the alpha-omega has long since been bred out of our dogs. intimidation in training could lead to aggressive behavior later because of the stress it causes the dogs. POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT, please. Not a 'tap'.
it's not a "kick" to hurt,it's more like a unexpected push that comes out of nowhere. i guess it breaks their focus enough for them to see that they aren't the one who is going to control the owners.
COULD THE HATER GET THE FUCK OUT OF HERE IF YOU HATE CESAR. PLEASE! ITS ANNOYING TO HEAR YOU GUYS TRYING TO INSULT CESARS WAYS. GO INSULT SOME OTHER DUDE. LIKE CHUCK TESTA.. or something.. xD jk but please stop hating on Cesar, he has his own ways and you do, so just shut up and enjoy the vid.
I adopted around a year ago a lovely 6 years old Golden Retriever, she is very sweet and I don't regret adopting her, but when it comes to try walking her the start is way too difficult and hurtful for me because she jumps at me in her excitement. Once she is not excited anymore it is a piece of cake, but no matter how many techniques I try, even this technique, it just doesn't work.
@illyas1 i have to kids i have moved them or when im doing something and they want to get in there to i move their hands til they get the point that i dont want them touching what im doing and thats what hes doing. and my kids and myself thing im a great parent as well as other bc my kids are well mannered.. and ive been doing this to my dog and its helping i cant put my hands on her bc she will bite out of excitement so i turn around and give her a light touch with my foot and it works great.
The people who think that this is animal abuse really need to look up what real animal abuse is. There is a difference between mercilessly beating a dog and giving him a light tap when he is getting out of hand.
lol the people who are anti-Cesar here don't probably have dogs LOL ! they just troll around the internet creating (stupid) hatred. because every dog owners I know love Cesar. I myself do.
I hate my dog walter. He listens to everything i say when i'm awake / when im asleep he pisses on my girlfriend's face...by girlfriend I mean my guitar gear...my actual real girlfriend keeps me from selling him to newly immigrated asian folks i know. I'm seriously thinking of starting to eat more "exotic" meats.
@BeowoofOmega, retard you keep talking about evidence and yet you show none. So far we've gotten irrelevant and overly long plagiarism, stupid quotes, and backwards writing. But in terms of evidence you've never presented any. And of course you can't since you are bloody idiot and a liar.
"Cesar Millan has an opportunity enjoyed by no other dog trainer in history. Here’s the only problem, the messages he delivers are sometimes debatable, some even say dangerous, leaving many animal behavior experts cringing about the outcomes. "
what is the touch? is it like pushing hjim out of the way? or is it like a touch on his shoulder like you would to a kid who is doing somethign wrong?
What's with all the sexist crap as well! My missus walks our collie and collie-x at the same time and the person that teaches us dog agility is a woman - wise up for goodness sake!
Everything that he taught her here could have been taught with patience and treats. I've never had to physically touch my border collie and he is one generation removed from working stock.
You guys who dislike him and somehow believe that hes abusing dogs that seriously hurt or may hurt people and other dogs can't deny the fact that he really does help people AND their dogs. There are many dogs that would have been put down or given up if it weren't for him. He respects the dogs by recognizing the fact that they are NOT human. Even if you love them like one you must respect them as a dog. They have a need for a hierarchy system (rules and boundaries), proper exercise, and love.
@hushesthepuppies, there is no evidence that dogs would have been killed without his help. But there is evidence that dogs have been killed after he claimed to have rehabilitated them.
@MagistrateOIFY , you are a fucking retard. Millan's dominance has been proven to be a lie. His methods rebuked by nearly every training, vet and welfare organization.
@AboutDogTraining3 its been rebuked by self proclaimed animal lovers aka retards such as yourself, in a selfish quest of delusion to pretend that nature is all fluffy. go back to watching snow white and live in your cuddly wuddly world, fucking moron
@MagistrateOIFY idiots like you who have no grasp on reality have been proven wrong again and again. You are a useless turd that needs to be wiped off the shoe of the world.
@AboutDogTraining3 I'm not trying to get into a fight here but... scientific? There are people who you could possibly go and meet or contact if you have the time and money who could easily show you how much there dog has changed for the better. They had a anniversary episode where quite a few people came out with there previously aggressive dogs from various seasons and it was clear that their dogs were much better behaved. Sometimes his method works, sometimes it doesn't. It's that simple.
@hushesthepuppies, as keeps being mentioned by others, Millan's own books "the ultimate episode guide' gives updates on the dogs. And more than half of them are still having the same problems, or in a few cases even worse.
The importance of science cannot be ignored. His methods have been rebuked. The evidence shows that his views are wrong. If we have solid evidence that his methods are dangerous, unpredictable and there are better ways... then why do it?
@AboutDogTraining3 I'll defiantly consider what your saying. Though you can't be sure that those dogs are worse off or haven't changed because of Cesar's methods. Sometimes, which Cesar and even the owners have mentioned, owners don't follow through with the rules and schedules he lays out for them. Aside from the physical corrections he does (which I don't always agree with) the psychology he puts forward does work for many dogs when applied Correctly depending on the dog, owner and issue.
@paulcottman i agree. I use foot taps but never kicks. if you are tapping you are not causing pain and to them, its the same as using your hand. they dont understand foot and hand.. to them its the same. all being need to be disciplined in order to trained. children, dogs... they need to know when they are doing wrong as well as right. reward the right but dont exactly ignore the bad. trian them thats it bad. for dogs, best done when catching in the act.
@illyas1 While I believe there is some truth to that statement it doesn't matter because in this particular video Cesar is not prompting the lady to physically punish her dog. Therefore, not only is a dog a different species with a different psychology but there is no physical punishment in the video so whether or not physcial punishment is admissable for dogs is another discussion. Cesar certainly uses punishment on other occassions but there is no punishment in this video.
@illyas1 Hitting a dog when the hitting is contingent on the dogs behavior is positive punishment. I will be the first to point out that Cesar often invokes the use of what he calls a "touch" when he creates what he says is "the mother's bite" when in reality it is a perfect example of punishment that he is disguising under the aforementioned euphemisms. In this particular clip however, there was no hitting ( hitting being distinguished by its quickness and forcefulness) despite the contact.
@illyas1 Dog arent humans, so they arent children. Did you never see how dogs among each other solve this kind of problem? They BITE...so this tab is kinder than dogs would correct that behavior...
@Bailarsonsa are you a dog? and the majority of dogs live with humans.your example is illogical because this doesnt happen in the wild.yes a dog may rebuke another with physical force,but actually the alpha male is usually cool and calm,and just has to look at another dog to get him to stop.u r right we arent dogs,we are smarter and can do things better than emulating aggresive dog behavior like ceasar is doing .
@illyas1 Of course Im not a dog, are you? Yeah, when the dog is the alpha male, then he dont have to do much. BUT in this video, the humans werent the alpha dog..so they have to get the position first from the dog who is the alpha in this house. So how to you take the alpha role from another dog? Just by a look? When two dominant dogs are together, they fight, chase each other till one give up s.o.
@Bailarsonsa alpha male huh? did you know that a lower ranking bitch can keep a bone from a higher ranking male?ceasar and others have spread this alppha fallacy,and i think you should go back and read updated scientific knowlege of what it means to be alpha.it is much more complex than you make it
@illyas1 And it doesnt matter if we are smarter or not...the dog knows the best answer, when its about dog psychologie..and not the "smart" human...we have to follow they example, not some human idea of the better world for a dog. They living another world which in their genes, so why they should like more our world?
@Bailarsonsa the dog knows the best answer? that is your opinion,im sorry but humans know better.it would be totally apprpriate for a dog to pee in the house chew on everything and bark all day,but they live under our rules.dogs are breed and have adapted to human life.
@paulcottman a child is human..a dog is an animal....helloo?? anybody there?? all of u ppl r humanizing animals which make them unstable then u cage them or u put them to sleep ...no i think a kick is better than a lethal injection....go buy a cat
At no point did I explicitly state or imply that humans and dogs are the same. However, I do agree with your statement that people are quick to anthropomorphisize non human beings and it causes several problems in how they relate to the animals; in this case, dogs. An excellent collection of essays on the matter is available online or at your local bookstore. It is called "The Culture Clash" by world renowned dog trainer Jean Donaldson.
