Never heard this version before, it is Great! I have the original studio version on a UK import album titled "Lady Samantha" which I bought in a TSS record shop (in Elmont, NY) in the 80's. I also enjoy the 11.17.70 version, but this is the best, I think. You can tell that this is from 1974...I hear the influence of bells like you hear in "Lucy in theSky", also from 1974. Elton, your voice in the early 70's was at its prime. Wish we had it back.
Wicket song. The live version is raw and has power, this version has more variation, more to listen to. April Wine did a commendable, job but there is no way April Wine or very many other bands for that matter, can come out on top compared with Elton in his prime (IMHO).
I have a mint copy of this double set on vinyl.... I need not say more. Its nothing short of awesome. Ata time when Elton went through a brief retirement.... Most thought it was over. Great compilation.
Just bought Here and There yesterday! Totally awesome. The secon disc is in NY and has the three tracks he and John Lennon done in 74, so great. This album has great live version of Satruday Night's Alright For Fighting and The Bitch Is Back....so worth it.
Does anybody know who covered Elton John's ballad, "I've Been Loving You" in the early 70s? I heard a beautiful version of it in Montreal as a young child, and am haunted by the wish to find it and hear it again.
it's better on 11-17-70--more "raw"--the "here and there' album was orig, 1 ALBUM!--didn't have Lennon on it--the cd is double and has LOADS more on it than the album-- also--the album 11-17 -70 doesn't have "Amoreena" like the cd has--also--this is not on "here and there"
it's better on 11-17-70--more "raw"--the "here and there' album was orig, 1 ALBUM!--didn't have Lennon on it--the cd is double and has LOADS more on it than the album-- also--the album 11-17 -70 doesn't have "Amoreena" like the cd has
Originally, written by Bernie Taupin and sung by Elton John but much more popularized by April Wine who seem to be only known among Canadians, dang it all. lol.
Originally, written by Bernie Taupin and sung by Elton John but much more popularized by April Wine who seem to be only known among Canadians, dang it all.
@EJinthe70s It is also out on Elton John (first American album) remastered as an extra, Rare Masters a two CD set, and To Be Continued a 4 CD box set.
Hey buddy. I am from Montreal, and am extremely proud of most things Canadian and Montreal-based, but c'mon. Elton & Bernie are on a par with Lennon & McCartney in terms of quality and volume of genius output over the years. April Wine is nowhere near their level, no matter how much I love them.
Another killer post EJ!! I have the extended version of this CD in which they finally included this version. Smokin' hot!!! Just brilliant!!! Hot band on the top of their game, taking an obscure track and putting the pedal to the metal the way the song was meant to be played. The 11-17-70 version has that raw feel that made the trio such a buzzworthy concert event at the time, and the original studio version with Caleb on guitar (Friends soundtrack?) was also tight, but this is my favorite.
This song was a massive radio hit in Canada in '72, as covered hardrock-style by our own April Wine. Being that in other countries (including England) the song is just an obscure Elton b-side, it's funny that "Bad Side" is very well known among all Canadians of a certain age.
You can hear "our" version on YouTube if you search it out.
11/17/70 was actually recorded at A & R studios in NYC, and the concert was broadcast live on a rock radio station. Three musicians making incredible music that is timeless. Hard to imagine that was over 40 years ago! Makes me feel too old!!!!
Here and There is a live album edited in 1976 but contains 2 concerts from 1974, in London (here) and New york (there) . Both great concerts, this track was taken in London; other nice versions are Skyline Pigeon, Love Song... THe concert in NY instead is famous because John Lennon played together with the EJ band. :D
I always loved this song. Though I have the studio version on one of his old box sets, I always wondered why they didn't inlude it on one of his albums.
@ antdigger Hard for him to rip off April Wine when he and Bernie Taupin wrote and recorded it in 1970 before April Wine recorded it in 1971
RAYDOG1957 2 months ago
This guy ripped off April Wine.
antdigger 2 months ago
Whose came first? April Wine or Elton John?
