Added: 4 years ago
From: XxEmoxGirlxX24
Views: 63,584
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (167)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I Can't imagine what it would be like to loose someone like that... To loose someone that you had 3 years to attach to. This is a very powerful song. <3

  • I am a twin mt sister died at birth. </3

  • This song makes me cry but i still love it :)

  • Holy shit even youtube thinks this video is about suicide, haha even the advertisment under the video was a depression hot line.

  • I think your all motherf**ker who don't understand what this song mean!! Evanescence wrote this song because her sister died. Just leave the whole emo thing out.

  • @rees8251 evanescence is a band, not a person. amy lee wrote this. so u cant say 'evanescence wrote this because her sister died', there not one person. get it??? ok not tryin to be mean, just sayin.

  • I cant fight the tears any longer ..its so beautiful...I cant speak..no matter what u relate it to for your own piece of mind or hurt...its your choice of vision to relate..and let no one take it away from you with their opinions of what is right and wrong.. ..you deep gentle souls..I understand your pleasure in this pain...

  • hey, the song is not about suicide!!!!!!!!!! her sister died! so for all u fucking assholes who think its all about death, and being emo, go to hell!!!! dont even bother getting on here and commenting because ur all full of shit and refuse to understand!!!

  • If I smile and don't

    Believe

    Soon I know I'll wake from this dream

    Don't try to fix me I'm not broken

  • If I smile and don't

    Believe

    Soon I know I'll wake from this dream

    Don't try to fix me I'm not broken

  • Surely all you plastic people have worked out 'emos' are misunderstood! if you were to stereotype me id be a 'jock'. Try getting to know 'emos', theyre actually lovely people! get off your egotistic pedestal and live properly!

  • @fwiths9 I like your words..they are the solid truth !!

  • <3 Evanescence <3

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24

    thank you finally someone knows what amy lee is talking about in this song everyone thinks its about suicide the first time i heard it ik that it was about someone dying!

  • 2 PEOPLE ARE HEARTLESS IDOTS!

  • i love this song <3

    

  • just listen to the song dont make it ur life its a tragady that she lost her baby sister :'( R.I.P Amy's Sis

  • I love this song, its so emotional and it reminds me of certain things that habe happened within my own life. I liked ur video btw, the images u chose were beautiful <3

  • these comments are depressing, im sorry people but no one wants to hear your life story, or bad things that have happened to you

    and theres probly tons of people who have it worse off reading your comment

    getting insulted by how good you have it yet you complain

    cant we just be greatful for a good song?

  • Even if you delete the song we can find it somewhere else, So settle down, Let people do what they want,

  • Such a beautiful and sad song. Love it. <3

  • @daynuhmarie18 Same here. I love this song. Beautiful, yet sad. And sometimes, I just need a good cry here and there. Better than bottling all those emotions up all the time like I use to do. A mix of this and talking to people and I'm usually better off. Sad that her 3 year old sister died, though. :( My heart's with her sister and her as well as her family and anyone else who lost someone close. Make your life a good one peeps. Keep living. :)

  • @RevanRA I like what you say... beautiful words !!

  • que voz perfeita meu pai!!!

  • I Love it.°!!♥

  • I love this song sooo deep and meaningful... luv u amy lee

  • wow how is it I never heard this song...amazing

  • check out my bestfriend sing this go to his channel thealejandrocousins HES AMAZINGGG!!!

  • check out my bestfriend sing this go to his channel thealejandrocousins HES AMAZINGGG!!!

  • I love this song..i raped, violated the replay button lol

  • its sad and kinda emo which rocks

    

  • its sad and kinda emo wich rocks

  • its sad and kinda emo wich rocks

  • I love this song..and thats awful how everyone things this song is about suicide when its about her dead sister..DO YOUR FUCKIN RESEARCH!!!!!!!!sorry..it jus bugss me...an this song is so sad

  • In my last comment I accidentally put my sis died.My sis didn't die.My FRIENDS sis died

  • Hi there, me again.

    This video isnt about suicide.

    She wrote it for her 3 year old sister who died.

    So for you dipwads out there who think this song is emo and suicidal..

    Do some research before you make yourself look retarded.

