It was good but I feel that the clips themselves were too slow. Not quality wise just slow. I mean the song is upbeat and fast in pace, the clips could have been sped up to make it more exciting.
Do you want to learn what is being said in this song? I downloaded the lyrics and their English translation. If you want a copy, I can send a message with these lyrics to you.
I live in Iceland, and we learn languages in school here depending on the grade, like 3rd grade is learning English, 7th grade...is a new language idk what it is, I'll be there next year.
@LaLunaHollow but isn't it kind of annoying if it fits the song? In my opinion it kind of is...well, it's still good even if the song doesnt fit, right??
it feels like you don't know what the words in the soing means as nothing really fit with what she sings.. then again most people wouldn't notics that unless they are Swedish like me
ok first of all people quit comparing to the other one so its the same song and same anime used so what! You did a nice job ending was awesome! though I kind of agree the video was a bit slow
I think it's unfair for people to keep comparing this to the old one. People make amvs with the same song and anime as others, and they're not usually compared (as far as I have seen)
You did a wonderful job :) I like this amv very much
i think the very ending fit it so perfectly, but during it the video itself seemed slow even though the music is fast....but i still like it very much either way ^^
I like this one very much! I think it has a completely different feel from the old one as well as a completely different focus.
I did end up feeling that maybe the pacing of the clips didn't fit the music at times, and some clips would have been better used at different parts of the song (like Kraehe kissing Mytho while taking the shard would have gone well with the kissing sound, I think).
Overall, very nice! I would like to see it in higher quality.
I think you did a very good job on this, however I would probably stay away from this song/anime combination simply because the original is so well known and so...well, fantastic. Ppl are naturally going to always compare anything that comes after to the original. You clearly have potential and talent so keep at it! Great job!
The original is probably unbeatable, but I applaud you for your effort. It looks like you did put a lot of thought into it. Nice job! It's a good AMV.
It's the episode with the ghost knight. Fakir was asked to play the knight in a play and that was his 'try out'. He left right after that without accepting or denying the part.
This is kinda comical, 'cause it's like a love song and in the beginning it seems as though Rue is in love with Ahiru, although she despices her in the beginning xD
Your amv is good, but I don't think it's good enough to rival the original Håll Om Mig amv. In the original amv, the creator has synched every clip to the music - every movement in each clip matches to the song. you, on the other hand, doesn't really have that much synching to the music at all. I'll say it again: It's good, but not as good as the original amv.
I really like this video. The music (burrows into my brain OMG) lines up with the scenes in the video really nicely, and the anime exploits my weakness for ballet liek whoa. Definitely Netflixing Princess Tutu ASAP.
I think it'd be better if you used a different song. That'd make it more original and it'd seem less like you were riding the coattails of that video. Especially since the comparison makes your AMV look more poor.
I think you used clips that were pretty long, like...it didn't seem as well edited, but it wasn't bad. You can definitely improve and be like...muchos better.
Hmm in my opinion not as good. i also went and watched the better quality. It doesn't wrap me up like the fast past in the other one does and the reason i liked the other one is that the characters move with the beat perfectly. In this one they will be standing still when the music is pounding. I also liked the fact that when the melody changed a bit the other video moves to the cranks to show it`s different. it was good and i hoped i didn`t sound mean i`m really just trying to give feed back.
Well, I really really like it, but I think a few scenes were a little out of place. Then again, that might just have been the timing issue youtube gave it and it threw off my view of what it was supposed to seem like. But anyways, GREAT video. :D (I don't comment on many videos, so... x))
I have to say it's a well made video! But I think you should stay the course of originality! It's not because it's not good (trust me, I'm HORRIBLE, so you have my praise at your abilities!) but being original always wins out, even over talent.
Most just don't want to see the something redone. It's like you're trying to outdo someone who did something amazing. Let them have that and put your talent to finding your own. Because from what I saw in that video, you have an awesome talent.
i hate people who say why did you even do this it could never compare. well who cares i did a lame remake of my own but yours is alot better then mine and i like it. it was your way of doing it and i like it
There was a trailer for the series that aired before the episodes. That's where Tutu's other transformation is from and also the dance between Ahiru and Kreahe. :) Hope that helped!
