Ugh. What a botch! This was totally the wrong way to end the Billy & Chuck storyline. IMO, they should've gotten "married", and maybe later, one of them could've had an affair with a woman or something. But not like this. It was so hasty and pulled from under us that anyone who was even slightly interested was made to look like a fool. Shitty, undeveloped writing at its finest!
how i miss this so much! when smackdown and raw were enemies and if you saw raw superstars on smackdown it was an invasion and all hell would break lose and there was drama where it all go?
i remember watching this when i was like 13 and i was really creeped out by the billy and chuck storyline lol very well played by Bischoff though, when he tore his mask out i was like WTF?? lol
@lionslicer9999 billy came back in 2005 then he left again in 2007 to go to tna then chuck came back he was the dude who rode his bike and he was the dude who fighted jamie noble because they both liked michelle mccool but u probaly didnt recongnize him because his hair was a different color but after that he left and no one havent seen him since 2009
@scarface1736 Chuck became part of the FBI stable only to see himself turned into a jobber, so he left wrestling to peruse music and Billy came back as a singles wrestler, but he also turned into a jobber and was released and went to TNA
@lionslicer9999 I wasnt really meaning like up to this point i was kind of meaning like wat happen to them after this cuz i dont remember seeing them again until i saw billy return in 2003
"JUST SAY NO" shows how fucking homophobic the WWE is. They should be ashamed of themselves. They wouldn't chant "JUST SAY NO" if it was a male and female being married. That's why I part HATE the WWE. Homophobic, bigot, pricks. They hate seeing this? But support a drug taking, wife-beater like Stone Cold? Disgusting.
@mowbrad86 Hate to burst your bubble, but Just Say No was chanted during the Lita/Kane Marriage. I'm not saying your argument isn't totally true, but your points are invalid.
@mowbrad86 Man this was 10 years ago. Just because someone doesn't agree with you doesn't mean they're bad people. You can't expect people to just be perfectly okay when gay is a very sensitive subject. Besides, the whole point in this had nothing to do with politics, Bischoff wanted to kill Smackdown and this was the only way. The crowd can chant whatever they want, the storyline wasn't about them.
@SilverSaturnstudios "Just because someone doesn't agree with you doesn't mean they're bad people." Just like the KKK aren't bad people? Just like murders aren't bad people? Just like rapist aren't bad people? Just like paedos aren't bad people? Think before you type. Idiot.
"You can't expect people to just be perfectly okay when gay is a very sensitive subject."
Did Martin Luther King expect people to be "perfectly ok" to a "very sensitive subject"???? NO.
@mowbrad86 Calling me an idiot is not gonna make me accept you. Never did I say rape or murder was okay. I only said that the writers have no control over what the crowd says but they should have a right to say what they want. Racism is horrible but we are not to control someone's beliefs simply because we can. Would you rather people accept you because their afraid of you or because it's out of their heart? Besides this was 10 years ago in WWE, calm down.
This was back when I was so into fucking wrestling!!! I was so shocked when lesmar suplexed big show off the turn buckle am ring broke!! I jumped off my bed in excitement lol I lost interest after WM24 I think it was in FL
Haha, thats John Cena in the bright-ass purple shorts with yellow lines. The last man who ran out with Rey Mysterio and Edge to stop Jamal (RIP) and Rosey from doing further damage to Stephanie McMahon.
These two haft to be the most amazing actors ever on the WWE xD, as always I have been a fan of Monty Sopp. Oh and I love how they say they ain't gay and the whole crowd cheers :P
@RavenCyarm Pay some respect to him... You don't have to write "R.I.P." or something... but don't question why he's wondering just beause you don't miss him...
@KillTheConqueror I never said I don't miss him. >_> And pay some respect? No offense... but the guy did nothing in wrestling or anything that effected me. Is that the purpose of our lives? To go around and pay respects to the dead even if we didn't mark the fuck out everytime they were on TV? If all we did all day was pay respects for the dead, we'd be not long dead dead ourselves.
I know it would be recycling an old storyline, but can you imagine if at Jeff & Karen Jarrett's wedding vow renewal coming up in TNA, the preacher is Kurt Angle in disguise..?
This was one of the best angles of the past decade in WWF/WWE. It was a COMPLETE surprise how Bischoff was the JotP and SmackDown invaded RAW. And naturally, because WWE are idiots, the whole thing was quickly forgotten about.
