Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (672)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Go big, because you're home is on stage.

  • Okay, THAT was just downright beautiful! :)

  • i dont mean this in a mean way but you remind me more of the witch, no saying you look like one lol but you are fantastic! :) x

  • wow this is amazing

  • this is totally amazing your voice sounds so like the original it's just mind blowing!! wow!! just love this, you are so talented

  • You did an amazing job singing this song. All i can say is wow

  • For God's sake...Get famous already!

  • god damn, this is good.

  • you are AMAZING! a great actress and a PERFECT singer!

  • can you tell me what singing/ recording equipment you use as i am sort of clueless to that lol x x

    Thanks xx

  • Your really gd and super talented :) x x

  • SO.........GOOD........

  • and if you look at some of her other vids I put that shes a great singer its just this vid that it seems like shes lip singing.

  • Dude I'm allowed to think shes lip sining. If she isnt then I think she great, but I think she is. + Im entitled to my own opion so dont call me an idiot for my opion.

  • I know it might sound a little stupid, but I like your pronunciation! You sang very well, I liked it.

  • Very Good!!

  • hahahahahah oh my goodness this is awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Fire13Love21 I hate idiots like you, Fire13Love21.

  • you have talent!!

  • you are so amazing at musical theatre its unreal x

  • u look really stunning here!! Do you have an agent? :-)

  • haha i tricked my mom into think this was Judy singing

  • You are amazing!!!

  • wow judy garland would be so proud to here this,By far the best cover i've ever heard just beautiful

  • wow you should be in the wizard of oz movie remake because you would make the perfect dorithy

  • Judy Garland is not dead!

  • i just love just really love this song- it is just damn amazing- i can almost see these places vivid in my mind. A place of total peace. Shhhh listen and feel the effects the song brings. wow

  • this is absolutely incredible.

  • your an amazinly talented.... person not in just one thing. dressing, acting, singing, ext ext

  • Amazing

  • I'm crying! You've got a definate chance gal! Beaut -3

  • miss my childhood compulsions

  • Never stop singing, no matter what life throws at you NEVER stop, God gave you this gift for a reason. Live it to your full potential Look around everyone loves it and i know " You changed and you don't wanna do it anymore because you wanna do what what to love" But DAMN. Just think about hw happy you have always been in these videos and the joy you bring people!

  • you are gorgeous Natalie.. and you have an amazing voice

  • omg its so annoying i sing this once and everyones all like," o you sound just like judy garland" and im a like like shut the F up!!!!!!!!!!!! but still your very talented and awesome :)

  • You should sing the wishing well song from the old disney snow white. Now that's an awesome song

  • This is amazing. Do not let this talent go to waste :)

  • You have a beautiful voice for this, wonderful!!

  • i love your voice <3 that sounds great!

  • u r incredible and the only girl i've ever seen on youtube that does judy and this song justice (singing and acting wise!).

  • wow..i'm speechless, you're an amazing singer(:

  • wow you are wow amazing

  • yeah, and the black cat from tom & jerry sang this lying in a trash can = )))))

  • Thank you so much for singing this straight through the way it was written. You sang it so beautifully.

  • i loved the whole black and white theme too =]

  • You are phenomenal!!!!! This was the first song I ever sang. Thank you for being so amazing

  • wait....you were 17 when you sung popular?

    ...man

    you were born for matinée

  • good frekan job

  • haha i love that you dress up! its adorable! and ur voice is gorgeous!

  • Just FABULOUS Natalie xx

  • OMG, you sound JUST like Judy!!!!!! :) i love it!!

  • I can't believe it! the Pony tails, the outfit, filmed in black and white, and that voice that is always astounding. You out did yourself on this one. God I love you (In a platonic little sister kind of way) ... your friend Ron Tanon

  • your voice gives me a reminiscience of the 1940's talent from MGM

  • my dear : you are professional and well trained . keep up the good work ! there is a opening for you in acting and singing

  • Wow you look like just garland there. Amazing x

  • Jesus

  • Amazing, Natalie - perfect in fact.

