 hey if you have a Iphone or Ipod you can download a free app that is a lot like it called D0TS Echoplex

  • @bullsfan93 Great! I use my iPod touch a lot, I need to check it out

  • Reznor won an Oscar!!

    So fucking great!!!

  • his voice just echoes off my walls. lol i LOVE the song/vid!

  • Hi there does anyone know what kind/make of drum machine that is?

  • The drums sound so fucking good in this version.

  • Friday morning and i'm here again...it almost seems it been a week since i saw this and became addicted...oh wait.

    I only wish there was more of this type of material...

  • If that is the same guitar Robin used in March of the Pigs...then it's just amazing...

    Just about 4 days ago i got really obsessed with NIN and Finck...i've known Nine Inch Nails since i cam remember but...i don't know. Ever since i saw the Live Version of Only i got hooked...

  • Sounds better than the album version thanks to the lice drums.

  • This is so much better than the album version!

  • Nothing like Illuminati free music.

  • i wonder what status trent will apply in music history

  • The sound of the bass still haunts me in my sleep...

  • Best rehearsals ever. This has to be the 30th time i've watched these videos.

  • Just beautiful.

  • this is AMAZING ..... i LOVE it! better than some old boring video. hats off to Rob! btw ... who's the bass player?

    almost forgot ..... i LOVE the LaLa's! :)

  • @DigitalBitch100 okay .

  • Good song, good album.

  • i fuckin love the ending!

  • most of this geniuine song ending is so great because of Alessandro, he´s a genius! check out his music if you havent done it yet! ;) Trent knows who should he hire, only the best

  • whats the touch screen and program that josh is using to set the loops?

  • Best NIN song in years.

  • @23house23 Very expensive, high-tech, drum machine

  • what is the thing the drummer is using at the start

  • @Rusty2540 Jazzmutant Lemur.

  • That song is so professional and mindcrushing. NIN are the best rock band at the moment. Electronic waves and power riffs, and something that I don't know how call it. A really really sick song. And they aren't just a band, it's like a movement. Trent is a Fuckin genius. Since I bought Pretty Hate Machine I saw the evolution, the sperimentalism. Things that today in music are disappeared.

  • i love this performance. the ending is so magnificant!

  • i love that ending! is more musical than the album version

  • This is fukkin amazing! I love it! Trent Reznor is genius! NIN FOR LIFE!!!!!

  • this is such an amazing performance of an awesome song. i like the band selection.

  • 100-2000 same girl : )

  • gran cancion trent n finck

  • Unfortunately there being STIFLED under his jacket...don't worry,they're there.... : )

  • @DigitalBitch100

    I don't see a single clam on him. I don't know what you're talking about.

  • I hope they come to Toronto...XD

  • i hope nin comes to edmonton again

  • 1st time i heard this song, album,or rehersal. i like this version :). seems though i like most of the rehersal versions, just me :)

  • I prefer the rehearsal of echoplex over the album version :P

  • co ty pierdolisz koleś??

  • no, ten utwór jest totalnie bezpłciowy ... ;)

  • jak ktoś ma "kudłaty" w nicku, to znaczy, że za dużo o muzyce nie wie ;]

  • dobrze, że przynajmniej szyderca potrafi z siebie wprawnie ZASZYDZIĆ ;)

  • szydzę z Ciebie ;]

  • damn i cant hear the beast bass song with my shitty speakers.. this song closer and piggy have great bass rythm

  • whats the program that guy uses there?

  • what happened to sexyiHoney90?

  • ...Sure, I'll give it a sniff.

  • The thing is called "Lemur"

  • Comment removed

  • is so fuking amazing i love this son and trent reznor it's so brilliant this men

  • hey, is the guy playing third guitar also in Queens of the stone age? I think he is. He gets all the best gigs!

  • I didnt see any third guitar. You mean the dude with the Afro?

  • Justin Meldal-Johnson, NIN's latest bassist. Allesandro Cortini (I think) is running the synths and keyboards, he has a guitar as well, and Trent and Robin Finck both have guitars too. If you group a bass in with lead and rhythm guitars, there's 4 guitars, and then add in the drum machine, Josh Freese drumming, and 4 people singing, you've got 10 different audio sources in one song. Incredible, isn't it? Gotta love NIN. Well done Trent.

  • And the beauty of it is that it's very minimalistic as well and every beat has its place but isn't overbaring, which was the case a bit on older NIN material which I love of course, but sometimes feels a bit crowded... if you see what I mean.

  • It's sorta like the NIN "Wall of Sound", as in the end of Mr. Self Destruct, and Burn, but stripped-down, refined, and formed into many different coherent melodies that work in harmony. It's unbelievable, when you think about it.

  • stfu.

  • @briani4735263 And yet it manages to stay so simple... HOW DO THEY DO IT???

  • @briani4735263 when linkin park tries to do that it sounds like total shit (their new album)

    which goes to show Trent's musical genius.

  • @briani4735263

    That's what makes this song so great. It gently adds layer after layer until it suddenly kicks your teeth in.

  • @briani4735263 man , keeo in mind that every audio source is in stereo ...

    thet gives you 20 mix channels ... you must love them 4 that :) ) )

  • @thomasrix No one in the LITS lineup ever played in qotsa. Aaron North played a couple shows with qotsa, but he left NIN after they finished touring in 2007.

  • Trent think of the pandas!

    they will have no music

    to listen to if you quit!

