@justschr You're an idiot. She's one of the few celebrities at a healthy weight. She's not going to purposely throw up like all the other female celebrities just because you want her to.
Kelly does a good job approximating the explosive 1945 classic Betty Hutton orginal hit version of this song. For the whole song, check out Betty's version on YouTube.
The firstest and still the bestest. All of the songs that she excelled at, including this one, just goes to prove that she is not being currently challenged. She is so much better than the cookie cutter songs that she is now singing. With songs like "I Surrender", "Without You", and others, she proved that she could match anything that the "big three" could do. I just love her voice and control.
@kingshane94 you cant lip sync or pre-record any of your tracks while being a contestant in a singing competition, are you fucking serious asking that question?? its a singing competition, not some brittany spears concert, wow you do you even know american idol??? its a serious singing competition, all live, she even sang i surrender live while having voice cracks because her voice was tired out of all the previous live singing, please that comment is NOT and WILL NEVER BE for Kelly Clarkson..
Seriously, this is absolutely incredible. It's like she took on a character just for the performance. Even better, I had the privilege of seeing her perform this live on tour, and it was even better. Ugh!
Ive seen this vid about 300 times...and I just realized this version---is the best version of any artist!!!! including Bette Midler...!!!
Kelly---even this early in the IDOL show---was already performing at a level that is Hall of Fame .....She is among the greatest singers and performers of all time.
Must have missed this performance live, but when I found this video, I decided that Kelly Clarkson is the best Idol performer yet. Love this sound, love this era, love Kelly. Hate the post-modernistic camera work! Really want to see Kelly sing all of this song... just her, nothing else.
...Kelly needs to stop producing the conventional pop stuff and try an album or two of this. This kind of noise could bring back the glory of the Big Band era to our modern day. (I still feel terrible I wasn't alive back when this music was popular.)
This is not the 2nd best "Idol" performance ever. It is the absolute BEST performance in the show's history. Everything nickargyle and 313TTra wrote in their posts here says it all!
if i could rewind things back to what season in american idol i would like to visit again. then season 1 would be the period i wanrt to go back again.. i also want to watch how kelly savor the moment when she won american idol.. i love kelly
Sometimes old Idol performances that you remember as being "great" at the time don't quite measure up when you revisit them years later...but this one is as amazing as ever. STILL one of the best AI moments of all time!
Kelly was awesome singing "big band music and Swing" as she was singing a "blues" song from the days of Billie Holiday. Those songs were sang during the AI1 Competition and she was awesome at it. The Universities kids are all into "Swing" dancing and Big Band Music today. I wish she would do some of this now.
She is so dang VERSATILE! pop, rock, power ballads, blues, you name it! this was one of American Idol's best performances ever. she looks great here too! Go Kelly!! I can't wait for your new album :)
This is just so perfect! Seems like a scene from a movie, can't believe it happened on live tv! No other idol performance has yet surpassed this one in the US or UK.
You need more than just a voice to pull off any Big Band song. That music came from an era of music wasn't just simply sang; it was felt. Kelly Clarkson has the personality and stage presence to pull off Big Band song which is incredibly rare. Sure, there are plenty of people who have the natural tone, but they usually lack the other half to make any big band song authentic
ohh..this another good and excellent preformance from kelly during AI after Natural woman..she's so cute here and i loved the way she sang this song...and..she's beautiful here...hehe;)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I've never seen a better performance of this song as performed by Bette Midler in the movie "For The Boys"...after you see this...you'll see Kelly's version could have been MUCH beter.
I just watched it on here. Since Kelly's is the version I'm used to, I wasn't as impressed by Bette's. She does a great job, but not even close to Kelly. She gives me chills every time. Plus, she has a more powerful voice for the big notes.
I love this perfromance. This shows you that she can sing just about anything. Nobody in any season except for Jordin Sparks and Carly Smithson can song like her. She is # 1 in my book.
100% totally agree...Underwood? Sure, great...not Clarkson. Daughtry...blast to see him make it...not Daughtry. Fantasia? Aiken? Just not Clarkson (or Tamayra Grey for that matter...I'd put her at #2 in terms of raw vocal ability and performance talent)
perfection...i went to a concert of hers in January and she waz just amazing, she waz hittin high notes lyke it waz nothing, so i dont understand this whole i miss this kelly clarkson nonsense...anywayz this waz brilliant!!!
