Melanie has such poise and stage presence for her young age. She sings from the heart and her voice flows like a fine wine...only getter better with time!
To everyone's saying she needs to loose weight. TRY TO GAIN SOME BRAIN FIRST! It's easier to loose weight, isn't it? so, learn a lesson and SHUT UP! Your comments have only one purpose, emphasize your envy.
37 ppl are haters I don't understand why ppl are such haters, instead of hating why don't you guys congratulate..Super proud of you melanie just remember GOD in everything you do & keep the faith and ignore all these idiots they're just haters.
@7cheeseman7 You need to shut the fuck up. She is perfectly fine the way she is. Why don't you go to one of Adele's songs on YouTube and say this. It's the voice that matters. Whether she looks like Jabba The Hutt or a supermodel is unimportant.
@Ftrmk I appreciate the sincerity and passion over this young lady.. Its an opinion I formed based on what I see here... I never once said she couldn't improve, However, it is my opinion....
Sorry but everytime i watch this, I wanna compare to Charice...lol. I guess once you hear the best, everything else is blah. Charice and Neyo duet was freakin great. And charice's voice so much stronger than melanie's.
Napansin ko lng mostly ng cover songs ni Charice eh un ang kinakanta ni Melanie... talagang gusto nyang tapatan si Charice... Sana mag showdown sila in the future...
Melanie is amazing! I love her! So glad she won! She got sent home, brought back, and came out with the win! Can't wait for her album to drop! :) And too all you fools who are complaining about her looks..... Reality check: She is just as beautiful as her voice!
shes so freaking amature and karaokee I dont understand why she won shes not distinct AT ALL! her voice would get lost with every other contestant I have seen legit youtube covers of people who are way talented.....Leona Lewis is my prime example of what a TRUE exfactor winner is...nature of the beast...she wont sell,, no stage presence, shes not memorable and everyone is forgeting about her as your reading this comment...just keeping it real american exfactor this year = FAIL!
It's not about how people look. It's about what's in their HEARTS. Physical apperance (in terms of beauty) lasts fleetingly... Inner beauty (like Mel has) lasts forever. Maybe YOU need to hit the compassion gym.
Melanie Amaro is amazing, so proud that she won!! This was my favorite performance of the whole season and I knew she would win or there was just no justice in this world lol!!
Jack Vidgen (Singer/Songwriter/Australia's Got Talent 2011 Winner/Caesar's Palace-Standing Ovation) new album "YES I AM" & "FLY!" on iTunes is AVAILABLE NOW! [Songs On Album/LIVE PERFORMANCES & ALBUM AUDIOS on Youtube] - Yes I Am, And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going, Set Fire To The Rain, Who's Lovin' You?, Because You Loved Me, River Deep Mountain High,Think, Hero, Glitter In The Air, I Have Nothing, Fly! and Loving You. Thank you & Have a great day! :)
Jack Vidgen (Singer/Songwriter/Australia's Got Talent 2011 Winner/Caesar's Palace-Standing Ovation) "Silent Night" and "Jesus O What A Wonderful Child"on iTines is AVAILABLE NOW! [LIVE PERFORMANCES & AUDIOS on Youtube] "Rolling In The Deep" at Ceasar's Palace, "True Colours/Colors" and "Halleujah". "HANDSOME AUSSIE, PHENOMENAL & SOULFUL STYLE". Jack Vidgen is "SETTING FIRE TO THE RAIN". Please Pray for Peace on Earth for this Gifted Child Prodigy. Thank you & Have a great day! :)
she has had more standing ovations than any one, all four judges have stood for over and over again because she is Amazing, her voice is simply fantastic and just think she had to teach her self to sing. WOW
Get Ready MELANIE AMARO FANS the call to ACTION is quickly approaching! Don't underestimate the competition - I know it has been a while since a female has won, but don't VOTE for her because she is a woman, vote for her because of what she has DONE on this show - VOTE for her because of how she makes you FEEL - VOTE for her because you believe that she is the BEST - VOTE for her because you are her X FACTOR - The only way that she will take her rightful place AMERICA is if we all VOTE TONIGHT
As we approach the finish line, some will try to convince you why Melanie does not deserve to win. Throughout this competition she has been the most consistent performer, just think what this show would have been like without Melanie. I am sure you got the picture. if you believe like I believe that she is unquestionably the best, then the time has come for us to convince everyone else watching, why she clearly deserves to win. VOTE FOR MELANIE
I WANT ALOT OF RESPONSES!!! WHICH LAST NOTE WAS BETTER THIS ONE ON EARTH SONG OR THE ONE ON FEELING GOOD. I THINK FEELING GOOD WAS BETTER. WHAT DO YOU GUYS THINK??