TheMeanSgtPlaysPiano 2 months ago
@TheMeanSgtPlaysPiano Elton, April Wine covered it
waffleownage 2 months ago
Canada's April Wine had the best version of this song. John's doesn't come close.
TheCanadianmade1 4 months ago
@TheCanadianmade1
Dude, I'm Canadian but I think Elton's version is better.
boideye 3 months ago
really really great - thanks for posting this
lakefield2112 6 months ago
Never heard this version before, it is Great! I have the original studio version on a UK import album titled "Lady Samantha" which I bought in a TSS record shop (in Elmont, NY) in the 80's. I also enjoy the 11.17.70 version, but this is the best, I think. You can tell that this is from 1974...I hear the influence of bells like you hear in "Lucy in theSky", also from 1974. Elton, your voice in the early 70's was at its prime. Wish we had it back.
LLCoolA63 7 months ago
please somebody find guitar tabs for intro
oasis9876 11 months ago
Best version I've ever heard, thanks for uploading!
Hendrucks 11 months ago
NICEEE thank you for uploading
eltonjohnfan100 11 months ago
Wicket song. The live version is raw and has power, this version has more variation, more to listen to. April Wine did a commendable, job but there is no way April Wine or very many other bands for that matter, can come out on top compared with Elton in his prime (IMHO).
Satchelabc123 11 months ago
I have a mint copy of this double set on vinyl.... I need not say more. Its nothing short of awesome. Ata time when Elton went through a brief retirement.... Most thought it was over. Great compilation.
spydey550 11 months ago
Just bought Here and There yesterday! Totally awesome. The secon disc is in NY and has the three tracks he and John Lennon done in 74, so great. This album has great live version of Satruday Night's Alright For Fighting and The Bitch Is Back....so worth it.
musicNpoets1 11 months ago
Holy. Moses. I have been redeemed !!!!
SabbeleuDesigns 1 year ago
Does anybody know who covered Elton John's ballad, "I've Been Loving You" in the early 70s? I heard a beautiful version of it in Montreal as a young child, and am haunted by the wish to find it and hear it again.
OronOfMontreal 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you people are all hateful bastards
mikecappa 1 year ago
it's better on 11-17-70--more "raw"--the "here and there' album was orig, 1 ALBUM!--didn't have Lennon on it--the cd is double and has LOADS more on it than the album-- also--the album 11-17 -70 doesn't have "Amoreena" like the cd has--also--this is not on "here and there"
3953871 1 year ago
it's better on 11-17-70--more "raw"--the "here and there' album was orig, 1 ALBUM!--didn't have Lennon on it--the cd is double and has LOADS more on it than the album-- also--the album 11-17 -70 doesn't have "Amoreena" like the cd has
3953871 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Originally, written by Bernie Taupin and sung by Elton John but much more popularized by April Wine who seem to be only known among Canadians, dang it all. lol.
TheGoddess1971 1 year ago
Originally, written by Bernie Taupin and sung by Elton John but much more popularized by April Wine who seem to be only known among Canadians, dang it all.
TheGoddess1971 1 year ago
this is april wine song
scottleach99 1 year ago
Is this out on CD in any form? If so, tell me where! I love 11.17.70, but this kills it.
nieckolai 1 year ago 2
@nieckolai
yes in the HERE AND THERE Album, released in 1976... lovely live double cd!
EJinthe70s 1 year ago
@EJinthe70s It is also out on Elton John (first American album) remastered as an extra, Rare Masters a two CD set, and To Be Continued a 4 CD box set.
buck2239 1 year ago
Great early Elton John tune. Tell me, am I the only one who remembers this song
being performed by a group called "Toefat" ?
ToneLilly1 1 year ago
April Wines version still has me vote
glamourboy89 1 year ago
@glamourboy89 That whiny Canadian band? Never as good as Elton John.
Hemingway271 1 year ago
@Hemingway271 What makes them whiny? I love both versions of it, don't trash a great Canadian band.
