This song has little to do about 9-11, but more about what pain the mother earth is in right now, the current path we are choosing is the discord of the life suffering, wake up people open your eye and realize that the number 1 must go down .9999646566 to find the path forward, and zero is .0000353434 relative to our current time on earth. WAKE UP.
All hail the great seal of the United States of America
god bless all the rescue workers firefighters and cops that died on 911 trying to save lives in the world trade center rest in peace everyone that lost there lives on that tough day
..."This beautiful drowning. This Holy Water"... Watching the memorial events this morning and I give such credit to the architect who designed the reflective pools where the WTC once stood. So symbolic. EVERYTHING needs water. Without it life would not exist. Primal, Baptismal, Healing. Forever Alive.
This is by far, the most ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL rendition of this song. ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL. What a blessing to have Ed Kowalczyk. Thank you Vodkaa1 for posting. May God's Love and Peace be with all of you today. 9/11/11.
@jormal2 ja nie powiedziałem że to jest żenada... podoba mi się ta piosenka... ale 18L też ma fajne... Każdy ma inny gust... Ja lubię z polskiego hip-hopu tylko 18L i Hemp Gru...
I first heard this song on the last episode of the second season of the fantastic series "The Shield". This song made that particular epsiode one of my absolute favorites of the entire series. So powerful. So deep.
Well, first heard Live in 1997 in the foreign Legion and I loved it. I was a sniper in 2eme REP and idid kill people. That's all behind now. Nowadays I'm an Intelligece Officer in Finnish Army. But my lt changed 9/11 2001. And this band really moved me. Have a mBA in Philosophy and whateverer it takes, my life's job is to prevent any more casualties. A bit strange comment from a career officer, but my job is to prevent war, not to create more violence.
haunting song ! written about all the violence in our world . why can't we all respect one another - color, religion, sexual orientation etc doesn't matter . as JESUS IS SUPPOSED TO HAVE INSTRUCTED : "LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF " That means all people , not just those next door
God, please heal the souls of those who lost loved ones in the islamic terrorist attack of 9/11. Never let hatred guide us but only Justice and Mercy.
What an awesome song....we should all be overcome every morning when our eyes open as we receive another gift from God to live another day of our lives.
What a song. "My Masters in the yard giving light to the unaware". "This Plastic little place is just a step amongst the stairs". Give up your blind devotion to Religions that only want to control you. Search for your own truth, your happiness awaits.
Hi, does anybody know at what concert/ festival there were performing in this video? I'd love to buy a DVD, but can only find a concert from Amsterdam. But in my opinion they performing the song better in this clip...
May God bless him and may the Good Lord watch over him, you, and your family my friend :) His is watching over you now with peace and love from above.
When a singer sings a hit song live in concert, and it sounds as good as it is recorded on the album..then you know they have reached perfection..Live is that band and this song sung here proves it.PERFECTION.
songs like Selling the Drama, Dolphins Cry, Lightning Crashes, and I Alone. Please tell me you've at least heard these songs and just don't know the band name. Give em a listen great band.
average?! LiVE is amazing. Ed is easily one of the top 10 rock singers of all time. The bass/drum dynamic in their music is perfect. powerful lyrics... what else could you ask for?
Wow, you really are an asshole aren't you! You've got your own opinion, but if it's against a video you just watched, why bother voicing it? It just proves how little of a life that you have & how pitiful you are.
what's sad is that we now have in office as our President a man who simply sat and did nothing as his preacher railed against our country and gloated about it happily the sunday after.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
bush looks like a monkey .............obama looks like a monkey, price charls looks like a monkey, tony blair looks like monky......hmmmmmmm. they all from the same place...hell
A tragedy is a tragedy. Whether it be 9/11, the loss of Princess Diana, the Tsunami, the wildfires of Australia, the Irish Famine, or two people being lost at sea. Don't say Americans don't care about international disasters because we do! We're always first in line to help out. It's your countries who play the news of current events. We don't make them report our current events!