Several people have commented on her weight. WTH? She is real, with real talent and doesn't need to loose an ounce. Life isn't about anorexics and botox. She is perfect just the way she is. I'll buy her music no matter her size simply for her talent.
I'd LOVE to see Melanie sing besides some real powerhouses like Patti LaBelle, Stevie Nicks, Chaka Khan, Christina Aguilera..Mary J.and watch her hold her own!
I think if her career is handled right....she could be the one to really give Beyonce' a real run for her money! Because there isn't a song made for Beyonce...that Melanie can't sing--yet!
With MJ's kids...right now...they're *coddling* them out of respect...of his fans! They don't want to get it twisted because he still holds power...worldwide..even after his death and with kids his own kids ages..but wait until the powers that be can get his kids *indoctrinated* into Hollywood society...then the gloves come off and you will see what will happen once they are adults and can do what they (really) want to do. I just pray they do not fall into those traps others would set for them..
Diet?! Are you crazy?! She doesn't need any diet! She's perfect the way she is now! Healthy, not sam anorexic girl. Gee, you people! It's her talent, and her beauty from within that really counts, not some bloody-fake (and so on) standarts that popular industry is trying to make. Just look at Adele. She is awsome, she is popular...and she also doesn't need to loose any wight, because she has talent. Yeah, some people must look like freakin' dolls, 'cuz they've got no talent!
I won't be able to watch the show next Wednesday. Please vote for Melanie. She's the only one who can save the show after this week's disaster. If you don't get a busy signal, vote again.
@TheSpiritOfTheWest---Thanks for agreeing with me! As much as I LOVE me some Melanie...I just couldn't stop wincing and being appalled at the sight of her ((*Herman & Lily Munster*)) make up job!
29 dislikes on this video? Oh My God, people are crazy!!! The song and Melanie are amazing, that people don't know anything about music, I feel sorry for them.
Yep! I said the SAME thing! I guarantee you..once he hits 18??? It's gonna be ON and POPPIN..cause then he'll have control over his inheritance and you will really see what a lil bast..he really is! Like, why'd he have on headphones during a talent show if not to drown out and tune himself out to what was going on onstage and around him? Also, notice how folks are zeroing in on Paris and subtly ignoring him...LOL!
i used 2 like melanie before sh revealed her accent ..... now i just feel like sh is kinda fake...like why wasnt sh true about hu she was n th beginning....its like."what else hav u been lying about???...anyways shes an amazing singer and will probably win. oh yeah and GO JOSH!!!
It started off great, had a great middle portion, and then...The last note unfortunately was little out of control for me, she could have done more with it than just yell it out and cut it off abruptly like she was out of breath or something. But she is still so young and her voice will only get more stronger with time. Overall really good performance
ILLUSION CONFUSION Simon"YOU ARE THE BEST GROUP IN THE COMPETITION BY FAR" 2 standing ovations 1st audition NEVER shown along with 2 performances at bootcamp,final straw,other 31 acts perform undisturbed at judges house an edited talking interveiw was put over theirs,THIS WAS PERSONAL Pharrell LOVED them,Paula's face and comment WAS edited in,they must have been a HUGE threat of taking away MILLIONS of fans from whoever some1 else wanted to win-POST 1ST AUDITION xfactor what are u scared of
Melanie is the hands down winner. I will say this again here. Simon sending her home was a set up by show producers to keep interest in the show and also to show that Simon does have some compassion. They knew she was going to wipe out the field. They never had any intentions of sending her home. Think about it. During the Judge's house episodes the show's ratings were dipping. There's no way they could have ever thought of sending her home.
Melanie’s performances: 1. Audition: Listen by Beyonce’ 2. Judges House: Will You Be There by Michael Jackson 3. Top 17: I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston 4. Top 12: Desperado by the Eagles 5. Top 11: Man In The Mirror by Michael Jackson 6. Top 10: Everybody Hurts by REM 7. Top 9: The World’s Greatest by R Kelly 8. Top 7: Earth Song by Michael Jackson She’s nailed every one of these. None of the other contestants can say the same. She is definitely special.