RIPjohnbonham 1 year ago
@Hemingway271 I would rather listen to April Wine then Elton John. But Elton John is a legend and doesnt even compare to the Canadian band
rentashoo 1 year ago
@rentashoo
Hey buddy. I am from Montreal, and am extremely proud of most things Canadian and Montreal-based, but c'mon. Elton & Bernie are on a par with Lennon & McCartney in terms of quality and volume of genius output over the years. April Wine is nowhere near their level, no matter how much I love them.
OronOfMontreal 1 year ago 2
@glamourboy89 Totally agree!
Negativerything 1 year ago
the best ever vesion of this tune ever what a gig wish i was there one of the best live tunes ive ever heard genious
tsw11385 1 year ago
Another killer post EJ!! I have the extended version of this CD in which they finally included this version. Smokin' hot!!! Just brilliant!!! Hot band on the top of their game, taking an obscure track and putting the pedal to the metal the way the song was meant to be played. The 11-17-70 version has that raw feel that made the trio such a buzzworthy concert event at the time, and the original studio version with Caleb on guitar (Friends soundtrack?) was also tight, but this is my favorite.
intrepidsinger 1 year ago
nice picture
great performance
elton14jp 1 year ago
This song was a massive radio hit in Canada in '72, as covered hardrock-style by our own April Wine. Being that in other countries (including England) the song is just an obscure Elton b-side, it's funny that "Bad Side" is very well known among all Canadians of a certain age.
You can hear "our" version on YouTube if you search it out.
fabrikk60 2 years ago 3
Nigel just shines on this track
mactheartofwarfare 2 years ago
Dig this sound of the boys in '74, Davey's guitar, Ray & Nigel percussion, and of course Dee omnipresent. Firing on all cylinders, tight~
rockitmanjohn 2 years ago
Got to see him at Carnegie Hall during their first U.S. tour. He, Nigel, and Dee on stage. It sounded like 100 musicians. Truly remarkable.
Entertainmentwriter 2 years ago
Great. Still love 11/17/70 version the best.
Entertainmentwriter 2 years ago
kudos
TJLan86 2 years ago 2
I agree TOTALLY! I wish he would slip this in every now and then-I think it'd go over well!
jpzollar 2 years ago
@Entertainmentwriter , the best version, i agree, it was a radio city music broadcast, that album was awesome!
pootski123 1 year ago
11/17/70 was actually recorded at A & R studios in NYC, and the concert was broadcast live on a rock radio station. Three musicians making incredible music that is timeless. Hard to imagine that was over 40 years ago! Makes me feel too old!!!!
Entertainmentwriter 1 year ago
My God... this is monsterously good!!!! Can't get enough!
OOOOOOOOOOOOH! 6:33
sbcruiser 2 years ago 28
yeah!! buy Here and There (it's a live album) VERY NICE!! all songs are like this and quality is very good
EJinthe70s 2 years ago
Jeez.. I thought Here and There was from 1976! I had that one years ago! Nothing like this on it! Gotta get out more!
sbcruiser 2 years ago 14
Here and There is a live album edited in 1976 but contains 2 concerts from 1974, in London (here) and New york (there) . Both great concerts, this track was taken in London; other nice versions are Skyline Pigeon, Love Song... THe concert in NY instead is famous because John Lennon played together with the EJ band. :D
EJinthe70s 2 years ago
Absolutely great!!! Thank you so much for posting this!!!
sbcruiser 2 years ago 14
An extraordinary version of a song that was once very popular but is now seldom heard. Genius!
voiceofmegatron 2 years ago 22
This version reminds me of Dear Prudence.
thespermdonor 2 years ago 16
Astonishing version... much more passion and drama than the studio version. Thanks for posting
RudlandSalt 2 years ago 19
I always loved this song. Though I have the studio version on one of his old box sets, I always wondered why they didn't inlude it on one of his albums.
mvarga1234 2 years ago 15
Absolute best performance of this song!
honkycabbit 2 years ago 17
Best performance of this song...Thaks for posting it!
babynavyblue 2 years ago 8
Great performance! Thanks!!
kylebedient 2 years ago 6