I have the book, he rapes her, but she couldn't scream for help, because the hat you see in the movie, he shoved it in her mouth. He rpaed her, slit her throat and probably choped her up. In the book her dad said a neighbor's dog found her arm in the cornfield(I think in the cornfield) they found her saliva on the hat, but nothing else.
No, Only in the book, Saoirse's parents were kind of against the whole idea of that and Mr.Tucci didn't want to have to do that to a young girl. So thye jsut show that he killed her but we don't see the murder all we see if that he's shoving a bag withy suzie's body into that safe. Remember when he was in the tub? shows that he did kill her as well. it's all bloody and muddy.
that was her killer. she didn't realize she was dead, and she was stuck in between the after life and the real world. the bath tub was muddy and bloody because it was showing her that he'd just cut up her body.
in the end Mr Harvey trying to persuade the other girl when an ice fell of onto him and he slipped into a cliff and DIE......i really enjoy seeing he died like that......
@drodriguez1630 a neighbour killed her, he tricked her into going into this underground hut he had created and claimed it was for the kids in the neighbourhood. In the book he rapes her first but i don't think he does in the film :S he chops her body up into many parts if you want the details :P
@drodriguez1630 In the book, her death was much more violent. He slit her throat. Don't ask what happened to the body, it was never written, I don't think it was entirely mentioned in the movie, but it was brutal.
@SpamBAT her rape wasn't even mentioned like in the book...im not even sure if he did rape her in the movie..it doesn't show anything or say anything :P
@SpamBAT I havent read the book yet but in the film it shows you him throwing a brown bloody bag into the safe and locking it away, suggesting he cut her body up or did something so horrific to her it caused her to bleed. Either way he deserved everything he got, still wish she could have had a proper burial though.
@MultiLoveMetal To the best of my knowledge (I briefly read a quarter of the book and skipped to the end, the middle was ... boring) they never mention it in the book, but the do describe an encounter with the police officer on the case (in the book he's a main character) telling them they found an elbow in the field. So he definitely cut her up. to make it worse he stared at the safe and re-lived her rape and death often while her family mourned.
@HikingForSpirit I actually found the book graphic in some ways and boring in others. It was the perfect choice for Peter Jackson. He made it subtle and interesting.
whats the name of the song it's kinda cool , oh and poor Susie she was so innocent , i hope that guy(the real guy) is rotting in hell , and i want to say hello to Susie if i ever see her on heaven =)
I dreamt about this movie to. i found myself walking near the dead cornfields and heard her screaming. i ran over there and killed the guy, and saved the girl!. By the way this movie is similar to what happend a year back in holland a girl named milly killed and raped by her neighbour who was even a Cop.
@TheZo4725lol Actually, this is based on a true story Her name was Siobhan. Another the same year, Susan Yaeger, and a few more. This takes place in 1973.
@TheZo4725lol Usually it's because the person who kills suffers from some sort of mental illness. But, there are other reasons, too.... Sometimes when a person kills, they get a strange feeling of feeling sorry for the person they kill, and they become addicted to that feeling. They become addicted to feeling sad over killing someone. It's kinda hard to explain... Also, some want to see the person's eyes when they die, and they become addicted to that. Some kill for fun, too.
What's up with this awful song being used again & again as some sort of soundtrack for these Bones bits?
808Lana 2 weeks ago
i love this movie
jjtocute 2 weeks ago
Me and my friends were at my best friends birthday tea and we saw a man who looked a lot like him and we were craping ourselves
CANTBK 3 weeks ago 2
i hate how harvey died. i wish he died a more brutal death and suffer like she did
skittle2008 1 month ago 9
I'm glad really glad that mr.harvey died
Echan12 1 month ago
see thats what i wanted to know, did he rape her or did he just kill her.
zackman6000 1 month ago
@zackman6000 he raped her then killed her
blackbutler2001 1 month ago 3
Comment removed
zackman6000 2 months ago
poor Susie! Best film ever!
rubyjermottaa 2 months ago
Her sister..
Drafterflamethrower 2 months ago
at the end it shows a girl preagnat who was it
2426TheDragon 2 months ago
I have the book, he rapes her, but she couldn't scream for help, because the hat you see in the movie, he shoved it in her mouth. He rpaed her, slit her throat and probably choped her up. In the book her dad said a neighbor's dog found her arm in the cornfield(I think in the cornfield) they found her saliva on the hat, but nothing else.
chibiusa10039 1 month ago
@chibiusa10039 did he rape her in the movie too? ive seen the movie a few times but It confused me because everyone said he raped her
CozmictheWolf 1 month ago
@CozmictheWolf
No, Only in the book, Saoirse's parents were kind of against the whole idea of that and Mr.Tucci didn't want to have to do that to a young girl. So thye jsut show that he killed her but we don't see the murder all we see if that he's shoving a bag withy suzie's body into that safe. Remember when he was in the tub? shows that he did kill her as well. it's all bloody and muddy.
chibiusa10039 1 month ago
@chibiusa10039 oh okay, thanks
CozmictheWolf 1 month ago
@chibiusa10039 It's her elbow not her her arm ...
melle7peace 1 month ago
@2426TheDragon susie's sister
blackbutler2001 2 weeks ago
@danismilez25:
that was her killer. she didn't realize she was dead, and she was stuck in between the after life and the real world. the bath tub was muddy and bloody because it was showing her that he'd just cut up her body.