She never once took my interest. I either really liked someone or really disliked someone. I completely forget about her. Nothing special about her voice, or her personality. I'll be so pissed if she wins. 2 of the bests have been voted off. I'm for Rachel now<3
nice rendition, check out on Charice version of this song at Mandalay Bay Las Vegas, Nov 25 2011. You could feel the emotion and soulful version of Charice. Both of them are good but you could feel the difference after listeing to their own version. Peace.
you can tell melanie has been set free! her voice has become so much greater than before. its God! he helped her and she accepted and now, her and God are singing together!!!! I couldnt imagine angels singing better than her. such a GREAT and LOVING and SPIRITUAL voice she has. I can not wait until she wins and I know she will, i will buy her album, I CAN NOT WAIT!!!!!!! GO MELANIE!!!!!!
With out a doubt she has the best vocals of anyone that has been on any singing competition EVER.. Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood were all great until I seen this beautiful woman show off her skills. She is a younger version of Mariah Carey. If she doesn't win then the X Factor should be taken off the air next year. Beautiful WOMAN & VOICE!!!!
She has a very powerful voice. At first I thought, "How could this be the best performance in the entire show?". But then I realized how much strength is needed to sing this song. Well done Melanie <3
Im glad she made it Thursday im happy for Racheal her Marcus chris and Josh i was hoping ASstro was going to make it but i guess not we will miss seeing you Astro you did good Wensday night on Black or White i loved it
This was a song badly edited, you can see her frustration at not being able to sing it fully. The first verse and chorus cuts off weirdly. Not really fair on her. And the fake guitars are terrible in production. All the 'wooooooOOOOooooo's got cut off.
Great singer, hot, and pretty good personality. She has the makings to be a superstar. Where Fantasia was too ignorant and Jennifer Hudson lacked to fan base and Personality, I think Melanie with thrive. Hope she gets great writers....
@jason50681 yes i thought EXACTLY that when I heard her sing this. The backing was very similar to leona's stuff. I don't know why he thinhks we need another leona or celine.
@kungfu1ize thank you people think she is the greatest thing alive shes nothing to be praised but i can see it now people just falling at her feet or throwing rose's like fools
Sowas bitte mal in Deutschland und nicht immer so scheißSänger in DSDS etc!!!!
beanly1986 8 hours ago
Que Talento por Dios!!, es una Niña muy hermosa en todos los sentidos, Dios te <bendiga Melanie
elijadiz 3 days ago
she is one of a kind :)
Firemanfh12351 5 days ago
Melanie has such poise and stage presence for her young age. She sings from the heart and her voice flows like a fine wine...only getter better with time!
urgalSue 5 days ago
If I was one of the other contestants I would have just went home. How do you compete with this?
arnoldis24 6 days ago
Not as god as haley reinharts... <3
NeXtGeNeRaTiOnPrAnKz 1 week ago
a beast with a bad voice
7cheeseman7 2 weeks ago
shes humble nd de fear of God, ofcoz his going to lift u up.
NO DOUBT U WON
nana1yaa2larbi 2 weeks ago
she went to my school Plantation High
flashajk 2 weeks ago
I LOVE HER, she totally deserves my love! =)
BeHappy522 3 weeks ago
To everyone's saying she needs to loose weight. TRY TO GAIN SOME BRAIN FIRST! It's easier to loose weight, isn't it? so, learn a lesson and SHUT UP! Your comments have only one purpose, emphasize your envy.
ventudeca 3 weeks ago
she has a beautiful voice!
ThingsWe 3 weeks ago
37 ppl are haters I don't understand why ppl are such haters, instead of hating why don't you guys congratulate..Super proud of you melanie just remember GOD in everything you do & keep the faith and ignore all these idiots they're just haters.
Sarvannah 3 weeks ago
i love her she is gonnig to be one of my idols and i am going to buy her alubums i love to sin
g
dominique42999 3 weeks ago
she should be a Jenny Craig spokes blob
7cheeseman7 3 weeks ago
@7cheeseman7 You need to shut the fuck up. She is perfectly fine the way she is. Why don't you go to one of Adele's songs on YouTube and say this. It's the voice that matters. Whether she looks like Jabba The Hutt or a supermodel is unimportant.
mindg33k 2 weeks ago in playlist Melanie Amaro! ♥ ♥ ♥ 6
omg...........shes crazy good
EleonoraSchawaller10 3 weeks ago
brava..la presenza scenica la imparera'..stage presence?she will improve that with time like good wine..
83papple 3 weeks ago
I think she's an amazing singer... BUT she has NO stage presence..