    :(

  • SOmeone who can explain me what kind of drum machine Josh using at the beginning? and someone else tell me how you do sounds like the ones you hear on NIN records..is by editing in specific programs or? just asking since i'm interested in doing my own thing..

  • That device is a Lemur, made by JazzMutant. Really really cool multi-touch device.

  • i cant waste the time it takes to log out of my wifes and into my account so heres my comment,

    WOOT TRENT! you rock my socks dude! just utterly amazing, over and over, its true, all of the comments, you are awesome, you grow, you get better and better and yes, even better.

    i saw a few comments and heard a few rumors about your retirement?? that would make me the BIGGEST sad panda of all time! OF ALL TIME!!!

    dont make me a sad panda, no sad panda for me :'(

    KEEP ROCKIN!!!

    Lopt_out

  • Go back to listening Linkin Park and let us listen to good Music.

  • Why did you even censor fucking? Go back to listening to the Jonas Brothers you faggot.

  • I ll do, thanks, kinda similar to this actually, I ll feel right at home!!

  • No, Echoplex is a perfect song, NIN's best song, in my opinion, and possibly one of the greatest industrial songs ever produced, in my opinion.

    If you want to listen to Lil' Wayne rap about his guns (which he was arrested for, by the way), be our guest.

    We'll stay here listening to perfect music that doesn't need to say "niggas" every five seconds.

  • Uhh, why the fuck to respond to me about this trivial info? Lil Wayne?

    Dude, I live in Sweden, do you really think I give a fuck??

  • Yes. Yes, I do.

  • love at 2:30 where they just start jamming

  • i love this fucking song...la la la la la

  • get well soon trent! [he has NINfluenza]

  • Truly one of the most talented musicians of today!! Thanks for everything over the Years Trent!!!! My life just won't be the same without the prospect of new NIN material just over the horizon!

  • I think that this is the only group out there that i actually love what they have become - they have matured - yet stayed true to their fans from the beginning.

  • <3 goshh.

  • No doubt: Justin is the coolest guy in the world

  • Is it just me or does he look incredibly bored all the time?

  • He's not bored, he's just  the least aerodynamic in the band (by the way, Meathead said goodbye :(

  • La la la la la la la la la la la...

  • Cant wait to see Nin concert in California

  • its amazing how it sounds exactly like it does from the album

  • Robin has such a warm tone compared to Aaron.

  • All the bands playing alive should sound as good as NIN does. I mean Trent sounds great!

  • Agreed. Year Zero and the Slip are possibly my favorite NIN albums.

  • I LOVE NINE INCH NAILS !!!!!!!!

  • tight shit. Love the band setup and how they are facing each other.

  • what is the pad that Freese used to create the drum loop?

  • Not sure. All I know is that it's a sequencer.

  • Its call Jazz Mutant Lemur.

    a midi/interface controller.

  • Trent Reznor is a mutha fuckin' wordsmithin' genius.

  • jazzmutant lemur

  • whar is the beat maker machine the dummer s using at the begining of this video?

  • Echoplex drum simulator :)

  • Its call a Jazz Mutant Lemur.

    a midi/interface controller.

  • That guy has a mohawk AND dreadlocks!

  • it would be i still miss aaron and jeordie

  • Who the hell is Hugh Jackman? Trent Reznor = sexiest man alive !

  • Who Jackman? *Fixed*

  • gonna see them tomorrow ^^ hope trent's gonna play echoplex!

  • No i zagrał :D To był dopiero koncert!!!

  • chwała mu za to ! ile ja się naczekałam! :D

  • Nic mi nie mów, myślałam, że nie dożyję tej chwili :D A tu proszę!

  • yep and they played echoplex^^

  • 2.31, that guitar, so haunting...

  • Friggin' amazing. One of the best live recorded songs I've ever heard.

  • So so so incredible... Id give anything to watch that go down

  • wtf? are you like on crack?

  • haha kickass man!!!!

  • It's great to see a band that fuckin' owns and that doesn't wear make up and Hot Topic clothing.

  • FUCKING AMAZING! one of my faves...

  • Fucking great song.

  • looks like the Jazzmutant Lemur Multitouch Surface

    ca. 2000€

  • that studio setup looks intense!

  • best line up ever. I'm not even a huge fan of NIN, but i've been rocking out to this all day.

  • YEAH! NIN KICKS ASS!

  • there's a fair amount of truth in that,haha

  • "You Will never never never ever evera awhwhwhwwhwh get to me IN HEREEEEEE."

  • Great! Love it , La la la la la la xD.

    And I like the guitar in this and the beat...

    NIN are great as , And I know somone who asked me to share some NIN with him and im like oh cool cause I'm glad people are getting into NIN and he was in hes teenz I am 14. And I am gettin into stuff that was from the year i was born so its sweet. Trent Reznor is so so so clever.

  • its funny you say that because im they same way with 80s music and people older than me feel the same way about music right b4 there time or around when the were born like the 70s,

    i swear its the infomercials they play on kids networks like nick or cartoon net work where in my child hood it was the best of the 80s all night long commerical after commercial , for you i guess the best of the 90s.

  • Nah I got into 90s music on my own... Like NIN i got into on my own...

    But it's funny. I got into NIN from being a Marilyn Manson fan. I was like... Alright I'll play Starsuckers and I watched it... I didn't overly like it... Then I got back into it and I played Closer and from that momment I didn't go back. And I reconise The Perfect Drug. So yeah. I dug myself into 90s and vintage music without anyones help and strayed away from mainstream...