I think her voice is so much better suited for music like this. Her kind of pissy rock singing is good, but I feel she's pushing it too much and you can hear that her voice is beginning to give out. I miss the Kelly Clarkson I used to love!
I love this performance so much. She sounds great, but what sets her apart is how well she performs as far as acting and playing to the audience. She could absolutely be a fierce, sexy starlet from the big band era here.
for real? kelly can outsing carrie on any song, any day of the week. this performance blows away anything carrie did on idol, including "alone" (which i did really enjoy, but which was also bettered by the harmony of the backup singers and a better arrangement than idol usually sees).
I knew right then and there that not only would Kelly WIN American Idol, but that she was a huge star that was born! It's hard to believe that she went from this performance to where she is now.
i could not agree more, carrie did hearts alone a little better than kelly did stuff like that there. they are both amazing tho!! when were the good days when good singers won idol...
LOL! You'e right! I meant this performance is one of the best! check out my countdown on my myspace blog at myspace(dot)com(forwardslash)gilbertgonzalezjr
Top blog "American Idol's BEST PERFORMANCES EVER!
Kelly is the BEST CONTESTANT EVER! NO ONE COMPARES!
WOW that is realy good. I have never seen her perform in American idol, mainly because by the time it got to Australia i think the USA were in ther 3rd season but still lol
...and we have celebrities like Britney Spears, Kesha, Dev....etc etc etc
xXinXtheXasylumXx 3 months ago
Wow she's so fat now...
justschr 4 months ago
@justschr You're an idiot. She's one of the few celebrities at a healthy weight. She's not going to purposely throw up like all the other female celebrities just because you want her to.
ilovekelly75 3 months ago 2
@ilovekelly75
yeah, ur right. i still love kelly. so what if she's gained weight? i hope she doesn't feel bad and continues to sing. her voice is just...... WOW.
t1a9c13ful 3 months ago
Kelly does a good job approximating the explosive 1945 classic Betty Hutton orginal hit version of this song. For the whole song, check out Betty's version on YouTube.
horarwgt 4 months ago
This is awesome! hahaha I LOVE YOU KELLY<3 I hope to see you again very soon! I haven't seen you live since '05!
KarleyIsAvrilsNo1Fan 6 months ago
she can do anything! Fantastickly!
duffybrady 7 months ago
The firstest and still the bestest. All of the songs that she excelled at, including this one, just goes to prove that she is not being currently challenged. She is so much better than the cookie cutter songs that she is now singing. With songs like "I Surrender", "Without You", and others, she proved that she could match anything that the "big three" could do. I just love her voice and control.
TheOoKevin 8 months ago 3
My favorite performance by Kelly Clarkson. She knocked it out of the ballpark on this one.
Lthrboots 8 months ago
This was fantastic! She is still the best AI to date.
MHBombo18 9 months ago 2
Easy ti see why she won.........
iconnian 9 months ago 3
Best performance EVER. :)
athornontherose 10 months ago
is it just me or does she look a bit like alison iraheta here?
lagofala 10 months ago
she did'n seem to try it hard! shejust came out extremaly easy!!
MiguelFRCable 10 months ago
@nickargyle Couldn't agree more. She's so cheeky.
bethelducky 11 months ago
I miss when American Idol used to be like this. No one can beat Kelly Clarkson!
reesespieces22 1 year ago 2
@reesespieces22 you are absolutly right!
MiguelFRCable 10 months ago
this was truly her best performance in the competition.
jmds88 1 year ago
Looks like it was pre-recorded? It's great though
kingshane94 1 year ago
@kingshane94 No it wasn't. You're not allowed to do that in a singing competition.
wiseguyknowsit 1 year ago
@kingshane94 you cant lip sync or pre-record any of your tracks while being a contestant in a singing competition, are you fucking serious asking that question?? its a singing competition, not some brittany spears concert, wow you do you even know american idol??? its a serious singing competition, all live, she even sang i surrender live while having voice cracks because her voice was tired out of all the previous live singing, please that comment is NOT and WILL NEVER BE for Kelly Clarkson..