TheMschellybaby 3 weeks ago
@TheMschellybaby so what! she'll learn it through practice signing on stage!
Ftrmk 3 weeks ago
@Ftrmk I appreciate the sincerity and passion over this young lady.. Its an opinion I formed based on what I see here... I never once said she couldn't improve, However, it is my opinion....
TheMschellybaby 3 weeks ago
HER ENTRANCE!! >>>
LILLEXYBOO 4 weeks ago
she is good (uranus)
luigibattista10 4 weeks ago
she is GOOD! (england) lol
Cooljes2 4 weeks ago
haley reinhart, please!
brunovtb1 4 weeks ago
Wow, I'm not used to seeing Simon Cowel give standing ovations. That's how you know she is good.
MegaSweetdulce 1 month ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@MegaSweetdulce
He was her mntor, so he MUST stand XD
but she is amazing!!!!
Annush674 1 month ago
2 words i have for this girl, FREAKIN AWESOME!!!!!!
bonesfreak203 1 month ago
@bonesfreak203 ,yes you right and she's so talented person...:))..God Bless and Good luck!
cynjhie 2 days ago
goose bumps !!
gertjong 1 month ago
she is good ! (germany) HAHAHHAHA :) ich liebe siiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiie :D
Depsrain 1 month ago
she is good!(Poland)
PaulinaPoland198705 1 month ago
she is good!(France)
chansondefrance 1 month ago
she is good!(Estonia)
naikluzz 1 month ago
Werk that weave! Haha
EthanCole15 1 month ago
WUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!!!!
JULISSAILDIVO 1 month ago
She reinds me of Raven Symone
funnygirl04 1 month ago
Sorry but everytime i watch this, I wanna compare to Charice...lol. I guess once you hear the best, everything else is blah. Charice and Neyo duet was freakin great. And charice's voice so much stronger than melanie's.
seff503 1 month ago
@seff503 Don't compare with Charice!! This is not a glee show ok?? Fucking with you"""
71Bray71 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WOW! Melanie is totally awesome, she is going to be one of the brightest stars this world has ever seen. Watch and see, you heard it here first
nspgize 1 month ago
I love this arrangement, feels like I'm at a rock concert... at church... And I'm not even religious.
sparbz 1 month ago
this girl is so damn good i almost sent a vote text when the number popped up on this video
WatchingQQ 1 month ago 3
Long live the KING
pers311 1 month ago
Everybody does not have to be a toothpick she has a wonderful figure. You did good Melanie and your very beautiful.
WCUDE83 1 month ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Napansin ko lng mostly ng cover songs ni Charice eh un ang kinakanta ni Melanie... talagang gusto nyang tapatan si Charice... Sana mag showdown sila in the future...
einnaorecul 1 month ago
Amazing!!!
AmorMuse 1 month ago
What's this talk about her losing weight? She looks damn sexy the way she is, and her voice is slammin'!!
Yuliin 2 months ago 37
Melanie is amazing! I love her! So glad she won! She got sent home, brought back, and came out with the win! Can't wait for her album to drop! :) And too all you fools who are complaining about her looks..... Reality check: She is just as beautiful as her voice!
TmHj011 2 months ago
Tyler: The Michael Jackson week was my favorite and i loved melanie's song .
TylerSevilleXD 2 months ago
Meu DEUS Michael deve estar tão feliz por ouvir isso...
TEPAYOU 2 months ago
She has a little appear to Raven Synmone... mmmm
LimanolAdams 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
shes so freaking amature and karaokee I dont understand why she won shes not distinct AT ALL! her voice would get lost with every other contestant I have seen legit youtube covers of people who are way talented.....Leona Lewis is my prime example of what a TRUE exfactor winner is...nature of the beast...she wont sell,, no stage presence, shes not memorable and everyone is forgeting about her as your reading this comment...just keeping it real american exfactor this year = FAIL!
MrTrezo 2 months ago
Comment removed
MrTrezo 2 months ago
she needs to hit the gym
tipsy3T 2 months ago
@tipsy3T
It's not about how people look. It's about what's in their HEARTS. Physical apperance (in terms of beauty) lasts fleetingly... Inner beauty (like Mel has) lasts forever. Maybe YOU need to hit the compassion gym.
FacelessFoxMask 2 months ago
@FacelessFoxMask lol sure thing bro.
tipsy3T 2 months ago
just perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hihihello1111 2 months ago
this totally gave me chills
dudedudedude94 2 months ago
i wish she coulda did the whole entire song!
