a Perfect Circle - The Nurse who loved me

[TheRayven760]

This sounds like something Maynard would do: "Hey guys, I dont like how we play Nurse live. Let's completely change it while making it sound exactly the same."

[thefallenfew]

I so much prefer the live version to the album version. Heavier version FTW.

[KapustaCuber]

Much more like the failure version than the album is.

[THEATHElSTPARADlGM]

@electroexecutoid I'm truely sorry for my comments. I understand that if I ever behave like that again, you'll hit me harder than you did on London. i understand that you said it was a warning , and that if you hit me properly, you'd kill me. The truth is, i suffer from alopecia UNIVERSALIS<----the WORSE kind, and being a gay man with AIDS myself, i was jealous of your body, hair and physicl strength. I'm not a fighting man as you know,and I BEG you not to hit me properly. I APOLOGIZE TRUELY SIR

[bilderbergresistance]

3 Peoples nurse didnt have pharmacy keys

[doncabb]

Pharmacy keys, shes fallin hard for me, I can see it in her eys. She acts just like a nurse.......with all the other guys.

one of the best songs period! See you in Pittsburgh!

[jimmy5150ify]

The bitch didn't love you and she done you a favor when she left.

[jimmy5150ify]

ARE YOU SURE SHE EVEN LOVED YOU

[lllldepechemodellll]

electro i am SOOOOOOOOOO sorry.. PLEASE DON'T COME AFTER ME!!!! i BEG!!! i've heard about you and you scare me =( you know i lost all my hair in 1996, i had hair like george michael<--- LOVE HIM he's gay like MEEEEEEEE WHEEEEEEEEE!!!! sorry electro i went off on one again.. your HAIR i want.. your BODY i want.. i'm a puny bald gay vegan.. my bf left me in 1996, now i look like the guy from the movie: "Powder" =( lol =/

[electroexecutoide]

@lllldepechemodellll Shut the fuck up, you drivelling simpleton. Any more shit from you and I'll find you, break every bone in your puny body, dislocate every joint, remove every tooth, and kill you. In that order.

[HeuristicThought]

thats such a cool switchup from the original...the whole song in general so cohesive

[infectrus]

Tbhis song, when they performed it in south florida back in 05, was a different version. They rocked it hard core live. 

[smallclone]

WORST FRICKEN COVER!

[DeathComing5]

@smallclone keep it to yourself and go watch the original then. Maynard James keenan has a FAR better voice than the original artist does. then again, he has a better voice than most singers. i would hate to have him cover a song of mine if i ever made one, because he would make my version sound like some poor little cereal commercial tune.

fricken is a sorry excuse for a word by the way. if you cant say fuck, dont just replace it, because it makes you sound ridiculous. just leave the word out.

[smallclone]

@DeathComing5 sorry you didnt like my opinion on this TERRIBLE cover!

[DeathComing5]

@smallclone i pity you. you can go back to listening to your noise now.

[smallclone]

@DeathComing5 i pity you cause youre a loser.

[Rechiau]

@smallclone o no dis guyz haz difer opinion 2 me ther4 he iz wrong

Grow the fuck up.

[smallclone]

@Rechiau coming from the person that types like a retarded 4th grader?

[Rechiau]

@smallclone You seem inept in the comprehension of sarcasm.

[TheAtheistParadigm]

@smallclone i know what's going to be on my tombstone..."You're next!"

[smallclone]

@TheAtheistParadigm good!

[TheAtheistParadigm]

@smallclone lol

[MistressOfTheDark01]

"Say hello to all the apples on the ground, they were once in your eyes, but you sneezed them out while sleeping."

...amazing!

[etheoreal]

what's your interpretation of that?

[corpse891]

I didn't get the appeal of A Perfect Circle until I did a shitload of drugs. Now their songs somehow make more sense (although this ones a cover)

[eudian]

Drugs. Is there anything they can't do?

[dbhaisley]

@eudian Get you a decent job?

[Rechiau]

@dbhaisley Carl Sagan... No clarification needed.

[madore517]

EVERYONE should do a shitload of drugs. APC and TOOL are best enjoyed while screwed up, but once the buzz wears out they are still with you forever......peace to all

[kurorenkinI]

the solo it's amazing!!

[eudian]

The most amazing version I've ever heard.

[Namine9314]

My God..this is amazing...His voice, like it comes from the darkness *.*

[SargentandGreenLeaf]

I went to this tour, and it looked exactly the same over here in indiana, USA, exact posistions colors, all that, the same, the sound was excellent, and the bass was overpowered and distorted(not good), but this was DEFINATELY not the version off the cd, and when they kicked into that big open chorus, it was fucking amazing live, and then i got laid/drunk/high

[tokyopancake]

I love it

[Namine9314]

sAY helloooooo *____* I'm taking her home with meeeeeeee all dressed in white

[Sharpshooter226]

just hoping everyone knows this is a cover the song is originally by Failure look em up

[llllllDJlllllll]

yeah, we know. but its more somber, more interesting. for me at least, im not a Failure fan personally

[robhudd]

who gives a shit a perfect cirlce blows them out of the water

[ImyourTOOLuseme]

Is howerdell using a silverburst?

[ChaoticGore]

I think this song is amazingly beautiful.. what's the meaning behind it? :/

[zippynmandar]

Being shot down in the prime, and then later, in the hospital falling in love with your nurse.

Absolute surrender to the system that betrayed you. Being fucked up by the system, and then falling in silent, pathetic love with the final agent of that system: the nurse that keeps you anesthetized.

[cptspalding66]

my god..what a fantastic version..better than the album version, yeah..I think so..

