Added: 5 years ago
From: chinter
Views: 62,832
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (222)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • que desafinado!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Impulzzkoor why are you so judgemental? it's a high school choir..not professionals.. they did great considering it's a group of kids who have never been in an satb choir in their life...give them a break. It's people like you who crush dreams.

  • I think for a first year choir, they've done wonderfully!.

    they aren't professionals.. why do people have to be such jerks?? stop hating and do it yourself if you don't like it...

    GOOD JOB 4th Period choir!!

  • okay....the harmonies suck!!! and they sang the wrong word. it's TOO LATE my time has come , NOT MAMA......

  • I personally know how hard this song is. I also know that giving this song to a choir that doesn't have strong vocal performers is a recipe for disaster. This choir director should definitely think before he chooses songs that are past the ability of his singers. Don't set your students up for failure, pick music that compliments your singers ability not one that is our of their league.

  • I personally know how hard this song is. I also know that giving this song to a choir that doesn't have strong vocal performers is a recipe for disaster. This choir director should definitely think before he chooses songs that are past the ability of his singers. Don't set your students up for failure, pick music that compliments your singers ability not one that is our of their league

  • i personaly think that this chorus did an awsome job at this...i would like to hear some more boys thou and the guitar and drums were really loud that in someparts i couldn't hear...but this song was really a difficult song to do and they totally kicked my choruses buts...u guys rocked! xD...i cant wait to see if u guys do more songs ill be looking forward to it! :)

  • it honestly isn't as bad as some of you have affirmed it to be. i 've heard MUCH worse!

    M.D.

  • Oh, my choir would PWN!

    >:D WE FUCKING LOVE THAT SONG!

    &they needed more men to nail it :/

    The drum is really fucking stupid.

    This should totally be done a capello.

  • the panic, the vomit, the panic, the vomit.... damn!! that guitar playeris horrible!

  • F all u guys, do u kno how hard this song is???, y would u put down these kid's spirit to take on a challenge, they're still developing as artists, they will get better as time goes on, and i kno this may seem cliche, but i wanna see all the people that left asshole comments and join in a choir and sing this dong better than them

  • this is awful, even for the FIRST year! as a matter of fact, the bohemian rhapsody isn't suitable for 1st year after all, right? just try orinoco flow, maybe they'd sing better...

  • this is awful, even for the FRIST year! as a matter of fact, the bohemian rhapsody isn't suitable for 1st year after all, right? just try orinoco flow, maybe they'd sing better...

  • What's with that wah wah pedal by the the guitar player at the end?

  • very messy, takes a lot of technical

  • My jr high chior could do better than this... they need to use taller vowels, raise their soft pallet. try to use more blend. thumbs down for this video

  • too fast

  • Sucked

  • what a shame! Queen doesn't sound like that at all!

    try harder next time...Everybody is singing at the same time? It is just not good.

  • these kids to be honest are absolutely s*** for one the tempo is all wrong and theres so many discrepencies in the tone

  • they look and sound bored

  • can you talk to the dead then,i think freddie would have said well done,thankyou for singing my song.

  • this i cruality to my ears... :( this is really bad...

  • OMG! From the comments I thought they were really going to suck. And they DO NOT SUCK! They are not great, but they are good. You guys are too critical.

  • I can get they are from 1st year, but who chose the song? and what about the band? the band really sucks!!!

    Next time try choose a easier song. Keep working on rock n roll music

  • who the fuck are you to say that queen sucks...... what song would have you chosen please tell...... queens to awesome for a person with shit taste in music like you... by the way they are rock n roll... get ur music genres right!!!!!

  • maby you have to start with simple songs, bohemian rhapsody is a very differcult song to sing..

    okee everybody is right, it sounds horrible, sorry;$

  • i agree that they suck... thats why people that sing queen songs should leave the song alone... unless they sound exactly like queen...but even then they would still not be able to replace queen... sorry how much people suck at singing queen songs

  • aggg... horrible!

    -5

  • it is too fast

  • the worst that i listened

  • It's a very difficult song to sing and it is so easy to give critics

  • it sucks !!

  • oh my god! this is so bad.. sorry...

  • The guys are flat!

  • Oh Lord. The Muppets did better than them. Yeesh, and were they supposed to headband, or were those few just Wayne's World fans?

  • Well...they have a lot to learn alright, but that wasn't bad, nice dynamic and all. It was fun to listen to :)

  • how are they going to learn if we provide you with positive feedback? You need negative feedback to improve your choir

  • well, it's the conducter's fault for letting them sing this song. he should know the level of his choir, and therefore choose songs that he knows his choir can do. i mean, it's good to push them, but this is too much. it all seems very un rehursed, like they only practiced the music. they need to work on dynamic, too. otherwise, it's a boring performance. there are many flaws in this, but i haven't got enough space to list them and have my solution to them

  • ...