Positive: Excellent timing; much better than most. I love the clips you chose for both the "Mwah" sound and the key change.
Crit: Although yours rocks, the other one beats yours out on a few things: There's a contact movemetn on just about every beat, and a remarkable fluency matching what the words are doing. Like around :50 in most of the vids, there's the lyrics "Ja kom närmare ett slag" and the "när" is drawn out just as Tutu dips.(continued)
But not just the fluency...the physical sound of the word fits. Around 1:00, the words are "Blodet rusar vilt och hett" and the "hett" (which sounds like a brutal "herr") is where Kraehe does this little...raven-y motion, just sharp and evil.
Now I'm not putting down your vid; it rocked out loud. But I've been obsessing over the original, and there are some things in there that I consider pure genius. How she pulls it off, I'll never know.
i think that the other was better but this one was better then other rival videos to this song i've seen. one was practically the same video but clips were just moved arouns a little.
I like how you didn't have a lot of the same scenes as in the other but I don't think a lot of the scenes matched up as well in the other. It has nothing to do with timing cause other than being off by a couple of seconds it's not bad. Where the other Hall Om Mig vid could be used as a opening theme, this one falls just short of that honor.
You did a very good job though, love all the scenes of Fakir with his sword. :D
I agree, You pulled off your theme very well, and overall i love your video.
It does seem kind of too slow moving for the song though, like- you didnt use enough fast moving scenes? i dunno, maybe its just because its 3:30 a.m here and i'm half awake ^^;
ok, if I had to rate this vid, it would be a 3. Iv'e seen a much better video version of this song. dont give up, it takes practice to make a really good video.
Nice. ^^ I admit you've got guts trying to rival that vid. I would be too scared too. x3
And it's nice, but for things to work on, I'd say more attention to timing and action matching to the timing of the clips. Like, when there is a large sound.. (I don't really know how to describe it. Like when the music goes, "BAM!" kind of) do a scene switch or a white/black flash. I dunno, makes it more interesting. Also, the theme of yours seems like Duck vs Rue, and the other is like a series trib.
I'm not insulted at all. I think your criticism is helpful. ^^
I was trying to make the theme Duck vs Rue. I'm glad someone noticed. :)
As for the effects I tried to put no effects in to just show the awesome scenes just like they are.
When I made the video the timing was right on but YouTube made it off a little. I'll be posting a better version on Veoh soon and hopefully the timing will be right. ^^
Thanks again for your nice comments and criticism! :)
It was good but I feel that the clips themselves were too slow. Not quality wise just slow. I mean the song is upbeat and fast in pace, the clips could have been sped up to make it more exciting.
LadyRuelleyn 2 weeks ago
Love this song an anime
otakufreak55 4 weeks ago
I hope I learn Swedish there because then I'll understand the song.
Sailorsallyrainbow 5 months ago
@Sailorsallyrainbow
Do you want to learn what is being said in this song? I downloaded the lyrics and their English translation. If you want a copy, I can send a message with these lyrics to you.
hoodlumrocknroll1 3 months ago
I live in Iceland, and we learn languages in school here depending on the grade, like 3rd grade is learning English, 7th grade...is a new language idk what it is, I'll be there next year.
Sailorsallyrainbow 5 months ago
@LaLunaHollow but isn't it kind of annoying if it fits the song? In my opinion it kind of is...well, it's still good even if the song doesnt fit, right??
Sailorsallyrainbow 5 months ago
wonderful job i love your ending!
WhiteRoseWolves 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Don't you mean " Håll om mig"? If you can type an "Å" Then I give you this so you can put it in the title
Å
å
leopold621 6 months ago
Comment removed
leopold621 6 months ago
i love it^^ its so awsome the song is great and princess tutu is a beautiful anime^^awsome work:D
XHanonXx 7 months ago
I've seen the hole show, it's quit good. But there music was much bsetter and fit the show!!!!
