Do not take the video seriously, and think that the Soviet Union lived alone "zombie", this movie - the show, and there are many "glossed over", for more emotion. (sorry for my english)
SU was better time,at least you knew the rights you gave up in order for a simple life, americans have no clue with all the rights they have given up and their society is full of drugs alcohol murder gangs war bankruptcy corruption disease and filth. If you have never lived in russia during SU times you have no say at all.. and those who have and whine how bad it was...Only reason you had such a bad experience was because you never produced anything of value to the society
You parents are standard grumpy people coming from SU who what ever happens claim that 'it was always better in the past'.
haha no homeless people, believe me there was starving people around; man the economy didnt work because there was missalocation of resources, there wasnt enough of food produced/supplied to the third parties, nepotism and alcoholism was at its highest; no innovations, technologies... Is this what you call good?
Got the last ticket for this movie at the International Film Festival. If I had come 1 minute later... Omg... I would never have got to watch this awesome movie!
@KitKat1199 Chained together, he's a traitor, he betrayed our ranks, he became an enemy, sold out, but we're united and bound with one chain....big brother wathces you stuff...bla-bla-bla..
Very good propaganda, though, this movie, top notch Goebbels syle.
The song reflects social problems of a late stage of development of the USSR. The song text contains a considerable quantity of the aphorisms which have entered into daily dialogue of Russian-speaking audience. In turn in the song text it is possible to meet phrases which very sharply respond on social and ideological problems of late communism.
@VChapaev While the cause was great, it had been taken to an absurd level of absolution. Stilyagi are people and I am sure they have played a role in Russia's history.
some people may say the SU was good in certain ways, and it probably was. but there was also the aspect that this movie treats, you couldn't do whatever you wanted. you could be send to prison just for listening to a certain kind of music or wearing the wrong kind of shoes. maybe you weren't in danger of being killed for money, but instead for your political views. hipsters are really supporting capitalism, and today we're all against that, but today at least we have the freedom of choice.
Communism by Marx is a perfect theoretical idea of just and equal society. However, its impossible to implement it in pracrice because of human factor. Human beings are always greedy and egoistic creatures competing for the better and warmer place under the Sun. Never ever humans will be able to build an equal society, because there always will be smarter, greedier and more cunning persons than others.
That's what we are: greedy and jealous animals, fighting for a better place.
Some people discuss about pluses and minuses of capitalism and communism and say that pluses of communism overweight minuses of communism. I can compare things since I lived in both systems. I say that capitalism is better for human beings, because it suits human's animal instinkts of greed and jelaousity. However communism is better in terms of having an Idea that You are on the first place Human and only then Animal.
Some pros of capitalism may argue that their western values and religion give them morales. However, seeing the real interpretation of these western and "religious" values, I see that westerners are just getting into demagogy. In terms of moral, communism is better. For capitalism there is only one moral: the moral of money. Westerners don't have those feelings of Motherland, real friendship, family and many other positive things that we, easterners possess.
tomleeza i for one have seen what both communism and capitalism have accomplished and people like you are the reason why communism did not succeed. Instead of complaining about the minuses of capitalism and communism it would do you good to remember the justifications for the actions the communist government took. All they wanted was a more united public, one in which ideals of human perseverance could prevail.
Ms Annushka, don't feel sorry. I am an egoist as everyone else in this world, I agree. However, I never forget about my "humanistic" nature as well, since I was brought up in eastern values. I know what is Motherland, friendship, family. I am not blidly egoistic. All I said above is just an attempt to summarize what capitalism, democracy and communism in terms of my perception. Maybe its too narrow or naive, but it is how I see it. Ms Annushka, mne ponravilsa Vash nik :)
"why do you think communism didn't work". I think it didn't work because 90% of the people are selfish bastards and the idea of communism requires human psychology that is non-existent. Please get it straight in your heads- THERE WAS NO COMMUNISM IN RUSSIA. It was a socialist-totalitarian state. Communism was never successfully built.
I have heard other older people say just the opposite and that the number was small and they were prosecuted and in my opinion persecuted for being different. Somebody was smuggling stuff into the USSR and somebody was using it. Just my opinion. I hear the distress in the girl's voice as she feels she is trying to save her country from rebellion. I can relate....до свидания для теперь!
Dude what is your problem? Do you want to have every single thing about your life controlled? How would you like it if the government didn't allow you to read the books you wanted to, listen to the music you wanted to, or even think what you wanted to? We are better than mindless puppets! Or at least we should be! Serioulsly why do you think communism didn't work? One of the reasons was that people realized it was wrong!
