Added: 4 years ago
From: Domokon
Views: 213,626
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (345)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 2:35 - 2:52 made me LOVE Roger's voice so much more! Pink Floyd is the best band ever and i think this is one of the most important songs on The Wall.

  • This song,"and whole album is so deep and personal" I love it so much I dont know how I would cope with out it. It is nice to know there are people in the world that feel the same way I do.

  • 6 people are just depressed cus nobody is home.......they should just do us all a favor and end themselves for disliking this video

  • @kaileighsdad86 This song is extremely depressing so that doesn't make much sense...

  • wow......simply amazing. He is a musical genius

  • Brilliant!

  • It doesn't play on mobile or I pad... the shit!? Fix it.

  • makes me want to destroy everything...

  • @PONYBOY430 wait...what?

  • Is this video available to buy anywhere??? Any info would be great....Cheers guys. BeGood.xx

  • pSYDchedelic

  • the music is great, thats really what i think, oh and by the way which one's pink?

  • All of the references are sooo obviously about Syd(Gohills boots, Hendrix perm,stain shirt.etc)...interspliced with Water's own life(calling his wife on the phone)...

  • @Philmod68 There are also some references to Rick Wright (Nicotine stains on my fingers, gotta silver spoon on a chain, got a grand piano to prop up my mortal remains.)

  • i got nickiteen stains on my finger tips and a silverspoon on a chain

  • Gohill Bootssssssssssss...........ts.­.......

  • Gotta pair of Gohills boots...and I got fading roots...........

  • I'm 14 , and i'm smoking my dad's weed and listen to this... ops where am i? o man i think i gonna die , oo fuck , i'm paranoid PRAM PRAM PRAM PANANA PANANA ... 'Finished with my woman 'cause she couldn't help me with my mind' hehe

  • @LSD0Moon wow, you clearly are high.

  • @LSD0Moon Don't reach for the secret too soon!

  • Comment removed

  • i got a stronge urge to fly,

    but i got nowhere to fly to....!

  • how come the crowd sucks in every 1980 wall video ive watched

  • The most creative people in the world

  • EPIC!

  • Fave lyrics and vocals/keyboards!

  • obligatory hendrix perm

  • @Tedericoe pinhole burns on my favorite shirt............

  • on this tour Rick played the keyboards , am I right ?

  • @vladepop This was (I believe don't quote me 100% on this)the last time the four of them (Roger, Rick, Nick and David, Syd was long gone) toured together as a band

  • @Ikki1604 correct. its painful to think about

  • 2:13

    My favorite part

  • 4 people don't really know what is the music

  • LADIES AND GENTLEMANS...

    THE BEST BAND OF SYMPHONIC ROCK IN THE HISTORY...

    ¡ PINK FLOYD !

  • I love this piano introduction, take us to the past, to the 10's!

  • Saw him live last night. Life changing-- even thirty years later. Waters is GOD.

  • all i will say is,...

    i am tearing...

  • MORAISITO - the best...

  • best floyd song.

  • Seeing this tonight.

    Can not fucking wait.

  • This is not lip synced. The way he says "I've got second sight" is different than the album

  • Seein Roger in Chicago on Thursday.  Can't friggin wait!!!!

  • roger writes it best.

  • i love you roger. he may not be the geratest singer but he sings with emotion. not to mention he wrights the greatest songs ever. Ive got a stronge urge to fly but nowhere to fly to. Fucking Genius

  • @xGillyVanillyx

    I dont know what your talking about but hes a amazing singer, and im not just saying that. And yes hes probably one of the best songwriters or all time. The Wall is nothing short of a absolute masterpiece.

  • shit is the perfect word to use.

  • This is just one beautiful song, one of the most underrated songs on a magnificent album.

  • cant wait to see roger do this live on tour, roll on april 9th

  • @timshill hes doin a tour?! april 9th? dood plz give me info

  • lip synching

  • @miamad No,this recording is from live cd,whitch was recorded on other show,not this one in the video.

  • Comment removed

  • I've got 900 channels of shit on the TV to choose from.

  • only 13 channels? i would of went crazy too!

  • It would be perfect if Leonard Cohen sang this song. Then my life would be complete

  • You obviously have never listened to the wall studio vs the live version his voice sounds way better live you are retarded. I get to see this live in November so FUCK YOU FAG

  • @erocks3421 LUCKY! im jealous i hope u enjoy it

  • Miamid or whatever the fuck you spell your name... Your a fuckin idiot... Roger is singing this and it doesn't even come close to the album... Anywho dam Roger waters voice in the 1980's singing this song is one of the greatest things this world has to offer...

  • if I was to sing that song live I think that I couldn't do it without bursting into tears...

  • ITunes says I've listened to The Wall 67 times. Get at me!

  • I always thought Gilmour sang the "Ohh Baby" part...