  • wow first year huh? eeep. not bad tho

  • is great, but....in the opera part its too fast = /

    guitar sucks = /

  • @mychemwwe If you watch alot of these, you'll find that the opera is usually insanely fast.

  • mmm mas o menos

  • i would just like to say, i think its discusting the comments people are leaving. Racism, cruel language and bagging. im a 15 yr old music student and have been since i was 6 i have travelled the the world from italy to china to spain and so on. if you have nothing nice to say then dont say anything at all. I DONT SEE YOU PEOPLE SINGING BOHEMIAN RHAPSIDY. yes its a hard song and i wouldn't have given it to them, but if they want to do it good on them, keep up the good work guys :)

  • @jaxonmccarthy

    if you want to act smart, at least spell your words right and SPELL this beautiful song RIGHT. It's Bohemian Rhapsody.

  • it is so sad that they cant sing the first "mama just killed a man" due to the fact that they are afraid some nut job might actually kill a man, what a shame. as the great freddie mercury once said. "is this the world we created, what did we do it for".

  • well maybe they just don't like an asian prick telling them what to sing to.

  • o.o uhm... well let's see where problem one started...

    First off, can you say too complex for a beginning choir? Yeah, exactly...

    Secondly, can you say POOR choir arrangement?! I know the quality isn't the best, but come on... I could hear the atrocious line up of the vocals!

    Third, where was the harmony? -_- so sad... I've never heard such a horrid version of this song...

  • ha wow NOOOOO!!!!

  • I don't know which was better. The choir or the guitarist.

    And the guitarist was shit.

  • @svolypet The choir was better than t guitarist. The guitarist should stick to the 3 bar chord, big overdone strumming style he is accustomed to.

  • Sad.

  • Mercury się w grobie ze śmiechu przewraca ;p

  • This comment is going to keep getting thumbs down until It is removed... but.... this SUCKED. The tempo fluxuations were dreadful, the drum beat was pathetic, and the singers sound like they are going to hide in a closet to cut themselves. And when they do try to sing loud and happier, they just shout on the top of their lungs. Freddie Mercury is ashamed.

    Go ahead, click Poor comment. I could care less

  • @DestroyAndVoid18 - Nah, you're being too harsh. Sure, it's not great, but did you notice "EVHS" in the description? It probably stands for East Valley High School.....I said High School. From me: Good job, EVHS! (BTW - I did click thumbs down, but I know you don't care. )

  • No no no no no no no no

    lol

  • oh. well, i'm sure you guys are better now :)

  • NOT an appropriate song for a first year choicr. just no. Way to complex. It's like watching a 12 year old singing before he cheats, slightly awkward and VERY unpleasant.

  • I don't know... well is their first year... but anyway...

    I sound bad...

  • StanAlter- If you want a smile, watch the Ten Tenors!

  • BAD!!!!

  • NO NO this is not good... this is not what freddy wanted to hear. A fair attempt but it doesn't honor the song..

  • It had its moments. I thought the rock break wasn't half-bad.

  • muito bom. quase perfeito, valeu a intenção nota 8

  • I liked it. Put a smile on my face.

  • not bad! but freddy is unique of course... but is very good... solo must practise.. but I think that the guitar player already knows it :)

    Greetings from Portugal \m/ 4:13 is not good, you should work on it, and next , is too fast....

  • i love how people dont read the info and Listen To The Guy at the Beginning

  • Sorry. This is terrible!!! Not everybody is singing in the same and the right key. Please try to sing in the right key. And PLEASE try to sing the songs of Queen with a British English accent. The American English accent sound terrible in this song. Proofs once again how high Queens (Freddie's) level was. Guitarplay sucks!!! Isn't concentrated on the song at all. Sorry!!! With more and better concentrated practice you could do it very well. Also with some adapting in the arrangements as well!!!

  • didn't you guys read the memo about keeping it positive... geez...

    Good job you guys.

  • Mmm.. a lot of choirs cut the first part out, ...

    I mean, 'Mama, just killed a man...'

  • They probably can't say it in school. My school's strict about words too.

  • ouch that was horrid.

  • didnt like it, may be thats not a song for a first year choir

    anyways, good try

    pd: the guitarist SUCKS!

  • didnt y hear what mr. chinte said? FIRST YEAR CHOIR. god damn.

  • Than you should NOT do a song like Bohemian Rhapsody. You don't learn to drive a car in a Ferrari as well!!!

  • The guitarist sucked. What's worse? the vocal accent or the guitarist? The guitarist is pretty bad. Sounded like he never listen to the original version.

  • pretty good job actually..

  • not very professional

  • Very rushed.... Need so much more emotion from the whole choir... Do they realize they are performing a legendary song!? Could have had so much more fun with it... Good attempt though!

