Added: 5 years ago
From: justinvicible
Views: 191,955
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (360)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • JENETTE'S VERSION IS WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY­YYYYYYY BETTER

  • Jennette's version is much better!

  • don't like his version. Amanda Stott's is sooo much better!!

  • janettes is better than his and amys

  • 1) Jennette McCurdy!!!

    2) Bryan Rice!!

    3) Amanda Stott!

  • well i think all 3 versions r g8

  • HE SINGS IT BETTER THEN AMANDA STOTT

  • Ew me no likey his voice, or his face.

  • this personally is my favorite version

    Jenette definetly didnt write this

  • @weirdotisALECCA I AGREE! :)

  • jennette beats amanda and bryan thats my opionin :P

  • perfect Feayero/Noq song; SOOOO SWEEEET!

  • As soon as he sang the first line, I knew this version was better. (No hate on Jennette)

  • Jennette wrote it. She wrote it for Cody Waters who had cancer and passed away. :'( Thumbs up if you are Team Jennette!!! I luv you, Jen ;)

  • To many breaths like that one girl jenette sing it better!

  • Ever since Jannette played Lily in Hannah Montana I lost all respect for her. I like Bryans version better.

  • @AkiChan323 No offense but Jennette didn't play Lilly. Emily Osmet did.

  • @Lukersismycutie22334 yeah i totally didnt remember that until AFTER i left the comment XD jannette played SAM on icarly, I meant icarly not Hannah Montana XD

  • Omg, really you guys, really?

    Get over it, and personally, i like Amanda Scott's version better.

    Besides, it doesn't matter who wrote it, as long as its message gets out, right?

    I swear, if i get crap about this, heads will roll! D:

  • he's good but jennette's version is better =D

  • am for jeannette's version!!!! i luv her voice

  • I think;

    1. Jennette

    2. Bryan

    3. Amanda

    {:

  • I don't give a damn who sings, this song is beautiful no matter who sings it (if the person can sing that is) Everybody who I've heard sing this song just make a perfect job/performance <33

  • bryan is way better

  • jennette, amanda, and bryan did very good~

    i love this song no matter who sings it!

  • seriously 3 people singing the same song?!

  • @Bobthepurplealien actually 4. tobias regner sang it also.

  • I like with ♥♥♥♥Jennette McCurdy ♥♥♥♥

  • people please if you like jennette better than amanda and bryan i think 1:amanda 2:bryan 3:jennette so any way bryan said lone some beauty not lone some stranger so that why hes better and hes the only guy i herd that sang thins so and it good because its the felling and the vocie you herd after the song so thats why but i did jennette last because every one said she better then them

  • all the people who singed this song sings it in a kinda different way

  • Jennette sings this really better than Bryan!!

  • i Like all 3 versions-

    1. Jennette

    2. Amanda

    3. Bryan

  • jennettes better

  • dude this is horrible!!!!!!!!!

  • y does he look so sad?

  • Comment removed

  • jennette's version is the best version

  • I like this version best.

  • i like this version toooo

    im confused

    there are three versions

  • omg! he's Danish .. og jeg elsker ham xD

  • Elsker digh Bryan <3 :)

  • i think everyone who has done a version of this song has good vocals for it!

  • @jahbrown012 Thats exactly what I think!!!!

  • 2:36 That's a pretty high note to hit for a guy xD

  • Doesn't sound bad at all, but Jenette's version is better =)

  • some of the note are takein off.

  • It's a little off pitch of the original...

  • i love this song so much x

  • Why does everyone think Jannette wrote this song? It's been out for five years and the origional artist that sang it was Ananda Stott. Then it was covered by Bryan Rice in 2006 and then some next guy AND THEN Jannette.

  • amanda scott....i think

  • @andreashel1 stott

  • jennette has a really good reason to sing this. he has a good voice but it isnt a song 4 him

  • jennettes is better

  • Jennette's version is better

  • @mariahrose210 yea i agree

  • @mahnesreen Jennette McCurdy wrote and sung this song and it belongs to her and i personally think she sing it better than him and Amanda Scott cause they changed the lyrics and the music also i dont get the emotions accros because the song was writen for a boy called Cody Waters who was only 9 when he died of cancer.

  • She didn't write it. It was originally sung by Amanda Scott, but she didn't write it, it was written for her. Jennette McCurdy DEDICATED it to Cody Waters, but she didn't write it.

    I do agree, I like Jennette McCurdy's version the best.

  • No. This is Amanda Stotts. Jennette Was the last one to cover it. Her only song out so far is So Close. AMANDA OWNS THIS SONG!!!!

  • @EmmaSan1 OMG! That is so true! Wait, when did Cody get cancer? In 2008 you say? This song got up unto YouTube in 2006, how is that possible, if the song was written for Cody? Jennette can see into the future! That is the truth and the only logical answer...