  • your so amazing, i love how you get ingto character by getting into costume :)

  • simply gorgeous your voice is phenominal.

  • Wow youve got talent...hope you dont mind the post.....THE DREAMS OF MR MULDOON is now available on AMAZON KINDLE for 2.99.The publishers said this novel would make a great film.If you like the Wizard of Oz you will like this novel too.

  • btw: your opinion of Judy Garland in the description is absolutely correct, she's incredible, there's no one else like her. I'm sad she died so young, all that talent, gone too soon. I would've loved to meet her, she's inspired me in so many ways. <3

  • i love ur voice ..so beautiful

  • jeezy creezy you sound just like Judy Garland. And she was an amazing woman, someday little girls will look up to you like so many have looked up to her. Just keep up the good work. I know that i wouldn't have the guts to sing on here like you. thats why your awesome.

  • Lovely.

    XX, Gay

  • Im not asking im TELLING you to become the next big hit!

  • try out for american idol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • sooo beautiful!... you are one talented woman!

  • your voice is really reminiscent of Judy's here, so so beautiful! but I'm also hearing hints of Billie Holiday in there. if you start uploading vids again, do more lower register ballads, your voice fits them. gorgeous cover. <3

  • My sister has been a singer for quite a long time now and I had to show her this video and she said she had never heard someone sound so much like Judy!!! Ur amazing and do this song and Garland very very proud!!!

  • OMG GONEY--YOU ARE A TRUE STAR AND WOW MAY GOD GIVE YOU EVERY STAR IN THE SKY--YOU MADE ME CRY---REALLY--WOW I AM A TALENT DIRECTOR---DAVIS4TX@GMAIL.COM-­--AND MISS BROOKE SAY'S --YOU BET YOU CAN---WHY OH WHY---WOW

  • @BROOKE4TX Miss Brooke I see we are on the same musical wavelength . Super World Saver found you at the doorstep of Andy Williams' Summer Place and will now take you on a real romantic tour starting with The Buckinghams and Don't You Care. Then I want you to follow me to Smokey Robinson's classic that he wrote for his wife who had several miscarries and could not bear him children the title of the song is More Love

  • Who knew that Dorothy had so many posters on her wall... Go figure.

    Beautiful voice.

  • This video is my favorite so far.  I love the way you turn into such a Judy Garland like character. You are awsome!!

  • @XxBFFAnniexX no 710 people like the video, and 28 don't.

  • 28 people wish they could go somewhere over the rainbow.

  • @kimt1987 so do i. :)

  • ;_; Beautiful!

  • WOW!! have just spent over an hour listening to all your songs, what a voice you have on you! would love to comment on them all but this one really caught my attention, if you close your eyes you really sound like Judy Garland. keep up the good work and keep the videos coming. Amazing!!

  • wow it's amazing *.*

    i like your voice :)

  • You are so good!Your voice is like coice Judy!

  • I grew up to this song and you sing this awesome !!!

  • omg this is scary good...u sound just like her...this is absolutely amazing... i showed my mom and she got chills...;)

  • What a beautiful rendition of this song.

    I think that's the best version i've heard since the original.

    And you actually, at least to me anyway, look a little more like the book Dorothy than Garland.

    Just incredible.

  • I would make the video a little more brown like the original film. Black and white is good but no cigar. Your voice is the cigar though :) keep up judy 2.

  • 26 people jelaus

  • Gorgeous! OMG!! I love your singing =)!

  • :') ur absolutely amazing

  • That was beautiful...seriously you deserve to be famous! I mean really this is A-MA-ZING.You brought me to tears,I couldn't believe what I was hearing! You have such a wonderful gift...God bless you.

  • I absolutley love this video! I have heard so many covers of this song and none have ever been as good as yours! You get Judy and what the song is about! Your voice is amazing!

  • you guys sound exactly alike its freaky but awesommeee!

