My choir did this piece this year for a music convention and it was a blast to sing. Perfecting it was definitely a challege, and the fect that there were no lyrics did not take away from the difficulty, but rather just made the importance of the tone and other musical aspects of the song that much more critical. The only thing that I think would have sounded better in the swingle singer's preformance is if they would have had cleaner cuts in the fist 5 chords. But that's just my opinion
I think many have lost sight of the important fact that this music was written 200+ years ago. This group is merely performing it in a style that is easier for the modern american audience to appreciate. If this is what it takes to get the common american to come to love classical music, then shouldn't we be for it?
@Belgarion9989 It is in a style that it would impossible for rats to appreciate, let alone human beings. This could not lead anyone to love beauty, quite the opposite.
@Schamshi are you trolling? If not then u need to calm down. Wtf do you know about singing? How can YOU deem someone else talentless if you're not a professional yourself? Is this how you get enjoyment out of your life? Trolling on videos? Its quite sad actually. If you dont like it simply dont watch it. Or go write to the swingle singers because they, if anyone, just might care.
I was searching for me zauberflöte videos, and i found this here, clicked on it and at 1:00 i was like, uhm.. not bad and then at 1:22 i was like god.. nice bass and just beautiful!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
God, these Swingle Singers piss me off so much. They're brutally mutilating good music just so that they can glorify themselves. I don't get how people seem to like, why, almost revere them. They're a bunch of suckers who destroy good music by "arranging" it (i.e. reducing and adapting to their pathetic voices) without really caring if it sounds good, as long as they can run around claiming that they perform "arrangements" of these pieces. Blimey, even the intonation is dreadful sometimes.
Drink your own acid instead of spitting on artists well respected by a lot of other people. About your opinion; far of reality and ful of hate. Get yourself a life!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
1. I've already got a live, thank you very much, which, among other things, included looking for the overture of Mozart's Zauberflöte. At this point, however, I was most unfortunately presented with this crap. As for "artists well respected by a lot of other people" - what does it matter how many other people respect them, I have my own opinion and I state it here, which is what the comments are for after all. Far of reality? How did you draw that conclusion? I thought opinions were subjective.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
2. Full of hate? Bingo. As I said, I get pretty pissed off when someone presents something under the title of something it has very little to do with (Mozart's Zauberflöte here) AND it doesn't even sound good if viewed independently of the original (of course, all in my humble, far from reality opinion). But of course, it's common Youtube practice to thumb down negative opinions of a video's subject and to make them out not to be taken seriously. Well, gotta go back to my far from reality life.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ah yes, and another thing which should make things even clearer: The fact that the Swingle Singers have cut the overture and completely removed the second part just shows they don't really care about the music, or Mozart. Their "arranging" and performing of famous classical pieces is just an excuse to have something to show off with, because if the pieces weren't famous, or at least written by famous composers, nobody would bother about some random uninteresting bunch of untalented singers.
Where would you draw the line? The way this music is played today, it is ALWAYS a strange arrangement that can never come close to what it was in the times of Mozart: Music never ever could be repeated (recorded). Very few people ever heard the "original". Then, music was copied, simplyfied, played by small bands, whisteled, hummed and sung by people who liked the melody and gave a damn, if it was "original" - as long as it felt good. I like Mozart both ways: Serious AND "without really caring".
@paulrandig Yep, I agree completely and have nothing to say against anything you said. The problem with this arrangement is that it doesn't "feel good", at least for me. I find it just annoying, the pretentious cheerfulness, the sickeningly pseudo-happy faces and the superficial music. In my opinion, if viewed on it's own, it's a short-lived, moderately entertaining, rather fake performance and mediocre singing. If viewed as an arrangement of the overture to Zauberflöte, it's just pathetic.
@paulrandig And also, if you make an arrangement of a piece, at least do it properly and don't just cut the second half away because you are incapable of making it sound interesting longer than 3 minutes. And if you DO make such a significant reduction, at least stand by it and declare that you shortened the original, and don't delude the audience and present this version as an arrangement of the overture, because this is deceptive.
@paulrandig What are you talking about, "the way music is played today?" who would listen to this except doddering gertiatics who can no longer get their Lawrence Welk fix?