    Wait... What?

  • @egadw Jennette covered this song and sang it as a tribute to cody after he died. Hope that helps :)

  • @Troyellaislove I know she did :P, it was an attempt to be sarcastic

  • He has a nice voice, but I think it doesn't seem to fit to this song.

  • I like Jennette's version WAY better. he and the other lady are ok. :)

  • Agree

  • I like this version of the song, although I do prefer Amanda Stott's version more. I think that all three versions have there merits though. Also, orionseesall76 is completely correct. Artists cover other artists songs all the time, it's not stealing. Recording artists have to get all sorts of permission etc. to be able to cover songs.

  • @kennedyliam14 No,orignaly Amanda Stott did,then he did,then Jennette

  • i agree with kennedyliam 14

  • I can't believe what I'm hearing. Does anyone really know there music anymore? There are so many songs out there that are re-makes, remixes, whatever. I'm certain both Bryan & Jennette cite the original writer of this song on their albums. Nobody stole anything. They requested or were asked to cover the song and thus the new version is born.

    I personally give them all credit for there performances. They are all equally good in their own right.

  • @kennedyliam14 i like jennettes 2 but she is the the song "stealer" this came out before Jennettes

  • this song is great!!!

  • son tres quienes la cantan o wuoo y a cada quien se les oye bien me gusta esta cancion!! me inspira escribire!!!

  • 3 versions are good!!

  • Jeannettes is better bt this is good 2, and Amandas

  • Ah, I have no idea whose I like better! I love them all.

  • I now know three versions of this xD Amanda Stott's, Bryan Rice's, and Jennette McCurdy xDD All good.

  • jennete wrote this song for a sick little boy who passed away she even announced it they are covering it,its what i heard from her so dont get pissed at me k

  • awsome and so is jennete mcurdy

  • me too

  • i like jennettte's version better

  • i like your voice

  • Opps wait no Bryan wrote wrong years my bad Bryans is in 2006 amanda's is in 2008 and jennette is 2009 so ya

  • Amanda wrote it because her is in 2006and Bryan is in 2008 and Jennette is 2009 so ya its Amanda's just that Brayans just has one different word. So i guess they all did an amazing job at singing it!!! :D

  • Jenette Mccurdy wrote this song and she is freaking awesome

  • No, Amanda Stott did it.

  • Amanda Stott wrote this song. Jennette covered it.

  • Jenette Mccurdy didn't write this song!!! Bryan Rice did. She just did her own version!!!

  • actually he didnt write it either, amanda stott did

  • @TheDiamondGirl12 really i though jennette wrote it

  • @TheDiamondGirl12 everyone syays jennette wrote it though????

  • @maddysoku not everyone, and even though that was the case, it isn't true.

  • @TheDiamondGirl12 I heard Jennette wrote it when she was 12

  • @561Mag That's wrong, she didn't. It was written by three songwriters. Amanda was the first to put in on an album, Bryan second and Jennette third.

  • one question,WHO WROTE THIS SONG!!!!!!! i mean there is jennette,amanda, and bryan,

  • dont forget tobias rennge somthinlike that

  • who the fuck wrote this song?!?!

  • for real how many ppl sing this song i think im going to sing it too..

  • jannatte is great but he is good

  • omg! how many ppl sing this song!

  • i know for real how many ppl sing this song lol omg

  • i think like 4 people. there is amanda,jennette,bryan,and last but not least, tobias

  • the most beautiful.

  • jannette is better but its a nice one..

  • luv jenette"s version over everyones

    sorr ee.....

  • Personally, this is my favorite version.

    Bryan Rice has such a great voice!

    Thank you so much for uploading this!

  • Jennette is better than any of them who sings this in my opinion

  • yea she does in my opinion also

  • jannette is better by miiiiles!

  • he is good, but jennette is better

  • i like this song but i think that jennette McCurdys version is better. but there all really good

  • He's got a nice voice. Amanda's is kind of plain.

  • ok......i guess

  • NOt my fav but good

  • i like his version and jennete's not really amanda's though

  • he is also pretty good, but jennette is better.

  • I actually love all 3 versions. You can't really compare them...

  • so this is the original?

  • this is his song but i do like Jennette's better :)

  • jennette is the best!

  • I like Amanda and Jennetes version better!

  • first he sang it then Amanda Scott and the Jennette if you look at the dates and this is original and so the words are a little different then Amanda's and Jennette's

  • Actually Amanda's version was released a year before this one. Just so you guys know.

  • this version was from 2006

    Amanda Stott's was from 2005.

    do the math, it goes amanda stott, bryan rice, tobias regner, then jennette mccurdy.....