MrMonsterlock 2 months ago
Kelly please these kind of music instead of just rock/pop music which I don't really enjoy thoroughly.. I like old school music!!
MrLuigiable 1 year ago
DIVA!
Seriously, this is absolutely incredible. It's like she took on a character just for the performance. Even better, I had the privilege of seeing her perform this live on tour, and it was even better. Ugh!
ninfan92 1 year ago 3
Ive seen this vid about 300 times...and I just realized this version---is the best version of any artist!!!! including Bette Midler...!!!
Kelly---even this early in the IDOL show---was already performing at a level that is Hall of Fame .....She is among the greatest singers and performers of all time.
greenwoodtea 1 year ago 8
Must have missed this performance live, but when I found this video, I decided that Kelly Clarkson is the best Idol performer yet. Love this sound, love this era, love Kelly. Hate the post-modernistic camera work! Really want to see Kelly sing all of this song... just her, nothing else.
six55three2one 1 year ago 4
Dang! I forgot how good this one was! She was my 2nd fave behind Tamyra, but by this point in the season, I fully expected Kelly to win.
sanchemusic 1 year ago 4
Now that is talent. Step outside the familiar and own it in every way.
truthisnice 1 year ago 5
@nickargyle great comment!!!! right on the mark!
charliebergy101239 1 year ago
She absolutely nailed the era. The inflections are perfect and the voice is just so suited to be singing it. Wonderful performance.
mhart78676 1 year ago 4
...Kelly needs to stop producing the conventional pop stuff and try an album or two of this. This kind of noise could bring back the glory of the Big Band era to our modern day. (I still feel terrible I wasn't alive back when this music was popular.)
AceOfDiamonds29 1 year ago 5
I wasnt a Kelly fan in the beginning, but i remember this moment very clearly. This is when she stood out to me!
LivingLegendMedia 1 year ago 2
This is not the 2nd best "Idol" performance ever. It is the absolute BEST performance in the show's history. Everything nickargyle and 313TTra wrote in their posts here says it all!
ghb61 1 year ago
Best American Idol performance of all time, for sure. This made Kelly a star. I miss this quality on Idol...
wonderland610 1 year ago 4
SPECTACULAR DONT U MEAN??
appledumpling032 2 years ago
amazing amazing amazing
Mernerwastaken 2 years ago
Just listening to this again...somehow I really love it! Thanks for posting this!
55jaro55 2 years ago
This song and Kelly makes me grrrrrrowwl... Grrrrrr..
peterdaniel66 2 years ago
i agree-- it would be great if Kelly would make a CD of songs of this genre! i'd definitely buy it! she's sensational!
charliebergy101239 2 years ago 8
I'd love it if she recorded this
IdaRuda 2 years ago 10
OMGGG! She is so amazing! I love this song!
snickerjonesmeg 2 years ago 5
Love this
melowe8 2 years ago 9
all u beyonce fans she does not sing all her songs with a live mic do u understand Kelly does
luckeyhal 2 years ago 9
this rocks!
realkellyclarksonme 2 years ago 4
she needs to sing the whole song on one of her cds !
sethsakeeper 2 years ago 13
@sethsakeeper Agreed...I'd def buy whatever CD she came out with if it had this song ♥♥
NYChica23 3 months ago
Wow! What a performance--I never knew she could sing like that. I wonder if she could do that today. Good for her! :)
ParksM5 2 years ago 7
Wow, this was freaking AMAZING. Do more stuff like this, Kelly!
SharpCookies 2 years ago 4
this shit is fucking perfect!!!!!