Communism wont work because it doesn't allow divination in its formula. PLUS, people building the so called communism were a bit ruthless while enforcing their rules. In reality, there was no communism but a dictatorship.
The thing about the government is rite, but communism is possible, but only after people will be smarter, and when they will stop running for money...
And communism does not stop any body from being them self's, maybe the USSR government did, but not communism, its just against some body being richer then every body else, and against some body being poorer then every body else...
People were executed, sent to siberia, etc. just for not believeing in communism. While capitalism may have it's faults communism takes away our individuality and, in essence, what makes us who we are! Trust me some of my friends are from Russia and they say that while there are bad things the pluses of capitalism outweigh the minuses.
It symbolizes communism and how the one kid breaks away from the majority because he wants to listen to the music he wants, read the book he wants, etc.
I asked my parents, they say that it was a lot better in the SU, then now in Latvia.
You can say any thing about the SU, but back then people could not imagine that their children will do drugs, that people can kill just for money, that they will have to pay for visiting their doctor, heck, my grand mother never closed the front door, and her children went any where they want, with out the thereat of being killed.
there ware no homeless people, now they are so many of them...
You hate Latvia? Thats bad, its not that i say thats it good here, but what i want to say is that the country it self is not responsible for being bad for living. The government, thats who is responsible for what is in Latvia, its a shame that people started to hate their country, and not the government, who are the real criminals that are responsible for all this...
@Vomittunen - U mean in Latvia? I am not there. I immigrated with my parents when I was 11. 12 years later, not even a hint of sadness or want to come back, not even for a visit. I hate this country.
@ComradPaco Seriously!? There were no homeless people? Are you kidding me?
It might have been good for people who were "good communists", but most people just dealt with it because couldn't even imagine something else. It might've been "better" then, but with one very important thing missing, freedom.
There was a lot of crime, but no one talked about it, the newspapers were not allowed to print anything bad.
I don't know where you live, but I don't need to pay for medical care.
@ComradPaco ...and there was also KGB, prosecution, deportation, a breach of almost every known human right, censorship, propaganda, shortage of everything, forced russification...
@ComradPaco I'm sorry but i can not leave this unanswered because I am latvian. 1. In SU were less murders because goverment murdered everyone who even thought of doing something wrong or against interests of party.
2. About 80% of people in jails over here are people who were brought in here from Russia and other countries for labor in SU time and their children.
3. SU tried to kill almost all local intelligent people.
I'm not saying Latvia is perfect, but you are trying to make SU look perfect
@ComradPaco sorry but I can agree with you, I'm from Poland and I would never say that life in SU was better, people back them also did drugs but they were not that easily available, people were killed for no reason or taken to prison because they said something wrong about Stalin, you couldn't tell who's your friend and who's not. Some forget about it and they're glorifying SU but trust me, life back then was not better at all.
@ComradPaco I completely agree with you, my parents are saying the same, and not just mine, Yea i agree that a lot of things were not good in SU, but overall life was better, there was no hunger, greed, envy all these cruelty and dirt.
Today its a trend to say there was nothing good in Soviet Union, but beats me its a BIG LIE!!! Education, healthcare, livings standards, jobs, everything was there. look at the EU structure and compare it to the SU structure its basically the same
@ComradPaco In SU also were no disabled people (guess why!). End of this clip shows the best was was important in those times. You may say that we're now in deep shit, but it is an absurd to say that SU was something good. No hunger and no greed? 7 million Ukrainians starved to death because SU decided to export grain from Ukraine. Living standards? Like drinking vodka, standing in lines to get some food and no freedom of say? Why the crime rate is so high in Russia now - because of education?
what the hell do you know of Russia's Soviet history?
Ask your parents, people were thrown out of komsomol for the so called "bowing before the west culture", their parents thrown out of work, blacklisted.
And before you call someone degenerate and scum - maybe you should take a look at what you are defending.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
how the hell did u find that to be a hilarious song? that is history our ancestors lived in that time i was scared that that actually happened and peple did go to the jail for nothing. I mean this is history only less than half of century ago so what did u find hilarious about it it is beyond me. can you explain please.
if u havent noticed throughout the entire movie they were trying to emphasize how stupid the government was back then and they were kinda making of it.
russia movie was great always. Soviet films are perfect. the problem is that the are not for fun, but for soul. they have not the same with holliwood movies
Do not take the video seriously, and think that the Soviet Union lived alone "zombie", this movie - the show, and there are many "glossed over", for more emotion. (sorry for my english)
zipmantube 11 hours ago
Comment removed
sandragardner1 4 days ago
A bit like Jennifer Lopez
Arni7957 1 week ago
@Arni7957
I noticed the resemblance, too.