MandisaAzalee 2 months ago 2
Absolutely sensational!! I voted for her every week! I Can't wait for her album to come out!!
nanaju 2 months ago
Melanie Amaro is amazing, so proud that she won!! This was my favorite performance of the whole season and I knew she would win or there was just no justice in this world lol!!
meffrey702 2 months ago
she is amazing but they changed her .
Montanameanjean 2 months ago
SOOO happy she won!
londonlove1212 2 months ago 74
omg shiverssssss! i love this song and she sang it soo well! love it
launicayoly2 2 months ago 5
Man I wish Michael Jackson was alive to see this! Omg I love her!
MultiDannie123 2 months ago 2
She deserves a standing ovation...
AnandMicheals 2 months ago 2
omg i have goosebumps all over...this girl is amazing.
krisxcouture 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jack Vidgen (Singer/Songwriter/Australia's Got Talent 2011 Winner/Caesar's Palace-Standing Ovation) new album "YES I AM" & "FLY!" on iTunes is AVAILABLE NOW! [Songs On Album/LIVE PERFORMANCES & ALBUM AUDIOS on Youtube] - Yes I Am, And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going, Set Fire To The Rain, Who's Lovin' You?, Because You Loved Me, River Deep Mountain High,Think, Hero, Glitter In The Air, I Have Nothing, Fly! and Loving You. Thank you & Have a great day! :)
AngelofHappiness8 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Jack Vidgen (Singer/Songwriter/Australia's Got Talent 2011 Winner/Caesar's Palace-Standing Ovation) "Silent Night" and "Jesus O What A Wonderful Child"on iTines is AVAILABLE NOW! [LIVE PERFORMANCES & AUDIOS on Youtube] "Rolling In The Deep" at Ceasar's Palace, "True Colours/Colors" and "Halleujah". "HANDSOME AUSSIE, PHENOMENAL & SOULFUL STYLE". Jack Vidgen is "SETTING FIRE TO THE RAIN". Please Pray for Peace on Earth for this Gifted Child Prodigy. Thank you & Have a great day! :)
AngelofHappiness8 2 months ago
YES. You better SANG you mini Mariah!!!
Kbyrd2011 2 months ago
@julian2984042 Haley Reinhart did it on American Idol last year, different style though, both are good
SGWEAVER99 2 months ago
LOVE that background singer at 1:37!! She totally loves singing with Melanie!!
Aton488 2 months ago 2
she has had more standing ovations than any one, all four judges have stood for over and over again because she is Amazing, her voice is simply fantastic and just think she had to teach her self to sing. WOW
taylor26101 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Get Ready MELANIE AMARO FANS the call to ACTION is quickly approaching! Don't underestimate the competition - I know it has been a while since a female has won, but don't VOTE for her because she is a woman, vote for her because of what she has DONE on this show - VOTE for her because of how she makes you FEEL - VOTE for her because you believe that she is the BEST - VOTE for her because you are her X FACTOR - The only way that she will take her rightful place AMERICA is if we all VOTE TONIGHT
nspgize 2 months ago
her voice.........fantastic
ABC9872011 2 months ago
i just cant help it! goosebumps all over me
MrsVickyta19 2 months ago
I thought The Situation was one of backup singers...
MrMetthias 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
As we approach the finish line, some will try to convince you why Melanie does not deserve to win. Throughout this competition she has been the most consistent performer, just think what this show would have been like without Melanie. I am sure you got the picture. if you believe like I believe that she is unquestionably the best, then the time has come for us to convince everyone else watching, why she clearly deserves to win. VOTE FOR MELANIE
nspgize 2 months ago
Love it!
Skinnytop1 2 months ago
I WANT ALOT OF RESPONSES!!! WHICH LAST NOTE WAS BETTER THIS ONE ON EARTH SONG OR THE ONE ON FEELING GOOD. I THINK FEELING GOOD WAS BETTER. WHAT DO YOU GUYS THINK??
ontheair91 2 months ago
@ontheair91 i think feeling good was better 2!
alexanddani87 2 months ago 2
@ontheair91 its a close call but i would say feeling good
alexhugh999 2 months ago
Me = O.O'
stevenutah 2 months ago
Holy Crap.
faithintensity45 2 months ago
Melanie Amaro - Feeling Good - X Factor USA (Semi Final) heres her best yet she just keep getting better, wow amazing amaro
taylor26101 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Very important - a vote for anyone other than Melanie is a vote against her. Vote Melanie til you drop.