KittyKatsGoRawrable 2 months ago
epic
52koolkid 2 months ago
Why was he in that disgusting bathtub? And why was his bathroom all muddy and bloody?
danismilez25 2 months ago
in the end Mr Harvey trying to persuade the other girl when an ice fell of onto him and he slipped into a cliff and DIE......i really enjoy seeing he died like that......
NoObEr72 2 months ago 5
is this the music from requiem for a dream?
wqsr4o 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love this movie!!!
VampireHalo1997 3 months ago
wtf?
otterlove4567vgvbvvv 3 months ago
how did she die?
drodriguez1630 3 months ago
@drodriguez1630 a neighbour killed her, he tricked her into going into this underground hut he had created and claimed it was for the kids in the neighbourhood. In the book he rapes her first but i don't think he does in the film :S he chops her body up into many parts if you want the details :P
horseluvaXxX 3 months ago
@drodriguez1630 In the book, her death was much more violent. He slit her throat. Don't ask what happened to the body, it was never written, I don't think it was entirely mentioned in the movie, but it was brutal.
SpamBAT 3 months ago
@SpamBAT her rape wasn't even mentioned like in the book...im not even sure if he did rape her in the movie..it doesn't show anything or say anything :P
RosesareAllie 3 months ago
@SpamBAT I havent read the book yet but in the film it shows you him throwing a brown bloody bag into the safe and locking it away, suggesting he cut her body up or did something so horrific to her it caused her to bleed. Either way he deserved everything he got, still wish she could have had a proper burial though.
MultiLoveMetal 2 months ago
@MultiLoveMetal To the best of my knowledge (I briefly read a quarter of the book and skipped to the end, the middle was ... boring) they never mention it in the book, but the do describe an encounter with the police officer on the case (in the book he's a main character) telling them they found an elbow in the field. So he definitely cut her up. to make it worse he stared at the safe and re-lived her rape and death often while her family mourned.
SpamBAT 2 months ago
The book is ten times as good as the movie ever will be
HikingForSpirit 3 months ago
@HikingForSpirit I actually found the book graphic in some ways and boring in others. It was the perfect choice for Peter Jackson. He made it subtle and interesting.
SpamBAT 3 months ago
o.O
mshuckster12 3 months ago
"Requiem for a Dream" music??? wtf?
unenlightenedshadows 4 months ago
How did she die? I haven't seen the movie..
RandomPeep4evet 4 months ago
@RandomPeep4evet
She was lured into an underground made 'hole or something' and then he raped her(book). After he was done, he hacked/cut her into pieces.
TxE 4 months ago
@RandomPeep4evet a neighbor tricked her into going into his hideout and he killed her there
ACwebshow100 3 months ago
hes killing lovely girls !!
LoVeSkIe11 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
everyone on earth should have seen this movie !
Caatrice 4 months ago
did he rape her too? cause if he did, it is a thousand times more terrible.... and no one ver mentions that. I mean that would be.. no..... :'(
KusinerneAF 4 months ago
@KusinerneAF No. In the book he did.
iSmokeCupcakes 4 months ago
whats the name of the song it's kinda cool , oh and poor Susie she was so innocent , i hope that guy(the real guy) is rotting in hell , and i want to say hello to Susie if i ever see her on heaven =)
615769 5 months ago
OMG the way that guy was using the cloth to clean his face was soooooo disturbing in many ways! 8p
Poor Susie RIP
lovemoviesmusic 5 months ago
whats da name of dis song?:L
LimeyEmz 5 months ago
whts the song?
Please0pay0me0in0gum 5 months ago
Is this a Horror Movie??? The trailer dint looked like!
ASWER ME PELASE!
hflgoulart 5 months ago 4
@hflgoulart It is not a horror movie, It's a drama
totyland99 5 months ago 22
@totyland99 but that part.. all that blood and thay guy... I really wanna see this movie..
hflgoulart 5 months ago
@totyland99 its one of my favorite movies! i think its more creepy then anything but like happy in the end
rawriheartyou77 4 months ago
@totyland99 a sad ass drama
BOBBY87265 1 month ago
@hflgoulart it has chilling thriller but its quite scary
Jessybear70 4 months ago
@Jessybear70 its not scary but their again i dont even think texas chain saw is lol
Vodkakickgirl21 4 months ago
@hflgoulart is a drama, I recommend it
chiripi11 4 months ago
@hflgoulart
No, it's actually a crime/drama film. The book itself is rather brutal in detail, so I would imagine the trailer and movie to be the same.
Maverickslayer744 4 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
All i can think about is this film and it gives me a horrible feeling
tornadotoz 6 months ago
Terrible, terrible movie.
wicNKWD37 6 months ago
I REALLY WANTED TO BRUTALLY MURDER MR HARVEY. I fell in love with Saoirse Ronan while watching this, so seeing him hurt her was painful.
piggyfatt 6 months ago 32
@piggyfatt Good news: at the end of the movie he dies :)
mariekeho 2 months ago 3
@piggyfatt Same with me.