Dude...with all due respect...if the US hadn't come in to WWII you'd be speaking German right now. My grandfather fought, and many of his friends died, fighting to save Europe so please get a grip.
you still haven't answered the question - why did it take 2 years for them to join the effort? and for the record, almost all of the men and some of the women in my family on both sides were in that war at the time it were going on. i think my grip is more realistically attached than yours. you are out of your element in this debate. thank you for your participation.
I beg to differ on being out of my element. Please consider that the vast majority of Europe stood by and allowed the National Socialist Party to rise into the vacuum created by WWI. The Brits stood down and the French came up with the Maginot Line...that was Europes answer? As to why America didn't come in...complicated but in short...we weren't ready for another war yet (both industrially and socially).
The French in WWI...impressive...the resistance in WWII...impressive. The Maginot Line?...a complete unthhought disaster. Normandy, the push through Europe...all US baby. (OK...Monty and the gang helped too)
If you were to read through our dialogue - I never denied your claim about the Maginot line. However, you haven't owned up to any of the faults that belong to the US. you just keep making excuses, and meager justifications.
no one here is denying your claims about US involvement. You just seem to have a lack of humility where the US is concerned, which is one of the bigger faults of the US. Probably why the world in general can't stand the US - you are so unnecessarily arrogant. admitting your faults, is a noble means of taking ownership. something you haven't done yet here.
...and yes the French helped during our revolution...but it was inevitable. England couldn't have ruled the Americas much longer anyway. Lafayette...I like...good guy (historically speaking)...but ironically you may want to remember that Washington was able to defeat Cornwallis/Howe/Clinton etc. because of the training provided to US troops by von Steuben...a German
My last post must not have made it through....I appreciate both your opinions and this discourse. I suggest we move it to a more appropriate forum (assuming you wish to continue it) as this is a great song whatever one's personal view may be...If not, peace...out.
Thats a very good question.Why did it take us americans to get in the war?My guess is that we needed to build a big enough army against hitler thats my guess. Hitler had a HUGE army and wanted to take over the world and if the USA would have never defefeated him the whole world would be speaking german right now.
While I agree that Hitler needed to be stopped, and America was a factor in winning, I think you're overlooking the contribution that Russia provided. Their resistance and losses were unparalleled in WWII. Just google "Stalingrad" or the "Battle of Kursk." These were two things that really broke the momentum and morale of the Nazi juggernaut.
Where is this concert?
blessmeish 3 weeks ago
@blessmeish Pinkpop Netherlands
nutsbof 1 week ago
Totally amazing.
blessmeish 3 weeks ago
greatest and most underrated band ever.
scottyrose11 3 weeks ago
This song has little to do about 9-11, but more about what pain the mother earth is in right now, the current path we are choosing is the discord of the life suffering, wake up people open your eye and realize that the number 1 must go down .9999646566 to find the path forward, and zero is .0000353434 relative to our current time on earth. WAKE UP.
All hail the great seal of the United States of America
TheJuglenaut 1 month ago
I have heard two different versions of this, its hard to pick a favorite, this one is somber and the other one is a little more uplifting.
MutimirRX 2 months ago
god bless all the rescue workers firefighters and cops that died on 911 trying to save lives in the world trade center rest in peace everyone that lost there lives on that tough day
MrKjurgensen 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
Hij blijft goed.
noicer 2 months ago
greatest and most underrated band of all time
hamletp 3 months ago 3
..."This beautiful drowning. This Holy Water"... Watching the memorial events this morning and I give such credit to the architect who designed the reflective pools where the WTC once stood. So symbolic. EVERYTHING needs water. Without it life would not exist. Primal, Baptismal, Healing. Forever Alive.
Overcome.
09amarin 4 months ago
This is by far, the most ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL rendition of this song. ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL. What a blessing to have Ed Kowalczyk. Thank you Vodkaa1 for posting. May God's Love and Peace be with all of you today. 9/11/11.
