Sweetbox - Chyna Girl LIVE

[DinexTaiwan]

Her voice is a little bit suck here. The album version is better.

I'm not sure if this version is the True original version. However, for another similar song "I Love You", I found out there was a line written "OP:More Than Love" in the pamphlet of Encore. This made me more confused because it often means the song is a cover version. I wonder whether Superstar has the same situation or not

[tkk30]

SHE is the best and they are the original singer den sweetbox take it n sing agn!!

[Joshorty]

get your facts right. Geo the producer/composer of the song Super star, used the same compositions and they decided to use it on Jade's "adagio" album, where Jade wrote her own lyrics and thus, "Chyna Girl" happened. So really, Geo is the rightful original owner of what you hear in the background. Nothing illegal happened. no one ripped anyone off. U gotta thank Geo for making them tons of hits so give the guy credit and a break.

[Ririeru]

still like S.H.E.'s version... but still cant believe that this is the orig version of superstar..

[ethanhunt134]

@Ririeru its not SHE was the original dun worry

[iLikeDragon]

lol is it just me or does it sound like they shout 朋友們! after the first verse? 0:58

[tech2kn0w]

@iLikeDragon not really. . . maybe because english is my first language but I know chinese because I am chinese. XD

[iLikeDragon]

both are good (i wont say which is better tho lol)

[03335111543]

S.H.E version is a hell lot better.

[FarewelI]

It's like they pronounce it like Chiar girl? ;S

[blossomgirl12]

i agree

[dormyzzz]

And again, NO.

[Mahalove]

This is a live version, on the album version they sound pretty alike (just checked out the S.H.E version)

[blossomgirl12]

S.H.E is wayyyy better

[dormyzzz]

NO.

[blossomgirl12]

actully yea it is

[dormyzzz]

Huh. SHE girls are weird.

But w/e to each his own.

You're totally missing out...

[xiaovianloveyou]

Gosh....i prefer S.H.E version!!

[dormyzzz]

NO.

[ManhuntFun]

this is gay

[JaLwYn2008]

in some cases, that's true.

[JaLwYn2008]

i meant to say that the song and melody was originally written for SHE. after SHE's "super star" became popular, that's the time sweetbox re-sung it in english.. :D

[yukihitoivanov]

i prefer S.H.E's Superstar ^.^

[JaLwYn2008]

"German producer Roberto 'Geo' Rosan composed "Super Star" for S.H.E. AFTER IT BECAME POPULAR, Geo HAD THE LYRICS REWRITTEN for his Euroband, Sweetbox, as the song "Chyna Girl""

-->quoted from wikipedia, man.

[remirap]

wuts "chyna" mean?

[HisSweetie188]

pretty plates and dolls you just keep for decoration and never use because you afraid it will break

[jdcunan]

the song of chyna girl has on audition ryt?

[SClubJuniorsRocks]

i kinda think she looks like kimberley from "girls aloud"

[DemonAng3l11]

oooh i didn't know that 'chyna' meant that 8.

whole new perspective on this song X/

[Pakbethol]

The original singers of this song is still the best!!! Go S.H.E !!!

[leafygirl99]

i hate to burst your bubble but S.H.E. did a cover of Sweetbox's original version. though in my opinion they're both great ^^

[Pakbethol]

I'm not denying the fact that they did covered songs from Sweetbox... and that Sweetbox's the actual composer of this song... I'm just saying that I like S.H.E's version better.... so I said they're the best...but they didn't cover this one, right? But I really really agree with you... Sweetbox and S.H.E are both great. ;)

[JaLwYn2008]

SHE is the original singer/s of this song. the original title is super star, and both english and chinese versions of the song has the same writer. it's just that the chinese song came out first. it became popular, that's why it was rewritten in english for sweetbox. :D

[joselle03191900]

aie..S.H.E much better than her..sorry! XD

[chrisse124]

how the hell u get that?

[jdiddy666]

white girls cant sing. i wanna hear salina, hebe and ella.

[XAznOfDoomX]

uhem, its selina but yea i prefer s.h.e xD

[carkod]

this is shit

[5061519]

chyna - meaning ridiculously good in bed!!!! It`s another word for vagina...

so fuck off you air headed asians! grrrrrr

[jean22s]

y r u being so racist??!!!...

asaians are smarter than western people so dnt call us air heads!

[obsesstvbfan]

S.H.E. is so much better than her singing.

[joydlsm]

SHE is the original of this song! much better even i dont understand mandarine, their version is way way much better!!!

especially if Ella was there!

[Sw33tb0x]

From what i read on wikipedia (not the best source i know), the song isnt referencing the country China. It refers to the porcelain china, whereas saying the girl in the song is delicate, much like porcelain.

As for the spelling... its their song, they can spell it however they like. Its not like the spelling is affecting the song anyway..

