Added: 4 years ago
From: bannerdb
Views: 56,521
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (183)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • That was pretty cool. Well done =)

  • In the words of The 9th Doctor, this was "Fantastic!"

  • Jack's hitchin' a ride.

  • gwen is so fit in sereason 1 but now she loks ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww­wwww

  • My only problem with the ending was: Would Tosh not have heard the TARDIS? I mean, she met the Doctor in 'Boom Town' with the Ninth Doctor and though it was a very brief meeting, she still should have heard it.

    Though, I like the episode ending because it makes it a bit more mysterious for those who don't watch Doctor Who. (not including me)

  •  this knew lke happen but thx for remmeber :D good job friend i love this serie my phone have this song of torch when someone calling me =D

  • Why did he do a gay jump? That kind of ruined it.

  • yeah but Jack's only there waiting for the doctor to come back cuz jack's vortex manipulator broke! but at the end of doctor who series 3 jack says that he has resonsibilites! which is torchwood which he found out when he was with the doctor! and then Ianto kept him there and at the end of torchwood (which i havent seen) i'm guessing he went because nothing was keeping him there! xxxxxxx

  • PERFECT!

  • I like what you did. good job

  • i saw a plot hole. I'n not saying its ur fault its the BBCs fault, when it zooms out of from the water tower theres no tardis

  • nicely cut....

  • Does anyone know when season 4 starts?

  • @rocknroller1986 Summer 2011

  • Captain Jack Harkness is by far my favourite companion, hence the reason him being the leader of a secret organisation, torchwood really is my favourite sci-fi after doctor who coz its for us older kids :)

  • that should have been the ending

  • and so therefore, in actual fact jack joining the Dr at this point has not been covered in a Dr who story as yet! could be any Dr - Matt smith even? just a thought

  • @BlackSuedeShoes1 watch the episode Utopia.......-.-

  • wow this ending is so much better than the original one.

  • Nice cut together of the two shows.

  • brilliant editing - seamless

  • I like yours better than the real one ^.^ haha

  • Watch popular TVShows at W W W . TV-Vide . NET

  • what appens after he holds on to tardis is in the doctor who episode where they visit the end of the world

  • Was good that. Well done. 10*

  • awesome

  • I like it.

  • He looks better as the Face Of Boe.

  • Nah. I think it would have been better without seeing the tardis, but jack running shouting 'Doctor!'

  • Creepy... Amd I the only one who heard a voice whipser 'Jack' at 0:30-0:31...

    Listen carefully, you briefly hear a really hunting whisper say 'Jack'... o_o

  • omg ur right i listened to it a few time yeah u can hear a voice say jack it really aint tho buh u can..good ear ive watch it a few times and never heard it till i listenin more carefully

  • i hadn't noticed that till i listened to it though my headphones lol cool

  • @MultiMatt666 i hear it too

  • nah i heard it too wow spooky

  • @MultiMatt666 I think Jack just exhaled quickly, but I know what you mean

  • @MultiMatt666 yeah, I could....

    creepy.

  • @MultiMatt666 I heard it but I don't know if it is saying "Jack". Was it a woman's voice, cause I think it might have been the Bad Wolf/Rose. Her telling him The Doctor is back. ??? xx

  • very nice.  I think it was better then the original ending... and I also think that the good doctor needs to make an appearance on Torchwood some time.

  • Nicely done!

  • what actually happened there i havnt seen the next episode

  • Amazing stuff!! :D

  • brilliant! I didn't catch this here in the states.. I would have preferred this ending over the one I saw.

  • That was brilliant, utterly fantastic well done

  • Fantastic :)

  • What always confuses me about the end of the Torchwood episode, Gwen is standing *right there* in the doorway. She would have heard the alarm, seen the hand glowing and flashing and basically going bonkers, and she would have seen Jack leave. It doesn't make sense that she'd say that she doesn't know. A better line would have probably been, "I don't know, he just ran off." or...something.

  • mmm that is not true he might have gone up on the lift. however, i think that they filmed them at different times, and in the TW one had the tardis come into headquarters because the TARDIS might be loud, but it isn't so loud you can hear it all the way down in TW HQ.

  • He left through the lift, the tardis was near it, and that was what was causing all the wind and such...

  • @dbvixxen You're right. What's more confusing is when the Tardis sound approaches at the Hub, some of the sound has been mixed or cut off. Instead of having the Tardis at the Hub to pick up Jack, the Tardis is outside of the Hub and having Jack running towards the Tardis. Incidentally; Jack would have heard the Tardis sound from the surface and teleported from the Hub to an open area and making a run towards the Tardis. I don't how he managed to get his backpack loaded and carried that fast.

  • @MF033D Well he seemed to be ready for the doctor to come with the hand and everything, so it was probably already there, the backpack packed

  • @dbvixxen *cough*sidewalk lift*cough*

  • @eddmario Not possible, because the Doctor landed where the sidewalk lift is.

  • Very nice job.. keep up the good work :)

  • that was great! you need to finish it, though, by having the doctor firing up the TARDIS and having Jack go through the vortex.

  • :D We need more of this.

  • Brilliant!