  • This is my favorite Pink Floyd song. So sad, so deep, almost brings me to tears.

  • @RogerWaters95 I definately agree! one of my faves. About Syd??

  • lip sync-hing? that is the most ridiculous comment ive ever scene on youtube and ive scene alot.. like roger waters is gonna fake it in 1980 or ever for that matter.. come on kid...

  • @VintageJamesT yeah and and floyd fan can tell this is not EXACTLY the same as the audio on the album...like you can tell he is singing it cause it sounds different to him singing it on the album

  • LAme... he was lip synching here... right off the album.

  • Comment removed

  • @miamad No he isnt lip synching mate dont be ridiculous, this is Roger Waters of PINK FLOYD the greatest LIVE band of all time..not the fuckin Backstreet boys, anyway it sounds nothin like the album listen where he says Ive got wild staring eyes and the ooooooooohhh babe bit its completley different you idiot

  • @82chrissyd Nope, you're wrong. The vocals are directly off the album, and he is lip synching. Sorry, but I know this for a fact.

  • @miamad How do u know it for a fact? i agree if u listen u can hear it echoing in the background that might be off the album but he is definatly not miming im not having that for 1 minute its different in the parts i mentioned in my previous comment, listen to it in conjunction you ll see...ps if u know it for a fact prove it? how do know for a fact ? do u know roger or what?

  • @miamad Im not having that mate sorry, its different in the parts i mentioned in my last comment, listen to it in conjunction with the album youll see...and can i just ask how do u know this for a FACT....do u know roger or sumthing

  • @miamad you are so fucking wrong i have listened to the wall dozens of times and i can tell the difference immeadiatley...this is not the audio of the album...doesn't even sound like THAT close you dumb shit listen to the album pay attention to the exact way he says and pronounces the words on the album and the way he sings them here...if you can't hear the difference you need to get your ears checked

  • @miamad Well, obviously you've listened to the album either once or not at all. And I've listened to it at least 10+ times, this song in particular, at least 20. But no, you're probably right, because you must be all powerful or something. P.S. Since you seem quite dumb, and didn't understand, that was sarcasm. And that basically means you are wrong. Very very wrong.

  • @MW2Ultrajman ITunes says I have listened to The Wall 67 times. Get at me...

  • @cturnow Ive listened to it in its entirety, 73 times, It never EVER gets old! I dont know how many times Ive watched the film.

  • @miamad Lol wtf how do you explain how he sings "I've got electric light, and I've got second sight"? That's waaay different from the album.

  • @miamad ur a fuckin retard mate

  • @miamad Why would Roger Waters lip sync? He has talent unlike all these hacks that are called "musicians" these days.

  • @miamad dumbest cunt this is the album 'is there anybody out there' live recording of the wall. listen to that and the wall album and tell me you dont hear the difference.

  • "I've got a wild urge to fly,

    But I've got nowhere to fly to"

    Is it just me, or are those really heartbreaking lyrics

  • Someone asked me recently who is your favorite band. I said, I don,t know, quite a few. Then I realised I had 5 Pink floyd albums in my collection. How can you ignore classic music?

  • I always preferred Water's songs and vocals to Gilmour's. Don't ask me why.

  • Definately best song on the album. One if my favorite songs ever! Roger is a genius. I love how he plays the character when he sings live in front of a huge audience.

  • Can only imagine how spectacular this show is going to be redone by Roger Waters for the 30th anniversary.

  • the biggest dilemma in my life is questioning whether i would rather be that chair, or the microphone.

  • Fucking Genius

  • i love the way roger sing this song after 28 years still the best,,,,,

  • Fucking Awesome, too bad that doesn't happen anymore.

  • I sometimes feel like this guy...just lying around in a somewhat vegtable state...except now I've got 900 channels of shit to chose from.

  • LOL

  • @GCMPJLRMYLIFE

    hahahh. that was a good one

  • probably my favorite song on the album

  • 2:37 of this song is one of my alltime favorite moment in the history of music.. so powerful... sends chills down my spine! amazing and beautiful..

  • Absolutely man! I love to hear Roger in my Hi-Fi, it's magical

  • @VintageJamesT I totally agree. 

  • @VintageJamesT know what sucks about this live version, when he sings all powerful in the background you don't hear the guy say "surprise, surprise, surprise" you hear some chick talking.

  • @LordOFThisWorld19 That's Gomer Pyle on thr TV

  • I,ve got also nikotin stains on my fingers - never the less -great song !

  • favorite song on the album. and the trial.

  • Thats one theatrical concert I wished I've seen.There's a band Pink Void that does an amazing job covering Floyd

  • fucking amazing!!!

  • one of the best songs

  • duuuuuuuudeee Rick fuckin OWNED this performance....