There's one thing i want to say about him. I think he's great. I don't know whats up with you guys to say like o my gosh he's kicking him, some of the dogs are really aggressive or just too overexited. What about the humans that could get hurt. I think his techniques are great, even when he needs to "touch" them. He could better do a touch so there no one will get hurt...
@Chiraiki Some things I dont agree with Cesar, but the main part is really great, what he is doing. The people who dont like this tap, they totally ignoring the fact what this dog do to this humans. He could seriously injure them with his jumping, so why can this dog hurt the human, and the human dont have the right to touch back, and the touching which cesar do is not overreacted or something, it is softer than what the dog do.
@Bailarsonsa basically an eye for an eye huh?if the dog bites you then u bite him back?an eye for an eye leaves everyone blind.why must we use physical force to correct our dogs?they are totally capable of understanding what we want and if we like what they are doing.it is peoples fualt for not taking the time to communicate with their dog and training good behaviors from the outset.dont blame the dog.
@illyas1 I didnt "blame" the dog. When the dog dont know best (I didnt meant peeing in the house, I meant something like taking alpha role, how to correct behavior s.o.), why they have so much issues when they live with humans, when they so brilliantly addapted the human life?
Well, just say your solution to the problem in the video, and dont just ignore, what Im asking.
@Bailarsonsa alpha role?why do you think that corrects behavior? dogs dont have problems.in fact alot of their behavior is neccessary.one thing i do agree with ceasar is that it is the humans fault.he doesnt teach dogs he teaches humans
The American College of Veterinary Behaviorists (ACVB), the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) and the Society of Veterinary Behavior Technicians (SVBT) have uniformly SPOKEN OUT AGAINST the punishment-based techniques employed by Mr. Millan on his television show “The Dog Whisperer.”
Unfortunately, people believe anything they see on TV.
women stick with cats i agree this dumb bitch i met walkink my dog also had a border ad mitted could not handle said she was a trainer told her numerous times my 15 month border possesion aggresivness be careful he finally nipped her agree it was wrong dont want get into details but now has to wear muzzle for 3 years may have to give him up we re treated him like a king trying or best all shots always up to date etc etc etc now we dont no what the hell to do
@fingaroll5 And is this based on this one woman or is this your just own ignorant and moronic belief? Because the last time I checked its a HUMAN (as in BOTH male and female) trait to make mistakes like this PERSON has.
The abusive practice of kicking a dog is moronic. All this dog needed was a highly reinforced sit - and since he was excited about going out, we could have used that as a reward a la PREMACK.
Of course he could help this dog, he has experience in borderjumping...I mean jumping..border..collies! :) No hate please, I LOVE Cesar, but I couldn't keep this joke to myself! :D
I think it's the dogs who phone cesar for help with their owners not the other way round. " My owner doesn't understand me. Please train them". And Cesar duly turns up and trains the owners how to behave. And the women always fall for him.
@BeowoofOmega is an asshole dog beater. He ignores the scientific evidence against aversive jerk and kick methods because he enjoys being abusive to dogs. Like most immature losers with no self esteem he seeks a weak victim so he can feel like he has some power over them. This loser has never trained a dog and still kicks and jerks dogs to force compliance out of them.
I don't care what anyone says. Cesar is a good trainer. I have yet to see him abuse the dogs or hurt them. People have to understand dogs are not like kids. They have a completely different mind set than humans. All of the people who click on DW vids just to bad mouth Cesar are just making themselves look like morons who have nothing better to do. Don't like his methods? Then don't watch his videos. Why don't you people go after real dog abusers?
When we first adopted Bobo, a wolf, from the pound, he kept running away. I didn't want to chain or fence him, so we went to the pound and let him choose a mate. We brought home Lady, a border collie his age (8). That kept him home.
He was twice her size, but she was clearly his boss. She could be a real bitch to him sometimes, but he loved her just as she was.
Now that Bobo has passed away, she misses him a lot. They were inseparable. So she keeps following me around the house, asking for hugs.
i have tried ceasar' s technique on my dogs, they are askals, and they had great improvement ever since, especially on controlling their excitement for meal time
Dogs, cats, and other non-human animals live much more in the present moment than humans do. We have rational minds that distort and filter life in the present, so we need to learn the truth of life with our rational minds to live more clearly and openly. When we learn the truth of life, pets will become even more popular. Search "Truth Contest" in Google and click the 1st result, then open The Present and read what it says to learn the truth of life.
@AboutDogTraining3 NO you fool - dogs BITE eachother.....something we for a few reasons would find hard to implement quickly, hence a toe jab (NOT A KICK!!!) is a suitable subsitute - can't believe that has needed explaining - god with people like you around no wonder the dog training world is f****d up.
@amberluka73, you bloody imbecile!! That dog's bite each other is irrelevant because the reason you think they bite happen to be wrong. Also you fucking fool, by kicking the dog you assume that the dog makes the connection that it is equivalent to a bite coming from another dog and that it has the same meaning as a bite. That has to be the most deluded conclusion ever. You are fucked up and the treatment dogs receive from people like you is why 4 million die every year.
I am not an imbecile I am an experienced dog trainer. YOU are the fool, the 'pokes' are to merely snap the individual out of a rising state of negative mind. I have met people like you before so on that note I am not going to waste any more of my precious time because people like you are closed minded and set in there ways. LOl lol lol lol 4 million dogs die cos of people like me? god your a comedian. oh and keep your abusive language and swearing to yourself moron
@amberluka73 , you are an imbecile, and you don't even know what you are arguing about. First you believe you are 'biting' the dog, they you are snapping it out the situation you created in the first place. Why the fuck punish a dog for something you started? By merely making a sit a highly reinforced behaviour, you solve this problem, without violence. Everybody else can do it.
this dog is a Border mix, i'm pretty sure this dog is just over bored and has nothing to do so it gets excited. I also noticed this dog may like going for walks but also doesn't enjoy it. Really, a choke chain on a border? I've never seen the day....
@Jal1515 its indeed sad, my border collie/pitbull mix pulls like crazy but i tried a choke chain and it did not get better and she ended up at the vet :(
@ATouchOfMagic88 Never use a choke chain. Search Kikopup on youtube and use that method. It is safer for the average dog owner and ALOT more effective. I am not saying Cesar is fake, just that his methods are for last ABSOLUTE LAST resort cases and professionals that know what they are doing. Training a dog takes weeks, months and sometimes years. My border collie was 6 years old when I began training him to walk on a loose leash but Kikopup's method works without negative side effects.
@Supercucu123 Already tried the choke chain...my dad is a former police dog handler and they all use it but seems only affective with certain dogs. I just bought myself a anti pull harness from ''halti'' which i am first going to use if that doesn't work i'll try search what you recommend me :) border collie and their mixes same with pitbulls need a different training approach also because my dog is dog agressive and sadly gotten away 2 times (got out of her dog collar) and attacked...
@ATouchOfMagic88 , we already know Millan's quick fixes only work as long as he is there to brutally punish the dog. I doubt you got a dog so you can mistreat it. Like anything worth doing, training takes time and the quick fixes are like the quick weight loss plans... they never work.
@AboutDogTraining3 I don't mistreat her, i hate the way people 'train' their dogs. training does take time i'm already busy for a few years and i see small progress but where i live i encounter lots of lose dogs and i hate it =\
@Supercucu123 oh my, absolute last resort? Why take years to train a dog to do or not do something that you can achieve in minutes? Cesar is not fake, I know cos I was born with the innate knowledge of dog psychology he was. I agree here is more than one way to get the same results but his methods are fair and kind.
@amberluka73 What Cesar does cannot be achieved in minutes. It's done with repetition. I taught my dog to walk on a loose leash in a week and he was already 6 when he began training (just to clear up any confusion you may have). What Cesar has done in this video in particular is perfectly reasonable for the average dog owner. His other methods are more questionable such as his usage of choke chains, and his more physical methods.