  • i luv this video but i cry because this video is made for amys little sister who died at three years old with an illness that was unknown

  • some people just dont get good music.

    evanescence, linkin park, green day, muse, theyre all amazing bands, who should win countless awards.

    amazing song.

  • @runeanaelle amen to that :)

  • i think people think that youtube is a place where you can get counselling or a place to get simpathy but its not if you feel that loe or have that low opinion of yourself you need to see a really shrink or talk to a family member cause if your comment isnt about the song we dont want to hear it.

  • Damn it... *sob sob* This song is just viciouly clawing out my heart strings *sob sob* TT__TT Especially the past that says 'Has anyone told you shes not breathing...' TT__TT ... that part reminds me of when my little cousin died and her mom was sitting there screaming and clutching at her lifeless body still trying to get her to breathe *sob sob* Damn it all TT__TT *sob* My tear ducts are drying up...

  • @jasdeviel oh wow..im so sorry..thats so sad...i remember when my friend died in a car crash..hher mom was barely hurt but in was in 09...March to be exact....she was my best friend..and this song reminds me of her..she also used to love it..an i cry just thinking about it...her mom was yelling for someone and when they got there it was too late..her head went through a window an glass was all in her body an i jus miss her...

    RIP!!!SHADOW YOUNGBLOOD

  • This song isn't about death or anything, (well kind of). She wrote this song for her little 3 year old sister that died. She is very emotional about this song she states she won't preform this song or she will get into serious breakdown.

  • were did u get the pics? i love them

  • i lv this song listen 2 it all the time

  • I Love this song and the vid

    Good Job

  • is only with the lack of understanding your own inner self that u would lead one to assume this is about suicide..lets grow up i love this and yes i relate and understand

  • love it

  • This song is so sad. I feel bad for Amy and her poor sister. She was so young when she died..... This song shows how much Amy loves and cares about her sister.

  • Look all you people who are judging us emos need to get a life if u hav a problem with us go grow up and when you are finaly old enough to deal with your problems come back emo is not a style its a way of life just like prep jock and all that so all u haters if you hate it you shouldnt be on this freaking page

  • tonight will be the longest night I've lived in my ears feel the sweet voice of Amy Lee also that beautiful piano that brings my soul back home to myself this mystery should be revealed and his name is Faith and I will give my life without hesitation to be with her, even I can write something crazy is just what I can do only in the light of my computer screen makes me see what I write haha. these drinks are confusing my mind but I can still not over how long

  • good song

  • Beautiful  song and Great Video :)

  • How did u make such a Great Video ITs GREAT I LOVE IT

  • this song is amazing i really like the pictures they suit the song perfectly

  • "Do you know the feeling of your heart being so terribly broken you can feel the blood dripping out?" -Lady Gaga

  • I love this song so much

  • Honestly..I wonder how many ppl really know that this song was for her late sister, Bonnie?? She died at the age of 3..Amy was only 6. She also has a few other songs for Bonnie as well..like "Good Enough" and "Like You" on her most recent album

  • Why is everyone is talking about suicide I dont think this beautyful song is about suicide. If you ask me I think its about.....that so very special person in ur mind in ur heart that you always run to when you need help At least to me..........IM NOT CRAZY!!!

  • i luv dis song

  • i love this song by Evanescence!!! it means so much 2 me ever snice i was a little girl....

  • I love this song so much, and with the pictures in the background, gives it alot of effect. Thankyou <3 x

  • One of my friends just commited suicide the other day, im still crying. God I hope he's in heaven. I still can't believe it, he was only a Junior in highschool. I don't think the tears will ever stop falling if I keep listening to this song. It is a great song though.

  • @MayKay86 ohhhi soo sorry!!!!! i will keep her in my prayers!

  • Ugh can ppl PLZ stop talking about suicide???? This song isn't even about that so can we plz focus on this beautiful song by Evanescence???

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • luv this song ppl need to shut the f**k up this is not their vid sooo if yal wanna talk crap do it on your own vids k thx

  • I realize now that the comment I made earlier was totally retarded. You just have never loved someone as much as I do- and be so very close to being that persons girlfriend- and then be visiously ripped away from that person. It hurts more than anything.