09amarin 4 months ago
How calls this song?
mardvBLOG 5 months ago
@mardvBLOG overcome by live :)
philosophyisthebomb 4 months ago
am i the only one who liked this song because i heard from the album not from 9-11 or the shield?
ncolson86 5 months ago
byłem juz tu 137 razy!!! piekna piosenka
kksmirek 5 months ago
Also heard this at the end of Season 2 of The Shield. LOVED that finale.
AdrunkGirlScout 6 months ago
Today it's already 8 years ago I lost my grandfather, I wish he was here...
MrVanBronckhorst 7 months ago in playlist Afspeellijst van Tom
@MrVanBronckhorst
Sry for your loss. I lost my big sister.
MelChafe 5 months ago
The greatest band of all time and the greatest front man of all time
hamletp 7 months ago
911 likes.... :O
pleepotnl 8 months ago
ONE M00:00RE TIME
MrVanBronckhorst 8 months ago in playlist Afspeellijst van Tom
Comment removed
MrVanBronckhorst 8 months ago in playlist Afspeellijst van Tom
Fucking EPIC
OctagonBiTcH 8 months ago 2
@jormal2 ja nie powiedziałem że to jest żenada... podoba mi się ta piosenka... ale 18L też ma fajne... Każdy ma inny gust... Ja lubię z polskiego hip-hopu tylko 18L i Hemp Gru...
dudinho132 8 months ago
I first heard this song on the last episode of the second season of the fantastic series "The Shield". This song made that particular epsiode one of my absolute favorites of the entire series. So powerful. So deep.
Morrowind11 9 months ago 21
@Morrowind11 Same here.
BlackOpsOnslaught 8 months ago
@Morrowind11 I still rate the shield as one of the most powerful shows I've ever seen. This song couldn't be more appropriate for that episode.
werideonsunbeams 7 months ago
Well, first heard Live in 1997 in the foreign Legion and I loved it. I was a sniper in 2eme REP and idid kill people. That's all behind now. Nowadays I'm an Intelligece Officer in Finnish Army. But my lt changed 9/11 2001. And this band really moved me. Have a mBA in Philosophy and whateverer it takes, my life's job is to prevent any more casualties. A bit strange comment from a career officer, but my job is to prevent war, not to create more violence.
Adamson11x 10 months ago
WOW!!! - Great O_o
kreidefelsen 11 months ago
Un máquina!
Verucarock 11 months ago
Sensacional, magnífico, simplesmente lindo.
Silvio1970votu 11 months ago
GOOOSEBUMPS!!!! Live aint done yet folks,. ROCK AND ROLL AINT NEVER GONNA DIE!!!
Rousska 1 year ago
polskie lepsze!
dudinho132 1 year ago
@dudinho132 nie wydaje mi sie ... polskie mto żenada ...
jormal2 8 months ago
this gave me the chills
masterfreestyler187 1 year ago
pinkpop nederland landgraaf supper vet
brianclenn 1 year ago
This is the only song that makes me cry.
bharo9 1 year ago
love you guys xx
shaznsteve 1 year ago 2
this guy is freaking awesome, and it only adds to his coolness factor that he cares
Rachelphobia 1 year ago
beautiful song, what a beautiful man with a lot of charisma...
breathtaking
AceMrMad 1 year ago 3
haunting song ! written about all the violence in our world . why can't we all respect one another - color, religion, sexual orientation etc doesn't matter . as JESUS IS SUPPOSED TO HAVE INSTRUCTED : "LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF " That means all people , not just those next door
randellcayla 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@randellcayla "Love your neighbor as you love yourself" That only works if you love yourself.
ladyfuschia 1 year ago
God, please heal the souls of those who lost loved ones in the islamic terrorist attack of 9/11. Never let hatred guide us but only Justice and Mercy.
Amen.