SuperMrduncan 7 months ago
why wont u be nice to everyone?
why are you not helpful?
why are you judgemental? why dont you allow other to express their opinion freely?
what is wrong with freedom? is freedom a bad thing?
is slavery good? is bondage feel good? you love bondage??? O.o
boostme405 9 months ago
i love how the tital is hall om mig (new) and the song name is hall om mi nu
irockthatsock 10 months ago
i like it and now that i think of it i actuarially LOVE rue
SuperEee1992 11 months ago
i like it
SuperEee1992 11 months ago
i think it would be better if u put the times with the eps cos some people can kinda lose track
animeloverdontcare 1 year ago
it feels like you don't know what the words in the soing means as nothing really fit with what she sings.. then again most people wouldn't notics that unless they are Swedish like me
LaLunaHollow 1 year ago
Great song, great video! I loved it!
RemyxedMagic 1 year ago
ok first of all people quit comparing to the other one so its the same song and same anime used so what! You did a nice job ending was awesome! though I kind of agree the video was a bit slow
animegirl677 1 year ago
i liked the old one better :/ this one is still good though
Spirit485 1 year ago
I think it's unfair for people to keep comparing this to the old one. People make amvs with the same song and anime as others, and they're not usually compared (as far as I have seen)
You did a wonderful job :) I like this amv very much
MangaPrincess2 1 year ago
No offense, still prefer the original amv way over this. Good effort though.
potatochan 1 year ago
o_O this is ... Pretty
oOMisseMisseOo 1 year ago
Love it! ^_^ <3
racerabbit93 1 year ago
this is the AMV i watch a year ago that got me hooked to Princess Tutu! xD
Awesome job on it!!
FumikoxShou01 1 year ago
i think the very ending fit it so perfectly, but during it the video itself seemed slow even though the music is fast....but i still like it very much either way ^^
miCHOOmi 1 year ago
its too slow for the music.. the original its faster thats why it is so good
Missfiregirl1 1 year ago
this song makes the show seem hardcore, they there's alot of ballet battle-dancing and people stealing boyfriends lol
theaterhobo 1 year ago
i like it mor ethan the original winner which won the contest .... i think everyone knows which one i mean. so great job^^
formalelogik 2 years ago
Quick question- where did you download the song.. ?
n.n;
hils22787 2 years ago
I looove it. C: You did a great job. <3
Ranma113 2 years ago
i've noticed something. in this video and the so magical one u made, they both have finnished in the ending pose of ahiru's transformation!
AussieAnime24 2 years ago
Is this song from Germany? Because the words sound German.
If so... BONUS TO THE AWESOMENESS!!!!!!!!!!
KHTimeProtecter 2 years ago 2
@KHTimeProtecter
It's Swedish.
LolFlame 2 years ago
the song is swedish by a woman named nanne gronvall
winscar666 2 years ago
It's sung in Swedish. n.n;
But German and Swedish language is closely related..
hils22787 2 years ago
I like this one very much! I think it has a completely different feel from the old one as well as a completely different focus.
I did end up feeling that maybe the pacing of the clips didn't fit the music at times, and some clips would have been better used at different parts of the song (like Kraehe kissing Mytho while taking the shard would have gone well with the kissing sound, I think).
Overall, very nice! I would like to see it in higher quality.
crimeofpassion279 2 years ago 2
wow very nice
well done^^
Toothclaw3 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its to much like the original one...
TobiLova779 2 years ago
How?
Because its the same anime and song?
LeelyLily 2 years ago 2
i disagree D:
nekokitten1193 2 years ago 2
i love this song!
AyuChanz13 2 years ago 5
i really wanted myto and duck together but fakir was better suited after all in the end.
AyuChanz13 2 years ago 4
I think you did a very good job on this, however I would probably stay away from this song/anime combination simply because the original is so well known and so...well, fantastic. Ppl are naturally going to always compare anything that comes after to the original. You clearly have potential and talent so keep at it! Great job!
anthyrose2 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Looks too much like the original, though not as good. Nice try though.
thetangerineotaku 2 years ago
I agree with the others that the original is practically unbeatable, but you still did a very good job! It still captured the feel of PT very well!
tokyogirl79 2 years ago
I still like the old one better, but this one is also good!