@Schamschi THIS THINKING FIXATION IS MUSIC'S WORST ENEMY. ANY OPERA BE THAT A PAINTING, A POEM OR A MUSIC PIECE IS BY NO MEAN SACROSANT AND MAY BE SUBJECTED TO VARIATIONS (*SHOULD BE* AT TIMES). THAT WHAT MAKES CULTURE DEVELOP. THAT IS THE PRODUCT AND THE CAUSE OF INSPIRATION. I REALLY DON'T KNOW WHAT MAKES A PERSON WRITE SUCH A NASTY COMMENT ON SUCH A BEAUTIFUL PIECE BUT I'M SURE YOU CONSIDER YOURSELF THE ONE TRUE AUTHORITY IN DETERMINING WHAT CONSTITUTES "GOOD MUSIC".
Wickedly beautiful.
thethikboy 6 months ago
Più Mozart di così!
marioguidoscappucci 7 months ago
Someone mentioned this a while ago. I thought they were joking.
To hell with Camping--here is the sure sign of the end of the world right here.
HConstantine 8 months ago
i like it when they sing "bummmmmmmmmm"
tickingpenguin 8 months ago
it's difficul, it's hard, it's IMPOSSIBLE
bluecity75 8 months ago
My choir did this piece this year for a music convention and it was a blast to sing. Perfecting it was definitely a challege, and the fect that there were no lyrics did not take away from the difficulty, but rather just made the importance of the tone and other musical aspects of the song that much more critical. The only thing that I think would have sounded better in the swingle singer's preformance is if they would have had cleaner cuts in the fist 5 chords. But that's just my opinion
NiNjUnIcOrN 1 year ago 2
Absolutely loved it! And I'm sure Mozart would have loved it too. That's the tops in a capella singing.
musicfanBRA 1 year ago
I think many have lost sight of the important fact that this music was written 200+ years ago. This group is merely performing it in a style that is easier for the modern american audience to appreciate. If this is what it takes to get the common american to come to love classical music, then shouldn't we be for it?
Belgarion9989 1 year ago
@Belgarion9989 It is in a style that it would impossible for rats to appreciate, let alone human beings. This could not lead anyone to love beauty, quite the opposite.
HConstantine 8 months ago
These guys are an absolute joy, this isn't my favourite piece of theirs, but their pitch perfection and timing always amazes me.
lluhsnimnyrhtak 1 year ago
@Schamshi are you trolling? If not then u need to calm down. Wtf do you know about singing? How can YOU deem someone else talentless if you're not a professional yourself? Is this how you get enjoyment out of your life? Trolling on videos? Its quite sad actually. If you dont like it simply dont watch it. Or go write to the swingle singers because they, if anyone, just might care.
captainamazing2007 1 year ago
espetacular, genial...
iriscelta 1 year ago
I was searching for me zauberflöte videos, and i found this here, clicked on it and at 1:00 i was like, uhm.. not bad and then at 1:22 i was like god.. nice bass and just beautiful!!!
polarkreis201 1 year ago
Not their best it has to be said. But a tricky piece to tackle!
atomicmrpelly 1 year ago
That's so good to hear.
realidadebysumu 2 years ago
Viva Mozart!!!!
rihannalover93 2 years ago
this is hilarious lol
somehow it seems much older than early 1990s though
whisperr33 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
God, these Swingle Singers piss me off so much. They're brutally mutilating good music just so that they can glorify themselves. I don't get how people seem to like, why, almost revere them. They're a bunch of suckers who destroy good music by "arranging" it (i.e. reducing and adapting to their pathetic voices) without really caring if it sounds good, as long as they can run around claiming that they perform "arrangements" of these pieces. Blimey, even the intonation is dreadful sometimes.
Schamschi 2 years ago
Drink your own acid instead of spitting on artists well respected by a lot of other people. About your opinion; far of reality and ful of hate. Get yourself a life!
Geepereet 2 years ago 17
This comment has received too many negative votes show
1. I've already got a live, thank you very much, which, among other things, included looking for the overture of Mozart's Zauberflöte. At this point, however, I was most unfortunately presented with this crap. As for "artists well respected by a lot of other people" - what does it matter how many other people respect them, I have my own opinion and I state it here, which is what the comments are for after all. Far of reality? How did you draw that conclusion? I thought opinions were subjective.