"it's hard though cuz she's so cute" - ...... really???? the OWNER should be ALWAYS be in control. Sometimes the owners on these shows just frustrate me... i couldn't imagine some of these dogs overpowering my life.
no abuse here. putting up your foot is not the same as a kick. For example, if my child is jumping on me and I put my hand in his way to keep him from jumping on me, that's not child abuse. The dog still seemed happy and excited for a walk after Cesar worked with her. No fear here.
CMIIW at first I admire Cesar Milan but it seems to me he did it with no love... he always talk about dominance and dominance and dominance. I agree dogs can read our 'energy' and aura and we should be the pack leader of the dog(s), but kicking doesn't seem too good to me. I mean -- humans should treat dogs like dogs, but we are humans... we aren't dogs. Dogs are supposed to be friends of humans ,no? Then why should we treat dogs like... slaves?
yo everybody if youll have a chance can youll please check out my video and tell me what you think just search" smartest pitbull pup" or "956razorramon" on youtube.. my pitbull dro is only 14 weeks old..thanks
Did you see how he wasn't sure how to respond to the woman's foot abuse question? He quickly replied, "He's abusing you!", a statement that makes not sense at all. The dog is reacting with natural dog instincts - he's excited, ready to go! The dog is obviously not happy about being touched, prodded. If they simply reinforced his calm behavior with a treat or praise he would be much happier to repeat the behavior in the future. It's dominance, instead. I like Cesar, but that's just my 2 cents.
I guess this is an ok way to train your dog. Kind of kicking at the dog I don't really like. I trained my Border Collie with positive re-enforcement. He knew that when I get the leash out to sit calmly and let me put the leash on him without him freaking out. Telling her to sit and stay was a good thing. If she got back up and I would just make her sit and stay again. A clicker would really help with that. I guess this ok if you want to train a dog not to get to excited and jump.
This is just a dominant, temporary fix. Not good. Positive re-enforcement is the only thing that works with dogs, especially border collies. With alpha mindset, you are breaking that dog's very spirit. The Alpha omega social instinct was bred out of dogs long long ago.
@BeowoofOmega, you are lying again you dumbass. You don't respect science, evidence or even basic common sense. You are enamored with the TV dog kicker and lap up his jizz without thought.
@BeowoofOmega , you are another ignorant liar, just like most of the people here who support Millan. You've made a log of false assumptions, starting with the one that lead you to believe a dog groomer who never finished high school. And don't thing you are fooling anyone, you don't respect evidence or science which tells me you don't work in robotics.
@BeowoofOmega, you are an opinionated unemployed asshole. And you should fuck off because you are using the internet, invented by the scientists you are now insulting . FUCK YOU ASSHOLE.
Millan's mangled hands are enough proof that he abuses animals and gets them to fight. No more need be said on this since we've all seen him get bitten time and time again.
BeowoofCrap, Until you can come up with some evidence to back the lies, nothing you write is credible. Millan's dogs do feel abused, and they do fight back and his mangled hands are proof of it.
@BeowoofOmega, you bloody moron. The fact is that Millan's hands look like raw meat from all the bites he has received by starting fights and attacking dogs. The fact is that his assertions have long been dismissed by knowledgeable people and the fact is that he only attracts people who don't know very much about dogs.
@BeowoofOmega, well moron, if you were willing to walk away from your masturbatory fantansy, Millan, and open a book on the subject you would know the answer to that. Needless to say, Various, PhD and respected trainers have pointed out and spoken out against these backward and abusive practices.
@BeowoofOmega - So now you want to take away kids ipods in order to punish a dog. Even by your standards, that has to be weird. But I guess it's better than hitting the dog, which is what you normally suggest.
Just because a dog has littermates, doesn't mean it's a pack animal. Other animals have littermates and they're not pack animals. Others also learn bite inhibition the same way - cats for example.
@BeowoofOmega, asshole. What video are you responding to? In this video, Millan kicks the dog for being happy and excited to go out. Instead of training, he promotes abuse.
The dogs is excited and happy and Millan responds to this by kicking and scaring the dog. So once it experiences Millan's painful "touch" he is no longer happy and as it has been documented for several decades his behavior is temporarily suppressed by violence. Simply teaching the dog to sit and rewarding the behavior would take care of this problem.
I don't know why people still keep criticizing Cesar, he has helped many people and rescued many dogs from being put down. For all those failed trainers who are trolling Dog Whisperer vids with their untrue comments, stop being so jelous you might learn a thing or two from this guy..
Fortunately, any person with good eyesight and a working brain can easily see Cesar's methods work. And, a well-known and recognized authority like National Geographic wouldn't have anything to do with a fake.
Naysayers (the mature ones, anyway) soon recognize what most others plainly see - that Millan's methods work. The fringe... well... eventually, they have to get off mommy's computer, have their drinky, then go beddy-bye. They're of no consequence at all.
@Redshield666, and a person that can read KNOWS that millan often fails. We know he fails because he has documented the failures in the Ultimate Guide... and 50% are as bad as worse than when Millan declared them rehabilitated.
@hendrixexperiencedig quite frankly i try hard to find a single point on which i can criticize him but i swear no matter how hard i try i cant find a single reason ! so thats why i just simply love that guy ! :)
how the faack do u ppl find reasons to criticize him?? :/
because they want to. They believe cesar is incapable of rehabilitating because he's 'unqualified' . But the truth be told what's better qualification than experience? Cesar is not about dog training he's about the physcology , those idiotic trainsers fail to understand him because of this. Cesar has rescued so many dogs that those trainers could never even dream of. No one has the right to criticize him.
@hendrixexperiencedig experience is useless if he learns nothing from it. MILLAN is stuck in a loop. HIT dog results in suppressed behavior. His ignorance allows him to call that a calm/submissive dog. He thinks he has achieved his goal. In reality most experts agree that this is a shut down dog
yes that's why they must be running around , eating , drinking , playing games , not get afraid , not get aggressive, not get put down and killed . Please keep your thoughts to yourself because they're ridiculous at this point. I'm suspicious that you even don't have dogs certainly you sound like you don't have any. Cesar is probably one of the best things that could've happened to those dogs out there because trainers like you gave up on them.
@hendrixexperiencedig sure you can be deluded and think that. OR you can read the scientific evidence and the opinion real experts and organizations that find his methods unproductive and dangerous. ... but hey, ignorant people are often fooled by what they are marketed to on TV
hehe, what do you think of those scientific evidence ? have they been handed over from some other planet? Cesar has the approval of the biggest organization on nature, animal acts ; Nat Geo, CLEARLY doesn't need the approval of people like you.
@hendrixexperiencedig Every Succesful Person in the Media has Haters and Dislikers, most are just jealous. How can someone critizise him nearly every dog in his cases gets Fixed !
@TheChefKev - Actually that's not true. About 50% of the dogs are not fixed and end up being rehomed or put down. That's according to one of Millan's own books. What he says on the show is very different from what he says in other moods. On his DVD's for aggressive dogs he reccomends the Thinschmidt group. They are using +R (clicker training) to treat aggression. Most of his explanations for behaviour on the show are just fabricated nonsense.
@sweenith - It's an opinion based on the scientific research of others, statements by various professional organizations, licensed veterinarians and various people holding doctorate degrees in animal behaviour. If you want to review some of this you can goto/google urbandawgs About half way down the page, you'll find a link to some of their comments.
Wow. This woman needs more work than the dog! She's not into this at all.
Good thing Cesar's expertise in interpreting the pack behavior of dogs is able to quickly illustrate how easily a creature of instinct is able to comply when it knows what is expected of it. This dog is far more intelligent than your average troll, better house-trained, more charming and FAR better-looking! Also, the dog quickly understands it's boundaries and abilities...
hehe that sounds funny, sure you're no zoologist. It is widely known that most canidaes have pack mentality and canis is in that group. They hunt , live and socialize in form of packs in their natural habitat. All canines have social hierarchy in forms of pack leaders and followers. You should review your sources before commenting and misinforming people.