sandragardner1 4 days ago
SU was better time,at least you knew the rights you gave up in order for a simple life, americans have no clue with all the rights they have given up and their society is full of drugs alcohol murder gangs war bankruptcy corruption disease and filth. If you have never lived in russia during SU times you have no say at all.. and those who have and whine how bad it was...Only reason you had such a bad experience was because you never produced anything of value to the society
KKCCYYCC 1 week ago
based off a pretty famous russian song.
cloxwork 2 months ago
@cloxwork what song
Rixarawr 1 month ago
ma moc
Aganastarn 3 months ago
Comment removed
Trillios 3 months ago
You parents are standard grumpy people coming from SU who what ever happens claim that 'it was always better in the past'.
haha no homeless people, believe me there was starving people around; man the economy didnt work because there was missalocation of resources, there wasnt enough of food produced/supplied to the third parties, nepotism and alcoholism was at its highest; no innovations, technologies... Is this what you call good?
kfxowner 4 months ago
@kfxowner well there was also a lack of resources in general, Russia still got the alcoholism
Trillios 3 months ago
This movie did not get near enough attention.
Athenator 9 months ago
The best song from this movie . This song show situation of USSR in 50´s.
xyroncz 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Do you have that song in mp3 format (just audio)? If you do, can you please send me??? My adress is: tanya666999@hotmail.com Thank you. :-)
tanya666999 1 year ago
Got the last ticket for this movie at the International Film Festival. If I had come 1 minute later... Omg... I would never have got to watch this awesome movie!
AgOkami 1 year ago
I wish I could understand russian, then I'd be able to watch this movie without subtitles.
VieRenChan 1 year ago
could anyone translate what theyre singing?
KitKat1199 1 year ago
@KitKat1199 Chained together, he's a traitor, he betrayed our ranks, he became an enemy, sold out, but we're united and bound with one chain....big brother wathces you stuff...bla-bla-bla..
Very good propaganda, though, this movie, top notch Goebbels syle.
IvanKolosnik 1 year ago
@KitKat1199 just type totalitarian rock stilyagi and you'll see translation (also third clip from the top on your left)
IvanKolosnik 1 year ago
@IvanKolosnik thx for your answer!!
KitKat1199 1 year ago
@KitKat1199 No problem -))
There's even the whole movie on youtube - Stiliagi (with subtitles)
IvanKolosnik 1 year ago
@KitKat1199
"Held down by one chain"
The song reflects social problems of a late stage of development of the USSR. The song text contains a considerable quantity of the aphorisms which have entered into daily dialogue of Russian-speaking audience. In turn in the song text it is possible to meet phrases which very sharply respond on social and ideological problems of late communism.
HHHPPP8 1 year ago
WOW! i fee in love...;)
Ha5ior 1 year ago
@VChapaev While the cause was great, it had been taken to an absurd level of absolution. Stilyagi are people and I am sure they have played a role in Russia's history.
dima1978 1 year ago
Poor guy, he was sung out from school:D:D:D
csizsikpizsik 1 year ago
story of life, priceless
CZpoli 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
powerful!!!
ntimdb 1 year ago
My Grandfather was called a "Stilyaga" because he dressed stylish. :D
Daniel7860 1 year ago
nice russian lady. and only these
rembrandt9000 1 year ago
HE SHOULD HAVE GONE WITH KATYA!!!!
don127quixote 1 year ago
some people may say the SU was good in certain ways, and it probably was. but there was also the aspect that this movie treats, you couldn't do whatever you wanted. you could be send to prison just for listening to a certain kind of music or wearing the wrong kind of shoes. maybe you weren't in danger of being killed for money, but instead for your political views. hipsters are really supporting capitalism, and today we're all against that, but today at least we have the freedom of choice.
MissMeshuggener 1 year ago 2
cool )
BestFriend4Me 1 year ago
Yah it was unsecsuful in Russia. Peoples undestood deifference...
But USA is like this moovie and they have no knowlege about fredom.
Pashok2002 2 years ago 5
Communism by Marx is a perfect theoretical idea of just and equal society. However, its impossible to implement it in pracrice because of human factor. Human beings are always greedy and egoistic creatures competing for the better and warmer place under the Sun. Never ever humans will be able to build an equal society, because there always will be smarter, greedier and more cunning persons than others.
