peanut3423 vs joshscorcher: An Objective Analysis

[Tobi3440]

0:33 every116: WHICH ONE IS BUTTER??

Tobi3440: no one... there cream...



[Mannetasi]

Great Analysis dude. I too think they both are great and comparing them is like comparing Zelda OOT and Majoras Mask: Very Difficult and its pretty much your personal opinions that sets the score.

Though one thing i didnt like here: Why did Josh lose a point just for liking the COD series?!

Thats just bullshit man. I too think the COD series is a great series but yeah it is overrated there is no denying but as Joshscorcher said: The people who whine about the it are way worse than the fanboys.

[MegaGoodoldtimes]

@5thBearCav

You said it man. Fuck FPS's

[MegaGoodoldtimes]

Both are awesome, but personally i like peanut3423 better

[biosector07]

joshscorcher FTW

[playrockchill]

call of duty is 10x better then halo



[5thBearCav]

@playrockchill Can't we all just agree that both are complete shit?

[NinThiago101]

My opinions:

#1: Joshscorcher wins

#2: Joshscorcher

#3: Joshscorcher

#4: Peanut3423

#5: Joshscorcher

#6: Peanut3423

#7: Peanut3423

#8: Joshschorcher

Joshscorcher is better, but Peanut is also really awesome. But hey that's my opinion, don't hate on me Peanut fanboys.

[SKnight8046]

ha, i loved josh's hitler parody. he should make a LOT more. :D

[TheNerdyTerd]

POTATOES!

[UrBrainOnDrugz1]

You are a biased as hell you can't compare Josh and peanut they're equally awesome you would never come close to either of them

[every116]

@UrBrainOnDrugz1 Why does nobody understand what sarcasm is?

[sephiroth8261]

FUCK U ASSFUCKER! NOBODY FUCKS WITH THE GAMING GODS

[every116]

@sephiroth8261 Spoken with such enlightening eloquence.

[sephiroth8261]

@every116 AND DONT FUCK WITH NOSTALGIA CREITIC OR AVGN!

[MRZOMBIEMASTA]

plus, you gave yourself 5 points for the lulz.

more bias.

[MRZOMBIEMASTA]

...

a point was lost because joshscorcher likes CoD and you like halo?

BI-ASED!!

[dementedvillian]

The ending sux in that vid

[screenON14]

@dementedvillian It's called a joke.

[pokechess1999]

i like em both but i personally favor Josh over peanut.

[dyldragon1]

I am a loyal fanboy to both Peanut3423 and Joshscorcher. Call of Duty IS a good franchise. But, your right. You can't compare them. They are both too awesome to do so.

[peanut3423]

My outro is actually my "An Autarch of Flame Production" clip with the matchstrike sound effect, as a nitpick. But Josh's outro is FAR better than mine, no contest xD

Overall a pretty interesting video. In the end it comes down to taste.

[alkapwnz1]

@peanut3423 scuse me, autarch, but i have a question that i need your opinion on. i have been working on a sprite indie game since 2006, and i can't decide on what the villains personality should be. here are two personalities i can't decide from. 1 is a seto massicist, pyrokinetic pyromaniac. 2 is an illogically insane genius. basically, one is destruction based, the other is comedically based.

i can't decide! what do you think?

sincerly, alkapwn.

[joshscorcher]

O_O

I'm uh...speechless.

But why does me liking Call of Duty warrant me losing a point?

[every116]

@joshscorcher Think of it this way: I thought of so many good things that I had to take away a point to make it even.

Plus, you know, it's Call of Duty.

[FelixFalora]

@every116 That's kinda sad >_>;

[joshscorcher]

@every116

...I don't follow that logic.

[CyberLink70]

@every116 YOU STEREOTYPE!!!

but i dont like COD as it's about war :(

and just look at the 1st and 2nd world wars!

[spongehead93]

@every116 You know you could have just made it even by giving Peanut the point, right? Judging by the way that this video was made, I'm going to assume that you didn't realize that.

[TheSuperEricWarshot]

@every116 "Plus, you know, it's Call of Duty"?

Not to be rude, but I don't think that gives you any reason to mark him down, at least give some reason about it. But that's just what I think. If Call of Duty is now an international "No-no" then it's fine with me.

[eviletcetera]

@joshscorcherSOMEONE on youtube who doesn't consintently (spelled that horrible) bitch about CoD. THANK YOU!

@every116 rating yourself above them.

1. Why were you even in the competition in the first place.

2. That was totally unncecesary and narcissistic.

[Aquashell11]

@joshscorcher I think he took a point off because he's probably a Halo fanboy. :p