@hendrixexperiencedig , it may sound funny to you because you dont know the facts. Look at the research, the whole pack theory has been dropped by wolf biologists, which means it must also be dropped by those pushing it in dogs, as they point to the wolf for the origin of the alledged pact hierarchy.
Intelligent people distinguish between socialbility and pack behavior. They are very different.
People can hate cesar's methods all they want.. but rather work like him than beat ur dog everythime they do something wrong. atleast he uses his body language more than he uses his fists
Ignore naisayd and ADT3, i have confirmed that they are both trolls whose greatest pleasure in life is arguing on yt armed with only a few articles they pulled up on google. Their only intent is to start fights and call people names. They say pack leaders/authority only cause harm. Therefore if they get shot nobody call the police so we can honor their view that authority/pack leaders are wrong.
Ignore BeowoofOmega, he has been a constant TROLL on all the Millan videos. His new technique of accusing people of having multiple accounts to distract from the fact that he has no counterpoint to all the scientific evidence that has been presented.
The sheer number of dog-owners and dogs who have been injured, physically or emotionally, by this claptrap is incalculable. Millan's NatGeo show is a debacle. his treatment of Riley was deplorable and if i ever saw ANYONE dragging a dog up stairs or anywhere like that i would put an immediate stop to that.. I don't agree with the Alpha human approach at all, dominance is never the answer!!!!!
I despise Cesar the Killer Milan. He should never be allowed around an animal, much less "teach" others his supposed "techniques." What a moral vacuum, and only morons would follow his advice.
@MsAnimalProtector ?? that dog is completely fine. all Millan said was to speak sternly and touch her with the side of the foot. I guess waving a hand over a dog is abuse?
hello if you have got any problems with your dog or you want to just ask sonthing
pleace go on my youtube channel i am not profesional i am still learnig but i try to solve you problems with you dog or if you just want to ask my sonthing i try to help.
Its free just leave comment on my channel and i contact you by e-mail i just conntact by e-mail i don;t visit because i am not sure if that work out.
so if you have problem or just want to ask me sonthing leave message and i contact you back.
Way easier than Cesar's method: First, hold the leash down at your side instead of at your chest. Then the dog will focus lower and be less likely to jump. Second: Turn your back on the dog if it jumps. If you are worried about getting hurt by the dog, keep a chair near where the leash is and put it between you and the dog. Third: Teach the dog a task to perform while you get the leash out, such as waiting by the door or laying down. The Cesar method will just agitate the dog in the long run.
Dogs should not be inside a house, they get real frustrated and aggresive. Dogs should be in open space at a backyard, ect. Dogs were meant to be outside having fun and in touch with nature.
Dogs shouldn't be inside a house . . . really? While I agree that some breeds should not be kept inside, thats not true of all breeds. It's a very ignorant statement to make. So being the kind hearted soul I am I'll help curtail that ignorance.
Many lap dogs (bred solely for companionship) are not good dogs to keep outside. Some are too frail for the outdoors and can't stand temperature variations. Greyhounds in particular climates also should not be kept outside. Ect.
the alpha-omega has long since been bred out of our dogs. intimidation in training could lead to aggressive behavior later because of the stress it causes the dogs. POSITIVE REINFORCEMENT, please. Not a 'tap'.
TrentGentry 3 days ago
I tried the food thing on my dog and he bit my foot! Haha
MsTeatime8 5 days ago
I am a Dog whisperer and learned from CM.
1st off Cm didn't use the back tap here he used his hand. she did the foot.
But Cm has got bite 1 time on camera from using a back tap move and I got 1 dog mad but dog miss the bite on me.
If your Dog is aggressive then I recomend getting a professional before using these techniques
Jeff
Dog Whisperer
Boca Raton fl
jsf525 6 days ago
its not kick at all, there is not power in it, its just a touch with feet
ambrosia1111 1 week ago
it's not a "kick" to hurt,it's more like a unexpected push that comes out of nowhere. i guess it breaks their focus enough for them to see that they aren't the one who is going to control the owners.
3344utube 2 weeks ago
COULD THE HATER GET THE FUCK OUT OF HERE IF YOU HATE CESAR. PLEASE! ITS ANNOYING TO HEAR YOU GUYS TRYING TO INSULT CESARS WAYS. GO INSULT SOME OTHER DUDE. LIKE CHUCK TESTA.. or something.. xD jk but please stop hating on Cesar, he has his own ways and you do, so just shut up and enjoy the vid.
minigunshooter1212 2 weeks ago
I adopted around a year ago a lovely 6 years old Golden Retriever, she is very sweet and I don't regret adopting her, but when it comes to try walking her the start is way too difficult and hurtful for me because she jumps at me in her excitement. Once she is not excited anymore it is a piece of cake, but no matter how many techniques I try, even this technique, it just doesn't work.
vasogoma 3 weeks ago
@illyas1 i have to kids i have moved them or when im doing something and they want to get in there to i move their hands til they get the point that i dont want them touching what im doing and thats what hes doing. and my kids and myself thing im a great parent as well as other bc my kids are well mannered.. and ive been doing this to my dog and its helping i cant put my hands on her bc she will bite out of excitement so i turn around and give her a light touch with my foot and it works great.
villarreal661 3 weeks ago
i enjoyed this video.
SuzieLopez11 1 month ago
The people who think that this is animal abuse really need to look up what real animal abuse is. There is a difference between mercilessly beating a dog and giving him a light tap when he is getting out of hand.
PempaP 1 month ago 4
"I thought using your foot was abusive. *Puts on Choke Chain"
inbarshema 1 month ago 6
alpha role?why do you think that corrects behavior?
illyas1 1 month ago
@illyas1 try it on your kid...they probably need it more than dogs
TazziBosco 1 month ago
@TazziBosco a good parent doesnt need to use physicall punishment
illyas1 1 month ago
lol the people who are anti-Cesar here don't probably have dogs LOL ! they just troll around the internet creating (stupid) hatred. because every dog owners I know love Cesar. I myself do.
hadabenz 1 month ago
I hate my dog walter. He listens to everything i say when i'm awake / when im asleep he pisses on my girlfriend's face...by girlfriend I mean my guitar gear...my actual real girlfriend keeps me from selling him to newly immigrated asian folks i know. I'm seriously thinking of starting to eat more "exotic" meats.
ShapiroJones 2 months ago
@ShapiroJones Your dog might be bored.
2550505 2 months ago
@BeowoofOmega, retard you keep talking about evidence and yet you show none. So far we've gotten irrelevant and overly long plagiarism, stupid quotes, and backwards writing. But in terms of evidence you've never presented any. And of course you can't since you are bloody idiot and a liar.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 OMFG get a life! You are in all videos talking shit with another person omg LOL!
TatianaBazan 2 months ago
@TatianaBazan, but I have the advantage of being right and I am able to prove it.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@TatianaBazan he doesnt have a life..and a dick..
shobin05 2 months ago
Steve Dale writes:
"Cesar Millan has an opportunity enjoyed by no other dog trainer in history. Here’s the only problem, the messages he delivers are sometimes debatable, some even say dangerous, leaving many animal behavior experts cringing about the outcomes. "
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
This guy has no basis for being an expert, people!
BOYCOTT NAT GEO NOW.
oxtotl 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The sooner this guy's show is cancelled the better off we will all be.
Why do all the credentialed, modern Professional Dog Trainers disagree with this person?
Join us to get this show cancelled.
oxtotl 2 months ago
what is the touch? is it like pushing hjim out of the way? or is it like a touch on his shoulder like you would to a kid who is doing somethign wrong?
MrShitstirer 2 months ago
What's with all the sexist crap as well! My missus walks our collie and collie-x at the same time and the person that teaches us dog agility is a woman - wise up for goodness sake!
MrWelshsean 2 months ago
Everything that he taught her here could have been taught with patience and treats. I've never had to physically touch my border collie and he is one generation removed from working stock.
