Liam & Noel Gallagher, Paul Weller - Carnation

[VxRhys]

@TheHeavyJetsBand

Wasn't expecting that at all! Class sound.

[Ryang403]

LIAM YOUR ARE MAGICAL MAN MEGA PROPER SOUL

[coldandfrostymorning]

gets me every time I hear it. Absolutely amazing cover

[58busby58]

The only Jam song covered by sumbody else that sounds bettter than the original, brilliant!!

[WalshieBruv]

Stevey Cradock with hair, fuck, now that's a site haha.

[Nacho2716]

What da' voice!!!!

[mistermadferit]

Unbelievable Liam vocal!

[VxRhys]

That 12 string sounds the absolute tits!!!

[Multimen100m]

i love it,its great fooking song :):):)

[ultimatebuzz1]

Love this song and this tune is proof that liam is one of the best singers this country has produced awsome:)

[danielferrergarrido]

the voice is....well just amazing

[MrNeil562]

Dickhead Gallagher actually does a good job on this. It`s a pity his vocals weren`t so consistent with Oasis!

[VxRhys]

At 2:47 i thought weller was going to play the melody from elenor rigby!

[joewalsh63]

OMG this takes me back to being 16 or something...huge respect all round!



[TheMickSgrill]

I prefer much than the studio version.

[89cheapmonday]

Liam's word of the day he had to squeeze in must have been "Lucifer"...not that it makes much sense in that sentence but whatever.

[125possom]

what a voice..

[adds3566]

great song!

[Sgtpepper212]

Liam sounds SO great here. Love him.

[sweetlorraine0]

I love it when Oasis covers The Beatles and The Jam, the bands that influenced them a great deal, and generally when they all collaborate with eachother. I'm a fan of all these bands, Beatles, The Who, the Kinks, The Jam, Oasis. Weller and Liam G are among my favorite vocalists. There's something edgy and cool in their voices that really hooks me!

[joon1014]

The drummer is WEller's old drumming mate from the style council days.

[mrhitmanisback]

cant stand liams voice noel is much better

[GuitarKLO]

@mrhitmanisback I wouldn´t say that... well maybe nowdays but he sings very well here I think :P

[pjlenny22]

The bass player is Damon Minchella - Ocean Colour Scene's original bassist.

[mrGamespump]

Amply proves Liam is the greatest singer!

[doubleredsx3]

who is the bassist?

[DannyMadFerIt]

Whitey on drumms.... not Alan tho :D

[LogWaft]

@DannyMadFerIt awesome, is that his brother?

[DannyMadFerIt]

@LogWaft Yes :)

[barrybradford69]

@LogWaft no its his cousin

[DannyMadFerIt]

Liam Gallagher is God... the best singer ever

[Ryang403]

This is better than the original love to be in a studio or a room with great accoustics when liam starts singing with the mic up to the right level all clear must be fucking awesome listening to that energy one of them moments wen ur pretty speechless just wow man

[DRxJiMi1]

mmmm.... dunno

[y04pickering]

Does anyone no if if this is a single on any oasis cd cant find it

[plane15]

@y04pickering it was released as a single, get it off ebay.

[DRxJiMi1]

The Jam's version is so fukin' better but still a gr8 vid thanx 4 postin' thiss (Y)

[DRxJiMi1]

The best song ever !

[foster672]

is this on I Tunes?

[TheKaz146]

Fkn class!!!

[saddler360]

1:26 Proof Liam still got it-I think live just wears him out

[THug0001]

cradock sux, i dont like him

[OverweightChicken]

17 people are out of season all year round.

[ImaniHekima]

Is this taken from a longer documentary? Excellent stuff.

[keerza]

Noel looks spaced. Can hardly hold the guitar, let alone make a noise! One of Liam's great vocals though.

[Medalion]

Wow... god what happened to this voice from Liam? If only he sang this way in Beady Eye...

[cosmosticality]

when was this?