  • Nice bed! Gives it a nice touch!

    good singing tho.

  • You have such control over your voice! I'm jealous!

  • w

    o

    w

    !!!

    that was so amazing *-*

  • Wow you really do sound like Judy Garland :D maybe you will make it to broadway someday

  • Omg! you are soo amazing! you sound so much like judy garland its ridiculous!

  • Try out on American Idol! I'll be watching!

  • My mother's favourite song was Over the Rainbow and NO ONE could ever sing it to her liking (or mine) except Judy. My mother passed away last week and I just happened to stumble over your video tonight. I can't tell you (as I wipe tears out of my eyes to see the keyboard) how wonderful your voice is, what an incredible gift you have, and....how much joy and peace you've given a hurting heart tonight. God bless you.

  • @Judan98 As a singer, I feel I can speak on the behalf of almost all of us, a compliment like that is one of the best you can revive. You never know who you are singing to, and the amazing connections they feel to you when you sing. This is the purpose of music. To bring us together.

  • sexxxy dorothy : ]

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful

    :)

  • this is amazing

  • I love that you went full out, even making it black and white! Fantastic job :D

  • Love your hair :) your amazing omg omgomgomgomg

  • i am in awee

  • This is was the best that I've seen. LOVELY

  • Wonderful, don't ever let anyone tell you not to be you. You have that something in your voice. And this is from an old guy that likes Judy.

  • PERFECT. u could b dorothy in a heartbeat!

  • wow... that was pretty brave and artistic of you! you're very talented!

  • i think you have an amazing voice iv listened to a lot of your videos and if you could i would love to here you sing a dream is a wish your heart makes from disney i know you love disney lol please sing it!!!! (=

  • hm, oh, I love the original version and this probably

    could help me if i just realiased: I va got lot too much weight! I have to get less weight°

    And its not done with just to advise this in your next vodavone corner...

  • aww you look cute :) where did you get the mic.?? ps, love your hair...never cut it or get plastic surgery !!! lol, love your work :) xxx

  • i LOVE this song!!!! R.I.P Judy Garland

  • At first I was expecting nothing but garbage as this is a fan-sung song. Thanks for proving my expectations very wrong :)

  • I've got to agree with you when it comes to Judy Garland. Even after all the drug issues and criticism, she's the most amazing performer I've ever seen. She really is the epitome of talent.

  • holy shit

  • and you look like Judy Garland....like Dorothy actually!!!

  • Outstanding

  • I watched a lot of your different videos, and the most amazing thing I noticed is that you sound exactly like the singer who is suppose to sing the song! your voice can sound like anything you want, lucky!

  • YOU SOUND EXACTLY LIKE JUDY GARLAND! AMAZING!

  • check it

  • This is absolutely captivating somehow...

    very good. =)

    This is easily my favorite song EVER to perform. 

  • You would be perfect for Dorothy!!!!

  • You are absolutely stunning, your voice is amazing and I love you!

  • that was heart toaching and is nataile hawkins the person that plays dorthy in the wiz ard of oz because she has awonderfull voice

  • I saw a whole bunch of your videos, you are a great singer, plus I think it is so cool that you get into character...LOL

  • I've watched so many of your videos (totally amazing btw!), and this one in particular shows just how much your voice gravitates towards the tone/sound of the original artist. Interesting ability; especially watching you sing like Idina Menzel one minute, to Kristin Chenoweth or Judy Garland.

  • you sing like marry poppins:D

    but very amazing♥ 

  • love it (:

  • The moment you started singing, I clicked subscribe. <3

  • Wizard of Oz is my all time favorite movie and a friend said I should watch this, iI dont tihkn anyone does this song as good as Judy, so I was gonig in totally full of judgement but holy crap YOU ARE AMAZING!!!! if you are ever in a broadway show I will buy tickets the first day they go on sale!! You are unbelieveable talented!!!!!!

  • amazing!! i wish i could sing and act like you!