MrWelshsean 2 months ago
You guys who dislike him and somehow believe that hes abusing dogs that seriously hurt or may hurt people and other dogs can't deny the fact that he really does help people AND their dogs. There are many dogs that would have been put down or given up if it weren't for him. He respects the dogs by recognizing the fact that they are NOT human. Even if you love them like one you must respect them as a dog. They have a need for a hierarchy system (rules and boundaries), proper exercise, and love.
hushesthepuppies 3 months ago
@hushesthepuppies, there is no evidence that dogs would have been killed without his help. But there is evidence that dogs have been killed after he claimed to have rehabilitated them.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 No there isn't. You're so full of shit.
MagistrateOIFY 2 months ago
@MagistrateOIFY, you are a retard.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 you are a hateful, spiteful piece of shit, also the true retard
MagistrateOIFY 2 months ago
@MagistrateOIFY , you are a fucking retard. Millan's dominance has been proven to be a lie. His methods rebuked by nearly every training, vet and welfare organization.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 its been rebuked by self proclaimed animal lovers aka retards such as yourself, in a selfish quest of delusion to pretend that nature is all fluffy. go back to watching snow white and live in your cuddly wuddly world, fucking moron
MagistrateOIFY 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MagistrateOIFY idiots like you who have no grasp on reality have been proven wrong again and again. You are a useless turd that needs to be wiped off the shoe of the world.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 There is evidence of both.
hushesthepuppies 2 months ago
@hushesthepuppies and yet no one on the Millan side brings any scientific evidence to support their case. State secret.
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 I'm not trying to get into a fight here but... scientific? There are people who you could possibly go and meet or contact if you have the time and money who could easily show you how much there dog has changed for the better. They had a anniversary episode where quite a few people came out with there previously aggressive dogs from various seasons and it was clear that their dogs were much better behaved. Sometimes his method works, sometimes it doesn't. It's that simple.
hushesthepuppies 2 months ago
@hushesthepuppies, as keeps being mentioned by others, Millan's own books "the ultimate episode guide' gives updates on the dogs. And more than half of them are still having the same problems, or in a few cases even worse.
The importance of science cannot be ignored. His methods have been rebuked. The evidence shows that his views are wrong. If we have solid evidence that his methods are dangerous, unpredictable and there are better ways... then why do it?
AboutDogTraining3 2 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 I'll defiantly consider what your saying. Though you can't be sure that those dogs are worse off or haven't changed because of Cesar's methods. Sometimes, which Cesar and even the owners have mentioned, owners don't follow through with the rules and schedules he lays out for them. Aside from the physical corrections he does (which I don't always agree with) the psychology he puts forward does work for many dogs when applied Correctly depending on the dog, owner and issue.
hushesthepuppies 1 month ago
Cesar is the best.
SrNostradamus2012 3 months ago
The same people who say that tiny little foot tap was a "kick" are probably the same people who think you should never ever punish a child
paulcottman 3 months ago 55
@paulcottman i agree. I use foot taps but never kicks. if you are tapping you are not causing pain and to them, its the same as using your hand. they dont understand foot and hand.. to them its the same. all being need to be disciplined in order to trained. children, dogs... they need to know when they are doing wrong as well as right. reward the right but dont exactly ignore the bad. trian them thats it bad. for dogs, best done when catching in the act.
angelmae3995 3 months ago
@paulcottman a good parent doesnt need to punish their child physically
illyas1 2 months ago
@illyas1 While I believe there is some truth to that statement it doesn't matter because in this particular video Cesar is not prompting the lady to physically punish her dog. Therefore, not only is a dog a different species with a different psychology but there is no physical punishment in the video so whether or not physcial punishment is admissable for dogs is another discussion. Cesar certainly uses punishment on other occassions but there is no punishment in this video.
paulcottman 2 months ago
@paulcottman hitting the dog isnt a punishiment?
illyas1 1 month ago
@paulcottman you can punish without physical abuse
illyas1 1 month ago
@illyas1 Hitting a dog when the hitting is contingent on the dogs behavior is positive punishment. I will be the first to point out that Cesar often invokes the use of what he calls a "touch" when he creates what he says is "the mother's bite" when in reality it is a perfect example of punishment that he is disguising under the aforementioned euphemisms. In this particular clip however, there was no hitting ( hitting being distinguished by its quickness and forcefulness) despite the contact.
paulcottman 1 month ago
@illyas1 Dog arent humans, so they arent children. Did you never see how dogs among each other solve this kind of problem? They BITE...so this tab is kinder than dogs would correct that behavior...
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
@Bailarsonsa are you a dog? and the majority of dogs live with humans.your example is illogical because this doesnt happen in the wild.yes a dog may rebuke another with physical force,but actually the alpha male is usually cool and calm,and just has to look at another dog to get him to stop.u r right we arent dogs,we are smarter and can do things better than emulating aggresive dog behavior like ceasar is doing .
illyas1 1 month ago
@illyas1 Of course Im not a dog, are you? Yeah, when the dog is the alpha male, then he dont have to do much. BUT in this video, the humans werent the alpha dog..so they have to get the position first from the dog who is the alpha in this house. So how to you take the alpha role from another dog? Just by a look? When two dominant dogs are together, they fight, chase each other till one give up s.o.
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
@Bailarsonsa alpha male huh? did you know that a lower ranking bitch can keep a bone from a higher ranking male?ceasar and others have spread this alppha fallacy,and i think you should go back and read updated scientific knowlege of what it means to be alpha.it is much more complex than you make it
illyas1 1 month ago
@illyas1 well when you have so much knowledge than all the others, then why you just explain this complex alpha role?
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
@Bailarsonsa You actually didnt answer my question how you take the alpha role from another one!
Lets here your idea how you would solve the problem in the video?
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
@Bailarsonsa there are many ways to be alpha, using force is not one of them!
illyas1 1 month ago
@illyas1 And it doesnt matter if we are smarter or not...the dog knows the best answer, when its about dog psychologie..and not the "smart" human...we have to follow they example, not some human idea of the better world for a dog. They living another world which in their genes, so why they should like more our world?
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
@Bailarsonsa the dog knows the best answer? that is your opinion,im sorry but humans know better.it would be totally apprpriate for a dog to pee in the house chew on everything and bark all day,but they live under our rules.dogs are breed and have adapted to human life.
illyas1 1 month ago
@paulcottman a child is human..a dog is an animal....helloo?? anybody there?? all of u ppl r humanizing animals which make them unstable then u cage them or u put them to sleep ...no i think a kick is better than a lethal injection....go buy a cat
dxbfreemind 6 days ago
@dxbfreemind
At no point did I explicitly state or imply that humans and dogs are the same. However, I do agree with your statement that people are quick to anthropomorphisize non human beings and it causes several problems in how they relate to the animals; in this case, dogs. An excellent collection of essays on the matter is available online or at your local bookstore. It is called "The Culture Clash" by world renowned dog trainer Jean Donaldson.
paulcottman 5 days ago
There's one thing i want to say about him. I think he's great. I don't know whats up with you guys to say like o my gosh he's kicking him, some of the dogs are really aggressive or just too overexited. What about the humans that could get hurt. I think his techniques are great, even when he needs to "touch" them. He could better do a touch so there no one will get hurt...
Chiraiki 3 months ago 25
@Chiraiki Some things I dont agree with Cesar, but the main part is really great, what he is doing. The people who dont like this tap, they totally ignoring the fact what this dog do to this humans. He could seriously injure them with his jumping, so why can this dog hurt the human, and the human dont have the right to touch back, and the touching which cesar do is not overreacted or something, it is softer than what the dog do.
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
@Bailarsonsa basically an eye for an eye huh?if the dog bites you then u bite him back?an eye for an eye leaves everyone blind.why must we use physical force to correct our dogs?they are totally capable of understanding what we want and if we like what they are doing.it is peoples fualt for not taking the time to communicate with their dog and training good behaviors from the outset.dont blame the dog.
illyas1 1 month ago
@illyas1 I didnt "blame" the dog. When the dog dont know best (I didnt meant peeing in the house, I meant something like taking alpha role, how to correct behavior s.o.), why they have so much issues when they live with humans, when they so brilliantly addapted the human life?