Wow, a HUGE chunk was edited out. The Godfather had a five-minute speech about how Billy and Chuck would ocassionally use his "services." He said that BG was a ladies man and took several on at a time and the CP usually liked his women "a little thick." LOL.
Thanks for posting this. I enjoyed the Samoan drop to that bitch, Stephanie. i wish you had the footage for Billy and Chuck's entrance to this event...where those women were singing "It's Raining Men." That was awesome. But thank you posting this! Loved seeing this again. When I watch WWE footage from back then, compared to now or later years, it let's me know...it's not me that's changed...wrestling has just gone down the toilet. THX!!!
Wow Cena looks so weird. lol
Luxiebabee 1 week ago
Bishoff...ALWAYS AN OLD FART=)Lol!!!
adampt1984 1 week ago
"If I was gay I probably wouldn't marry chuck" Taz couldn't just hold that in. Classic moment!
EricMW211 2 weeks ago
at the end, was that Edge, Rey Mysterio, and John Cena soon after he debuted?
MrWwefanz123 3 weeks ago
@MrWwefanz123 Yep, that would be correct.
MrWright621 1 week ago
Stephanie is an ugly bitch.
Chonson 3 weeks ago
@Chonson You're high.
MrWright621 1 week ago
3 minutes wait a minute did i just hear you said 3 minutes eric bishoff funny moment
miss him way better than te anonymos gm
alo61997 4 weeks ago
Those two years Smackdown was a freakin fantastic show
smcphee101 1 month ago
I remember this. Freakin' epic moment!
Drewamania 1 month ago
Me and my mom met the Rico,Jamal and Rosey at Waffle House in Roanoke!!
LawtonBoy7 1 month ago
Nice somoa drop there Omaga
DMaddox2010 1 month ago
A standing ovation for coming out that's you're straight... Brilliant
HOOMV 1 month ago 7
crowd erupts when he says they're not gay rofl
LMW87MMA 1 month ago
I LOL'ed so damn hard when i saw cena as prototype
jaydeath1887 2 months ago
Billy looked like he was in front of a firing squad @ 3:06. He sold the whole thing like a champ
CalVersion1 2 months ago
I remember watching this, I would have never guessed that old man was Bischoff. He played it so well.
yuc321 2 months ago
"Wait a minute..did i just hear myself say 3 minutes" Nice haha
Israel5234 2 months ago
Rey Mysterio, Edge and John Cena to the rescue!
JonasBalili 2 months ago
"we're not gay"... everyone cheers
welzen 2 months ago
Comment removed
uiwertysteve67 2 months ago
Holy shit the OLD Michael Cole and Tazz!! miss those guys!
ItsTimeIDisappear09 2 months ago 2
Steph was extremely hot back then btw.
MiamiMike215 3 months ago
My favorite moment in SD history. Me, & my classmates did Bischoffs voice for months.
MiamiMike215 3 months ago
Loved this. Such an awesome swerve with Bisch being the justice of the peace
RamboA17 3 months ago
RICO Lol
n3wvagabond 3 months ago
lol...JOhn Cena in the purple tights. faggot.
napalmman420 3 months ago
Its so funny because I was really shock when that old guy ended up being Bischoff.
napalmman420 3 months ago
This had to be THE GREATEST setup in WWE History!!!
warriorsfan19 3 months ago
In sickness and in hell. LoL
TheChadintheHat1 3 months ago
gotta love that crowd tho !
relaxitzjustkrystal 3 months ago
THREE MINUTE WARNING!! ROTFL
ojones46 3 months ago
Without a doubt one of the greatest payoffs to an angle in WWE history. Nobody saw this coming.
JonasDygd 3 months ago
What the hell is going on
08NATSUKI 3 months ago
i pretty sure 2 big samoans, bischoff, & rico could of handle cena, edge & rey mysterio.. so why they ran off lol @6:53
jamal23607 3 months ago
john cena @7:00
jamal23607 3 months ago
"We're not gay" and everyone went WOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!