MrSploderfan 1 month ago
@piggyfatt LOL
Tyannalyn 3 weeks ago
Really bad film its ruined the book for me x
MissLauren151 7 months ago
she should of suffocated him at 8
hammythehamstergirl 7 months ago
So what percentage of youtube videos have this cliched song on them? 30%? 40%?
Ugh.
melosebrainuhoh 7 months ago
I dont get it
MissAnna889 7 months ago
@nkns123 Uhm, if that made you laugh, then maybe YOU are the killer.
kaijab615 8 months ago
@nkns123
LOL that's fine. The other day I commented on a comment from a YEAR ago! LOL
erinsteffens 8 months ago
I screamed at 1:11! Throughout this whole movie I was crying, crying, crying because it was awful!
mrsdracomalfoy1000 8 months ago 2
I dreamt about this movie to. i found myself walking near the dead cornfields and heard her screaming. i ran over there and killed the guy, and saved the girl!. By the way this movie is similar to what happend a year back in holland a girl named milly killed and raped by her neighbour who was even a Cop.
roy1345 8 months ago
@nkns123
Thanks but I was really thinking of WHERE I head it. But thank you so much. I'm going to google it now. :D
erinsteffens 9 months ago
Oh man I know this song! But I can't remember it!! THIS IS GOING TO BOTHER ME ALL DAY!
erinsteffens 9 months ago
GROSS i never wanted to see mr harvey in a bathtub.
gothicjade0202 10 months ago
this was a beautiful movie and it brings me to tears every time
lulup0p1 10 months ago
this makes me sick and horrified.
thats like my neighbor, he stares at me constantly and is so creepy
katostrophic96 11 months ago 2
@katostrophic96 i suggest you move, or call the po-pos
zoliviaepisodes 10 months ago
This was a very good movie. Dark and emtionally compelling.
globaloiltrader 11 months ago
@HelloHoz its all good lol
TheZo4725lol 11 months ago
@HelloHoz wait i didnt even say anything about her being raped what are you talking about
TheZo4725lol 1 year ago
@TheZo4725lol In the book the man raped and murdered susie...
Ch4rli3heart 11 months ago
@HelloHoz oh didnt know
TheZo4725lol 1 year ago
But How did she die cuz rember how she got away ???
iSWAGGERED 1 year ago
@iSWAGGERED it was her ghost/sprit running away he had already killed her
mir2k9 1 year ago
@mir2k9 yo but y didnt they show it
iSWAGGERED 1 year ago
@iSWAGGERED
that's what i don't get!
Ratmaster100 11 months ago
@iSWAGGERED
it was her ghost/spirit running away cuz ya man already raped & murdered her
4myb34r 5 months ago
Fuck this gave me chills down my spine.
SatansHelper95 1 year ago
Wow! i have never seen the kidnapping part , where he like traps her! this frikin scared me when he was like pulling her down!
PiinkBarbiex 1 year ago
Had to watch this in school in RE, 'Life After Death' and never got to watch the god damn ending. I just like Mark Wahlberg
TheRockoRoller 1 year ago
y would a man kill such aan innocent child. i no this is realistic fiction but r8 up if u agree w/ me.
TheZo4725lol 1 year ago 107
@TheZo4725lol Actually, this is based on a true story Her name was Siobhan. Another the same year, Susan Yaeger, and a few more. This takes place in 1973.
CandicelikesCandy 11 months ago
@CandicelikesCandy but then if this was based on a true story did siobhan's ghost write the story or something i mean it HAD to be fiction lol
TheZo4725lol 11 months ago
@TheZo4725lol Well, part of it was fiction
CandicelikesCandy 11 months ago
@TheZo4725lol
Thumbs DOOOOOOOWN!
MercurialIris 10 months ago
@TheZo4725lol Usually it's because the person who kills suffers from some sort of mental illness. But, there are other reasons, too.... Sometimes when a person kills, they get a strange feeling of feeling sorry for the person they kill, and they become addicted to that feeling. They become addicted to feeling sad over killing someone. It's kinda hard to explain... Also, some want to see the person's eyes when they die, and they become addicted to that. Some kill for fun, too.
Cyraina13 5 months ago
@Cyraina13 well, i still think it's fucking wrong
TheZo4725lol 5 months ago
@TheZo4725lol I never said it WASN'T wrong. I was just explaining the reason why people kill in the first place. I agree, that what they do is wrong.
Cyraina13 5 months ago
@TheZo4725lol there is actual sickos out in the world like that man who killed her, this is based on a true story
ThePoopy111 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ThePoopy111 how is this a true story ?
TheZo4725lol 5 months ago
@TheZo4725lol its a phsycological disease pluse he saw he mom murdered and she was abused (im not defending him and he is wrong but still)
thisoneskaterxx428 3 months ago
yes. it is EPIC movie. Cant forget it
pashawc3 1 year ago 54
it is the second time that a Lovely bones fan video is using the same soundtrack (from Requiem for a dream). Good work.
Seventh7Art 1 year ago