@seonidh This has Nothing to do with Ulster. It was an outlaw in scotland. His father killed at an early age. He was betrayed by one of his own clan. While in the dungeon preparing for his hanging he wrote a lament. Then Robert Burns wrote this version of his lament. This has nothing at all to do with Ulster. So SammyEnglish is spewing bullshit
still, the change in words change the meaning. In the original version, MacPherson sounds like a kind of mortal Jesus, in this he sounds like he's a bloodthirsty bandit, not a noble thief like Robin Hood
Didn't they change/omit some of the lyrics? If I remember correctly, the version that either MacPherson or Burns wrote (I forget which I read) said that he didn't want to be avenged, but don't the Corries say that he did? They do this with a good amount of songs, and while I love listening to them, it just is confusing to me.
Folksongs are like that. There are about twenty verses to this song, about fourteen of which I have actually heard in recordings, and have never heard a version with more than eight verses at once. Some are traditional, some written by Walter Scott, some written by Robert Burns. It's public domain, and people are free to sing as they like! That's why it's called folk, it travels by word of mouth.
Loved the Corries since I first saw them singing Killicrankie on TV when I was a kid. They did an earlier version of this which had slightly different wording.
This is the first song I was ever taught at primary school in Leith around 1970. I've been singing it ever since and reckon The Corries do it more justice than most others I've heard. Superb performance!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
dont fuck wi the macphersons my dads name was murdoch which is scottish for "sea warrior" he came from the islands and he was a diamond he was in the british army and was feart of fuck all
I have a dear friend in North Carolina whose maiden name was MacPherson. Her family has been here in the new world since before the revolution, so she is long removed from her Scots ancestors, but I can't wait to point her to this! She will be charmed!
She will be charmed indeed. She will also find out that we landaed in south Carolina we decided it was too bloody warm and moved north! Canada there we went!
i've loved the corries since being wee when my dad and i used to sit and watch videos of them. i will always love their music and im proud to be scottish!!
Sorry lads that I can't give any better rating, but since I heard the Scocha-Version of this song I have to say I prefer that one. This one is not bad at all, it is good, but there is a better version out there...
"Give it laldy!" It means give it everything you have, go for it, put in your all.
Here's to Scotland rejoining the international community as an independent nation asap - to stand as equals with our friends and partners all over the world. Like your pal, I'm also a member of the MacPherson clan.
Peace and love from Edinburgh. The Corries are awesome.
yeah, pretty much "give it hell!" like alba said. but i'm liking the idea of inventing a noun meaning too! is it a bird? is it a plane? no, it's a laldy!
anyone know where you can download corrie songs onto mp3 as an mp3 file i ripped some of a cd but all my other fave corrie songs are on about 7 different cassetes somewhere in my room
Braw. This is by far my favourite version of this song, but what a shame Roy's no longer with us. Thank you so much for uploading it, always makes me proud to be a Scotsman.
Just learned to play this great tune on my accordian !
8busby 5 months ago
Its nothing to do with ulster scots or scottish history for that fact.
Its a story about a fiddler who's has been imprisioned and about to be hung. He's playing his last tune on his fiddle before he has to die.
bigbandswinger 6 months ago
Whisky time.... gaun yersls boys!! Caledonia forever..hic..
kiltsnhaggis 11 months ago
Im confused does it have a speacial meaning to the ulster scots?
seonidh 1 year ago
@seonidh This has Nothing to do with Ulster. It was an outlaw in scotland. His father killed at an early age. He was betrayed by one of his own clan. While in the dungeon preparing for his hanging he wrote a lament. Then Robert Burns wrote this version of his lament. This has nothing at all to do with Ulster. So SammyEnglish is spewing bullshit
DrinkToIreland 2 months ago
Ah! Roy & Ronnie.....the sweet, sweet memories. Happy days!
leithboy1 1 year ago
A good Ulster-Scots song
SammyEnglish 1 year ago
@SammyEnglish
This is from Scotland Banff/ Mcduff pure Scotland the North East of Scotland the finest place in the world
uo8am 1 year ago
@uo8am
Yes, like i quoted - a Scots/Ulster tune.
SammyEnglish 1 year ago
@SammyEnglish its about a man being hung in scotland its not a song about ulster.
seonidh 1 year ago 2
@seonidh
It's a Scots/Ulster connection- which apples to much of our history.