Knoh 3 months ago
At 5:33 did the commentator say what the fucking hell
lilwinner98 4 months ago
Ugh. What a botch! This was totally the wrong way to end the Billy & Chuck storyline. IMO, they should've gotten "married", and maybe later, one of them could've had an affair with a woman or something. But not like this. It was so hasty and pulled from under us that anyone who was even slightly interested was made to look like a fool. Shitty, undeveloped writing at its finest!
SwitchbladeKitty 4 months ago
5:40
JR: Aw son of a bitch!
King: You were fooled JR!
Mysticblademastergun 4 months ago
Aye that's john cena, Rey mysterio and Edge that came down to the ring at the end. lol
Thecreator54 4 months ago
Rico looks like Tom Cruise.
mike20956 4 months ago
R.I.P. Jamal/Umaga...so sad he died =/
maclieberman 4 months ago
lol Jamal is Umaga :D
Winning20000 4 months ago
fuck rico
BRBgottaskate 4 months ago
ricos pissed lol
carl96p 4 months ago
rico is rediculous. Lol Billy and Chuck are so secretly together
DeathlySyndrome 4 months ago
rico is rediculous
DeathlySyndrome 4 months ago
Brings back classics memories
UndercoverAHole 4 months ago
UMAGAA!!
chicovill305 4 months ago
Comment removed
SegaGenesis4100 4 months ago
how i miss this so much! when smackdown and raw were enemies and if you saw raw superstars on smackdown it was an invasion and all hell would break lose and there was drama where it all go?
4EVAVIVALARAZA 4 months ago
Bischoff greatest wwe movement ever
mattheweirk777 4 months ago 2
this was entertainment at its best!!!!!!!!!
calvarado1520 4 months ago
nothing like Super Cena trying to get tv time.
TheeMikeBone420 5 months ago
That was a long time a go :( when smack down was better than raw
Lapizista 5 months ago
This is when the competition between the RAW brand and Smackdown brand meant something and was interesting
cafecitojcv 5 months ago
@cafecitojcv Great days in wrestling and I do miss them
ozzietheyid 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stephanie should have fired everyone except for Edge, Rey Mysterio, and John Cena, since they were the only ones to come to her aid.
Knightphall 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stephanie should have fired everyone except for Edge, Rey Mysterio, and John Cena, since they were the only ones to come to her aid.
Knightphall 5 months ago
Stephanie should have fired everyone except for Edge, Rey Mysterio, and John Cena, since they were the only ones to come to her aid.
Knightphall 5 months ago
"Hey we're not gay!!!!!"
blazeboy06 5 months ago
@torchrelwood Um.....if you actually watched the clip you'd see that Eric Bischoff fooled the shit out of everybody. Thus, a great actor.
crumpton4 5 months ago in playlist Fricken Beasty Wrestling Vids
How lame, is this. The fucking guy couldn't even say "hoes". He had to say "good time girls". Fuck this shit and fuck the WWE.
FallingDown80 6 months ago
@FallingDown80 A. This was 2002 so he could've very easily said hoes.
B. Rico's, the guy's, character was gay, and he wasn't a big fan of Godfather and his Hoe Train.
crumpton4 5 months ago in playlist Fricken Beasty Wrestling Vids 14
i remember not reading spoilers that week so when i watched it on thurs and bischoff said 3 mins, i marked so hard. incredible acting
jaznpwnz 6 months ago
I loved how Raw was so hated for invading Smackdown and vice versa!
TheTreWay83 6 months ago
Skip to the better part by pressing 7 on this video!!!
MrMichaelChua 6 months ago
0:30 is that mickie james?
ENSAR36TV 6 months ago
That was a damn good disguise from bischoff
Mpritchard1995 6 months ago
i like how everybody cheers for billy and chuck after they say their not gay
TheKevinwashere 7 months ago
i swear i woulda never guessed that was bischoff lol
bballbeast16 7 months ago in playlist tagist
ok im really sorry i never watched wrestling back at this time who was a heel in this and who was a face??
cutecarrieunderwood 7 months ago
This angle was awesome.
PropheseasOfSaFire 7 months ago 9
You know I have to admit, for a queer guy with incredibly long side burns, Rico was actually really muscular.
nWoFan100 7 months ago
i remember watching this when i was like 13 and i was really creeped out by the billy and chuck storyline lol very well played by Bischoff though, when he tore his mask out i was like WTF?? lol
iamthegame06 7 months ago
was that john cena in purple and yellow outfit? before the whole rapper gimmick thingy?