GosfordAbercrombie 2 years ago 14
Bette Midler performs this song in the movie "For the Boys". She plays a USO-type entertainer singing for the troops in WW II.
jsidewinder 2 years ago
is this song off of a movie? if so whats the name?
lovecountrymusic12 2 years ago
Kelly has the classic voice. Her rendition of at last, beats christina's and beyonce's. SHE should have done back to basics.
stoningking 2 years ago 6
Love love love this song! Kelly Rocks! =)
JimmyRH2005 2 years ago 5
if i could rewind things back to what season in american idol i would like to visit again. then season 1 would be the period i wanrt to go back again.. i also want to watch how kelly savor the moment when she won american idol.. i love kelly
lyricsandinfo 2 years ago
Sometimes old Idol performances that you remember as being "great" at the time don't quite measure up when you revisit them years later...but this one is as amazing as ever. STILL one of the best AI moments of all time!
centzon 2 years ago 10
Kelly was awesome singing "big band music and Swing" as she was singing a "blues" song from the days of Billie Holiday. Those songs were sang during the AI1 Competition and she was awesome at it. The Universities kids are all into "Swing" dancing and Big Band Music today. I wish she would do some of this now.
amarettaludia 2 years ago 2
I really like Kelly's rendition of this song.
damsel2007 2 years ago 6
amazing
Jule0104 2 years ago 3
Smokin' performance.
In this performance, Kelly Clarkson reminds me of Patty Andrews of the Andrews Sisters; and she even looks a little bit like her too.
olhole 2 years ago 3
Total awesomeness!
FiestaTexas01 2 years ago 2
amazing!!!!
ewkakc 2 years ago
Kelly's Natural woman was even better IMO. This is the 2nd best performance in Idol history. :)
928sniper 2 years ago 7
best performance by an idol contestant evvvaaah
jenie212 2 years ago 3
still the best performance ever
bluewhale18 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I love Kelly !!! Such an awesome singer!!!
Check out a Hot band from Vancouver BC. Search for "Brandon Paris Band + Say Goodbye"
<3 Rachel
shnobunnie 3 years ago
wow!
freecas 3 years ago 4
This is the first idol performance that really blew people away and i dont think anyone's even matched it since.
Sirwastealot 3 years ago 12
I totally agree I loved when she sang this and I dont think its been matched since. Even till this day I still think of it.
ash12488 2 years ago 2
This performance gives me chills. Kelly can sing anything.
BestScreenameEver 3 years ago 4
I adore this song iz's so incredible and kelly has such a wonderful brilliant voice...LOVEEEEE ITTTT
shojonael 3 years ago 12
She is so dang VERSATILE! pop, rock, power ballads, blues, you name it! this was one of American Idol's best performances ever. she looks great here too! Go Kelly!! I can't wait for your new album :)
passi0nfruit25 3 years ago 11
I remember seeing this on Idol and realizing she was the real deal. This is when I became hooked on Idol. This song. Plus she's hot in this clip! LOL
TVATodd 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
no puede cantar ese temaaa jajaja. no tiene la voz para hacerlo. tiene linda voz, pero no, ese tema no.
buhdoble 3 years ago
i cant understand that
codeblue2187 3 years ago 2
WOW!!! KELLY can sing anything!!!!!
JCartagena89 3 years ago 12
Kelly is just awesome!!!!!
hardinja01 3 years ago 10
This is just so perfect! Seems like a scene from a movie, can't believe it happened on live tv! No other idol performance has yet surpassed this one in the US or UK.
Kelly you are the greatest!!
3l3TTra 3 years ago 69
there are no words to describe how incredibly amazing this performance is.
SmplKindOfLvly88 3 years ago 17
You need more than just a voice to pull off any Big Band song. That music came from an era of music wasn't just simply sang; it was felt. Kelly Clarkson has the personality and stage presence to pull off Big Band song which is incredibly rare. Sure, there are plenty of people who have the natural tone, but they usually lack the other half to make any big band song authentic
ub3rsc00ber 3 years ago 15
ohh..this another good and excellent preformance from kelly during AI after Natural woman..she's so cute here and i loved the way she sang this song...and..she's beautiful here...hehe;)
daisynatural 3 years ago 7
Carrie CAN'T do this.
<3 Kelly
IloveKCxox 3 years ago 18
carrie + big band = UGH!!!!
KELLY is better
osahju914 3 years ago 5
Quite possibly the best Idol performance, period. Everything else seems amateur.
Jahjjj 3 years ago 8
She should record this.
smileuall 3 years ago 7
Kelly did an absolutely AMAZING job singing this song. Her performance made her look like a natural.
ninfan92 3 years ago 7
in ai she's the only one who can do it..haha
otarish 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
What genre of music would you call this?
