I have to dement what i wrote, i understand Swans are getting together again. So Swans arent that dead! Lucky for us fans i believe, for me for certain..
Estoy de acuerdo con uno de los comentarios. esta cancion es puro arte. es magnifica. es potente, lenta, poderosa, rotunda, dolorosa.. impresionante. en una palabra es SWANS.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song is supposed to be a based on a dream/nightmare M. Gira (who is a boxing fan) had about Oscar De La Hoya's decision to quit boxing and become a professional surfer.
As such, this video montage is wholly inappropriate and a complete (as opposed to incomplete) waste of time.
I think your video is just fine. M Gira uses a lot of archetypal nature metaphors - so I don't see what's so inappropriate here.
Besides, I head Gira say that this track was about an acid trip on the beach, when he was a teenager in California, where he thought he saw himself in the water.
You ever heard of a concept called "Shut Your Damn Pie Hole"?
Secondly, I'm not sure you understand the concept of "Death of the Author". It does not apply to criticism of another's interpretation of a work. It applies to criticism of the work itself.
The funny thing about creativity, is it means something different to everyone. You should know better than anyone, being a Swans fan, that there is no such thing as "inappropriate" creativity.
@greedholymoney - Would it have been more appropriate to have filmed a wilder sea? One with giant waves constantly? That would've been cheesy. He became a surfer, his life is now devoted to the main thing in this video. Often times, you'll see videos where the music backdrops a lot of random images. This image, however, is beautiful & calming. It really allows you to hear the music.
Because it's very bad. It's scattered all over the place. It's a collection of b-sides from White Light from the Mouth of Infinity. That's the way I see it.
I understand that ,I heard it from a few people...but when the years pass some things that are not very indentified can influence our feelings much more...
I was listening to this album 10 years ago and i remember that about 6 month ago I was looking on youtube for Swans and there wasn't any... Thank you so much for posting this.
THANKS...i love...
cananga47 9 months ago
un...wait for it...super
Dorkas12345 1 year ago
I don't believe in God but if I did I'd strongly suspect Gira was involved somehow.
dukeon 1 year ago 4
I love the video and boxing is for troglodytes.
ParisSpleen74 1 year ago
This album MADE me love life. It blows my mind every damn time I listen to it...
GoldenBoySwallowSea 1 year ago 2
poetry, poetry, poetry...
DesolationRow0 2 years ago 2
Excellent job MyStrangeMind... You made me a happy swan this evening...
squirrelike 2 years ago 2
i'm a new swans fan. started listeneing today.. love it
letshurtplanfans 2 years ago 7
You're lucky..they just reformed.
TheFingerbang1 2 years ago 4
They did? so what 'bout Angels Of Light?
And when did that happen? You see - i have problems believing that.
Trgr66 2 years ago 2
Swans are back together. No joke. Go look at Gira's young gods records site.
thenewhumandesign 2 years ago 2
Well, not necessarily back together, but back.
thenewhumandesign 2 years ago 2
Try Angels of Light.
Swans are dead, thats what they say.
Trgr66 2 years ago
I have to dement what i wrote, i understand Swans are getting together again. So Swans arent that dead! Lucky for us fans i believe, for me for certain..
Trgr66 2 years ago 3
Estoy de acuerdo con uno de los comentarios. esta cancion es puro arte. es magnifica. es potente, lenta, poderosa, rotunda, dolorosa.. impresionante. en una palabra es SWANS.
sveikasveta 2 years ago 4
gira for world president !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)))
stiggyh 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is supposed to be a based on a dream/nightmare M. Gira (who is a boxing fan) had about Oscar De La Hoya's decision to quit boxing and become a professional surfer.
As such, this video montage is wholly inappropriate and a complete (as opposed to incomplete) waste of time.
greedholymoney 2 years ago
You ever heard of a concept called 'The Death of the Author'?
This video is about what the song means to the person who MADE the damn thing.