Labyrinth1959 2 months ago
incredible! MELANIE ROX!
nathykawano 2 months ago
YAL JERK BAGS BETTER VOTE!!!!!!
TheCreolesoul 2 months ago
waw melanie ...... :o)
1919colorado 2 months ago
Several people have commented on her weight. WTH? She is real, with real talent and doesn't need to loose an ounce. Life isn't about anorexics and botox. She is perfect just the way she is. I'll buy her music no matter her size simply for her talent.
bajaraquel 2 months ago 6
I'd LOVE to see Melanie sing besides some real powerhouses like Patti LaBelle, Stevie Nicks, Chaka Khan, Christina Aguilera..Mary J.and watch her hold her own!
mslegacy01 2 months ago 3
I think if her career is handled right....she could be the one to really give Beyonce' a real run for her money! Because there isn't a song made for Beyonce...that Melanie can't sing--yet!
mslegacy01 2 months ago 2
With MJ's kids...right now...they're *coddling* them out of respect...of his fans! They don't want to get it twisted because he still holds power...worldwide..even after his death and with kids his own kids ages..but wait until the powers that be can get his kids *indoctrinated* into Hollywood society...then the gloves come off and you will see what will happen once they are adults and can do what they (really) want to do. I just pray they do not fall into those traps others would set for them..
mslegacy01 2 months ago
i hope she goes on a diet to get to be a superstar ....
Athorios 2 months ago
@Athorios
Diet?! Are you crazy?! She doesn't need any diet! She's perfect the way she is now! Healthy, not sam anorexic girl. Gee, you people! It's her talent, and her beauty from within that really counts, not some bloody-fake (and so on) standarts that popular industry is trying to make. Just look at Adele. She is awsome, she is popular...and she also doesn't need to loose any wight, because she has talent. Yeah, some people must look like freakin' dolls, 'cuz they've got no talent!
Sytopanaki 2 months ago 147
@Sytopanaki spot on she is perfect just the way she is
carlpow 2 months ago
@Sytopanaki If you weight more than your car, then you should think diet.
lautaset 1 month ago
@lautaset Yeah, but she doesn't, and it's not like all she does is eat and sleep, and nothing else, right?
Sytopanaki 1 month ago
@Sytopanaki So so so true she is Fantastic and what a real woman should look like :) :)
MsJonesy1984 1 month ago
Amazing voice...but I'm with the guy who said this was kind of creepy.
SongbirdGLS 2 months ago
I won't be able to watch the show next Wednesday. Please vote for Melanie. She's the only one who can save the show after this week's disaster. If you don't get a busy signal, vote again.
sunnygrace57 3 months ago
i love her she is the new generation beyonce
MrAgonsalvez 3 months ago
so talented<3
OfficalJLSFan 3 months ago
I will say it. Mike is wishing from the grave he could done this song that good.
MrBiggreedy 3 months ago
it feels like every song she sings is to give hope... I like that
sarazoarleyva 3 months ago 3
She nailed that song even though after Michael it is deadly. My hat to her!
THEBOLDCORSICANFLAME 3 months ago
o my gosh .. tears in my eyes! She did it so beautiful <3
xMICHAELJACKSONJFANx 3 months ago
Haley did this song better
Dylanjrvs 3 months ago
Her accent/diction disappeared? What are you people talking about?
mslegacy01 3 months ago
@mslegacy01 Many singers have this distinction. This year's winner of America's Got Talent has a low speaking voice, but sings like Sinatra.
sunnygrace57 3 months ago
Who did her makeup!?! Ugh....it looks like somebody slapped the living sht out of her with all that damn hideous blush!!!
mslegacy01 3 months ago
@mslegacy01 haha you got that right. im a guy and i find it creepy
TheSpiritOfTheWest 3 months ago
@TheSpiritOfTheWest---Thanks for agreeing with me! As much as I LOVE me some Melanie...I just couldn't stop wincing and being appalled at the sight of her ((*Herman & Lily Munster*)) make up job!
mslegacy01 2 months ago
29 dislikes on this video? Oh My God, people are crazy!!! The song and Melanie are amazing, that people don't know anything about music, I feel sorry for them.