And are there any artists you would recommend who sing this type of music?
nylatinguy3000 3 years ago 2
swing music, i guess, Michael Buble can do it really well, but not as well as Kelly does this
ilovekelly75 3 years ago
She's amazing.
SmplKindOfLvly88 3 years ago 7
shes soooo funny !!
yepthatsme8787 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I've never seen a better performance of this song as performed by Bette Midler in the movie "For The Boys"...after you see this...you'll see Kelly's version could have been MUCH beter.
blueride38 3 years ago
I just watched it on here. Since Kelly's is the version I'm used to, I wasn't as impressed by Bette's. She does a great job, but not even close to Kelly. She gives me chills every time. Plus, she has a more powerful voice for the big notes.
ilovekelly75 3 years ago 4
I loved that.
betaaaaa 3 years ago
She resembles Judy Garland when she sings this song :) and it makes me happy
dreamdisneyhill 3 years ago 2
the original & best.
melloe 3 years ago 3
I love her facial Expressions when she sings. She is so cute. lol
uberrios 3 years ago 6
I love this perfromance. This shows you that she can sing just about anything. Nobody in any season except for Jordin Sparks and Carly Smithson can song like her. She is # 1 in my book.
uberrios 3 years ago
u forgot Carrie
Maximum179 3 years ago
Oh Yeah! Sorry!
uberrios 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and lakisha
osahju914 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what about vonzell and david archuleta? and brooke white? and a-fed?
osahju914 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and melinda
osahju914 3 years ago
This is my fave kelly clarkson performance. I really became a fan after seeing her sing this.
jenie212 3 years ago 2
wow this is amazing! I like her range and her ability to make a seemingly boring theme a lot of fun to watch...
chatterbox1229 3 years ago
This performance makes a lot of "Best of AI" lists -- and with good reason. Kelly shows such spunk here, and her voices sounds fantastic.
centzon 3 years ago
100% totally agree...Underwood? Sure, great...not Clarkson. Daughtry...blast to see him make it...not Daughtry. Fantasia? Aiken? Just not Clarkson (or Tamayra Grey for that matter...I'd put her at #2 in terms of raw vocal ability and performance talent)
qdome 3 years ago
That's the only time I can recollect an audience on their feet.
indycat47 3 years ago
This is the performance that made Kelly stand out from the rest --she clearly showed she is a winner
gailduran 3 years ago 3
I love all her performances
she is so sexy in this
i love her
she is the best
and she made this song...wordeful
and this song is so difficut
diguinhos2kelly 3 years ago 2
Best performance ever on American Idol :O
lolh3h3h3aeg 3 years ago 3
Perfect. I love this performance. I actually love almost all her performances.
Tuciiii14 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nisiquiera se aprendio bien la letra...
She doesn't know the lyrics...
SClubRachel7 4 years ago
What's she saying 1:27-1:30?
xchangedyoux 4 years ago
great great great performance
callseba 4 years ago 2
chills.
marco114 4 years ago
She was amazing singer though....... Truly remarkable... Lucky us to have that bright star shine upon us by music
ray8 4 years ago
I can't believe my ears.
MusicAdd4ever 4 years ago 3
perfection...i went to a concert of hers in January and she waz just amazing, she waz hittin high notes lyke it waz nothing, so i dont understand this whole i miss this kelly clarkson nonsense...anywayz this waz brilliant!!!
musicallywild123 4 years ago 2
i wish more contestants sang song like this..!!
shmuckzz 4 years ago
Ai is so lucky to have found her..
alowaaaaa 4 years ago 3
I think her voice is so much better suited for music like this. Her kind of pissy rock singing is good, but I feel she's pushing it too much and you can hear that her voice is beginning to give out. I miss the Kelly Clarkson I used to love!
abangel16 4 years ago
Better than bette, yes, but Betty Hutton kicks her to the curb. Kelly does a stellar job though
osahju914 4 years ago
Betty Hutton, from 1944, before Bette was born.
osahju914 4 years ago
i love this omg i think she is the best i miss her being on idol. she is so cool and loves everyone!
hersheyspresents 4 years ago
Wow Awesome!! What a voice...control...stage presence....she still has these things!!