[oasis9867]

@cosmosticality

1999

[cosmosticality]

@oasis9867 cheers

[DannyMadFerIt]

@cosmosticality I think it's 1996

[themahermax]

@cosmosticality it was september 1999, a few months before (standing on the shoulder of giants)

[cosmosticality]

@themahermax cheers man

[TheCharlatan74]

cant stand oasis but ill take my hat off to liam,steve and paul fuckin great version of of this song!!!

[inspiredbyshikari]

yeah!! i got the 800th like, 17 people hit the wrong button, by mistake!

[jimmyzgames]

Mr weller

Mr Craddock

The Gallaghers

Fuckin Brilliant!!!!

[oasis12334]

WHO THE FUCK DIDNT LIKE THIS- GLUE BAGS

[Fashizle20]

Would fit well 45 yrs. back, too! In their own class!

[eatmypies]

i love pauls piano playing,it blends in and stands out in the hill of the song.

[MrBrenolisboa]

the liams voice is so much better in 99 than in 97, so in 00 it change a lot, but still amazing =)

[brownfinger76]

Superb!!!

[jimmynettles]

what year was this, cuz if thats alan white he looks way different rom here to like anything from the sotsog tour

[Kimorrissey]

@jimmynettles That's Steve White, the brother of Alan, which used to be the drummer for The Style Council and Paul Weller up until '06.

[barrybradford69]

@Kimorrissey they not brothers they are cousins

[Kimorrissey]

@barrybradford69 Not according to their Wikipedia entrys and interviews I've seen.

[seanlikestoskate1]

im not a big fan of liam, but this is brilliant

[dylanmorgan17]

who is the line-up here?

[mcnultyfrank]

Lucky Liams voice is so amazing as it hides how much of retard he sounds when he talks

[matthable]

fantastic



[smhassanr]

tits

[EvelinevandeWinckel]

when his voice kicks in at 1:15, it's amazing!

[Kwales66]

Whata a crowd

[INDIANBLANKET]

At 3:33, Noel is thinking to himself, 'thank fuck he didn't screw it up this time.'

[LordEizen]

haha noel looks funny here.. like ''where the fuck am i ? ''

[EviICorporateWhore]

Liam... give me your jacket!

[MrJonesGallagher]

Liam's singin's perfect here !!!!!!!

[hedgeolly]

Is that Mani on bass?

[chazde14]

@hedgeolly No, Damon Minchella, was in Ocean Colour Scene and Used to be bassist for Weller

[FretLegendSmithy]

whos that guy playing the acoustic?

[FretLegendSmithy]

@mrmagoo1016 Nice one. Didn't recognise him at all.

[zebady3]

Love it at 1:27 when Weller looks round. Like he's thinking "shit, that's good".

[thepittsrnr]

fuckin love this song me and my bandmate have just formed and covered it and would appreciate any feedback @rivalry1000 or from my favourites page

[agosgtt]

Liam looks so sexy ♥

[dreck93]

amazing 

[billydaspliff]

noel thinks it's shit.

[arfer]

mmmm....meh....decent effort.....not that good actually....compared to the original.

[MsSavannah95]

who the fuk needs to feel famous in the U.S annoying yank voices,no sense of humour,its ok we'll fight ur war though,if u stop shootin our soldiers!!! 2 top British blokes,too good for the U.S ,Oasis cool Britannia best band in the world anyway.thank god f The Hacienda Manchester,where it all started. mad fer it!!!!

[eatmypies]

I WOULD LOVE A STEVIE WHITES WARTS AND ALL BIOGROPHY TO HIT THE SHELVES.THAT WOULD REALLY PUT AN END TO ALL THIS SHIT. ABOUT WELLER.OK WELLER HAS WROTE BOOKS BUT NOT A REAL BIOGRAPHY IN HIS OWN WORDS TRUE AND TO THE POINT.

[suckusoff1]

liam the boys and sir paul! it doesnt get any better than that!!

[jonathanhudgins]

@BigTuna1994 Well...I was fucking drunk when I wrote. My point is if you listen to the radio in America everybody's vocals sort of sound the same. Liam is very different in his style and approach and part of the reason they never "broke" America is because most Americans are too stupid to appreciate his talent and unique style that they just think he sounds too raspy and can't really sing.

