Ashlee Simpson in Chicago

[clubglam00]

Soooo lame

[buglover625]

When I went and saw it Michelle Williams was in it....SHE WAS HORRIBLE!!!!

[WickedTheMusical1000]

Her compared to Ruthie Henshall or somebody like that theres no comparisent! Her acting is AWFUL! Im so Glad Ruthie is back init

[BossyPenguin]

AWFUL

[Tacoflavoredkiss1]

ehhhh wow. this is why celebrities shouldn't be on broadway, broadway actually requires real talent.

[deadexecs]

oh dear. she didn't pull this role off, and i actually really like ashlee and her voice. she didn't have enough pizazz in my opinion. stick to recording studios, babygirl!

[balletgurlie]

I think vocally she's fine and when she's actually dancing she does pretty good but she's not bringing that Fosse spunk into the moves and she's not sassy enough. It's like she's afraid to go there or something. I just wanted more.

[deadexecs]

i imagine she was probably super nervous and didn't let loose as much as she could have. which is understandable.

[riotofred]

She's boring in this role. Her voice is mediocre, and it's not like these are challenging songs. She's terrible at the choreography (she's out of sync and her form is loose and sloppy.) She doesn't even know the correct name for musicals.

I'm an actress living in NYC and it's so disheartening to see roles like this go to people who can't perform them as well as some of my colleagues but who have some sort of box office pull.

[abbyanne05]

her face is too monotone for roxie.. but awesome singing

[kmodrow44]

she sucks....sorry ha

[kakyajun]

I mean, yeah I guess if this were a high school, community, or even some college shows she'd be pretty good, but certainly not for this level of supreme theatre. There's nothing about her voice or movements that really grip the audience.

Also, her calling shows "Broadways"... gets me every time.

[junkmailboy1000]

good high school theater at best, and even that's a stretch.

Ashlee Simpson is a talentless hack who thinks being a "celebrity" by riding the coattails of a less talented sister suddenly gives you a license to be an actress.

[XblablablablablaX]

i love ash, but i must admit, she does look like shes had botox and lip implants. but now, she looks amazing and really natural.

Ah well! i love her

[yumichan89]

Hmmm... I do admit she does sound good on the fast songs. But what about the slower songs? What about every other aspect about her? Pop singers just don't belong on Broadway. Period.

[raemando]

well, at least so sounds like roxie

[kgirl101333]

worst.roxie.ever. RENEE WAS BEST!

[hanzkydubbs]

Okay. Why hasn't anyone commented on the fact that she's just dumb.

"It is such a great Broadway."

"It is one of my favorite Broadways."

DUMB. ASS.

[JORDYxBANG]

thats what i was thinking! its a musical not a broadway. she is stupid.

[theandyandsamyshow]

its a broadway musical, your the stupid one

[JORDYxBANG]

Actually you are the stupid one. My roommate is a theater major. You do not call a musical/play, even if it started on broadway, a broadway. Right now she is ON broadway performing in Chicago, which is not a broadway. When she was in London it was just a play. Why do you think so many are saying that what she is saying is wrong. Google it before you insult people.

[Marylill]

She's not really good

[Minyadagniriel]

i like renee better

[grace317]

um.... she looks like she's lipsyncing during the performance of the roxie song. at around 3:40

[tinkerbellfreak]

the video is just out of synch.

[grace317]

but she doesn't even look like she's singing loudly.

[tinkerbellfreak]

think what you may, but people in broadway shows NEVER are allowed to lipsynch.

[grace317]

that's what confuses me.. lol. anyway, i'm not criticizing, just curious. she sounds pretty good and looks even better.

[tinkerbellfreak]

yeah i think she did good. I saw Chicago when it came to my city about a year ago and the girl that played Roxie was pretty good too:]

[wannabeindependent]

she's GREAT, and don't even like her...

[markymarc45]

I know Right?

[mcb1160]

She is not at the Bob fosse level for this musical!! He would have never picked her in a million years!! She ruined the JAZZ feeling about this musical!!,it very slow and without energy!!

[Mrsefronda1st]

Im not an Ashlee simpson fan but she wasnt horrible she was pretty good

[sexytyrafan]

SEXY!! Ashlee = PERFECT as Roxie. Ash has a LOT of talent, after seeing this. She's really taking it to another level

[GypsySky]

I hate the way she laughs on 00:51

She always laughs like that..

[XxWicked28xX]

I'm sorry but did she stop a live show because she sung the wrong words??? if im wrong correct me but how unprofessional, i dont think they casted very well at all big mistake

[pineduh23]

because she SUNG the wrong words? Bad wording! Because she SANG the wrong words.

[Jevo90]

She didn't stop a live show, that was a rehearsal!

[mebee415]

it was a rehearsal obviously

[Niteowl128]

the performance was at a rehearsal.

[JuCeSoDi0711]

you are wrong, like always

[roxiotor1]

it was a rehearsal, not the show... obviously no one would stop a show because of that, and even if she tried, the others wouldn't have stopped..

but, hey, rehearsal!

[ToniAndMiyaShow]

hahaaaa, rehersal.

[maddmatt66]

I can't stand watching her interview, she's very irritating to watch. Very unprofessional.

[JuCeSoDi0711]

then don´t wath her videos son of bitch!

[maddmatt66]

Ok, I won't "wath" her videos you illiterate moron. Just what I expect from a Assleak fan.

[JuCeSoDi0711]

stupid, ok I made a mistake beacuse English isn´t my first language, I´m from Venezuela

=(

[Oracle411]

hey.....she's not bad. quite good. i had to see the clip, to see if it was THE 'ashlee simpson'; watching this, i was reminded that, yeah, pop career & fiascos aside, she'd started out in acting; this will give her a lot of cred, and it shows she's actually got a great voice.

[Staccas]

As much as I hate Ash Simpson, she really nailed this. It's very diff to Renee, but I think it's great!

[xxxbroadwaygalxxx]

how long was she in london for?

[PinkkElefants]

Why does everybody complaining? She's really good!

[TangoMaureen07]

wow she doesent even sound like herself.. she sound good

[hilzsuperduck]

she sounds good, but she actually looks a state though, in my opinion.

[EmtheSoprano]

she makes me sick a little bit. she doesnt even look like herself and i think thats how she got that part. they didnt realize who she was

[markymarc45]

Actually.. She didnt even audition! They called her and asked if she wanted to do it!