[tamadrummer21]

i think so for sure

[TOOLGODDESSTT]

they are soo talented. beautiful song with a fucked up meaning

[tamadrummer21]

ahhhhhh....

[darksecretlife]

I love the live version of this song!!! :D

[SLiMxShANuS]

Badassss

[RHPSGal]

Maynard sings almost as good live as on the album PS I LOVE this song ‼

[lsrockhell]

Muito obrigado pelo video.

Este foi sem dúvida 1 dos melhores concertos que já assisti. Voltem depressa....

[lsrockhell]

Grande... grande concerto.. Voltem depressa.

4 anos já é demasiado.

[elway0798]

WOW I'll take the failure version 8 days a week over this

[tankjr85]

this song was wrote by ken andrews by failure.

[TheSaurusThumb]

Wow. I am so glad that I'm able to be absolutely in love with this live version... it's amazing.

[KidZiDx]

yea the more failureish version is better!

[July4thGatti]

good cover =)

[arquitectop]

say hello...

[imnotrance]

failure would be proud

[992171B]

Great record!! thx

[trustinme25]

it is so awesome how Maynard's voice sounds the same in concert as it does on the apc cd's

[alphamop]

One of the best male vocalists ever in my opinion. It would be cool to hear him to a solo record of lighter edged material in the vain of Jeff Buckley's Grace or Chris Cornell's Euphoria Morning :). I can only hope.

[GonzoNose11]

No he's better live!! Saw Maynard 3 times so far!

[Mixarenan]

Yeah, but he didn´t sing like in the album. Unfortunately.

[trustinme25]

true

[IIIIdepechemodeIIII]

@trustinme25 just as he does it on TOOL's shit too. excellent live singer.

[InvisibleTeeth]

I miss Failure:(

[Nazeal]

poor failure

[chimaera01]

I fucking love this performance so much, I could literally sit here all day playing it over and over and over again.

What a band. Sad to see it end...

[beer4me88]

i have a really hard time with deciding on whether i liked troy or james better in this band

[Grumm669]

another beautiful cover..

i will miss them dearly

role on billy's new band

[theamazingchuy]

APC did a great job with this song both live and on the CD.

Maynard and Ken Andrews of Failure need to get together to play this song. What a great tune

[d1sp0s1t10n]

they did a few years back in Philadelphia when APC had an acoustic set which Ken produced and he guessed appeared on that song.cheers.

[InvisibleTeeth]

I don't understand why they didn't more since Year of the Rabbit opened for APC...

[pudhap]

maynard is the master! i like this version equally to the one on the album.

[Klaxon101]

Fuckin' awesome...I was there and this wasn't even the better part!

[TheLemon22]

This live version is much much darker than the recorded version.

I love it.

[kiwiteepee]

i love the changes from some major melodies to minors

[michaeljfox16]

i really like the variation in Maynard's melodies

[whoracle3]

The CD version of this song is much different than this live version. on the cd there's no guitar or drums or bass.. its just an organ and violins with vocals

i like the live one better

[M4rjolein]

I'm pretty sure this recording is of the post-Troy-era. I see Jordi White on base not Paz. I also think a lot of people know Failure because APC covered this song.

[sudajmahi]

i do....but i have since fallen in love with failure, and fantastic planet. so i guess its a good thing

[codifiedmatter]

Yes, this is the new line up of APC with Jordie and James. as much as i like it, i kind of miss Paz. 3 Libras just isn't the same without her.

[whorehoppin]

amazing song - the original by Failure was great but APC's version is excellent - anything by Failure is amazing though, it's too bad nobody knows of them.

[RequiemPAPE]

Maynard voice is a beautifull instrument in APC and a weapon in Tool...

Mers de noms is just perfect. I just hope that many people could hear it

[Migh3l]

maynards voice...nothing to say about that!unique

[Vamp182]

this is the best song from them i<3 them! =D

[nunolousa]

Eu adorei esta versão... eu estava lah!!!

[telekinesis21]

best song ever from them

[daweadil]

i disagree...3 libras was a decent song too!

[abakaneza]

this band sounds pretty good but i always thought maynards voice killed it, he shouldve stuck with tool

[chimaera01]

(derogatory reply inserted here)

[nrscj4]

Are you on drugs!!!! Do you have any clue what his voice is????

[vihcn]

i know! people whose opinions don't match your own are obviously on drugs.

[duran]

at least give credit where credit is due Maynard.

You're covering Failure. THEY wrote the song, not you.

[PikkaBird]

Dude, settle down. The resolution in this video is gross, and I can't be arsed to look closely, but chances are Troy is there on stage. You know, Troy FROM FAILURE!! Do you get this worked up every time a band doesn't announce who wrote the tune they're covering?

[descendtheshadesofni]

if you watch it again and listen REAL carefully you'll hear that he doesnt say "i wrote this song" or anything to that effect

now calm down

[chords06]

AWESOME! I bet this confused the audience when they played it the way failure did. Most people dont know that its a cover song and even fewer know who failure is. I like this much better than the cover apc did on thier album. Thanks!

[thefallenfew]

This is the version I saw. OMG I loved it so much. So glad someone recorded it!

[quesefodam10vezes]

beatifull version.

[TheSiteTV]

The live version of this song is so much cooler than the album version. Thanks for posting...

[skonthebass]

I don't think so nickkicks, I think it's more about delusions of reality while being in mental hospital/drug treatment.

[nickkicks999]

is this song about rape?

[westy13]

i love this version. its an awesome song. way better than the album version

[AOCRkid]

its good

but i dont know if i like failure's version better. almost two different songs

[ayistromia]

this is awsome, totally changed up the key, i like