Dawnstreak 2 years ago
The original is probably unbeatable, but I applaud you for your effort. It looks like you did put a lot of thought into it. Nice job! It's a good AMV.
Schizm11 2 years ago 4
yaay it´s a swedish song...XD goo sweden
xAngelsCryTonightx 2 years ago
i love this vid!!
AbbyXme123 2 years ago
really good
TigerTy24 2 years ago 2
cute
Misaspuppy 2 years ago
its not as good as the original tutu hall on mig song, sorry.
Blackemperess 2 years ago 5
that isnt t say that what you've done isnt good, its just the other one seems more appropriate and timed better.
Blackemperess 2 years ago 3
I love this video!!! What program do you use?
MangaMoon95 2 years ago
wat episode is it when teh chick and teh other chick r dancing together?
JeremySumpterIsMine 2 years ago
awesome AMV! which episode is 1:15 to 1:29 from? i don't remember seeing that part.
DoctorWhoFan93 2 years ago
It's the episode with the ghost knight. Fakir was asked to play the knight in a play and that was his 'try out'. He left right after that without accepting or denying the part.
SatsukiDate 2 years ago
It closely resembles a similar video by ElhaymVanHouten.
sinmajik 2 years ago
what episode is the ghost knight in i kinda lost track of the episodes. sorry great vid by the way!!!
wintermint08 3 years ago
It's episode 18. :)
Thanks. ^^ Glad you like my video!
Ruby7490 3 years ago
@Ruby7490
I would like to see clips with Ahiru and Fakir put to the song I Will Always Be With You from All Dogs Go To Heaven 2
hoodlumrocknroll1 3 months ago
wow this is really good :D
KawaiiAnimeLuverGirl 3 years ago
Amaazzzziinnggg job! No wonder why it has well over 10,000 views. =]
♥
BeautyFromAshes91 3 years ago
Hunny, this was very good to remake the old one. Seeing the old one gets tiring and its wonderful to see a new one out there! <3
alenadautry 3 years ago
Yeahyeah <3
OnlySolitude 3 years ago
wow that was a reaaly good video! i luved it! <33 ^^
goddesofshine 3 years ago
Very well done.
voo0 3 years ago
Lol in 2:51 I swear I heard "slip into target"
I love this AMV. I'm not gonna compare it to others, because that's mean. This one's actually really awesome.
nonaloll 3 years ago 7
i like it alot
princessserena1995 3 years ago
where did you get the song?
kairahiwatari104 3 years ago
This is kinda comical, 'cause it's like a love song and in the beginning it seems as though Rue is in love with Ahiru, although she despices her in the beginning xD
SofiaSwe94 3 years ago
Great job!
I voted for this song in "Melodifestivalen" by Nanne grönvall
And I love this video awsome job!
5 stars and added to favorites!
Ylmi17 3 years ago
very good! i enjoyed watching it.
Although i like this one very much i don't think it can be compared to the original one
pineappleblanket 3 years ago
I liked it, But the original one hit all of the beats, your clips just dragged on a bit. Not as fast.
Well keep up the good work. It was still a good video. Well done
<3Blueangel
AoiSakura06661 3 years ago
Can u tell me where u got the clips?
ReleaseUrself 3 years ago
Your amv is good, but I don't think it's good enough to rival the original Håll Om Mig amv. In the original amv, the creator has synched every clip to the music - every movement in each clip matches to the song. you, on the other hand, doesn't really have that much synching to the music at all. I'll say it again: It's good, but not as good as the original amv.
DeepAquaNeptune 3 years ago
where did u get the clips 4m?
ultimatebishoujo29 3 years ago
I really like this video. The music (burrows into my brain OMG) lines up with the scenes in the video really nicely, and the anime exploits my weakness for ballet liek whoa. Definitely Netflixing Princess Tutu ASAP.
SandMagic 3 years ago
Kawai!!!
Lirena24 3 years ago
omg i really wanna watch this anime but WHERE??