  • jennette is better but he sung this B4 her so he's not copping her so cool it~

  • ew....

  • Thank you thats all i had to say!

    All that is true though :]

  • jennettte is better!!Stop Trying they suck she is better F***ing people Stop you all suck exept fer her

  • chill he song it first. Jennette and his are better then amanda Scott but no need for cussing

  • this is soo sweet

  • Jennette Is LOTS better!

  • sooo many to think who's the best jennette , amanda , or rice i dont know!!!

  • oh my gosh. this is so beautiful. i think theyer all awesome!

  • i think

    jennettte is better

  • Wow. This is nice. :) I like Jennette's the best, mainly because it was the first version I heard & I loved it. Wasn't Amanda Scott or whatever the original artist? I like her version cuz it's pretty & simpler to sing than Jennette's. This is my first time hearing this guy's version. It sounds nice. So I like all of them :)

  • *Amanda Stott. Sorry lol.

  • i like jenettes version but it so sad i wanna cry :'( :'( to sad

  • I lyk all 3 versions but Jennette's is my fave

  • jennettte is way better!!!!

  • jennette and bryan sound so good! they should do a duet! :)

    <3

  • I've heard three versions of this song now. Jennette Mccurdy's version was best, but he sounds really good too! Thanx for uploading^^

  • jennette sang it better

  • Jennete did the best

  • this song makes me cry every time i hear it

  • i really like it

  • jennette is better but the original song is from jennette or from bryan

  • no...they didn't write this..amanda stott did

  • well i fdont think so because im a big jennettes fan but if you think so ok

  • amanda's versin came out like 2 years before jennette....its not bad to do a cover of a song.....

  • ok but i think jennettes vercion are better

  • me too. :D

  • this sucks jennette mccurdy sang this so much better

  • eww! this sux!

  • i luv it but need to say something why is so many celebrity singing this song first jennente mcurdy then amanda scoot now bryan rice wht the hec this song is so popular oh well i cant do anything i guees i will just go with the flo n work with it

  • maybe because they lost a person think about it.i lost my uncle and i sing it.i plan to if i get famous

  • kinda good!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I love this song and do they have a music sheet for piano for this song? if so email Brookie1414 thanks! oh and Keep up the Good work! PEACE!

  • I honestly like all versions of Homeless Heart (all the artists who have sang this song)

  • well ok there is 3 ppl that sing with! Jennette McCurdy sings it the best tho

  • there are actually 4, there was a version from tobias regner that came out in 08.

  • Amanda Stott is the origional, and the best!

  • To clarify for everyone, 4 people sing this song officially: Amanda Stott, Bryan Rice, Tobias Regner, and Jennette Mccurdy. The order of the artist are also correct. It even says so on wikipedia.

    Here's the years they made the song in:

    Amanda Stott - 2005

    Bryan Rice - 2006

    Tobias Regner - 2006

    Jennette Mccurdy - 2009

  • who actually wrote the song?

  • awh, this is by FAR the cutest version of the song.

    they always say the writer of the song always does it best.

    they are so right in this case<33

    but i do like jennettes too, just not as much(:

  • omg how many people sing this song!?

  • ALOT!!!!

  • yea i think all versions are cool

  • I like all 3 and I think each artist added their own interpretation to the song.

  • great opinion!!^^

  • Not bad but Slotts better but JENNETTE MCCURDYS IS THE GREATEST

  • You can give me a thumbs down...I don't care but I actually like all three versions...Jennettes, Amandas and this one...

    I actually like all three

  • me too

  • Ok uhm wtf? Why is everyone stealing Jennette's song? This amanda stott person stole it, now him? Ok, Jennette's version is the original, and the best!!! This is ok, better then the amanda persons version

  • To clear up the confusion, Bryan Rice was the original version. Amanada Scott's Was a remake of this.

    And Jennette McCurdy's is the latest version to be made.

    I personal like Jennette McCrudy's because of its up-beat tune style to it. Then this version. Althought I like Amanada Scotts version, I did not enjoy it as much as the other two, because of it sorrow-"ish" feel to it.

  • uhh. they're actually NOT stealing Jenette's song because she didn't write it...

  • nooo,

    amanda orginally did it.

  • Not the best! See Jennette McCurdy's Version!

  • i like this!! this is sweet but sorry i like jennettes better

  • In Jennete's version it is "Lonesome stranger" in this one it is "Lonesome Beauty"!

  • this song is originally by amanda stott her lyrics are stranger but since he's a guy I guess he has to make it sound like a guy talking about a girl and beauty refers to a girl and stranger refers to a guy. =)

  • I like jennette mccurdy's version alot better! Hers actually has character and meaning behind, but dont get me wrong this is okay, but jennettes has something this song doesn't possess like her

  • i agree with u

  • thx!