Schamschi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
2. Full of hate? Bingo. As I said, I get pretty pissed off when someone presents something under the title of something it has very little to do with (Mozart's Zauberflöte here) AND it doesn't even sound good if viewed independently of the original (of course, all in my humble, far from reality opinion). But of course, it's common Youtube practice to thumb down negative opinions of a video's subject and to make them out not to be taken seriously. Well, gotta go back to my far from reality life.
Schamschi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ah yes, and another thing which should make things even clearer: The fact that the Swingle Singers have cut the overture and completely removed the second part just shows they don't really care about the music, or Mozart. Their "arranging" and performing of famous classical pieces is just an excuse to have something to show off with, because if the pieces weren't famous, or at least written by famous composers, nobody would bother about some random uninteresting bunch of untalented singers.
Schamschi 2 years ago
@Geepereet
and who are you to judge others-one has a right to express one's opinion so chill out
vkoracx 1 year ago
@ Schamschi Go die :D
singerguy93 2 years ago
No. But if you can't stand it, you can go kill yourself if you wish.
Schamschi 2 years ago
Can't stand it that there are people who disagree with you, that is.
Schamschi 2 years ago
Where would you draw the line? The way this music is played today, it is ALWAYS a strange arrangement that can never come close to what it was in the times of Mozart: Music never ever could be repeated (recorded). Very few people ever heard the "original". Then, music was copied, simplyfied, played by small bands, whisteled, hummed and sung by people who liked the melody and gave a damn, if it was "original" - as long as it felt good. I like Mozart both ways: Serious AND "without really caring".
paulrandig 1 year ago
@paulrandig Yep, I agree completely and have nothing to say against anything you said. The problem with this arrangement is that it doesn't "feel good", at least for me. I find it just annoying, the pretentious cheerfulness, the sickeningly pseudo-happy faces and the superficial music. In my opinion, if viewed on it's own, it's a short-lived, moderately entertaining, rather fake performance and mediocre singing. If viewed as an arrangement of the overture to Zauberflöte, it's just pathetic.
Schamschi 1 year ago
@paulrandig And also, if you make an arrangement of a piece, at least do it properly and don't just cut the second half away because you are incapable of making it sound interesting longer than 3 minutes. And if you DO make such a significant reduction, at least stand by it and declare that you shortened the original, and don't delude the audience and present this version as an arrangement of the overture, because this is deceptive.
Schamschi 1 year ago
@paulrandig What are you talking about, "the way music is played today?" who would listen to this except doddering gertiatics who can no longer get their Lawrence Welk fix?
HConstantine 8 months ago
@Schamschi THIS THINKING FIXATION IS MUSIC'S WORST ENEMY. ANY OPERA BE THAT A PAINTING, A POEM OR A MUSIC PIECE IS BY NO MEAN SACROSANT AND MAY BE SUBJECTED TO VARIATIONS (*SHOULD BE* AT TIMES). THAT WHAT MAKES CULTURE DEVELOP. THAT IS THE PRODUCT AND THE CAUSE OF INSPIRATION. I REALLY DON'T KNOW WHAT MAKES A PERSON WRITE SUCH A NASTY COMMENT ON SUCH A BEAUTIFUL PIECE BUT I'M SURE YOU CONSIDER YOURSELF THE ONE TRUE AUTHORITY IN DETERMINING WHAT CONSTITUTES "GOOD MUSIC".
Saar221184 4 months ago
Qui sono davvero stonatissimi però...
Matteo7419 2 years ago
Another fantastic arrangement by Ward Swingle and another wonderful performance by the Swingle Singers!
dwf56 2 years ago
ooh dat is lang geleden, ik had dit op videoband en heb het grijs gekeken, ze zijn echt geniaal !!!!
julauzan 2 years ago
klingt zuerst nach Kirchenchor o_o
aber sehr beeindruckend
DepressivCat 2 years ago
Tering, wat zijn die lui goed. Verder geen commentaar nodig.
hanjomorren 3 years ago