  • Not bad for a bunch of old farts. A lot of bands don't make the transition from studio to live. These guys make it sound almost like a studio version live, with a little more emotion. Nobody does it better.

  • Whaddaya mean, Old Farts? They were in their 30s when they did this.

  • no shit ???????

  • Profunda... amo de paixão!

  • Their music will be in my heart forever... have never been so deeply touched by another.

  • although im a Gilmour fan by nature, I've been listening to alot more Waters -heavy stuff lately...this song stands out to me as one of his best off the wall...it just feels so...honest...it gives me a melancholy feeling...in the best of ways

  • RIP Rick!

  • this has always been one of my if not favourite song on the wall.

    ive got wide starting eyes..

    AND IVE GOT A STRONG URGE TO FLY

    but ive got nowhere to fly to, fly to, fly to.

    no band will ever equal floyd's genius

  • I liked "13 channels of shit on the T.V to choose from." That's genius.

  • The vocal performance of Waters on The Wall was majestic.

  • He used to be really good. I thought his 'performance' on Wish You Were Here for Live 8 was shameful. 'Yeah I'm Roger Waters, I think I'll just speak the words, I'm too successful to slum it with melody these days'

  • @crispypanda he's actually very deaf nowadays, that's why his singing has suffered so much. we all know he was incredibly egotistical, but his recent performances are due to his health, not his ego.

  • underrated song, definitely one of my favorite of the wall. i don't see this one mentioned as much

  • You're right.

  • immense!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • R.I.P Rick

    forever to be missed...

    he always shined in this song

  • Thats Bob ezrin on piano not rick

  • Metric has a pretty solid cover of this song

  • "I got 13 channels of shit on the tv to choose from"- great line. nowadays it is 800 channels of shit

  • @kidjon My thoughts exactly. TV has always sucked, except there's just a wider selection now.

  • @kidjon people aren't there for eachother anymore ... so sad

  • 2:36! oooooooh babe!

  • roger is so great!!!!

  • 2:36 i didnt know that was Roger, i thought that was Gilmour

  • magic, best song ever...

  • Semplicemente Perfetta!!

  • Comment removed

  • ooooooooooo babe when i pick up the phone there still nobody home

  • the greatest song on The Wall

  • No, The Trial is the best.

  • Comment removed

  • Such a great song, man. Such an AMAZING band...

  • i like the part from 0:00 to 3:16

  • Me too

  • @soccerdank21 That's a pretty good part.

  • @soccerdank21 I like part -Master of Ceremonies part 1- to -Outside the Wall-

  • @soccerdank21

    me too!

  • water's and gilmour were great togeher........rick too

  • technically they weren't so "Great" together, but I see what you're trying to say.

  • I've got 13 channels of Shit on the t.v to choose from

  • mass dosing !!!!!

  • That piano line is wonderful!

  • this is my favorite song from The Wall

  • Absolutley, one of the most beautiful lyrics written by Waters

  • his voice is hypnotic..freakin brilliant.

  • agreed, his voice was really something great. its a shame he has lost most of his voice in the last few years.

  • Very cold feeling. That's why I like it so much

  • i envy water's voice more than gilmour

  • Roger sings with so much emotion it adds a great effect to an already great song.

  • i'm in a very wall mood... i'm on the inside shouting out.

  • oh........ so beautiful........ *cries* Now I know what song to recommend to my guitar teacher. I don't play the piano unfortunately.

  • Roger said he wrote it about the people he knew

  • i had never in my life, by just listening to a song, felt the way i felt when i first listened to this song... deep, touching, just perfect.. this is a lot more than just any other type of music.. simply amazing... because of masterpieces like this, that cling its way onto the listener's soul, is that PinkFloyd's music will forever live on..

  • Is This From The Wall Anniversary ?

    I Have The Original Of This Concert In Black And White , But I Haven't Found This One In Colour ?

  • I have it on the Wall The Collection

  • probly my favorite song on the album

  • i got the obligatory hendrix perm. and the inevitable pinhole burns, all down the front of my favorite saturday shirt..

  • its not saturday its satin

  • and not the evil god of the underworld... satin like the material

  • haha

    yeah

    is that from something?

  • More of this is about sid than roger.And it is a very

    sad story..And its TRUE...

  • it's Syd, with Y. Roger said that the song is about all the kinds of people he knew. The lines "I've got nicotine stains on my fingers/ I've got a silver spoon on a chain/ I've got a grand piano to prop up my mortal remains" are apparently about Rick Wright

  • This song is awesome, classic Pink Floyd.

  • this song is so sad ='(

  • 2:36 What a voice ^^

  • This song always gets to me, so sad yet so beautiful

  • This is about him trying to reach his ex. but when he calls, nobodys home.

    ach well, just spark up a dooby, and, chill.

  • haha i like your style, man.

  • i love this tour, it's like a play, executed so well! my favourite concept album of all time