Well, just say your solution to the problem in the video, and dont just ignore, what Im asking.
Bailarsonsa 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Bailarsonsa alpha role?why do you think that corrects behavior? dogs dont have problems.in fact alot of their behavior is neccessary.one thing i do agree with ceasar is that it is the humans fault.he doesnt teach dogs he teaches humans
illyas1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The American College of Veterinary Behaviorists (ACVB), the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB) and the Society of Veterinary Behavior Technicians (SVBT) have uniformly SPOKEN OUT AGAINST the punishment-based techniques employed by Mr. Millan on his television show “The Dog Whisperer.”
Unfortunately, people believe anything they see on TV.
AgilityFox 3 months ago
The lady is an airhead lol
shallwe3148 3 months ago
@BeowoofOmega, idiot, stop using the unnatural internet.
AboutDogTraining3 3 months ago
women stick with cats i agree this dumb bitch i met walkink my dog also had a border ad mitted could not handle said she was a trainer told her numerous times my 15 month border possesion aggresivness be careful he finally nipped her agree it was wrong dont want get into details but now has to wear muzzle for 3 years may have to give him up we re treated him like a king trying or best all shots always up to date etc etc etc now we dont no what the hell to do
mike300406 3 months ago
Some people ESPECIALLY WOMEN do not need to have dogs.
fingaroll5 4 months ago
@fingaroll5 And is this based on this one woman or is this your just own ignorant and moronic belief? Because the last time I checked its a HUMAN (as in BOTH male and female) trait to make mistakes like this PERSON has.
hushesthepuppies 3 months ago
The abusive practice of kicking a dog is moronic. All this dog needed was a highly reinforced sit - and since he was excited about going out, we could have used that as a reward a la PREMACK.
AboutDogTraining3 4 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 hey fukhole stop posting your stupid comments.just because of some cannie research doesn't make u a dog expert dumbass
Sparta861 3 months ago 2
@Sparta861 Fucking turd, the scientific evidence is clear. Get your head out of Millan's ass.
AboutDogTraining3 3 months ago
Of course he could help this dog, he has experience in borderjumping...I mean jumping..border..collies! :) No hate please, I LOVE Cesar, but I couldn't keep this joke to myself! :D
solidus24 4 months ago
I think it's the dogs who phone cesar for help with their owners not the other way round. " My owner doesn't understand me. Please train them". And Cesar duly turns up and trains the owners how to behave. And the women always fall for him.
bobbylockes 4 months ago
@BeowoofOmega is an asshole dog beater. He ignores the scientific evidence against aversive jerk and kick methods because he enjoys being abusive to dogs. Like most immature losers with no self esteem he seeks a weak victim so he can feel like he has some power over them. This loser has never trained a dog and still kicks and jerks dogs to force compliance out of them.
AboutDogTraining3 4 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 And when did he Kick the dog? I'm not trying to be rude but I don't think you really know what a kick is.
hushesthepuppies 3 months ago
@hushesthepuppies, he kicks the dog. You may have been hypnotized by his faulty use of the word 'touch
AboutDogTraining3 3 months ago
w cesar millan
ExignotysTube 4 months ago
@TheHooligan1968 you are an asshole idiot. I have no idea what you are talking about, sounds like you are delusional
AboutDogTraining3 4 months ago
using the foot might be abusive if you wind up lol
thegander213 4 months ago
1:19 LMAO
fullfist 5 months ago
I don't care what anyone says. Cesar is a good trainer. I have yet to see him abuse the dogs or hurt them. People have to understand dogs are not like kids. They have a completely different mind set than humans. All of the people who click on DW vids just to bad mouth Cesar are just making themselves look like morons who have nothing better to do. Don't like his methods? Then don't watch his videos. Why don't you people go after real dog abusers?
pamlovsy2j 5 months ago
that dog can JUMP!
darthvader363 5 months ago
When we first adopted Bobo, a wolf, from the pound, he kept running away. I didn't want to chain or fence him, so we went to the pound and let him choose a mate. We brought home Lady, a border collie his age (8). That kept him home.
He was twice her size, but she was clearly his boss. She could be a real bitch to him sometimes, but he loved her just as she was.
Now that Bobo has passed away, she misses him a lot. They were inseparable. So she keeps following me around the house, asking for hugs.
eastariel 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I dont see why this requires a dog whisperer, Id just kick the fuck out of it.
aaronvespro 5 months ago
Holy shit that dog jumps high.
pimpjuice8921573 5 months ago
I wish I'm a dog whisperer like cesar :(
MichSushiGyoza 6 months ago
i have tried ceasar' s technique on my dogs, they are askals, and they had great improvement ever since, especially on controlling their excitement for meal time
jamienueca 6 months ago 18
@jamienueca at last a comment i was looking for, thank u.
Pathrissia 5 months ago
I own a pitbull terrier with a border collie and trust me this dog is nothing compared to her x_x
ATouchOfMagic88 6 months ago
Dogs, cats, and other non-human animals live much more in the present moment than humans do. We have rational minds that distort and filter life in the present, so we need to learn the truth of life with our rational minds to live more clearly and openly. When we learn the truth of life, pets will become even more popular. Search "Truth Contest" in Google and click the 1st result, then open The Present and read what it says to learn the truth of life.
AllThatYouSense 6 months ago
I've never seen dogs kick each other. So how is he treating a dog like a dog.... IT MILLAN BULLSHIT 101
AboutDogTraining3 6 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 NO you fool - dogs BITE eachother.....something we for a few reasons would find hard to implement quickly, hence a toe jab (NOT A KICK!!!) is a suitable subsitute - can't believe that has needed explaining - god with people like you around no wonder the dog training world is f****d up.
amberluka73 5 months ago
@amberluka73, you bloody imbecile!! That dog's bite each other is irrelevant because the reason you think they bite happen to be wrong. Also you fucking fool, by kicking the dog you assume that the dog makes the connection that it is equivalent to a bite coming from another dog and that it has the same meaning as a bite. That has to be the most deluded conclusion ever. You are fucked up and the treatment dogs receive from people like you is why 4 million die every year.
AboutDogTraining3 5 months ago
I am not an imbecile I am an experienced dog trainer. YOU are the fool, the 'pokes' are to merely snap the individual out of a rising state of negative mind. I have met people like you before so on that note I am not going to waste any more of my precious time because people like you are closed minded and set in there ways. LOl lol lol lol 4 million dogs die cos of people like me? god your a comedian. oh and keep your abusive language and swearing to yourself moron
amberluka73 5 months ago
@amberluka73 , you are an imbecile, and you don't even know what you are arguing about. First you believe you are 'biting' the dog, they you are snapping it out the situation you created in the first place. Why the fuck punish a dog for something you started? By merely making a sit a highly reinforced behaviour, you solve this problem, without violence. Everybody else can do it.
AboutDogTraining3 5 months ago
Cesar you are a God's gift...!!!
manolino1969 6 months ago
this dog is a Border mix, i'm pretty sure this dog is just over bored and has nothing to do so it gets excited. I also noticed this dog may like going for walks but also doesn't enjoy it. Really, a choke chain on a border? I've never seen the day....
Jal1515 6 months ago
@Jal1515 its indeed sad, my border collie/pitbull mix pulls like crazy but i tried a choke chain and it did not get better and she ended up at the vet :(
ATouchOfMagic88 6 months ago
@ATouchOfMagic88 Never use a choke chain. Search Kikopup on youtube and use that method. It is safer for the average dog owner and ALOT more effective. I am not saying Cesar is fake, just that his methods are for last ABSOLUTE LAST resort cases and professionals that know what they are doing. Training a dog takes weeks, months and sometimes years. My border collie was 6 years old when I began training him to walk on a loose leash but Kikopup's method works without negative side effects.