evarph 3 months ago
that prince looks like an arrogant bastard
lloydbanksfan123 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lloydbanksfan123 ---that prince looks like an arrogant bastard
Yep! I said the SAME thing! I guarantee you..once he hits 18??? It's gonna be ON and POPPIN..cause then he'll have control over his inheritance and you will really see what a lil bast..he really is! Like, why'd he have on headphones during a talent show if not to drown out and tune himself out to what was going on onstage and around him? Also, notice how folks are zeroing in on Paris and subtly ignoring him...LOL!
mslegacy01 2 months ago
OMG...I can't get enough of this performance! I love how the backup singers were just as fantastic as Melanie was!!!
awomaninva55 3 months ago
frank mir will knock out big nog
outsidedark 3 months ago
she rocked them again with her two songs, she is truly amazing singer. WOW
taylor26101 3 months ago
i used 2 like melanie before sh revealed her accent ..... now i just feel like sh is kinda fake...like why wasnt sh true about hu she was n th beginning....its like."what else hav u been lying about???...anyways shes an amazing singer and will probably win. oh yeah and GO JOSH!!!
tyree1236 3 months ago
@tyree1236 Didn't you leasing that people didn't understand her accent? You judged too quickly.
evarph 3 months ago
Comment removed
geraldtui 3 months ago
Comment removed
geraldtui 3 months ago
It started off great, had a great middle portion, and then...The last note unfortunately was little out of control for me, she could have done more with it than just yell it out and cut it off abruptly like she was out of breath or something. But she is still so young and her voice will only get more stronger with time. Overall really good performance
dudeonthepiano 3 months ago
@dudeonthepiano and her diction all but disappeared during the shout/sing
mawsley9 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ILLUSION CONFUSION Simon"YOU ARE THE BEST GROUP IN THE COMPETITION BY FAR" 2 standing ovations 1st audition NEVER shown along with 2 performances at bootcamp,final straw,other 31 acts perform undisturbed at judges house an edited talking interveiw was put over theirs,THIS WAS PERSONAL Pharrell LOVED them,Paula's face and comment WAS edited in,they must have been a HUGE threat of taking away MILLIONS of fans from whoever some1 else wanted to win-POST 1ST AUDITION xfactor what are u scared of
use2slam2 3 months ago
Melanie is the hands down winner. I will say this again here. Simon sending her home was a set up by show producers to keep interest in the show and also to show that Simon does have some compassion. They knew she was going to wipe out the field. They never had any intentions of sending her home. Think about it. During the Judge's house episodes the show's ratings were dipping. There's no way they could have ever thought of sending her home.
medicgor 3 months ago
i bet shes gunna win
bonesbaby18 3 months ago
Amazing.
countrygalnd 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
This has been flagged as spam show
Melanie’s performances: 1. Audition: Listen by Beyonce’ 2. Judges House: Will You Be There by Michael Jackson 3. Top 17: I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston 4. Top 12: Desperado by the Eagles 5. Top 11: Man In The Mirror by Michael Jackson 6. Top 10: Everybody Hurts by REM 7. Top 9: The World’s Greatest by R Kelly 8. Top 7: Earth Song by Michael Jackson She’s nailed every one of these. None of the other contestants can say the same. She is definitely special.
Labyrinth1959 3 months ago
1st: Melanie
2nd: Josh
3rd: Rachel
mrstaylorswift9 3 months ago
@mrstaylorswift9 no its 1st melanie 2nd rachel and 3rd chris
Liz063092 3 months ago
My favorite part of this was LA Reid's reaction. Literally lmfao
TheMaineShow1 3 months ago
Melanie 1st place in this competition, and the 2nd place goes to the background singers. Yeah, they're great all the time. Am I wrong? :D
ricardodanielm 3 months ago 63
@ricardodanielm The background singers are better than 75% of the artists who have stepped foot on this show.
MegaRenee07 2 months ago
Backgrownd singers Rocks !
bella5072 3 months ago
I like her voice but she is to predictable # Chris rene to win
90srealmusic 3 months ago
She never once took my interest. I either really liked someone or really disliked someone. I completely forget about her. Nothing special about her voice, or her personality. I'll be so pissed if she wins. 2 of the bests have been voted off. I'm for Rachel now<3
Kfanna66 3 months ago
I love her!! She's the best!!! Melanie gonna win!!!
71Bray71 3 months ago
nice rendition, check out on Charice version of this song at Mandalay Bay Las Vegas, Nov 25 2011. You could feel the emotion and soulful version of Charice. Both of them are good but you could feel the difference after listeing to their own version. Peace.