That's what we are: greedy and jealous animals, fighting for a better place.
tomleeza 2 years ago 2
I really hate capitalism, but seems like that it is the only best idea that can suit our nature of parasites.
tomleeza 2 years ago 2
Some people discuss about pluses and minuses of capitalism and communism and say that pluses of communism overweight minuses of communism. I can compare things since I lived in both systems. I say that capitalism is better for human beings, because it suits human's animal instinkts of greed and jelaousity. However communism is better in terms of having an Idea that You are on the first place Human and only then Animal.
tomleeza 2 years ago 2
Some pros of capitalism may argue that their western values and religion give them morales. However, seeing the real interpretation of these western and "religious" values, I see that westerners are just getting into demagogy. In terms of moral, communism is better. For capitalism there is only one moral: the moral of money. Westerners don't have those feelings of Motherland, real friendship, family and many other positive things that we, easterners possess.
tomleeza 2 years ago
tomleeza i for one have seen what both communism and capitalism have accomplished and people like you are the reason why communism did not succeed. Instead of complaining about the minuses of capitalism and communism it would do you good to remember the justifications for the actions the communist government took. All they wanted was a more united public, one in which ideals of human perseverance could prevail.
AlexKiric 2 years ago
Напиши на русском что ты имел ввиду - я не понял то что ты написал :)
tomleeza 2 years ago
@tomleeza Amerika angliiskii perevod na russkii yazyk, putayut posle perevoda. lol
Not all confuse translated regional dialects with the main languages used. lol
Still, nice feedback on your current/late? discussion. ~Hânh
Catsfaith 1 year ago
It's selfishness that keeps mankind alive.
stumpy457 2 years ago
Completely agree. Mankind in terms of animal side of our nature. However, the human side of our nature should also be very improtant.
tomleeza 2 years ago
Feel sorryYou really thinkssoabout urself Tomleeza...
MsAnnushka85 2 years ago
Ms Annushka, don't feel sorry. I am an egoist as everyone else in this world, I agree. However, I never forget about my "humanistic" nature as well, since I was brought up in eastern values. I know what is Motherland, friendship, family. I am not blidly egoistic. All I said above is just an attempt to summarize what capitalism, democracy and communism in terms of my perception. Maybe its too narrow or naive, but it is how I see it. Ms Annushka, mne ponravilsa Vash nik :)
tomleeza 2 years ago 2
It was shown in Warsaw at the Russian Films Festival and I was amazed by this film and I was pushed into my armchair while whatching this scene
*****
lOo0la 2 years ago 9
"why do you think communism didn't work". I think it didn't work because 90% of the people are selfish bastards and the idea of communism requires human psychology that is non-existent. Please get it straight in your heads- THERE WAS NO COMMUNISM IN RUSSIA. It was a socialist-totalitarian state. Communism was never successfully built.
TheBishopSSR 2 years ago
Good words, Im glad some body else here understand this...
ComradPaco 2 years ago
I have heard other older people say just the opposite and that the number was small and they were prosecuted and in my opinion persecuted for being different. Somebody was smuggling stuff into the USSR and somebody was using it. Just my opinion. I hear the distress in the girl's voice as she feels she is trying to save her country from rebellion. I can relate....до свидания для теперь!
JOBRAIL1 2 years ago
Недостроенна, все деньги в москву шли. Остальные все в Жо
dima1978 2 years ago
My mom and mother-in-law say they were stylish like that.
dima1978 2 years ago
Dude what is your problem? Do you want to have every single thing about your life controlled? How would you like it if the government didn't allow you to read the books you wanted to, listen to the music you wanted to, or even think what you wanted to? We are better than mindless puppets! Or at least we should be! Serioulsly why do you think communism didn't work? One of the reasons was that people realized it was wrong!
sonic25799 2 years ago
Communism wont work because it doesn't allow divination in its formula. PLUS, people building the so called communism were a bit ruthless while enforcing their rules. In reality, there was no communism but a dictatorship.
dima1978 2 years ago
The thing about the government is rite, but communism is possible, but only after people will be smarter, and when they will stop running for money...
And communism does not stop any body from being them self's, maybe the USSR government did, but not communism, its just against some body being richer then every body else, and against some body being poorer then every body else...
ComradPaco 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
TheBishopSSR 2 years ago
Ah thanks, and please do not argue about this. Everyone have his own point of view.
killermonkeyye 2 years ago
People were executed, sent to siberia, etc. just for not believeing in communism. While capitalism may have it's faults communism takes away our individuality and, in essence, what makes us who we are! Trust me some of my friends are from Russia and they say that while there are bad things the pluses of capitalism outweigh the minuses.
sonic25799 2 years ago
Can someone tell me the meaning of this song? I dont really understand the lyrics. Or if theres a video with subtitle pls link me.
killermonkeyye 2 years ago
It symbolizes communism and how the one kid breaks away from the majority because he wants to listen to the music he wants, read the book he wants, etc.
sonic25799 2 years ago
I asked my parents, they say that it was a lot better in the SU, then now in Latvia.