:)
cpluvr4ever 3 years ago
here! or on Veoh
kittenlove34 3 years ago
its called princess tutu
iluvani132 3 years ago
I think it'd be better if you used a different song. That'd make it more original and it'd seem less like you were riding the coattails of that video. Especially since the comparison makes your AMV look more poor.
I think you used clips that were pretty long, like...it didn't seem as well edited, but it wasn't bad. You can definitely improve and be like...muchos better.
citizen00erased 3 years ago 19
what language is this song in?
shamanking48 3 years ago
Swedish
citizen00erased 3 years ago
Hmm in my opinion not as good. i also went and watched the better quality. It doesn't wrap me up like the fast past in the other one does and the reason i liked the other one is that the characters move with the beat perfectly. In this one they will be standing still when the music is pounding. I also liked the fact that when the melody changed a bit the other video moves to the cranks to show it`s different. it was good and i hoped i didn`t sound mean i`m really just trying to give feed back.
KatherineenirethaK 3 years ago 6
pretty awesomeeeee
:D
XoFireAngleXo1231 3 years ago
Well, I really really like it, but I think a few scenes were a little out of place. Then again, that might just have been the timing issue youtube gave it and it threw off my view of what it was supposed to seem like. But anyways, GREAT video. :D (I don't comment on many videos, so... x))
Abrkdlasjf 3 years ago 2
There's a link to a better version of this video in the description. It's on my freewebs site. It's much better timing than this one. :)
Ruby7490 3 years ago
I'd like to request the song too, please!
KikaiMazdaspdFD 3 years ago
Wow, I love this! The song fits the video so perfectly :)
I like this one a whole lot better than the other one, in my opinion.
TsubasaChroniclesgal 3 years ago
I have to say it's a well made video! But I think you should stay the course of originality! It's not because it's not good (trust me, I'm HORRIBLE, so you have my praise at your abilities!) but being original always wins out, even over talent.
Most just don't want to see the something redone. It's like you're trying to outdo someone who did something amazing. Let them have that and put your talent to finding your own. Because from what I saw in that video, you have an awesome talent.
DemonuntilDeath 3 years ago 14
i hate people who say why did you even do this it could never compare. well who cares i did a lame remake of my own but yours is alot better then mine and i like it. it was your way of doing it and i like it
punkanime14 3 years ago 2
=3
copy and paste
XxKandyHeartsXx 3 years ago
Why there r some scenes I have never seen in the episodes?? Can u tell me that??
U did a great job ;]
XxDarkBlackRosexX 3 years ago 2
There was a trailer for the series that aired before the episodes. That's where Tutu's other transformation is from and also the dance between Ahiru and Kreahe. :) Hope that helped!
Ruby7490 3 years ago
Can you send me this version of the song please.
Mitokoko 3 years ago
i can send you the song i have it
punkanime14 3 years ago
Thanks
Mitokoko 3 years ago
no prob pm me your email
punkanime14 3 years ago
Could I request the song from you as well? I'm in love with it.
DemonuntilDeath 3 years ago
yea just pm me your email
punkanime14 3 years ago
I enjoyed it. As you said the timing was off just a bit but yeah I like it. 5/5
^_^
CrissySubaku 3 years ago
I like the choice of clips, but the timing could be a whole lot better
chimerademonninja 3 years ago 4
Positive: Excellent timing; much better than most. I love the clips you chose for both the "Mwah" sound and the key change.
Crit: Although yours rocks, the other one beats yours out on a few things: There's a contact movemetn on just about every beat, and a remarkable fluency matching what the words are doing. Like around :50 in most of the vids, there's the lyrics "Ja kom närmare ett slag" and the "när" is drawn out just as Tutu dips.(continued)
Saraiiwuzhere 3 years ago
But not just the fluency...the physical sound of the word fits. Around 1:00, the words are "Blodet rusar vilt och hett" and the "hett" (which sounds like a brutal "herr") is where Kraehe does this little...raven-y motion, just sharp and evil.
Now I'm not putting down your vid; it rocked out loud. But I've been obsessing over the original, and there are some things in there that I consider pure genius. How she pulls it off, I'll never know.
Saraiiwuzhere 3 years ago 3
Thank you for your nice comments! I'm glad you like my video so much.