SammyEnglish 1 year ago
@SammyEnglish how is it a connection is it sung in ulster then if so its a scottish song sung in ulster
seonidh 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@seonidh
It's a Scots/Ulster connection- which applies to much of our history.
SammyEnglish 1 year ago
@SammyEnglish Hundred percent nothing to do with Northern Ireland .Not a thing .Im North East Scotland .I know go read your history .
MrRobertson52 9 months ago
I absolutely love the expression on Ronnie's face during the verse beginning at 1.43. Quality!
caxy2001 1 year ago
Comment removed
caxy2001 1 year ago
also, do you know any other versions with the traditional lyrics?
BlindKakashi 1 year ago
still, the change in words change the meaning. In the original version, MacPherson sounds like a kind of mortal Jesus, in this he sounds like he's a bloodthirsty bandit, not a noble thief like Robin Hood
BlindKakashi 1 year ago
What is the REefrain?
1qaud 1 year ago
@1qaud
Sae rantin'ly, sae wantonly, and sae dauntin'ly gaed he
He played a tune, and danced it roond, below the gallows tree
JBurdoo 1 year ago
Didn't they change/omit some of the lyrics? If I remember correctly, the version that either MacPherson or Burns wrote (I forget which I read) said that he didn't want to be avenged, but don't the Corries say that he did? They do this with a good amount of songs, and while I love listening to them, it just is confusing to me.
BlindKakashi 1 year ago
@BlindKakashi
Folksongs are like that. There are about twenty verses to this song, about fourteen of which I have actually heard in recordings, and have never heard a version with more than eight verses at once. Some are traditional, some written by Walter Scott, some written by Robert Burns. It's public domain, and people are free to sing as they like! That's why it's called folk, it travels by word of mouth.
JBurdoo 1 year ago
Loved the Corries since I first saw them singing Killicrankie on TV when I was a kid. They did an earlier version of this which had slightly different wording.
Just about anything they did was brilliant.
scottyscouter 1 year ago
one of my favorites. MAN, ronnie has a head of hair.
arkhangelsk 1 year ago
burns burns burns
mrbonedigger 1 year ago
What happened to this verse. "I have lived a life, o' straught and strife
I die by treachery, It burns my heart, that I must depart, An no avenged be".
deskpot1 1 year ago
These men are irreplaceable.
JohnnyContagious 1 year ago 4
fantastic !!
paul1314 2 years ago
Great stuff !
josparkes1 2 years ago
Ive just heard a couple versions of this and this one is definately the best :-)
joeygsmom 2 years ago
really stirring and Im not any kind of Celt/Scot, just a Yank who likes the whole Rebel idea...
joeygsmom 2 years ago 6
This is the first song I was ever taught at primary school in Leith around 1970. I've been singing it ever since and reckon The Corries do it more justice than most others I've heard. Superb performance!
leithboy1 2 years ago 5
BRILLIANT.
arkhangelsk 2 years ago 2
May God keep you in his holy keeping Roy.
deskpot1 2 years ago 3
Absolutely superb. This is proper music - better than the tripe you hear today.
Ebenezerg00de 2 years ago 36
Comment removed
hoadmaboab 2 years ago
So true!
kldudmp 2 years ago
wow...its like a bathroom wall on utube....
catholicrik 2 years ago
my comment was directed at the language some choose to us on you tube...not this great song sung by two great men..
catholicrik 2 years ago 3
Phuckin awesome,
Per Mare Per Terram
johnny65 2 years ago 2
This song always gets me riled up!
Clan Macpherson forever & Alba gu brath!!!
semperfijoe92 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dont fuck wi the macphersons my dads name was murdoch which is scottish for "sea warrior" he came from the islands and he was a diamond he was in the british army and was feart of fuck all
MrPmac1964 2 years ago
What the fuck are you talking about?
semperfijoe92 2 years ago
Rabbie Burns at his best
mrbonedigger 2 years ago
@mrbonedigger : don't understand why you received the thumbs down for referencing that this is a Burns work; are many ignorant to this fact?
mikeygg3 1 year ago
@mrbonedigger : Don't understand why you are getting thumbs down for referencing this as a Burns work. Are many ignorant to this fact?
mikeygg3 1 year ago 2
Dedicated to a friend Jonn Macpherson who died recently.. yer wi yer Clan noo pal
Alba gu brath!
jacobiker 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lmao... it's a scotish Kenny Rogers.