AWESOMECHARICE 3 months ago
you can tell melanie has been set free! her voice has become so much greater than before. its God! he helped her and she accepted and now, her and God are singing together!!!! I couldnt imagine angels singing better than her. such a GREAT and LOVING and SPIRITUAL voice she has. I can not wait until she wins and I know she will, i will buy her album, I CAN NOT WAIT!!!!!!! GO MELANIE!!!!!!
fallenkracker 3 months ago
I love how much the background singers are into it!!! :)
Godzchild45 3 months ago 2
@Godzchild45 yes they mimed well to the backing track
mawsley9 3 months ago
Melanie (because she good and its my name) and Rachel for the finals!!!!!!!!!
HOP4SMOOTHIES 3 months ago
she will win IMO....
Marianna9351 3 months ago
she my favorite
socccergu123 3 months ago
Of haaayyyell YES! Go girl!
TwitterBug26 3 months ago
Comment removed
TalentadongPinoyAko 3 months ago
LA REID is rude! Every single jugde was stand up but him... GOD Next week Eliminate LA Pleaaaaaaaase...
ricardodanielm 3 months ago
@ricardodanielm simon and LA have not worked well in this show. I would be surprised if simon has him as a judge next year.
dhw314 3 months ago
@ricardodanielm i think he did stand up but sat down first because he was the first to speak out of the judges. he loved her performance.
wundeeg 3 months ago
@wundeeg I guess that's maybe what happened.
ricardodanielm 3 months ago
Good, but Haley Reinhart was way better.
lordbyron59 3 months ago
With out a doubt she has the best vocals of anyone that has been on any singing competition EVER.. Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood were all great until I seen this beautiful woman show off her skills. She is a younger version of Mariah Carey. If she doesn't win then the X Factor should be taken off the air next year. Beautiful WOMAN & VOICE!!!!
MrJUNGLEMAN12 3 months ago 2
WOO HOO GREAT I LOVE HER SINGING THIS SONG.
CatnipCari 3 months ago
L.A fucking cunt only person that didnt stand up
ToKsxxxRush 3 months ago
@ToKsxxxRush lol take it easy
Truther271 3 months ago
She has a very powerful voice. At first I thought, "How could this be the best performance in the entire show?". But then I realized how much strength is needed to sing this song. Well done Melanie <3
iqeekijerk 3 months ago 33
was novemebr 30, 2011 michael jackson week?
3623john 3 months ago
chillllsssssss
hhhaaammmzzz 3 months ago
MAN O MAN she is fantastic..i hope you win.
musiclover47335 3 months ago
Im glad she made it Thursday im happy for Racheal her Marcus chris and Josh i was hoping ASstro was going to make it but i guess not we will miss seeing you Astro you did good Wensday night on Black or White i loved it
Utaudrakjewel 3 months ago
Why are three backing singers singing to a backing track of a full choir? If Mel has to sing live...so should they. :(
ManButterMmm 3 months ago
This was a song badly edited, you can see her frustration at not being able to sing it fully. The first verse and chorus cuts off weirdly. Not really fair on her. And the fake guitars are terrible in production. All the 'wooooooOOOOooooo's got cut off.
ManButterMmm 3 months ago
Great singer, hot, and pretty good personality. She has the makings to be a superstar. Where Fantasia was too ignorant and Jennifer Hudson lacked to fan base and Personality, I think Melanie with thrive. Hope she gets great writers....
DJBrandit 3 months ago
Someone just give her the $5 million prize already and put us out of our suspense. It's obvious she is gonna win. No one else even compares.
FiestyKiki 3 months ago
She has a really great voice, but i'm afraid simon is making her too"Leona Lewis"now
she deserves much more than that...
simon is supposed to "discover" great singers, not reinventing them into somethin' he wants
jason50681 3 months ago
@jason50681 yes i thought EXACTLY that when I heard her sing this. The backing was very similar to leona's stuff. I don't know why he thinhks we need another leona or celine.
dlfunky1 3 months ago
She is being overpraised by those who've become prisoners of the moment ... In reality, she has an OK voice, nothing more.
kungfu1ize 3 months ago
@kungfu1ize thank you people think she is the greatest thing alive shes nothing to be praised but i can see it now people just falling at her feet or throwing rose's like fools
royallove23 3 months ago
@royallove23 How about you and ur little bum buddy stfu... that would be nice. She is talented n yall will deal.
MrPuunk100 3 months ago
KICK ASS! Melanie, now that Drew is gone, I am now rooting for either you or rachel...!
10respect 3 months ago