  • Nice, but only if you Series 3 of DW already

  • Its really good

  • Great! You really showed the linkage between Dr Who and Torchwood and it fitted really well, excellent work ! I'm very Impressed!

  • well done

  • BRILLIANT!

  • Oh. My. God. Best ending EVER! You'd be good as an editor on the BBC!

  • great idea! it illustrates the link between shows some people miss... though i cant see how they could xP 10/10!

  • I went and watched Utopia strait from the season finale of Torchwood. I wish it would've ended like this. But its a great job!

    Thanks for putting it together!

  • Thats cool, it should have ended like that!! five stars

  • epic editing. great job mate.

  • Great Job!

  • ACE !!

  • Great editing. I wish the BBC had done it like that. The only thing I'd of liked to see is the TARDIS next to the water tower on the Cardiff Bay flyover thing. But that's a but difficult to do.

  • that was a really epic leap

    awesome work

  • You should send a link to the BBC of this.

  • Best Edited Ending Ever. No questions asked. 5/5

  • I wish the BBC would of thought of this

  • much better ending for it, about time the doctor did make an appearance in torchwood for once as jack is always returning to doctor who so david tennant should appear in an episode of torchwood as the doctor

  • I'm pretty sure that also the Doctor is left out specifically in order to let people enjoy Torchwood as a standalone show and not need to even know what Doctor Who is (although, really - FAT CHANCE).

  • i love this nice edit

  • Great editing, wish they'd really done it like this

  • I like how you inserted Doctor in the end especially music and Jack's jump. That would be great ending -even more intense than how it was on TV. Good work :)

  • bloody fantastic!

  • Bravo! Finally a Torchwood/Utopia Transition that actually Works. 5 Stars!

  • gr8 video!

  • it kept the audience wondering what happened if they showed that it would of been good but give away to much and the pitstop was like the twist in the tale.

  • nah the ending they had was better because gwen asumed that somethings taken him but because we know the sound of the tardis we assume the doctor came back for him but in reality he was there purly to, well have a pitstop.

  • And why is that better? The continuity was way off with the original ending. This edited ending was designed to provide more linkage, if you read the info section, you would have realised that. Please do so

  • Nice edit. But I fail to see how the continuity was "way off". Explain.

  • Well the most obvious was the Tardis materialising in the Hub at the end of Torchwood series one, and in "Utopia" it materialises outside. That explanation goof enuf?

  • Not really, as the TARDIS was never shown to have materialised inside the hub. The only thing that suggests the TARDIS landed inside was the wind blowing through, and that was put in to make the Doctor's arrival all the more 'glorious'.

  • Jack looked directly at the Tardis as it materialized in the hub. The reason we never saw it appear was a budget issue, pure and simple, and to add some mystery. However, the fact remains that it appeared inside the hub in Torchwood, and outside in Utopia. Thanks

  • this wouldn't have worked in torchwood Because when this episode was shown we hadn't met Martha Yet So that would give away series 3 and confuse people as to where Jack was

  • The TARDIS just wasnt there. it landed on torchwood lift and blew down some wind. but luv the edit you cant even see the joins.

    XXjXX

  • @bannerdb

    Torchwood series 1 sucked anyway and Utopia was a good episode. The Mothership show got the better deal if you ask me - considering Jack had to cling onto the TARDIS as it pelted through the Time Vortex to get away from him...

  • @bannerdb It wasn't a budget issue, if they'd have put it in it'd be too blatant. It doesn't matter that there's no consistency, it's done for pure artistic effect.

  • @Scarperguy yeah and otherwise Gwen and the others wouldn't have been thinking something had taken Jack, which is a big part of it, if a big blue box had appeared then it would have ruined that part

  • @bannerdb Well the hub is directly under the tower so it would still have been heard and wind would still becused

  • @bannerdb But how do you know he was looking at the TARDIS? The light on his face may have been the Doctor's (other) hand and maybe the wind was the reaction of the other hand to the Doctor's arrival.

  • @akiugn

    Your Right, it never landed in the hub

    That wind was from his hand

  • @LolGuy619 Well It's only for artistic license and limited because of budget issues--

    wait a minute...

    ...THAT WAS POSTED TWO YEARS AGO?? I don't even remember seeing this vid :P

  • Perhaps, the platform cover was open, allowing the "backwash" from the tardis to enter

  • or maybe it was The Doctor's severed hand did that as Jack had rigged it up to make it a doctor detector.

  • Love it!

  • Very nice!

    Have to admit that made more sense than what they showed but I suppose they thought it was better to keep people guessing.

  • Okay, yeah. This is aewsome.

  • I agree that would have made a better ending well done!

  • that should of been the real ending VERY GOOD

    10/10

  • thts VERY gd

  • thats way better ;]]

  • good ending. well edited. =]

  • That would have been better, the wait for DW season 3 would have been more intense. Good work!

  • True, but we would never worry about Doctor or Martha in that season because we know they would have to survive long enough to get to this moment. Still, I agree with you.

  • Well, you can see in the trailers they showed for the seasons that both would survive.

  • tbh i thought the little teaser they gave was enough. i got very excited by that moment. n it means the shows arnt repeating themselves. just enough to show where they cross over

  • that is really good, i like it more than the real ending!