DerekNS74 2 years ago
DerekNS74-----Hmmmm, the big difference is, Ronnie knows how to sing! :)
uggyoggy9 2 years ago 6
love this version sung at a faster pace than the studio version
dangledoop 2 years ago 2
Classic!!!
captaincaveman1874 2 years ago
This was one of the first versions of this I learned.
JBurdoo 2 years ago
I have a dear friend in North Carolina whose maiden name was MacPherson. Her family has been here in the new world since before the revolution, so she is long removed from her Scots ancestors, but I can't wait to point her to this! She will be charmed!
EMesaros 2 years ago 2
She will be charmed indeed. She will also find out that we landaed in south Carolina we decided it was too bloody warm and moved north! Canada there we went!
bennyfaethebrig 2 years ago
Comment removed
EMesaros 2 years ago
i've loved the corries since being wee when my dad and i used to sit and watch videos of them. i will always love their music and im proud to be scottish!!
BandieO9 2 years ago 4
Being a MacPherson myself, living in a far away country, I must say this song makes me proud of my heritage, and of who I am.
beXda313 3 years ago 7
Sorry lads that I can't give any better rating, but since I heard the Scocha-Version of this song I have to say I prefer that one. This one is not bad at all, it is good, but there is a better version out there...
Lucarius1 3 years ago
the corries made it a great scottish song go on the corries
ciarangrahan12 3 years ago 15
we usually find that the first version of a song you hear is always the best
bennyfaethebrig 2 years ago
great version...first heard it by john meadows...who played Job during the last season of the
Book of Job at Pine Mtn. State Park, after a 20 year run. he did an acapella version in the newspaper office one afternoon.
barrymore 3 years ago
sae rantingly, sae wantonly,
ans sae dauntingly gaed he,
he played a tune and he danced aroond
below the gallow's tree
pure class
Snadd1987 3 years ago 6
Sung this song when i was over in russia with some Royal Navy Veterans a few years ago had everyone tapping along with me.
oddball24sco 3 years ago
wild mountain thyme is brill but the battle songs r jist is good
42hunchie 3 years ago
At 1.55 ronnie looks like a proud lion.
foxyrocket 3 years ago 4
Brilliant. Love the lacklustre clapping at 2:08 - gie it laldy wumman!
Strarnin 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
EMesaros 2 years ago
Hi there!
"Give it laldy!" It means give it everything you have, go for it, put in your all.
Here's to Scotland rejoining the international community as an independent nation asap - to stand as equals with our friends and partners all over the world. Like your pal, I'm also a member of the MacPherson clan.
Peace and love from Edinburgh. The Corries are awesome.
alba1gubrath 2 years ago 7
yeah, pretty much "give it hell!" like alba said. but i'm liking the idea of inventing a noun meaning too! is it a bird? is it a plane? no, it's a laldy!
Strarnin 2 years ago 2
Thanks for the information about "Laldy!" Now I know. And I loved the bird and plane stuff. I get a lot of good laughs off Ytube.
EMesaros 2 years ago
Brilliant song
ALFcurrie01 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
anyone know where you can download corrie songs onto mp3 as an mp3 file i ripped some of a cd but all my other fave corrie songs are on about 7 different cassetes somewhere in my room
airfixbuilder 4 years ago
minted
taity39 4 years ago
ya canna get much better than that
goggsie123 4 years ago
Aye , wan o' oor braw yins.
Free Scotland and the world , Gordon Brown , (me)(Paisley)
BantheRiver 4 years ago
Braw. This is by far my favourite version of this song, but what a shame Roy's no longer with us. Thank you so much for uploading it, always makes me proud to be a Scotsman.
SaintJimmy671 4 years ago
Love it! Thanks for the upload!
foxyrocket 4 years ago
Brilliant
wysie2007 4 years ago
love this song,but have driven my lassie roond the bend with me singin it for the last 12months.
cheers fur thi upload
rosswatt1979 4 years ago 3
Comment removed
EMesaros 2 years ago