MatsPT 1 year ago 4
piękna piosenka
MarcinKoma 1 year ago
this song is beatifu
TheBryantje3 1 year ago
great song,great voice and very great band.
thx for posting
Darkvision45 1 year ago
What an awesome song....we should all be overcome every morning when our eyes open as we receive another gift from God to live another day of our lives.
mswildiidol 1 year ago 2
He NAILED this song! Amazing.
gavinsone 1 year ago 3
What a song. "My Masters in the yard giving light to the unaware". "This Plastic little place is just a step amongst the stairs". Give up your blind devotion to Religions that only want to control you. Search for your own truth, your happiness awaits.
buddatheone 1 year ago
this guy is just pure magic...........sings from the heart.
burgwerfen 1 year ago 4
This beautiful drowning...
jaipasseparhazard 1 year ago
really this song makes me cry ..........
its so damn beautifull
ricochetlaugh 1 year ago
Really great!!!!!!!!!
Thank you very much for sharing Brainge.
Friendly greetings,
Michael
michaelplaying 1 year ago
Excellent. Laura
laurabrake1 1 year ago
Hi, does anybody know at what concert/ festival there were performing in this video? I'd love to buy a DVD, but can only find a concert from Amsterdam. But in my opinion they performing the song better in this clip...
Unr33L80 1 year ago
@Unr33L80 yep! its a Dutch festival called Pinkpop and i was lucky to be there.They where great!!
c1975s 1 year ago
Possibly the best song ever and I'm not religious at all.
jrmhrpr 1 year ago 2
love this song
anjibufas 1 year ago
I think this is one of the best ballads that I´ve heard
agussoler 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing.
0zonnebloem 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing.
0zonnebloem 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing.
0zonnebloem 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing.
0zonnebloem 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
amazing.
0zonnebloem 1 year ago
from who is the original??
i want to download it
punkrulesz 1 year ago
@punkrulesz live made the original song but its like their special song
HBK4President 1 year ago
@punkrulesz it's in the titel of the vid?
mu5ic1 1 year ago
The bridge... it's got so much power, i don't know how to explain it... the whole song is a masterpiece. <3
elinola 1 year ago
WHOW weetje hoe mooi!
Pixelpc 1 year ago
WHOW
Pixelpc 1 year ago
its a shame this song got synonymous with 911, its a beautiful song on its own
cillian1983 1 year ago
And I am overcome,Holy water in my lungs....Rest in peace Dad and everyone else 9/11
Doukatas26 1 year ago 96
May God bless him and may the Good Lord watch over him, you, and your family my friend :) His is watching over you now with peace and love from above.
Proflutzn 1 year ago
@Doukatas26
rip baby
HNNZ88 1 year ago
@Doukatas26 I'm sorry about your father, I'll keep him in my prayers...as well as the others
rockndude87 1 year ago 5
@rockndude87 thanks very much my dear friend
Doukatas26 11 months ago
@Doukatas26 You're very welcome, Godbless
rockndude87 11 months ago
@Doukatas26 I am so... So sorry.
rupefan 1 year ago
@Doukatas26 damn i'm sorry for you, you must
really hate that osama bin laden and those terrorists,
like everybody should do, there are no words for
those awfull people . . .
jeroen0011 1 year ago
@jeroen0011 i hate no one.i'm thankful for the life that lord let me live with my father.Hate brings hate.i just let those souls to rest in peace.
Doukatas26 1 year ago 2
Breathe of life.......
lucycomstock 1 year ago
911 2001 i had holy water in my lungs, those who have to ask fuck off
skirbyr 1 year ago
i love it in my lungs!!!!!!!1 iii i remember pls lord
skirbyr 1 year ago
agasse, that's brilliant!
sumwun26 1 year ago
i didn't know andre aggassi sang, he's good too
jocorocket 1 year ago 2
epic comment XD
ruuuuddd 1 year ago
@jocorocket rofl at your comment "i didnt know andre aggasi sang, he's good too"!
troglodyto 1 year ago
Jeden Osiem L coped better with this primer
Erni1407 2 years ago
truly unbelievable
katek28 2 years ago
i hope you can understand what this meant,and yes i was there and i did l have lost friends
firebirdss 2 years ago 2
Wonderfull!