Thanks also for the criticism. I know there's some stuff that didn't match up but oh well. ^^
I agree: I'll never know how she made a video that good. O_o
Ruby7490 3 years ago
Im confused mabey she used Vegas editer???
Mitokoko 3 years ago
i think that the other was better but this one was better then other rival videos to this song i've seen. one was practically the same video but clips were just moved arouns a little.
punkanime14 3 years ago
I know, I've seen that one. No originality. Thanks for the comment! ^^
Ruby7490 3 years ago
lol
this was so cool
glittergirl84 3 years ago
I liked this, but I don't think it can quite compare to the other one. Great job regardless and 5/5
yukixnoxjutsu 3 years ago 2
5/5 and much better than the other one... although... if it weren't for the other one, I wouldn't be into princes tutu(or into ballet XD)
mirokusonlywoman 3 years ago
Thankies! :D
I felt the other one didn't have enough dancing scenes and more battle scenes so I wanted to make one of my own. Glad you like it. :)
Ruby7490 3 years ago
Rating: 3/5
I like how you didn't have a lot of the same scenes as in the other but I don't think a lot of the scenes matched up as well in the other. It has nothing to do with timing cause other than being off by a couple of seconds it's not bad. Where the other Hall Om Mig vid could be used as a opening theme, this one falls just short of that honor.
You did a very good job though, love all the scenes of Fakir with his sword. :D
Seylin 3 years ago 2
Wow, this vid is soooo awesome! I only wish I could actually make cool vids like this! Great job! I don't think the timing is that bad!
bubblyhinata 3 years ago
I really like this, i think u did well.
mangalover31392 3 years ago
Thankies. :)
Ruby7490 3 years ago
I agree, You pulled off your theme very well, and overall i love your video.
It does seem kind of too slow moving for the song though, like- you didnt use enough fast moving scenes? i dunno, maybe its just because its 3:30 a.m here and i'm half awake ^^;
BUT- I loved your video, :]
Great job!
Komakii 3 years ago
It matched perfectly in my file when I made it but YouTube throws off the timing so it looks funny. ^^; Glad you like it though!
Ruby7490 3 years ago
ok, if I had to rate this vid, it would be a 3. Iv'e seen a much better video version of this song. dont give up, it takes practice to make a really good video.
kaibakitty05 3 years ago
Did you go to the link in the description? Youtube messed up the timing and quality so I posted it elsewhere. Thanks overall for the comment! ^_^
Ruby7490 3 years ago
fantastic!!! and this video don't have 100000 honours???? damn youtube XD fantastic and awesome video!!! :)
AuroraLancaster 3 years ago
XD Thanks very much. :)
Ruby7490 3 years ago
Nice. ^^ I admit you've got guts trying to rival that vid. I would be too scared too. x3
And it's nice, but for things to work on, I'd say more attention to timing and action matching to the timing of the clips. Like, when there is a large sound.. (I don't really know how to describe it. Like when the music goes, "BAM!" kind of) do a scene switch or a white/black flash. I dunno, makes it more interesting. Also, the theme of yours seems like Duck vs Rue, and the other is like a series trib.
camichan19 3 years ago
Anyway, still I think it's pretty good.
Keep up the good work.
5/5
(and I hope you aren't offended. I didn't mean to comment like an insult, just critiscm. ^-^;; ))
camichan19 3 years ago
I'm not insulted at all. I think your criticism is helpful. ^^
I was trying to make the theme Duck vs Rue. I'm glad someone noticed. :)
As for the effects I tried to put no effects in to just show the awesome scenes just like they are.
When I made the video the timing was right on but YouTube made it off a little. I'll be posting a better version on Veoh soon and hopefully the timing will be right. ^^
Thanks again for your nice comments and criticism! :)
Ruby7490 3 years ago
Anytime. ^^ I'm glad it helps. And well...since you wanted it to Duck vs. Rue, you pulled it off well. =]
When you get up the new version message me the link. =]
*goes to watch more of your vids*
camichan19 3 years ago
Okay. :) Sure thing!
Thanks a lot again! ^^
Ruby7490 3 years ago