Slim2Freaky 7 months ago
@Slim2Freaky Yes it was, It was in Minneapolis and he was wearing Viking colours.
Robulas 7 months ago
this was the time when a raw superstar appears on smackdown.. vice versa.. is a big deal.. even for a tag team superstars..
pieeatin1234 7 months ago
disgusting..
krixtaker 7 months ago
im guessing jamal is now umaga?
ishkiller49 7 months ago
@ishkiller49 yes he is, but now he is dead :(
MrJake1300 7 months ago
@ishkiller49 yes he was but he passed away recently... rip UMAGA! (Edward Smith "Eki" Fatu)
mr83 7 months ago
Not being gay = big pops :p Billy says ''Hey we're not gay'' BIG POP lol
wwedude1987 7 months ago
10 years later Rico was right - as openly gay couple, they would have been way more famous by now and made more money
Lius525 7 months ago
LMAO. Steph is like. WTF IS GOING ON HERE?!
wordlife31619 7 months ago 2
Best segment in history of WWE
MrVivekdantas 7 months ago
lol best way to crash a weeding lol.
SHYBOYKUN22 7 months ago
It cuts off so is there extra footage?
Manismi 8 months ago
damn man this was the wwe. When bischoff revealed himself i shit myself
FrostGibbon 8 months ago
this was one of the best story lines they ever did! i had no idea at the time that Bischoff was the minister!
MrManfly 8 months ago 4
damn! stephanie is so hot!
damn! stephanie is so hot!damn! stephanie is so hot!damn! stephanie is so hot!
BROO666 8 months ago 15
@BROO666 Triple H's a lucky bastard! Triple H's a lucky bastard! Triple H's a lucky bastard!
gn0015 7 months ago
damn! stephanie is so hot!
BROO666 8 months ago
damn! stephanie is so hot!
BROO666 8 months ago
From 1:50 onwards rico forces them to do it lol
DewsburyRams4ever 8 months ago
lol John Cena looks like half of what he is now.
nycbobo322 8 months ago
Anybody who liked this is a retard.
Faggots suck.
evanstoler 8 months ago
Eric played that so well
But you can tell its him at times, he has a very distinctive voice
DMaddox2010 8 months ago 4
@lionslicer9999 billy came back in 2005 then he left again in 2007 to go to tna then chuck came back he was the dude who rode his bike and he was the dude who fighted jamie noble because they both liked michelle mccool but u probaly didnt recongnize him because his hair was a different color but after that he left and no one havent seen him since 2009
9thslim 8 months ago
Comment removed
9thslim 8 months ago
Bischoff did a really good job of hiding his voice, I remember this like it was yesterday
NorthWest237 9 months ago
@NorthWest237 as do I. I have a question though, was that Cena in the trunks with the Laker colors on it?
ComaAlpha 8 months ago
@ComaAlpha yup, back when his move set was more than 4
NorthWest237 8 months ago
@ComaAlpha Yup. That was John Cena. I think he had been in the WWE for a few weeks now.
Knightphall 8 months ago
btw... Jamal = Umaga
getodachoppa1 9 months ago
This was the best moment for Bischoff in the WWE by far. Amazing performance and got such a huge reaction.
getodachoppa1 9 months ago 3
Wat happens to billy and chuck after this?
scarface1736 9 months ago
@scarface1736 Chuck became part of the FBI stable only to see himself turned into a jobber, so he left wrestling to peruse music and Billy came back as a singles wrestler, but he also turned into a jobber and was released and went to TNA
lionslicer9999 9 months ago
@lionslicer9999 I wasnt really meaning like up to this point i was kind of meaning like wat happen to them after this cuz i dont remember seeing them again until i saw billy return in 2003
scarface1736 9 months ago
@scarface1736 That litterally was it. They had 1 match the week after this which they lost to APA and like dropped off the face of the earth.
lionslicer9999 9 months ago
@scarface1736 Sorry not APA... Ron Simmons and D-Von
lionslicer9999 9 months ago
lol Why did Jamual and Rosey run? It was juss Rey Mysterio, Edge and John Cena! They were nothing back then!
362Spence 9 months ago
Bischoff revealing himself was the best part of this segment.