[Karenpang93]

S.H.E

[puls1356]

Though I'm a Korean, I Can't understand Why Korean enthuasis at Sweet Box...Look this song! there's no Asian In stage..but she sang a 'Chyna Girl'!that's pretty funny asian are not Fucking Concerning Toy!!XD

Chyna girl? FUck off!! and fuck Your Boy Friends Dick!!lolㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[chrisjma]

the producer of this song orginially composed this song for S.H.E, you can look up the info on wikipedia

[sabioluv]

what a fuck are u saying about S.H.E did NOT COPY this song sweetbox really wrote this song 4 s.h.e BUT THEY DIDNT COPY THIS SONG and S.H.E 's performance better so dont say that s.h.e copy this song

[TrinityBloodRox]

the lyrics to shes superstar in english are in a skye sweetnam cover, cuz the translation is wrong for sweetbox

[eseclip]

who the hell is S.h.e???

nothing beats Original =_=+

[jadecat6194]

S.H.E is a Taiwanese all-female group consisting of three girls. They are quite popular. I honestly love S.H.E's version better.

[chrisjma]

this isn't the original version, the producer originally composed this for S.H.E, u can look up the info on wikipedia

[9958521zai]

Sweetbox wrote the song for SHE, the song would then become such a hit that they decided to sing their own version in English.

[9958521zai]

Sweetbox wrote the song for SHE, the song would then become such a hit that they decided to sing their own version in English.

[hello0647]

wow S.H.E. really did copy this song.

[hello0647]

oh wait i meant to say it the other way around S.H.E. sounds better anyways

[RyogaDaze]

The lyrics are so crap (and really kind of cheap... "The sky's getting dark/There's no secret that I'm your China girl")

-.- SHE's Superstar wins hands down.

[GuRLjUic3]

i prefer the chinese version sang by S.H.E

[tarakuto0]

heck yeah!! SUPERSTAR is way better than this..no offence though but it's true

[spnjin]

dood wow its from sbs .... KOREA!!!!

[Jade91011]

I really dun like her that much I just dun like this coz they copied the beat/music/melody from S.H.E...

[Vaarsuvius89]

hmmm..... well, I'll admit she's not as good live............

but actually, they didn't copy it, the song was written in different versions for both of them.

[rockhotchick]

yeah,but Jade91011 said that sweetbox copied the beat/music/melody from S.H.E

and not the words

[yummeow]

emmm....she copied them...

[horyboyzzzz]

Jade wrote this sogn for them, SHE bought from Jade... I love Jade n SHE equally!!!

JADE DOESNT COPY!!!

[SephyInABox]

Jade didn't necessarily copy. The composer of this song composed this song for S.H.E. and since it was so well received, he decided to take the song to Sweetbox and have it be done in English to reach a broader audience.

[13ooster]

U meant the other way around. S.H.E. is getting the 2nd dip on this great piece.

[foreverfay101]

actually, for this song, s.h.e were the first to sing it.

"chyna girl" and "more than love" were orignally written for s.h.e. other songs like "read my mind and that night" are originally sweetbox's.

[roxanne410]

@Jade91011 But the thing is they gave SHE a song in return. Wo Ai Ni in fact.

[EurojEniar]

jade's father is actually a Filipino, that makes her half Filipino.

[minyi1993]

there is southkorea

she played at southkorea

[xMrRand0m]

OMFG U GUYS SUCK!!! S.H.E pwns!!

[itzXsammyXyo]

listening to this version, i really like the one SHE sings. that one seems better.more meaningful

[darkstrong92]

Yes, she is japanese. But she sing in english.

[fetuskarate]

she's not japanese.

[basch2020]

Born in San Diego, USA.

[teenstarlover101]

is sweetbox, jappanese?

[Esterr1124]

this version is more meaningful, i think.

[anime03otaku]

do you have this song??? i've been looking for it for so long...but i can't find it....if you do let me know and maybe you could send it to me!

[jessutubedavies]

I have it!! I've got a lot of sweetbox songs...I can send them to you if u want...

[anime03otaku]

i love this song.

[GLAMOUROUSuu]

Jade sucks at singing live. D:

[Gr3eNt3a]

she sing tis song...dun realli "power/high" enuff...HM.. I STILL PREFER S.H.E wans!

[jinyu31]

I prefer the mandarin version than her version.

[ForeverMe16]

i like the chinese version waaaaaaay better...XD...this version kinda sucks...this girl can't really sing as well

[lightstar300]

by S.H.E ^_^

[mytristan]

I'm sorry for her that the chinese version one which is copied from her sounds much better.

[moongirl54]

You should research first. The songwriter wrote for S.H.E first then had the lyrics written for an English version

[aeirissa]

She's so ugly ... -_- Bleghh ,, I like the song but I don't like her ! She can't sing live !!

[Luciper911]

I wonder what you look like.

[aeirissa]

I like ... Uuhm .. Well not this !

[J1129]

She sings ballads great live! Her performances of For The Lonely, Read My Mind, & Every Step are powerful & moving!

[GothicLoser411]

I love this song.Thanks for uploading this! its awesome! ^_^