[LgFaver]

Liam looks like a character out of those twilight movies lol he needs a tan

[jonathanhudgins]

Liam Gallagher's voice is so wonderfully unique, most people are too stupid to even get it in America.

[BigTuna1994]

@jonathanhudgins That doesn't even make sense.

[joannecox2002]

loving stevies input x

[CCSofChocolatesvill]

steve craddock shud be in liams new band his guitar work in OCS n weller is tha fookin brummy hairy Bow-locks.

[august251976]

why is it every time Liam opens his mouth i wanna punch him in it. Great song, Weller does it best

[Eezaspanner]

sweet, Noel Gallagher is playing the guitar Johnny Depp gave him (white guitar with the letter P on it). This was a good tune, these guys made it great, Liams voice totally suits this song.

[CraicCocaine]

@Eezaspanner Paul Weller gave Noel that Rickenbacker not Johnny Depp. 

[Eezaspanner]

@CraicCocaine sounds pretty much like the guitar Johnny gave him, a white one with a P on it, was the one Johnny gave him a different make?

[Eezaspanner]

@CraicCocaine yeah your right, it seems that article I read picked up on the wrong guitar, that is the one Weller gave him.

[CJHugh1508]

Liam & Noel Gallagher, Paul Weller  forgetting sum 1 Ocean colour scean are epic

[EvelinevandeWinckel]

look at his smile at 1:14

[TheMrbollox]

When liam actually tries, he sings really well. half the time he couldn't be arsed.

[lunny5]

listen to paul wellers so better

[danmang92]

Who's that guy on the 12 string??

[HarleyDX]

@danmang92 - That is Steve Craddock who has been Paul's guitarist since he went solo and still is with him now! He is also was the lead guitarist for Ocean Colour Scene which was a band put together by Weller.

[tabris7]

@danmang92

Steve Cadrock 

[jimmyzgames]

oasis and jam rather than noel liam and paul

[lowde01]

liam gallagher is a twat end off

[saddler360]

@lowde01  Liam is a twat, but hes a talented twatwith a gift for eb

ntertaining people.

[iHeadmind]

@lowde01 fat ass

[li4m]

I think it was recorded back in 2000

[shakypam]

soz, the jam did it so much better

[lovingweller]

liam.. such an arse but amazing cover of an amazing song. pure class xxx

[manifesto2006]

brilliant.....

[delabresse]

Ce titre repris par Oasis est juste PARFAIT. Legend ! Une de mes favorites, dans le top 10 direct !

[Stereotype23]

When was this recorded? His voice is realy good here

[blakeguitar94]

@Stereotype23 1999

[josephgregory07]

It seems as Liam was finally having fun and enjoyining it ..::OASIS::..

[dianmarin]

pure genius

[emilianslitfibatex]

willie wonka!!

[jerdel33]

Ca c'est de la voix

[TheMoonsOfficial]

brilliant!

[spurscab]

Some one explain somthing to me! Noel is always slagging Cockneys off.

Nothing never comes out of London...(only The Who, The Pistols, The Jam)

Then he lives in London & has his tonuge stuck up Weller's & Townsend's arsholes...Is he a cunt or what?

[lnForTheLongFaul]

@spurscab Very true mate.

[julie2009ish]

pure quality

[WELLER2002]

Paul Weller what a legend!!!, he is responsible for this touching performance, he wrote the song and Liam many years later do this amazing version, thank's Modfather & friends...

P.D: Paul Weller you must come to Agentina!!!

P.D: Oasis Live Forever!!!

[whatalifeitwouldbe1]

@WELLER2002 Gracias a Dios todavía existe gente con gusto en Argentina! :)

[WELLER2002]

@whatalifeitwouldbe1 SI, SOMOS MUCHOS PARECE!!!

[flypast5]

I meant Liam's

[flypast5]

Liana voice at it's best.

[oiergasdn]

dear lord

great vid!

Liam is great! Impressive xD

[lolisdegallagher]

This is so cooL!!!

[jimmyzgames]

This sounds amazing but liams voice dosent fit as good as paul's reggee Type voice in the original, still awsome-ly different though

[sacredo07]

I like how Liam just grins and walks away at the end...as to say "Yeah man...I'm the bollocks!"