JoeCoolFreeman 9 months ago 4
i wish bischoff is the anonymous GM... :(
game4764 9 months ago
@game4764 hes in tna now so its not him
11094DEREK 8 months ago
Rosey & Jamal were awsome (R.I.P Jamal)
Bischoff is a joke who created his own hype & believed it.
86Stooy 9 months ago
HOOOOOOOOOOO train!
mmscott9 9 months ago
imagine if this was bishoffs debut
X360H911 10 months ago 7
Just Say No is Right!
Dont be Queer Drink a Beer!
RealityEscapes101 10 months ago
Comment removed
bibboorton 10 months ago
john cena in them tights ...he needa wear them again :)
ItsNecieNee 10 months ago
billy gunn is so funny .
thanhbites 10 months ago
I wish I lived in america :(
code0Star 10 months ago
Looks nothing like Bischoff. Amazing makeup job.
blackout2189 10 months ago 11
@blackout2189 Not even when he said the magic words "three minutes" did I know it was him until the makeup was removed.
hargosh37 10 months ago
These days you can get sued for doing a scen like this because its an insult to homos, well their an insult to humans
shiney94 10 months ago
"JUST SAY NO" shows how fucking homophobic the WWE is. They should be ashamed of themselves. They wouldn't chant "JUST SAY NO" if it was a male and female being married. That's why I part HATE the WWE. Homophobic, bigot, pricks. They hate seeing this? But support a drug taking, wife-beater like Stone Cold? Disgusting.
mowbrad86 10 months ago 3
@mowbrad86 Hate to burst your bubble, but Just Say No was chanted during the Lita/Kane Marriage. I'm not saying your argument isn't totally true, but your points are invalid.
blackout2189 10 months ago
@blackout2189 - if you say so! If believing your dribble makes you feel better, then more power to you.
mowbrad86 10 months ago
@mowbrad86 Man this was 10 years ago. Just because someone doesn't agree with you doesn't mean they're bad people. You can't expect people to just be perfectly okay when gay is a very sensitive subject. Besides, the whole point in this had nothing to do with politics, Bischoff wanted to kill Smackdown and this was the only way. The crowd can chant whatever they want, the storyline wasn't about them.
SilverSaturnstudios 4 months ago
@SilverSaturnstudios "Just because someone doesn't agree with you doesn't mean they're bad people." Just like the KKK aren't bad people? Just like murders aren't bad people? Just like rapist aren't bad people? Just like paedos aren't bad people? Think before you type. Idiot.
"You can't expect people to just be perfectly okay when gay is a very sensitive subject."
Did Martin Luther King expect people to be "perfectly ok" to a "very sensitive subject"???? NO.
You are showing true ignorance.
mowbrad86 4 months ago
@mowbrad86 Calling me an idiot is not gonna make me accept you. Never did I say rape or murder was okay. I only said that the writers have no control over what the crowd says but they should have a right to say what they want. Racism is horrible but we are not to control someone's beliefs simply because we can. Would you rather people accept you because their afraid of you or because it's out of their heart? Besides this was 10 years ago in WWE, calm down.
SilverSaturnstudios 4 months ago
This was back when I was so into fucking wrestling!!! I was so shocked when lesmar suplexed big show off the turn buckle am ring broke!! I jumped off my bed in excitement lol I lost interest after WM24 I think it was in FL
richard21solava 10 months ago 2
Jamal is Umaga
JESSE75946 11 months ago
RIP Jamal a.k.a Umaga
sharifah143 11 months ago
@sharifah143 Or as William Regal would say, RIP YOUMANGA!
hargosh37 10 months ago 2
you saw cena even back then was a crap!!!
navieedful 11 months ago
@navieedful cena back then was cool
THEFRESHISHERE 9 months ago
Thanks for uploading this.
Lorric101 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
50 Years
16 Months
Or
3 Minutes Wait A Minute Did Just Here Myself 3 Minutes
berownesgirl 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
50 Years
16 Months
Or
3 Minutes Wait A Minute Did Just Here Myself 3 Minutes
berownesgirl 11 months ago
60 Years
15 Months
Or
3 Minutes Wait A Minute Did Just Here Myself 3 Minutes
berownesgirl 11 months ago
Thats very entertaining.. Where did all the drama go WWE?!