  • this song is not made for a big choir

  • zero emotion :(

  • wow, freddie is better than al those people together!

    and ps, WHAT DICKHEAD PLAYED THE SOLO?

  • a little fast but good work tough

  • That was pretty nice considering they're not professionals and the camera changes a lot of what you really sound...

    you did well...

    =D

  • needs some work.

    went a little too fast when it came to the "opera" part

    and vowel shapes, those are important

    and have more blending, and confidence.

    then you'll be fine.

    nice job for a first try, keep practicing

  • Comment removed

  • they scipped the "mama just killed a man" part

  • yak!

    i am wonna sick

  • "bad" is the best thing i can say...

  • absolutely

  • O.O

    There are no words.

    And that's a bad thing, my friend.

  • i've been on a choir(bass), we sang it acapella and we're 20 in a group and from what i see, my opinion is you could have done better if there are more guys,i mean the number of girls are so many, its hard to hear voices from the guys. It could have been better if all voices are balanced =)

  • enough flak! They do a good job of a hard task.

  • ouch

  • i just threw up a little

  • Yeah, that was pretty much terrible. No men, overpowering women, lack of vowels. 'Nuff said. They all sounded like their 12 years old! Too bad...

  • This is not a song for a first year choir but for being first year i think they did very well.

    My choir director would have a ball on them. =]

  • wow that was bad.

  • im a tenor and i couldnt hear the tenors at all and it saunds like they are rushinnn the whollee song, they can do a better job

  • Im happy that people choose a beautiful song like this, but DESTROYING is not human-like...

  • I think this high school group, which I guess is a beginning choir group, could have done a lot better, if not nearly perfect, if they spent more time practicing. Plus, a whole chunk of the song is missing. Why is that?

    Anyway, they should have really practiced more. Either that, give the song to the higher choir groups, like the Chamber or Chorale groups.

  • At first I thought the comments were just people saying all this stuff due to an overreaction... But I heard the first line and my jaw literally dropped...

  • What was that?? Im sorry but the Waynes World version was better.

  • DO YOU KNOW WHAT IN KEY IS cuz u werent freddie mercury is rolling in his grave this is sad work on it and the guitarist screwed up

  • i agree...never give this to a beginning choir.........ya...enough said

  • lol i agree...dont sing that as a first year work...the problem was the unity. the choir itself had no unity, they need to learn 2 listen to themselves and adjust, so many ppl sang too fast/slow, out of pitch and stood out...needs team work..and start on the accompianent..and too fast....

  • We did this bohemian rhapsody in the hall with the 5OOO people with the philharmonic orchestra, whats this??? shouting to moon? Are you normal its a very bad video... Dont singing, please dont singing....

  • omg...I'm a gospel singer and I sing this song...but we've had a solist, and we were reeeeeeeeeeeeally better than this...

    they seem to sing so fast because dinneris already on the table...!!sorry freddie!!

  • oh my god.. it is so horrible.. how?? I mean how??? I would understand if there will be group of drunk people singing .. but a normal choire? it is just awful.. I feel sorry for myself that i listened to this...

  • did they even LISTEN to the song before they sang it?

    that was a disgrace to Queen.

    it would've been nice to use some cresendos, or to have blended better.

    this is EXACTLY why you don't give this song to first year choirs.

  • BADDDDDDDDDD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • complete disaster!!!

  • the tempo was to fast and the guitar over powerd them

  • Quote: "You do NOT give this song to a first year Chorus" -Stick to those words sir.

    The conduction was misleading.

    Guitarist needs A LOT of pedal work.

    Section everyone off to do separate intervals then keep them that way. BTW im gonna do this song by myself Piece by piece on multiple tracks :) it should be fun.

  • There are lots of accelerations in there that don't belong there. It could have been nice if the beat wasn't there. Guitar sounds weird.

    The choir sounds pretty good, but needs some practice.

    Once more, work on your tempo.

  • jaja minuto 3.30 la guitara como la mierda jaja, son mejores los teen tenors caxen la diferencia

  • what in the name of god was that??????

    how can i keep it positive when they kill one greatest songs(and possibly de best one) of all times with their horrible singing.

    Thank god freddie mercury is dead, because if he hears this, he would probably die again.

  • awful. the tenor part was revolting

  • The chair which was creaking all the time sounded way better....

    Sry this was absolutely horrible....just listened to the first few sounds...

    No being in tune, changes in tempo all the time....sry but this was and still IS ridiculous....

    You guys thought about practising until you sound fairly listenable? Don't think so...but expect to hold the commentary positive? Sorry, but no way....

  • this is really awful. as well, you skipped a large part of the beginning of the song. what gives?

  • a mess there..

  • I'm sorry, but there are too many of you.... and it was out of tune almost all the time.... i don't criticize, but this was horrible...