I have a question, what does he mean with: holy water in my lungs?
janroelofff 2 years ago
not speaking for the poet
my interpretation "this beauriful drowning" and "holy water in my lungs" : the overwhelming complete suttender to love, even in death.
mayasattva 2 years ago
my God why this song makes me cry everytime i heard it.. ?? oh how i love LIVE.... amazing performance..
hyeangel16 2 years ago 3
i cry by this song wow peace arie
47arie 2 years ago
When a singer sings a hit song live in concert, and it sounds as good as it is recorded on the album..then you know they have reached perfection..Live is that band and this song sung here proves it.PERFECTION.
BX02 2 years ago 2
no need to say more
you said it all
shame though that the album Songs From Black Mountain never been a success over here for it has good songs try : Where do we go from here
24AB2 2 years ago
UNBELIEVABLE MAN !!!
amgoldriver 2 years ago
greatest band ever
hamletp 2 years ago
Saw this band several years ago and was blown away by how good they really were....Poetry to say the least....Enough with the 911 crap......
urlipsmydik77 2 years ago
This band LIVE is truly Amazing their lead singer has a great voice
This band with hard work and many hours has showed so much faith in their music to the world they are truly Amazing.
Thank you for sharing this beautiful video.
This song and video is Awesome
~ Peace be with you all ~ LIFESTARS
LIFESTARS 2 years ago 2
In 9 / 11 as 1st argument and still think of that sad story.
I came back from school, and saw on the news.
As a boy of 7 shakes you so ..
colinhabbo813 2 years ago
Comment removed
colinhabbo813 2 years ago
Me too.
colinhabbo813 2 years ago
beautiful song
pestjoch123 2 years ago 2
cool
boavista1222 2 years ago
it does make me think about 9/11
anaaldigitaal 2 years ago
From Brazil (TheRonisrock): Live...the best!!!
TheRonisrock 2 years ago
amazing song!
mitchverleun25 2 years ago
Thats because its relaxing. Relaxing makes you go. LoL
W78516 2 years ago
when I have constipation, I think of this song. And it actually helps me. Its like laxative for the ears.
bigpowerfulpeople 2 years ago 3
hahaha. that is funny. so for you this is actually re-titled "constipation song" hahaha.
fleawulf 2 years ago
This song is actually very much applyable to a lot of situations and emotions.
That's why it makes it such a great song.
1603ben43 2 years ago
One of the greatest songs of all time. Brings tears to my eyes every time.
tones7mca 2 years ago
this song is incredible. The lyrics are so relaible and the wonderful music...
ps. the singers voice make feel uhlalala... :)
cr00pie 2 years ago
Man why cant the world think like this. It sure would be a nice place.
W78516 2 years ago
You can get this version. With the crowd singing with him on iTunes. It's amazing. It's a live live version lol
Iamyourgod93 2 years ago
Let's hear it for bald guys who can fill a stadium.
G58 2 years ago
never heard of this song.
Who are these guys?
JeanBebop 2 years ago
WHAAAAAAAA?!?!?!!?
The band is "Live" (long I sound)
songs like Selling the Drama, Dolphins Cry, Lightning Crashes, and I Alone. Please tell me you've at least heard these songs and just don't know the band name. Give em a listen great band.
xaero300 2 years ago 2
average?! LiVE is amazing. Ed is easily one of the top 10 rock singers of all time. The bass/drum dynamic in their music is perfect. powerful lyrics... what else could you ask for?
tallicafan1221 2 years ago 10
sorry man accidentally thumbs downed your comment but i completly agree THUMBS UP
queenforlife96 2 years ago 3
He is definitely one of the best live singers
empirecircle 2 years ago 2
Live is an average band but this is a very special song and amazing performance .
nutsbof 2 years ago 5
Live is an average band... this song is cool.