Supercucu123 6 months ago
@Supercucu123 Already tried the choke chain...my dad is a former police dog handler and they all use it but seems only affective with certain dogs. I just bought myself a anti pull harness from ''halti'' which i am first going to use if that doesn't work i'll try search what you recommend me :) border collie and their mixes same with pitbulls need a different training approach also because my dog is dog agressive and sadly gotten away 2 times (got out of her dog collar) and attacked...
ATouchOfMagic88 6 months ago
@ATouchOfMagic88 , we already know Millan's quick fixes only work as long as he is there to brutally punish the dog. I doubt you got a dog so you can mistreat it. Like anything worth doing, training takes time and the quick fixes are like the quick weight loss plans... they never work.
AboutDogTraining3 5 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3 I don't mistreat her, i hate the way people 'train' their dogs. training does take time i'm already busy for a few years and i see small progress but where i live i encounter lots of lose dogs and i hate it =\
ATouchOfMagic88 5 months ago
@Supercucu123 oh my, absolute last resort? Why take years to train a dog to do or not do something that you can achieve in minutes? Cesar is not fake, I know cos I was born with the innate knowledge of dog psychology he was. I agree here is more than one way to get the same results but his methods are fair and kind.
amberluka73 5 months ago
@amberluka73 What Cesar does cannot be achieved in minutes. It's done with repetition. I taught my dog to walk on a loose leash in a week and he was already 6 when he began training (just to clear up any confusion you may have). What Cesar has done in this video in particular is perfectly reasonable for the average dog owner. His other methods are more questionable such as his usage of choke chains, and his more physical methods.
Supercucu123 5 months ago
"it's hard though cuz she's so cute" - ...... really???? the OWNER should be ALWAYS be in control. Sometimes the owners on these shows just frustrate me... i couldn't imagine some of these dogs overpowering my life.
pessimystica 6 months ago
no abuse here. putting up your foot is not the same as a kick. For example, if my child is jumping on me and I put my hand in his way to keep him from jumping on me, that's not child abuse. The dog still seemed happy and excited for a walk after Cesar worked with her. No fear here.
pongo5544 6 months ago
Children who view the program may try to attempt the same techniques with their own pets and could be injured.
MsLabMom 6 months ago
CMIIW at first I admire Cesar Milan but it seems to me he did it with no love... he always talk about dominance and dominance and dominance. I agree dogs can read our 'energy' and aura and we should be the pack leader of the dog(s), but kicking doesn't seem too good to me. I mean -- humans should treat dogs like dogs, but we are humans... we aren't dogs. Dogs are supposed to be friends of humans ,no? Then why should we treat dogs like... slaves?
futarinokizuna 6 months ago
@futarinokizuna hes just teaching them discipline..
mikpisofare 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cesar Millan is Cool O_O not he?
vmxitaryan 6 months ago
Cesar Millan is Cool O_O
vmxitaryan 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
yo everybody if youll have a chance can youll please check out my video and tell me what you think just search" smartest pitbull pup" or "956razorramon" on youtube.. my pitbull dro is only 14 weeks old..thanks
please check it out and leave a comment
956razorramon 6 months ago
Did you see how he wasn't sure how to respond to the woman's foot abuse question? He quickly replied, "He's abusing you!", a statement that makes not sense at all. The dog is reacting with natural dog instincts - he's excited, ready to go! The dog is obviously not happy about being touched, prodded. If they simply reinforced his calm behavior with a treat or praise he would be much happier to repeat the behavior in the future. It's dominance, instead. I like Cesar, but that's just my 2 cents.
hope336 7 months ago
I guess this is an ok way to train your dog. Kind of kicking at the dog I don't really like. I trained my Border Collie with positive re-enforcement. He knew that when I get the leash out to sit calmly and let me put the leash on him without him freaking out. Telling her to sit and stay was a good thing. If she got back up and I would just make her sit and stay again. A clicker would really help with that. I guess this ok if you want to train a dog not to get to excited and jump.
SummerFoxi 7 months ago
hehe, that's true, she's abusing me! crizaaack~
MsHMChai 7 months ago
01:25 @ Is that a highfive fail?
wiilah 7 months ago
This is just a dominant, temporary fix. Not good. Positive re-enforcement is the only thing that works with dogs, especially border collies. With alpha mindset, you are breaking that dog's very spirit. The Alpha omega social instinct was bred out of dogs long long ago.
TrentGentry 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BeowoofOmega, you are lying again you dumbass. You don't respect science, evidence or even basic common sense. You are enamored with the TV dog kicker and lap up his jizz without thought.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
@BeowoofOmega , you are another ignorant liar, just like most of the people here who support Millan. You've made a log of false assumptions, starting with the one that lead you to believe a dog groomer who never finished high school. And don't thing you are fooling anyone, you don't respect evidence or science which tells me you don't work in robotics.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
@BeowoofOmega, you are an opinionated unemployed asshole. And you should fuck off because you are using the internet, invented by the scientists you are now insulting . FUCK YOU ASSHOLE.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
Millan's mangled hands are enough proof that he abuses animals and gets them to fight. No more need be said on this since we've all seen him get bitten time and time again.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
BeowoofCrap, Until you can come up with some evidence to back the lies, nothing you write is credible. Millan's dogs do feel abused, and they do fight back and his mangled hands are proof of it.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BeowoofOmega, we all know you are full of shit. That' why you can't back up any of your lies.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
@BeowoofOmega, you bloody moron. The fact is that Millan's hands look like raw meat from all the bites he has received by starting fights and attacking dogs. The fact is that his assertions have long been dismissed by knowledgeable people and the fact is that he only attracts people who don't know very much about dogs.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
@BeowoofOmega, well moron, if you were willing to walk away from your masturbatory fantansy, Millan, and open a book on the subject you would know the answer to that. Needless to say, Various, PhD and respected trainers have pointed out and spoken out against these backward and abusive practices.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
@BeowoofOmega - So now you want to take away kids ipods in order to punish a dog. Even by your standards, that has to be weird. But I guess it's better than hitting the dog, which is what you normally suggest.
Just because a dog has littermates, doesn't mean it's a pack animal. Other animals have littermates and they're not pack animals. Others also learn bite inhibition the same way - cats for example.
naisayd 7 months ago
@BeowoofOmega, asshole. What video are you responding to? In this video, Millan kicks the dog for being happy and excited to go out. Instead of training, he promotes abuse.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
The dogs is excited and happy and Millan responds to this by kicking and scaring the dog. So once it experiences Millan's painful "touch" he is no longer happy and as it has been documented for several decades his behavior is temporarily suppressed by violence. Simply teaching the dog to sit and rewarding the behavior would take care of this problem.
AboutDogTraining3 7 months ago
Ha I go SSST like Ceasar to shut up my sister!
CatalystofDoom 7 months ago
okay it just me, or when he "tapped" her, she YELPED? wtf?
Feelsloved 7 months ago
@Feelsloved relax my border collie yaps when I wave at her. dogs vocalize in many ways for many reasons--don't anthropomorphosize it.
pongo5544 7 months ago
I don't know why people still keep criticizing Cesar, he has helped many people and rescued many dogs from being put down. For all those failed trainers who are trolling Dog Whisperer vids with their untrue comments, stop being so jelous you might learn a thing or two from this guy..
hendrixexperiencedig 8 months ago 47
@hendrixexperiencedig
Fortunately, any person with good eyesight and a working brain can easily see Cesar's methods work. And, a well-known and recognized authority like National Geographic wouldn't have anything to do with a fake.
Naysayers (the mature ones, anyway) soon recognize what most others plainly see - that Millan's methods work. The fringe... well... eventually, they have to get off mommy's computer, have their drinky, then go beddy-bye. They're of no consequence at all.
Redshield666 8 months ago
@Redshield666
very true
hendrixexperiencedig 8 months ago
@Redshield666, and a person that can read KNOWS that millan often fails. We know he fails because he has documented the failures in the Ultimate Guide... and 50% are as bad as worse than when Millan declared them rehabilitated.