  • This song always makes me cry. It was playing when i got the call to say my Nana had passed away. Rest in paece Nana <3

    Miss you so much

  • Good song!

  • <3

    :*(

  • for all those ppl who hav lost som1 important/close to them/u i shed tears cuz i just read that this song was made cuz her sis died wen she was 6 and her sis was 3 so sad im intears T.T

  • @TheKikyo1234 Tha happend to a good friend of mine. Her sister had no chance of living. I think it was her older sister though.

  • my life as i know it is over

  • i <3 this song cuz im goth

  • @TheKikyo1234 congradulations!!!!...no1 cares!......u dnt hav 2 label urself!!!!!!!!

  • @aharlow98 Okay, that's just fucking rude. If you don't like what someone says just ignore it. No need to be an asshat.

  • @britbritburger i love the word asshat sorry random moment :)

  • @aharlow98 u no what? u dont either.

  • @TheKikyo1234 so am i and when i listen to this song i feel like im understood, even my mom doesnt understand me, she tried making me go to therapy but instead i just had to talk to a conclier everyday for 180 days straight, he understood me and i only have a few great frds who do, but other than tht im an outcast and made fun of for it, but i just take it because it makes me stronger and this song makes me feel understood and excepted

  • ....I no likey the comments on this vid.... You should disable them...please...?

  • @PyroBookworm I'm sorry hun. I'm not a big fan of it either but try to ignore it.

  • Hehe. K. I just annoys me when people bring up other stuff instead of the vid. It REALLY bothers me. But thnx! (P.S. Luv ur Profile name)

  • Best song ever!, just heard it today, <3s

  • love this song <3

  • Please! I'm on my knees! Don't take me!! Not from my love! Please! I'm begging you! Don't take me! I'm worn down I won't give up! I used to be strong. I'm so very weak. Good bye. I love you Caleb...

  • Please can you people just stop trying to correct eachother? This kind of conversation is very personal and I think now you are just starting to come here to argue so I'm gonna comment approve now.

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24 Suicide, in my opinion, is something that someone can only have a balenced argument for if they have been that low themselves. i completly agree with what you are saying, about how it can never be erased. It can not only destroy your life, but the lives of people around you. this song makes me remember how low i once was, and listen to it when i'm down. but, if you're considering ending everything, then please consider what you're missing out on, and other people's reactions.

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24, That was me. I know suicide isn't the answer. What I'm trying to say is that, when you're in that state of mind, you're not really thinking about anyone, not even yourself. You're just thinking you want out, and you want out now. I used to be suicidal. I cut my arms. It's been a year since I've cut, and my scars are finally disappearing to strangers. No one asks me why they're there anymore. & I never did it for attention. That was far from what I was trying to do.

  • im pretty sure this song was written about her sister who died age three when amy was still a child, it makes sence.

    and stop having a pity party, watching you fools fight for the title of 'im the most depressed' is embaressing.

    In modern society you could do so much good, suicide is weak. If you kill yourself for whatever the pathetic reason you will be no more loved then when youre heart was beating

  • @RecycledSmiles, I don't think it's your right to tell someone that whatever they're going through is pathetic all because they want to take their lives. You apparently don't know what it feels like to be in a deep place, and feel like you can never get out. People who feel lost, they don't need people like you telling them that w/e they're going through is pathetic. U're a pathetic human being who doesn't know their pain. Please keep ur opinions to yourself if u're going to be ignorant abt it.

  • toogoodtobetrue89

    Dont you dare tell me i dont know about pain

    i was bought up neglected in an abandoned schoolhous & had to raise my brother whilst mum got high and screwed her clients infront of me. when she OD's and i tried 2 call for help i hadnt been outside for so long i forgot where i lived

    &when i finaly got out of all that crap they seperated me from the child i raised!

    dont you f*cking fdare call me ignorant u biased fool

    suicide is a 'f*ck U" 2 any1 who evr lovd or cared about u

  • @RecycledSmiles i am soo srry :( i hope thongs are getting better. and they will i swear!

  • @RecycledSmiles i am soo srry :( i hope thongs are getting better. and they will i promise!