GeorgeskoorB 2 years ago 3
Depressing? This song is pure magic. Overwhelming. Holy water...
Stero71 2 years ago 39
This has been flagged as spam show
i was searching looking for all that remains... and i came to this shit on a stick..
z0oy0rkskater123 2 years ago
Wow, you really are an asshole aren't you! You've got your own opinion, but if it's against a video you just watched, why bother voicing it? It just proves how little of a life that you have & how pitiful you are.
The1DayeV 2 years ago 3
what a great song, anyone know how i copy the audio to this?? ive got the cd version but this is awesome
bapo74 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Fajnie. Ale moim zdaniem lepiej brzmi to w "JAK ZAPOMNIEĆ" 18L ... Czuć życie do piosenki, a tu jest trochę płytko zaśpiewane...
przyjaciolka8 2 years ago
Comment removed
przyjaciolka8 2 years ago
GOD, QE LINDA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FCaz4 2 years ago 2
omg
niekhorstman 2 years ago 2
excellent
ce morceau je l ai decouvert dans la serie americaine "the shield" saison 2 dernier episode
marcobac59 2 years ago 4
Unlocking the gates of love......
When do we make a start with that.....?
DeHef15 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm bringing back the Ottoman Empire. Who's with me?!
Rasha5377 2 years ago
As a man of Polish descent, I will bring back John Sobieski's legacy and kick ur ass!
williamsobieski86 2 years ago
In Poland we have gropup which is named "Jeden 8 L", and they have song with that same start.
rbk17 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
And that's the biggest shit I have ever hear.
Stupid men - nothing but copying another motives.
I mean 18L of course
mumin54 2 years ago
yo man he ain't copied that song he was 1st, after 18L COPIED it if u wanna know.
GothKnight18 2 years ago
This Song is Just Simply Excellent!.....no matter What..Powerful!
Gadgetkid4ever 2 years ago
is that pinkpop??
XsweetguyX 2 years ago
no its the band LIVE
evigatornoob 2 years ago
yes i know but isnt that AT pinkpop (festival)
XsweetguyX 2 years ago
ooh you mean that, hmm dunno. 8-)
evigatornoob 2 years ago
Ed says
"Holy water in my lungs" or "Only water in my lungs"?
The 90% of lyrics on web says "Holy", but I wanna know what do you tink about it.
Thanks
Malefix777 2 years ago
I think he says Holy..
No , actually , i'm pretty sure about it.
Gajiem 2 years ago
I have the official single and on the back stands the lyrics. And the lyrics say Holy water in my lungs
DafBnTs 2 years ago
indeed !!
playboygent 2 years ago
this song makes me cry, very very beautiful!!!!
evigatornoob 2 years ago 4
what's sad is that we now have in office as our President a man who simply sat and did nothing as his preacher railed against our country and gloated about it happily the sunday after.
williamsobieski86 2 years ago
As an irish guy who is not able to vote for the most powerful man in the world, I would like to say that I am confident in Obama...
Bush was an idiot, but not as big an idiot as the 59,054,087 people who re-elected him...
shiverstone1 2 years ago 3
Don't get me wrong... I can't stand Bush, but Obama is an anti-American black supremacist asshole!
williamsobieski86 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
bush looks like a monkey .............obama looks like a monkey, price charls looks like a monkey, tony blair looks like monky......hmmmmmmm. they all from the same place...hell
ranifloat 2 years ago
why do you find Obama an anti- american black supremacist asshole?
Paawned 2 years ago
obama,,,,bush they all the same,
ranifloat 2 years ago
Super top dit nummer !!
jojonkjes 2 years ago
lol this is like a freakin history lesson
meteorguydude 2 years ago
Wat een hoop Reactie in het Nederlands joh...