[DamienMcLachlan]

Fair fucks to em....good stuff

[leighslambchops]

I love the echo effect on Liams's voice, makes him sound more like Lennon than ever.

[LordEizen]

@leighslambchops i dont think he sounds like lennon at all :S

[waymondo1955]

this is from back when liam COULD sing ...hes lost it now bless him.

[septip123]

Can I borrow someone's Liam Gallagher to English dictionary?

[Eltroim]

@septip123 i got liam gallagher's english for dummies

[Acoustix4]

sorry... but I don't like liam... don't like his charakter, don't like his voice, ..... but it's not that bad at all... i just like it.... cause I love noel and paul...

[svjaty]

Personally I'd prefer to listen to Noel any day over Liam, however I realize that if it weren't for Liam I' never would have heard of Noel ;)

[leemain88]

wot the fuck are you on about if it wasnt for noel liam would still be on the doll!!!!! oasis are nothing without noel

[nahgajorma]

of course but Liam originally formed the band..

[Fordy875]

Ramiro...It`s Steve White on drums,Alan`s brother.

[Lin6161]

Liam is so stupid ...

[JamesGoals]

Why? What he says to be a stupid one?

[Mikkokokko]

Good vocs!

[nevernever22]

proper lucifer innit?

Great version of a great song.

[RamiroHF]

yeah, at last Alan White is not making his "signature druming" (some people who listens to oasis live will undestand what i mean).

[liveforever14]

love it :)

[themadtonic]

tae everycunt,oasis fucking rule,always did and always will,if ye dont like them,fuckoff n listen tae yer barry manalow records you tarts!

[neilbee]

The greatest performers in one room together. It doesnt get much better than that folks!

Awsome song.

[kevthejester79]

is that steve craddock ?

[ansenpietje123]

yes it is

[dannyjar100]

Didn't think I'd like him singing this, but.... he does a good job.

[pushyba]

Ok Norse John, so listen to the original Caranation from The Jam : 1 drums, 1 bass and 1 guitar ... that my favorite as well.

Enjoy the ''old'' JAM and still enjoy OASIS ...

Peacefully :)

[NorseJohn]

im an oasis fan.. but this is absolute wank.. only cos paul the cunt weller is involved.. i mean, for fuck sake, how many guitaists do you need to play a basic, shitty rhythym? really? 3? the mind boggles.

[pushyba]

You cunt ... you didn't understand man ....

Oasis is great ... and it's thanks too guys like Weller if they are here ...

[NorseJohn]

yeah man, i dont understand man, cos, man, like you need 43 guitarists man, to like play a shitty rhythym man

[Milanotjuh]

@NorseJohn of all people oasis fans should understand what multiple guitars with different effects contribute to the music and Oasis (especially on be here now) made it their philosophy.

[lenlagher]

Well, there's only two guitars on this mate. One acoustic and one electric. And lets face it mate, on most of the songs on the first Oasis-records both Noel and Bonehead played rhyhtymn, even though Noel would throw in the occasional riff. So i dont see the problem here personally.

[C18GLASGOW]

Magic only comes around once.

[Irlandese64]

Liam nails this with Paul right there. I'm not usually a fan of covers, but this is fantastic.

[Jack01142]

My 3 favourite muscians.

[TheEezergeezer]

check out tales of george if you like these guys you will not be dissapointed!

[nirchuy]

la canto conmadre 3:

[micaheynow]

I think nobody can sing it better

[steg0979]

What a line up!

[noelsplectrum9]

the voice of a generation greatest voice ever no argument

[copout7]

@noelsplectrum9 a spoilt brat and a lennon wannabe.....please, do you actually like music? that is overly engineered vocals or my arse doesnt point downwards!!!!

do yourself a favour and listen to Steve Marriot or Paul Jones sing

[noelsplectrum9]

@copout7 do i like music? how about bite me you twat if i think liam gallagher has the best voice ive ever heard who the fuck are you to question it? and what are you doin listening to him if you dont like him? are you strange?