  • im a guy and im in choir it isnt gay!!!i hate people that think that!!!

  • no. Soprano is the highest, then mezzo soprano, then alto.

  • Fuck that is a tough song to sing. They should have chosen something easier.

  • Too many soprano's, not enough of boys or alto's

  • Remind me please Haah,

    Alto is highter right?

    x

  • most the time alto's parts are really really tough cause they wanna go w/ the melody and some guys think choir is gay and you're gay if you're in it. D: which is not true.

  • mmmmm. i thought it was going to be good. those lads need sacking, and if it is the first year of the choir boh rap possibly wasn't the best option.

  • sorry, but that was really really bad, i mean im in a school choir with people from all grades, and its really not that awfully out of tune as that at all!!

  • haha chipmunks on crack

  • I like it !!

  • That was too fast but really good for a first year choir.

    Please dont ever let that man play the guitar again.

  • Omg. I know that this choir is young but they are singing with instrument, and there is still bad tones. Sound- where are male voices?

  • totalmente fuera de ritmo!!!sorry!!!

  • You need more gravity in the choir, more basses, more guys with grave voices.

    But of course this song is very hard to sing live and you are on the right foot.

    I wish you all the best in future!

  • The singing wasn't so bad, needs some work. The guitar was TERRIBLE.

  • not bad for a first-year choir. i wish ours would do this

  • ummmmmmmmm. Well it was too fast and i think if you went slower you would stayed on pitch. But i must say you guys are brave and that maybe that shouldn't of been the first song you attempted. Queens is very hard to live up too. Also the guitar killed it at the end. Work hard! I beileve with time u guys will be great!

  • Too fast but pretty good for first year. Keep trying.

    Kill the guitar man!!!

  • okay...

  • el cuate habla mucho antes de empezar

    mala primera impresion

    se saltaron la primer linea de la letra

    nononononono

    maaaaal

    too fast

    noooooooo

    horrible

    freddy rules

    nadie como el

  • Gross. This is horrible.

  • OH MY GOD ur right!!!!!!!!

  • LMFAO!!!

  • for a first year, they're pretty decent.

  • too fast!!

  • the kid playing electric messes up at about 3:28

  • in the beginning line they all sound like robots with no emotion.

  • Nice diction through the fast part (slightly rushed maybe?) Sounds great ^^

  • Puhlease.........can someone punch the guy talking forever in the beginning!! He's so irritating with all his talking that little fag........lol

  • why does this guy talk forever?

  • He's killing time for the band to set up.

  • what does EVHS stands for? i guess this school was a international school.. some looks asian and some are american

  • evergreen valley high school based in california

    it's just a normal public high school

  • wow, throw some asians in a school and you think it's international? lol

  • jajajaj como rechina la banca donde esta el q tomo el video jajajaja

  • Sweet.. atleast you didn't edit the song for content.

  • honestly, for a first year choir this isn't bad. although, it could be better, of course. but i'm sure they worked hard! :)

  • please come and hear my version of this song where i play and sing all the parts

    myspace DOT com/dunce3500

  • Look, I understand that some small quoir wanted to sing a crazy awesome song but its impossible. All that I hear is crap.

  • The choir is pretty good but they mix up the text singing the part with "sent shivers down my spine" first.. thats wrong. BTW im in a choir too and we have only been singin for half a year, but we still do better than these people so its not that amazing in my oppinion..

  • The choral music is rearranged - my choir is doing it too and they cut a verse from the beginning for the arrangement. It isn't their fault.

    I'm actually not much a fan of any choral group doing it (including my own) because it's so complex and too closely associated with the original. Nobody will ever be happy with it because it isn't Freddie.

  • Yeah. In the Hal Leonard arrangement they cut out "Mama just killed a man..." and the rest of that verse. My choir is doing this song. I'm the only one who really loves it. Everyone else just thinks it's an acid trip.

  • yeah mr chinte!

  • Erg. I know EVhs choir can do way better. Im in choir and i have heard wayyy better. This is to much for a begining choir, it sounds to mixed up. This isnt What eastview choir is suppose to sound like.

  • The singing is great...But the guitar sucks!

  • Very nice. They must have worked hard!

  • 1 star

  • i have 2 words

    bad and bad

  • you should have made them mosh and headbang on the heavy part!!

  • I have this in my Suzki book 1 # 13 and were r u from I am from Guilford ct age 16 and who old r u and what insterment do u play I play viola and piano

  • nice cover

  • i like more bass voices

  • we only had 3 bass in this group.

    still it's not more bass, but stronger bass that's needed. check out my Ikaw or Star Spangled Banner videos for far better bass voicing. We only had 4 bass there but they were stronger than this group by far.

  • Why does everyone always skip "mama just killed a man" part?

  • Probably not school apropriate

  • The choral version of the song you have to order doesn't include that part.