TomasgeenH 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
maxamillion1011 2 years ago
It is all about the music you stupid fuckers.....and LIVE is the music!
eatfreaky 2 years ago 4
RESPECT.
NLD007 2 years ago
i raped a lesbo chik on 9-11
lythiumhead619 2 years ago
A tragedy is a tragedy. Whether it be 9/11, the loss of Princess Diana, the Tsunami, the wildfires of Australia, the Irish Famine, or two people being lost at sea. Don't say Americans don't care about international disasters because we do! We're always first in line to help out. It's your countries who play the news of current events. We don't make them report our current events!
tnic469 2 years ago
yes - that's why it took the USA 2 years to give a s#@$ before they decided to get involved in WWII
minou1et1aline 2 years ago
Dude...with all due respect...if the US hadn't come in to WWII you'd be speaking German right now. My grandfather fought, and many of his friends died, fighting to save Europe so please get a grip.
sf147147 2 years ago
you still haven't answered the question - why did it take 2 years for them to join the effort? and for the record, almost all of the men and some of the women in my family on both sides were in that war at the time it were going on. i think my grip is more realistically attached than yours. you are out of your element in this debate. thank you for your participation.
minou1et1aline 2 years ago
I beg to differ on being out of my element. Please consider that the vast majority of Europe stood by and allowed the National Socialist Party to rise into the vacuum created by WWI. The Brits stood down and the French came up with the Maginot Line...that was Europes answer? As to why America didn't come in...complicated but in short...we weren't ready for another war yet (both industrially and socially).
sf147147 2 years ago
spare me - if it wasn't for the french, you'd be speaking the queen's english now.
minou1et1aline 2 years ago
The French in WWI...impressive...the resistance in WWII...impressive. The Maginot Line?...a complete unthhought disaster. Normandy, the push through Europe...all US baby. (OK...Monty and the gang helped too)
sf147147 2 years ago
If you were to read through our dialogue - I never denied your claim about the Maginot line. However, you haven't owned up to any of the faults that belong to the US. you just keep making excuses, and meager justifications.
minou1et1aline 2 years ago
no one here is denying your claims about US involvement. You just seem to have a lack of humility where the US is concerned, which is one of the bigger faults of the US. Probably why the world in general can't stand the US - you are so unnecessarily arrogant. admitting your faults, is a noble means of taking ownership. something you haven't done yet here.
minou1et1aline 2 years ago
...and yes the French helped during our revolution...but it was inevitable. England couldn't have ruled the Americas much longer anyway. Lafayette...I like...good guy (historically speaking)...but ironically you may want to remember that Washington was able to defeat Cornwallis/Howe/Clinton etc. because of the training provided to US troops by von Steuben...a German
sf147147 2 years ago
England held on to their Empire until the 1950's. what is your definition of "much longer"?
minou1et1aline 2 years ago
My last post must not have made it through....I appreciate both your opinions and this discourse. I suggest we move it to a more appropriate forum (assuming you wish to continue it) as this is a great song whatever one's personal view may be...If not, peace...out.
sf147147 2 years ago 2
indeed...lol.. you are right...
wermarch 2 years ago
So what is the answer to the quwstion I wold like to know.
535wer 2 years ago
german is pretty cool only the ideas were not that cool-> just like your megalomaniac-USA-vision!
smig0497 2 years ago
Thats a very good question.Why did it take us americans to get in the war?My guess is that we needed to build a big enough army against hitler thats my guess. Hitler had a HUGE army and wanted to take over the world and if the USA would have never defefeated him the whole world would be speaking german right now.
535wer 2 years ago
While I agree that Hitler needed to be stopped, and America was a factor in winning, I think you're overlooking the contribution that Russia provided. Their resistance and losses were unparalleled in WWII. Just google "Stalingrad" or the "Battle of Kursk." These were two things that really broke the momentum and morale of the Nazi juggernaut.
cyanide585 2 years ago
Let's not forget how Belgium kicked German ass
haha ;)
stijnvandenbroeck 2 years ago