  • i like it, i think its better.

  • how did u get dat thing in da corner

  • they never made a real crossover, but the sound at 0:49 is the TARDIS, and the first sentence of the video...I think they want to give an impression.

  • please can anybody tell me where i can find the one where jack finaly meets the doctor

  • You won't find the answer here I'm afraid. This thread is for the discussion of this video only. Thanks

  • Excellent. Very well edited, especially due to the continuity problems the two shows brought up.

  • brill i wish it had ended like this

  • wonderfully edited needless to add

  • I think they should include the Doctor in one episode of Torchwood. Like a crossover between Simpsons and Family Guy.

  • Great ending, timed with music! love it! maybe less Doc and Martha to make it a true Torchwood ep, but still great!

  • If you got rid of the clips with The Doctor & Martha it could have been the perfect ending to that episode.

    Still, very good though.

  • No it needs the Doctor and Martha to give it some context...

  • Not necessarily, if they'd done that wiv that episode at the end but getting rid of the Doctor and Martha then it would have finished a TORCHWOOD episode and not started a new Dr Who one.

  • But that was the idea of the ending....to gives Jacks story a continuation in Doctor Who

  • True, but you've done the ending for a Torchwood episode. Several Torchwood fans don't like Doctor Who, so don't watch it. So giving it a continuation in Doctor Who is not always a good thing.

  • True...but like it or not....Torchwood is a Doctor Who spin off and there are connections all over the place. The tardis was already in the episode, I just expanded on it a little.

  • not really, the fact that we didn't actually SEE the Tardis was probably due to conflicting filming schedules between the two shows. Hearing the Tardis enough to make the connection......

  • Come on, if they wanted the TARDIS in then they would have built the box as a prop. It's not that hard to build I don't think. Plus they could have used video footage & mixed it with the episode!

  • Not necessarily. Anyway Nearly all reviews of that episode and subsequent reviews of Utopia gave out about the lack of continuity between the two episodes, so I have tidied that up. :)

  • Shall we just agree to disagree?

  • i like this movie.....and i like that song too

  • i love the music at the end

  • that would have been a good ending!

  • Wow, that was absolutely AMAZING! you edited it really well and i loved that you made Jack just fly thru the air and then finish it, so you have no idea what'll happen to him!

  • cue capt jack for batman theme music while hes running towards the tardis

  • Eh.....no

  • lol soz... lol ooooo that was well a good cliffhanger oooo lol i thought u'de get wot i meant...o well

  • oooooooo

  • care to say something a bit more constructive than "oooooo"??

  • awsome. wer did you get the clips

  • omg wow!! thats really good!!

    I really think we should of seen the TARDIS at the end of End of Days, and the way you did it would of bin fab!

    5 stars form me!

  • Nicely done!

  • god sake video taking years to buffer

  • Contact Youtube then, or your service provider.....

  • I prefer the ending that was actually put on air, this one wasn't acted out so well

  • It would of been cool for the people who don't watch doctor who and they would be like "Is that the doctor?..."

  • Much Better

  • hey should of used that insted of the orliginal ending thats was mint

  • I think that was really clever and much more of a dramatic ending. :lol Well odne.

  • This is much better than the Torchwood Doctor Who crossover. Better editing too.

  • dat iz wot de endin should av been lyk 2 llnk da 2 programs

  • That is better than the real ending! I love it lots! John barrowman rules...Frema drools! Boo 2 Freema! Yaya 2 Rose!!!!!!!!

  • That is a better ending by far!!

  • Very well done!!

  • I absolutely love this. This is brilliantly done. Could go straight into the series if it were up to me.

  • Tres bien. Merci.

  • Unfortunately, you seem to be the only poster that is of that view. A lot of people complained about the continuity between the Torchwood finale and the Episode "Utopia" in Doctor Who. This project was an attempt to bridge the gap between the two episodes.

  • That was great editing.

    But would only work if viewers were both watching Doctor Who and Torchwood (not all are).

    Plus, the orginal gives more "mystery" to jack (not that he needs anymore).

    But I do like it.

  • Very slick!!!

  • thats so much better, works very well, good work!

  • JUST WAT THE SHOW SHOULD OF ENDED LIKE!

  • cool

  • that was awesome, great ending

  • I LOVE IT

  • that was really well made good job

  • it was vry good

  • Nah, dont think so. The way I ended it, left the viewer gagging for more in my opinion

  • Awesome editing, if only that was in the show. You could've added the bit where jack is clingin 2 the tardis thru the vortex.

  • Awesome! This is seriously what they should've done!

  • That's eactly what I was looking foward to when I was watching that. Great job.

  • That would have been so great. Great stuff.

  • OMG! well good editing

    i was just thinking someone needs to do one excalty like that!

  • Perfect! The only way it could have been better is to show him hanging on the TARDIS...but DAMN good job!

  • Does he make it?

  • Very good. Great editing skills

  • awesome

  • This is how Torchwood should've ended. Nice job putting it together.

  • That would be an amazing cliffhanger. Well done :)

  • AWE.SOME.