AboutDogTraining3 8 months ago
@hendrixexperiencedig quite frankly i try hard to find a single point on which i can criticize him but i swear no matter how hard i try i cant find a single reason ! so thats why i just simply love that guy ! :)
how the faack do u ppl find reasons to criticize him?? :/
RIZWANshaikh91 5 months ago
@RIZWANshaikh91
because they want to. They believe cesar is incapable of rehabilitating because he's 'unqualified' . But the truth be told what's better qualification than experience? Cesar is not about dog training he's about the physcology , those idiotic trainsers fail to understand him because of this. Cesar has rescued so many dogs that those trainers could never even dream of. No one has the right to criticize him.
hendrixexperiencedig 5 months ago
@hendrixexperiencedig experience is useless if he learns nothing from it. MILLAN is stuck in a loop. HIT dog results in suppressed behavior. His ignorance allows him to call that a calm/submissive dog. He thinks he has achieved his goal. In reality most experts agree that this is a shut down dog
AboutDogTraining3 4 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3
yes that's why they must be running around , eating , drinking , playing games , not get afraid , not get aggressive, not get put down and killed . Please keep your thoughts to yourself because they're ridiculous at this point. I'm suspicious that you even don't have dogs certainly you sound like you don't have any. Cesar is probably one of the best things that could've happened to those dogs out there because trainers like you gave up on them.
hendrixexperiencedig 4 months ago
@hendrixexperiencedig sure you can be deluded and think that. OR you can read the scientific evidence and the opinion real experts and organizations that find his methods unproductive and dangerous. ... but hey, ignorant people are often fooled by what they are marketed to on TV
AboutDogTraining3 4 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3
hehe, what do you think of those scientific evidence ? have they been handed over from some other planet? Cesar has the approval of the biggest organization on nature, animal acts ; Nat Geo, CLEARLY doesn't need the approval of people like you.
hendrixexperiencedig 4 months ago
@hendrixexperiencedig Every Succesful Person in the Media has Haters and Dislikers, most are just jealous. How can someone critizise him nearly every dog in his cases gets Fixed !
TheChefKev 5 months ago
@TheChefKev - Actually that's not true. About 50% of the dogs are not fixed and end up being rehomed or put down. That's according to one of Millan's own books. What he says on the show is very different from what he says in other moods. On his DVD's for aggressive dogs he reccomends the Thinschmidt group. They are using +R (clicker training) to treat aggression. Most of his explanations for behaviour on the show are just fabricated nonsense.
naisayd 5 months ago 2
@naisayd "Most of his explanations for behaviour on the show are just fabricated nonsense."
Does Cesar admit this in his books as well, or is that just an assertion of yours?
sweenith 3 months ago
@sweenith - It's an opinion based on the scientific research of others, statements by various professional organizations, licensed veterinarians and various people holding doctorate degrees in animal behaviour. If you want to review some of this you can goto/google urbandawgs About half way down the page, you'll find a link to some of their comments.
naisayd 3 months ago
@hendrixexperiencedig envy
MARGARET2082 4 months ago
@hendrixexperiencedig The winner is rarely nice.
buddabar00 4 months ago
Wow. This woman needs more work than the dog! She's not into this at all.
Good thing Cesar's expertise in interpreting the pack behavior of dogs is able to quickly illustrate how easily a creature of instinct is able to comply when it knows what is expected of it. This dog is far more intelligent than your average troll, better house-trained, more charming and FAR better-looking! Also, the dog quickly understands it's boundaries and abilities...
Redshield666 8 months ago
@Redshield666, there is no pack behavior in dogs. And what Cesar claims is usually false
AboutDogTraining3 8 months ago
@AboutDogTraining3
hehe that sounds funny, sure you're no zoologist. It is widely known that most canidaes have pack mentality and canis is in that group. They hunt , live and socialize in form of packs in their natural habitat. All canines have social hierarchy in forms of pack leaders and followers. You should review your sources before commenting and misinforming people.
hendrixexperiencedig 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hendrixexperiencedig , it may sound funny to you because you dont know the facts. Look at the research, the whole pack theory has been dropped by wolf biologists, which means it must also be dropped by those pushing it in dogs, as they point to the wolf for the origin of the alledged pact hierarchy.
Intelligent people distinguish between socialbility and pack behavior. They are very different.
AboutDogTraining3 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@AboutDogTraining3 Prove it to me.
spacetubecleaner 7 months ago
People can hate cesar's methods all they want.. but rather work like him than beat ur dog everythime they do something wrong. atleast he uses his body language more than he uses his fists
keleroo 8 months ago
@keleroo, he uses his kicks a lot more.
AboutDogTraining3 8 months ago
See what the lying asshole has done. He is trying to link two ideas and present them as one. This lying shithead will do anything to defend his here.
Of course all mature minds know that because dogs don't form packs and have leaders it doesn't mean human don't. All but that idiot CVTPitbull.
AboutDogTraining3 8 months ago
Ignore naisayd and ADT3, i have confirmed that they are both trolls whose greatest pleasure in life is arguing on yt armed with only a few articles they pulled up on google. Their only intent is to start fights and call people names. They say pack leaders/authority only cause harm. Therefore if they get shot nobody call the police so we can honor their view that authority/pack leaders are wrong.
CVTPitbull 8 months ago
Ignore BeowoofOmega, he has been a constant TROLL on all the Millan videos. His new technique of accusing people of having multiple accounts to distract from the fact that he has no counterpoint to all the scientific evidence that has been presented.
AboutDogTraining3 8 months ago
@MsAnimalProtector are you and idiot ?
he was just teaching it ?
what is bad about teaching ?!
you moron !!
20MayGad 8 months ago
The sheer number of dog-owners and dogs who have been injured, physically or emotionally, by this claptrap is incalculable. Millan's NatGeo show is a debacle. his treatment of Riley was deplorable and if i ever saw ANYONE dragging a dog up stairs or anywhere like that i would put an immediate stop to that.. I don't agree with the Alpha human approach at all, dominance is never the answer!!!!!
MsLabMom 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That bitch is fucking retarded... Peace
Sampopankki 8 months ago
I despise Cesar the Killer Milan. He should never be allowed around an animal, much less "teach" others his supposed "techniques." What a moral vacuum, and only morons would follow his advice.
MsAnimalProtector 9 months ago
@MsAnimalProtector Care to elaborate?
FallenKain 8 months ago
@MsAnimalProtector ?? that dog is completely fine. all Millan said was to speak sternly and touch her with the side of the foot. I guess waving a hand over a dog is abuse?
sue8765 8 months ago
@MsAnimalProtector your ignorant dogs do that to each other
besides he dosnt even hurt the dogs
fuckin hypocrite
alexandre007opa 8 months ago
hello if you have got any problems with your dog or you want to just ask sonthing
pleace go on my youtube channel i am not profesional i am still learnig but i try to solve you problems with you dog or if you just want to ask my sonthing i try to help.
Its free just leave comment on my channel and i contact you by e-mail i just conntact by e-mail i don;t visit because i am not sure if that work out.
so if you have problem or just want to ask me sonthing leave message and i contact you back.
HELP4urDOG 9 months ago
vergüenza !!
bond19761 9 months ago
Way easier than Cesar's method: First, hold the leash down at your side instead of at your chest. Then the dog will focus lower and be less likely to jump. Second: Turn your back on the dog if it jumps. If you are worried about getting hurt by the dog, keep a chair near where the leash is and put it between you and the dog. Third: Teach the dog a task to perform while you get the leash out, such as waiting by the door or laying down. The Cesar method will just agitate the dog in the long run.
mcgransazer 9 months ago
Dogs should not be inside a house, they get real frustrated and aggresive. Dogs should be in open space at a backyard, ect. Dogs were meant to be outside having fun and in touch with nature.
videotitan1 9 months ago
@videotitan1
Dogs shouldn't be inside a house . . . really? While I agree that some breeds should not be kept inside, thats not true of all breeds. It's a very ignorant statement to make. So being the kind hearted soul I am I'll help curtail that ignorance.
Many lap dogs (bred solely for companionship) are not good dogs to keep outside. Some are too frail for the outdoors and can't stand temperature variations. Greyhounds in particular climates also should not be kept outside. Ect.
Psychelectric 9 months ago