  • I miss your videos!! This is beautiful :)

  • is this in its original key? cause it sounds almost like judy? your really great and i see that tony award in your grasp

  • wow you keep singing this beautiful you are gonna win a tony award some day

  • Is she looking at me or some dude standing to her far faaar faaaaar left?

  • That was AMAZING!

  • You are awesome.

  • there r no words to explain how good you are! :D

  • Very good intonations! You are very talented. x

  • what kinbd of micraphone is that??

    you did wonderful! beautiful voice!!!

  • WOW! ... just.. wow! you have the accent down and her singing down and you have a BEAUTIFUL voice and you're a beautiful girl. keep up the good work!

  • you become famous if you are not already famous!

  • UH....AMAZING!!!!!!!! Perfect Tone, Perfect Pitch, Note Perfect, The Perfect Persormance! THUMBS UP!

  • so cute.......this songs hard to sing but you got it

  •  How could anybody have disliked this?!

  • AvidActress007 You have to contact me asap I work for a Film and Television Company and I have found myself listening to your videos for the last hour. You have a talent, the look, and the personality for this industry. I want to hook you up with the right people if you are interested? Let me know. S

  • you are like Judy Garland!!!

    how amazing!

    x

  • You sound just like her. Oh my godd. Haha, phenomenal.

  • wow that's not your voice. this makes me really mad. everyone thinks you're soo good when you're just a fake >:(

  • @jessisings4life7 lol, erm, how is she a fake? That's her real voice love.

  • @jessisings4life7 Um, excuse me, THIS IS her real voice.

  • for some reason this brought tears to my eyes...i dont know why

  • Beautiful voice!

  • Your voice is perfect for this song!!!

  • At least you point out in this that your trying to be someone else.

  • WOW!

  • i think u r good. do something to your talent.

  • wouw ....you're amazing!!!

  • exquisit. judy, is that you?

  • your voice is amazing. that was just as good as judy garlands. i cant even say how jealous i am of ur voice :)

  • AWW CUTE! YOU DRESSED UP AS DOROTHY! :)

  • I LOVE Judy Garland, so at first I was cocking my eyebrow and immediately judgemental... But I gotta tell you, giving it a chance I found myself listening and watching this like it really WERE Judy Garland. Words can't describe... You are fabulous. I only wish I could do what you can do. Thank you for posting!

  • How do you sing like this! lol ive been wondering for soo long how ppl sing like the 40's

  • Oh my freaking gosh you are amazing! I've seen all your other vidoes, your so animated and all kinds of wonderful! Keep up the awesome work! Are you on broadway yet?? If not...WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR???

  • you have a beautiful voice, but i feel like with each song, you sound like the original recording. i'm actually having a similar problem-it's best to not listen to the recording of a song you perform-learn it with a piano.

  • wow!!!! costume?? lol loved it

  • This is beautiful! I was listening to your other music and i love it! I want to sound just like you whenever i sing "Think of Me" from the Phantom of the Opera for my school musical.

  • omg i love this song and ur voice just makes it better

  • wow you really are amazing you look just like judy garland that it like seeing her ghost . you should get a movie deal because it they ever decide to do a remake of the wizard of oz I hope you get the part because I think you have a beautiful voice and you would make a wonderful actress . who knows mabe one day you might get an tony award for singing the most beautiful song on earth .

  • u can be an actress!!

  • Amazing....simply....amazing.

  • WOW, unbelievable! You're great! OMG

  • YOU ARE AMAZING!!!!!! You are destined to be a huge Broadway star!!!!

  • really awesome!

  • awesome... really awesome!

  • seriously, sometimes i wish putting thumbs down was impossible, because this is amazing, and who put their thumb down??

  • wtf stop it. seriosuly your breathtakingg.

  • Natalie é incrível, divertida, brilhante, linda, talentosa e eu amo assistir aos seus videos. O mundo merece conhecer você e seu talento. I love you Natalie.