  • @toogoodtobetrue89 I know what it's like to be in a deep place, but I never thought about suicide, because suicide is weak. I was able to pull meself out of the gutter and to the other people who can, kudos to them. To those who can't, boo fricken who, go cry yourself a river, build a bridge, and jump off it. Maybe by the time they're done, they'll realize how stupid and pitiful they're being.

  • @BrokenHeartedAngel11 kudos to that man well said

  • @BrokenHeartedAngel11 kudos to that man well said

  • @RecycledSmiles, I just said that I didn't think you were right to tell someone whatever they are going through is pathetic. I don't know you, or your life, so I don't know your past. If that's the case, you'd be more understandable about someone's situation rather than judging, and belittling someone's troubles and struggles. Yes, you went through something LIKE everyone else does. But your struggles are no different than anyone else's. The pain is different of course, but in general speaking.

  • I understand what its like 2 want to die, u get this feeling in ur chest so vicious as ure mind rakes over every regret and bad feeling u ever felt and it hurts so bad u could stab yourself just 2 get rid of it.Yes u want 2 die, just tear urself apart & start fresh but what about the few people that love you? The friend that finds the body? the parent that has 2 claim the corpse? Anyone whos willing to hurt the people they care about like that dosent deserve 2 live in the first place

  • @toogoodtobetrue89 i agree. and by saying that it is pathetic is no help at all!!

  • @RecycledSmiles agreed. This is kind of dumb, this little "pity party" as you called it, is just embarassing.

  • @BrokenHeartedAngel11 u know what? Amy Lee's sister died when she was only 6 yeasrs old.. and her sister was 3

    respect Amy lee.

  • @RecycledSmiles u know it helps to tell others about your pain.

  • this song is good but it brings back haunting memories x/

  • i cried when i herd this song its sooo sad!!

    i herd she made it for her sister's death or because of it. idk there are a lot of rumors about it. but thos were the most common i herd.

    i love this song!!!

  • i was emo. it's a stage in life.

    make the most of what you did wrong.

    made a mistake? learn from it.

    think something's your fault? do something good to make yourself feel better.

    think no one understands? then FIND someone.

    we were given life. live it. and make the most of it.

    smile. coz' every 60 seconds you spend sad is a minute of happiness you will never get back.

    and dont be afraid to cry. we were born with tearducts--use them.

    advice from a 12 year old girl. :3

  • @clarclar08 thx for the inspriation although i slightly dissagree thank you :)

  • I am on suicide risk My parents beat me and dont care i cut

  • @mudermissed, please don't listen to any of these fools on this page. I used to cut back in 2008. I was depressed most of my pre-teens and teenage years. It's not a pretty place to be. I may not feel your pain, b/c I'm not u, but I understand if anything. I'm here if u ever need someone to talk to, cause sometimes, thats just enough. I know I dont know u, and I dont really care that I dont. Im more than happy to be there for someone who is struggling. Unlike u people.

    THIS WORLD MAKES ME SICK.

  • @toogoodtobetrue89 i knopw people seem soo heartless.

  • a really good friend of mine, wen we were 12 at the time, and her dad would constantly beat her, one time wen i was over there he walked up and took her to the other room,i heard screaming and gunfire. he shot her, then himself. i could have stopped it its my fault shes dead,

  • Suicide is a sin and you can never go back once you did it.

    It would be the biggest mistake of your life. You would miss out on a lot of good stuff, like falling in love, starting a family..

    Life isnt fair, but it is what you make of it.

    I swear if People keep talking about suicide because of this song I will delete it.

    Suicide is not youre way of being free.

    Talk to people. Dont bottle things up. I made that mistake.

  • thanks for the advice. i'll be sure to put it in action

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24

    exactally. i mean, ya i'm emo, nd i say stuff like i wanna kill myself or shoot myself nd stuff, but i'd nvr do it cuz thn i think of my friends nd family nd all the things i'd miss out on if i did tht. if n e of u hve n e suicidal thoughts, just think of ur friends nd family nd kno tht there r ppl out there who care about u nd love u.

    sry bout the txt language, btw ^^;

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24

    yeah thats true. ppl should grow up. no one wants to here ppl wine about how there life sux. ITS YOUTUBE not F*ck my life!!!. or some suicide hot-line. u comment on the video not about ur life and how sorry you feel.

    p.s. im not trying to be mean just stating facts about what everyone knows

  • i completely agree

  • @spiddamunkky shut the fuck up this aint fact-tube

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24

    I think you're 100% correct here. One of my friends, her mum's old best mate tried killing herself, but luckily her parents saved her, and then later on in life she regretted even trying it. So XxEmoxGirlxX24 has a valid point in this comment.