KKBrit 4 years ago 3
it is "her"song.the best song she did yet( in my opinion)
luxcretia2 4 years ago 23
No one could have done that better!
jackson4socks 4 years ago 20
omg! she looks so beautiful!!
ldrockstar69 4 years ago 7
oooooh-that would be awesome!!!!!
k2a4 4 years ago
i miss this kelly clarkson.
omgcutiestephy 4 years ago 4
she has great stage presence
purexample 4 years ago 8
She's vocally perfect..
Calo0o 4 years ago 12
excellent ! =D
EliseWhatever 4 years ago 3
amazing!!!
volcanicrain 4 years ago 2
so good...
mrwafi 4 years ago 2
kelly so rules.
dancindude03 4 years ago 6
<3333333333
allyx3 4 years ago
Who sings the original?
curiegurl 4 years ago
betty hutton
osahju914 4 years ago
This is my favorite kelly performance.
2RLadies 4 years ago
ok, because in Germany there's just one known guy who can sing.
luxcretia2 4 years ago 3
oh my gosh she is just too good!
blue4penguins911 4 years ago
I love this performance so much. She sounds great, but what sets her apart is how well she performs as far as acting and playing to the audience. She could absolutely be a fierce, sexy starlet from the big band era here.
hokieashleyt 4 years ago
for real? kelly can outsing carrie on any song, any day of the week. this performance blows away anything carrie did on idol, including "alone" (which i did really enjoy, but which was also bettered by the harmony of the backup singers and a better arrangement than idol usually sees).
semicolin 4 years ago 3
kelly isnt a god... good lord.
OrdinaryGirl22 4 years ago
no, she's just a better singer than carrie underwood. i have never tried to deify her.
semicolin 4 years ago 9
Best Idol performance ever! Some compare her to Carrie?!!! Get it together...
scarcastic 4 years ago 3
carrie and her are amazing.
OrdinaryGirl22 4 years ago
I knew right then and there that not only would Kelly WIN American Idol, but that she was a huge star that was born! It's hard to believe that she went from this performance to where she is now.
soundsatdjs1964 4 years ago
I love this performance!!
Orsex 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
see how a hot chick loses a bet and has to strip in front of her classmates <b>(_stripAss.com_)<b>
tqsofjxcasmndc 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
second best AI performances ever (the 1º its carrie's alone)
krum13 4 years ago
i could not agree more, carrie did hearts alone a little better than kelly did stuff like that there. they are both amazing tho!! when were the good days when good singers won idol...
st0602 4 years ago
wow great song ;)
by the way i love her voice
aduchaaa 4 years ago
She won!!!
latifa84 4 years ago
Ive jacked of to this video like 50 times,
boozehound420 4 years ago
and to think they stuck her with Justin for a year.
XyIv 4 years ago
TOP
luxcretia2 4 years ago
I LOVE KELLY!!! She placed 2nd in world idol but she should've won. She probably would've if she sang this.
st0602 4 years ago
and who did win?
luxcretia2 4 years ago
im pretty sure the guy from germany...not sure tho
st0602 4 years ago
you mean Mark Medlock?
luxcretia2 4 years ago
she's out of this world! One of Idol's best!!!
free2bfierce 4 years ago
um, ONE of? I think she's THE best so far. Carrie is good, but nothing like k.
galadriel6969 4 years ago
LOL! You'e right! I meant this performance is one of the best! check out my countdown on my myspace blog at myspace(dot)com(forwardslash)gilbertgonzalezjr
Top blog "American Idol's BEST PERFORMANCES EVER!
Kelly is the BEST CONTESTANT EVER! NO ONE COMPARES!
free2bfierce 4 years ago
WOW
luxcretia2 4 years ago
WOW that is realy good. I have never seen her perform in American idol, mainly because by the time it got to Australia i think the USA were in ther 3rd season but still lol
spankykit 4 years ago
I still remember that performance. When I saw that I knew she was going to win.
XyIv 4 years ago
holy friggin. i loved it then and i'm happy i found it here again. that was great. her best for sure.
mowho33 4 years ago
:)
love ya, kel!!! :D :)
stampnstom 4 years ago
i started watching american idol only during the 3rd season. Gosh! i didn't know there were also good performers during the first season.
pajodaep 4 years ago