Mav88misery 11 months ago 20
@Mav88misery The PG era swallowed it up and spat it out!
xyPERSON 9 months ago
@Mav88misery Agree
abe1289 6 months ago
was this planned? or was it a kayfabe fuckup?
sortman94 1 year ago
Haha, thats John Cena in the bright-ass purple shorts with yellow lines. The last man who ran out with Rey Mysterio and Edge to stop Jamal (RIP) and Rosey from doing further damage to Stephanie McMahon.
Tanat83 1 year ago 3
These two haft to be the most amazing actors ever on the WWE xD, as always I have been a fan of Monty Sopp. Oh and I love how they say they ain't gay and the whole crowd cheers :P
SpikeFancier 1 year ago 2
why is no one saying rip umaga rip
messi265 1 year ago
@messi265 Just because Umaga is in a video, doesn't mean you have to rend it asunder with comments of RIP. >_>
RavenCyarm 1 year ago
@RavenCyarm Pay some respect to him... You don't have to write "R.I.P." or something... but don't question why he's wondering just beause you don't miss him...
KillTheConqueror 1 year ago
@KillTheConqueror I never said I don't miss him. >_> And pay some respect? No offense... but the guy did nothing in wrestling or anything that effected me. Is that the purpose of our lives? To go around and pay respects to the dead even if we didn't mark the fuck out everytime they were on TV? If all we did all day was pay respects for the dead, we'd be not long dead dead ourselves.
RavenCyarm 1 year ago
2002 The Year of Ruthless Aggression Era of World Wrestling Entertainment.
dreg015 1 year ago
cena at 6:55 haha what a loser
matthebrat1228 1 year ago
@darkeradicator1990 lmfao
MrSoloscreationz 1 year ago
This was the biggest pop for Bischoff ever. I can't remember bischoff getting cheers like this before.
MrThetjf 1 year ago 5
I know it would be recycling an old storyline, but can you imagine if at Jeff & Karen Jarrett's wedding vow renewal coming up in TNA, the preacher is Kurt Angle in disguise..?
TroyConvers5000 1 year ago
aHHH i saw JOHN CENA IS PURPLE AND YELLOW TIGHTS!!XD
DonGenerico88 1 year ago
Taz: "Theirs a lot of gay people here" 3:34 LMAOO
DonGenerico88 1 year ago 37
@DonGenerico88 I lost it there...during wrestling lol. Only Tazz or The King.
WisconsinParkour 8 months ago
This was one of Bischoff's best moments, I never knew it was him
Juvy29 1 year ago 2
Fag hag Stephanie!!!
GayUOPXBoy10 1 year ago
Lol check out John Cena wearing purple and yellow back then.
PennydalePalace 1 year ago
This was one of the best angles of the past decade in WWF/WWE. It was a COMPLETE surprise how Bischoff was the JotP and SmackDown invaded RAW. And naturally, because WWE are idiots, the whole thing was quickly forgotten about.
quincyhughes 1 year ago
isn't that the guy from fast and furious haha just kidding.. they do look alike though BG would beat paul walker's ass!
badassindo 1 year ago
Wow, a HUGE chunk was edited out. The Godfather had a five-minute speech about how Billy and Chuck would ocassionally use his "services." He said that BG was a ladies man and took several on at a time and the CP usually liked his women "a little thick." LOL.
NXSeven 1 year ago
Thanks for posting this. I enjoyed the Samoan drop to that bitch, Stephanie. i wish you had the footage for Billy and Chuck's entrance to this event...where those women were singing "It's Raining Men." That was awesome. But thank you posting this! Loved seeing this again. When I watch WWE footage from back then, compared to now or later years, it let's me know...it's not me that's changed...wrestling has just gone down the toilet. THX!!!
thetrophyone 1 year ago
hooooooooooooooo train!
marty34156 1 year ago
funny thing is after this billy andchuckstoped the gay angle and went straight, they instantly loss popularity
igustistwinkle 1 year ago
Billy & Chuck were quite big at one point. WWE had them leave Wrestlemania 18 with the tag team championships, over the hardys, dudleys and APA.
beanniectw 1 year ago
EDGIE!! <3<3
EdgeHead8806 1 year ago
lol at john cenas purple tights
jm42445 1 year ago
Comment removed
JuicyPlayer 1 year ago