    <3

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24 need to soothe somehow lots of pain babe but is not a way out shoot in the head it won`t fix anything just will carry out more problems life is outthere is challenging i know of it but these songs just brings down into my mind to find some consolation a desperated soul like mine

  • @XxEmoxGirlxX24 i hope your ok now...

  • and also, i have been having thoughts of suicide. what should i do?

  • think of the people who love you. ESPECIALLY ur parents... Think of how devistated they'd be... Think of every one of your friends and family members...even though you may feel like it's not true, a lot of people love you... I mean i love my best friends boys and girls... But at times i think of suicide, everyone does... That's when you think of everything u'd miss out on...

  • Comment removed

  • this song reminds of a day at summer camp at the elementary school. we were all playing. the bell rang at its usual time, but we never went inside. we all saw it. a car had crashed right next to us. what a tragic sight...

  • this song remindes me of my best friend shelby andrews today still remains in my heart. killed by her parents. i miss her so much. she was my only friend in elementry school. i should have told when she promised me to not tell it's my fault. i know. she was betten to death by her parents i was alone untill the 8th grade. i still regret my choice but i cannot go back.

    jamie

  • @ORMACNOR No, it's not ur fault. Every mind goes to that senario. If you told, her parents would have come right out of jail and beat the crap out of her and you. (Maybe) It's not your fault.

  • I know how you feel. My BEST friend killed herself with me standing right in front of her.

    I could have stopped her, it's all my stupid fault.

  • trust me it wasnt your fault it happens thiers nothing i could do it was horrible but when it gets that far its 2 late

  • but it is...

    :(

  • omg! how they do it?

  • my friend cut herself too deep.

    with me right down stairs

    :(

  • No, Its the wrolds fault for making her lose herself.

  • I know. It was all her boyfriend's fault.

    :/

  • my bestfriend kill hemself i miss hem so much rip emerson i will alway love you

  • This reminds me of my ex  best friend. She has so many thoughts of killing herself she always seemed so happy but on the inside she was dead.. i love her.

  • this song is depressing but good it xplains how life can be lonley with no one to talk to but yourself

  • this is my theme song :3 i love it!

  • my best friend as of right now just killed her self 8/29/09 ): becuz her bf just broke up with herr. ):

  • omg...im so sorry :'( i wouldnt know wat 2 do if i lost my best friend :'( but im so sorry :'( thats so sad :'(

  • im sorry for your loss

  • 2;29 the minute and second is amazing cuz it has marilyn manson

  • sometimes i just want to listen to this song and think about how shitty the world can be!

    great vid, thanks for the upload!

  • one of the best videos I've seen for Evanescence!!!

  • You know what the story behind this song is??

  • Yeah, Amy Lee's sister died at a young age so she wrote this song for her cause she misses her.

  • this makes me cry everytime i hear it :'(

  • why is that a bad comment? >>>>>>>

  • i know

  • wow i love the one where she is holding the rose...gotta love evanescence

  • The video is wow! The pictures are so beautiful and I realy love this song!<3

  • Don`t cry :(

  • I love this so much!

  • i like her voice and she is amazing at the piano but all of her songs sound the same...

  • i love this song so much i listen to it all the time..nice vid..

  • i LOVE this song....i can play it on the piano..so it's fun.....i just think this song is sooo beautiful =)

  • Woah, I like this sooo much, I can't stop watching it...thanks for making great videos like these =P

  • Aww! Thanks :] That means alot

  • thats so awesome i luv evannessance!!!! shes like an oh my god and a holy shit!!! ^-^

  • just amazing...love you pics xD

  • T~T just awsome....

  • First to comment :P yay i love it

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more