SpawnofHastur 2 years ago
Personally, I'd rather not know that the song was about some stupid boxing nonsense. My imagination had much more intricate designs for it (:
MyStrangeMind 2 years ago 7
I think your video is just fine. M Gira uses a lot of archetypal nature metaphors - so I don't see what's so inappropriate here.
Besides, I head Gira say that this track was about an acid trip on the beach, when he was a teenager in California, where he thought he saw himself in the water.
"We were injecting colors into our open veins"
sex6cult9revolution 1 year ago 2
You ever heard of a concept called "Shut Your Damn Pie Hole"?
Secondly, I'm not sure you understand the concept of "Death of the Author". It does not apply to criticism of another's interpretation of a work. It applies to criticism of the work itself.
greedholymoney 2 years ago
The funny thing about creativity, is it means something different to everyone. You should know better than anyone, being a Swans fan, that there is no such thing as "inappropriate" creativity.
MyStrangeMind 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The Swans is a bunch of egotistical junk created by an egomaniac.
Your video is not creative by my standards. It is far too literal.
greedholymoney 2 years ago
what are your other perversions and obsessions otherwise? stalker?
Casar1973 2 years ago
i like turtles
greedholymoney 2 years ago 6
@greedholymoney hey man, well put.
boxeater406 8 months ago
@greedholymoney - Would it have been more appropriate to have filmed a wilder sea? One with giant waves constantly? That would've been cheesy. He became a surfer, his life is now devoted to the main thing in this video. Often times, you'll see videos where the music backdrops a lot of random images. This image, however, is beautiful & calming. It really allows you to hear the music.
KTandRama 5 months ago
@greedholymoney there is no room for your vanguardism here or anywhere.
nonfictionstory 1 month ago
Comment removed
greedholymoney 2 years ago
this song is more art than music, damn good song!
kawamaha 2 years ago
Love of life is my favorite album ,I dont know why Gira said its the worst...
FedjaSrbija 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
greedholymoney 2 years ago
Because it's very bad. It's scattered all over the place. It's a collection of b-sides from White Light from the Mouth of Infinity. That's the way I see it.
greedholymoney 2 years ago
I understand that ,I heard it from a few people...but when the years pass some things that are not very indentified can influence our feelings much more...
...sorry for bad English ;-)
FedjaSrbija 2 years ago 3
love this shit
kicksex 3 years ago 3
I just heard this one band cover this song, The Sound Of Animals Fighting, I think. It's nice to hear Swans being covered.
sonicjoydivisonswans 3 years ago
i wouldnt really call it a cover. lol. all they do is recite the lyrics as a poem with static noise in the background.
counterfeitG0d 3 years ago
lol
budgallant 2 years ago
This is a song about Jesus.
MyFavouriteBanjo 3 years ago
tHIS song is about LSD
azathoth12 3 years ago
when I was on heroine i thouth he sings about dope:we are injecting colors into our opened veins...
FedjaSrbija 2 years ago
I was listening to this album 10 years ago and i remember that about 6 month ago I was looking on youtube for Swans and there wasn't any... Thank you so much for posting this.
mareleblond98 3 years ago
ha, youtube.
dodecalogue 3 years ago
I have more Swans in my c.d. collection than
any other band.
Burningchromosome 3 years ago 5
Swans were geniuses. Bar none.
lonelyboy03 3 years ago 13
Love of life...an orchestra of rock muscicians, brilliant. a timeless piece of music. awsome.
Putyourknifinme 3 years ago 3
Thanks, you made my day.
ivana312 3 years ago 3
Man thanks for putting Swans up on YT. Hopefully more people learn of Gira's genius through this.
OnTheRazorsEdge 4 years ago 16
Nice work! Love, love, love this song.
swans1997 4 years ago 6
Gods Gift to His Children... the Sun! Thankyou and God Bless You
pamdamodem 4 years ago 4