You can say any thing about the SU, but back then people could not imagine that their children will do drugs, that people can kill just for money, that they will have to pay for visiting their doctor, heck, my grand mother never closed the front door, and her children went any where they want, with out the thereat of being killed.
there ware no homeless people, now they are so many of them...
ComradPaco 2 years ago 27
I was born in Latvia. There is no country in the world that I hate more then Latvia. Burn in hell, motherland!
ucTepuka 2 years ago
You hate Latvia? Thats bad, its not that i say thats it good here, but what i want to say is that the country it self is not responsible for being bad for living. The government, thats who is responsible for what is in Latvia, its a shame that people started to hate their country, and not the government, who are the real criminals that are responsible for all this...
ComradPaco 2 years ago
Government is what makes a country.
ucTepuka 2 years ago
No, people is what makes the real country! Or you want to say that all of Latvia inhabitants are criminals that rob people from Latvia...
P.S. Sorry that I answered so long
ComradPaco 2 years ago 2
May I ask you what makes you stay there? Just a question, please don't get offended.
Vomittunen 2 years ago
@Vomittunen - U mean in Latvia? I am not there. I immigrated with my parents when I was 11. 12 years later, not even a hint of sadness or want to come back, not even for a visit. I hate this country.
ucTepuka 2 years ago
OK, thank you for reply. What was so bad there?
Vomittunen 2 years ago
@ComradPaco Seriously!? There were no homeless people? Are you kidding me?
It might have been good for people who were "good communists", but most people just dealt with it because couldn't even imagine something else. It might've been "better" then, but with one very important thing missing, freedom.
There was a lot of crime, but no one talked about it, the newspapers were not allowed to print anything bad.
I don't know where you live, but I don't need to pay for medical care.
martake4 1 year ago
@martake4
for what its worth, neither of you have any idea what the fuck you're talking about. but i guess that's what the internet is for.
Kingfunkster 1 year ago
@ComradPaco yeah and people back then were getting killed for no reason
julie101rox 1 year ago
@ComradPaco ...and there was also KGB, prosecution, deportation, a breach of almost every known human right, censorship, propaganda, shortage of everything, forced russification...
I'm sorry, you were saying...?!
4ndr4kn0wz 1 year ago
@ComradPaco i'm sure a lot of ethnic latvians would agree.
angelojacopucci 1 year ago
@ComradPaco I'm sorry but i can not leave this unanswered because I am latvian. 1. In SU were less murders because goverment murdered everyone who even thought of doing something wrong or against interests of party.
2. About 80% of people in jails over here are people who were brought in here from Russia and other countries for labor in SU time and their children.
3. SU tried to kill almost all local intelligent people.
I'm not saying Latvia is perfect, but you are trying to make SU look perfect
kazhaaa 1 year ago
@kazhaaa LIE !
papakiev 6 months ago
@ComradPaco sorry but I can agree with you, I'm from Poland and I would never say that life in SU was better, people back them also did drugs but they were not that easily available, people were killed for no reason or taken to prison because they said something wrong about Stalin, you couldn't tell who's your friend and who's not. Some forget about it and they're glorifying SU but trust me, life back then was not better at all.
DooIII 1 year ago
@ComradPaco I completely agree with you, my parents are saying the same, and not just mine, Yea i agree that a lot of things were not good in SU, but overall life was better, there was no hunger, greed, envy all these cruelty and dirt.
Today its a trend to say there was nothing good in Soviet Union, but beats me its a BIG LIE!!! Education, healthcare, livings standards, jobs, everything was there. look at the EU structure and compare it to the SU structure its basically the same
414bushman 1 year ago
@414bushman Your parents are right.
I can add: inflation 0%, unemployment 0% ....and free education
papakiev 6 months ago
@ComradPaco well your right but then we wouldnt have the freedom we have our life would be decided for us
daredevil19910724 10 months ago
@ComradPaco In SU also were no disabled people (guess why!). End of this clip shows the best was was important in those times. You may say that we're now in deep shit, but it is an absurd to say that SU was something good. No hunger and no greed? 7 million Ukrainians starved to death because SU decided to export grain from Ukraine. Living standards? Like drinking vodka, standing in lines to get some food and no freedom of say? Why the crime rate is so high in Russia now - because of education?
KlaavsG 10 months ago
@ComradPaco where you're from?
gyvate151 9 months ago
Comment removed
Mandarinukrems 8 months ago
You're 22, kid.
what the hell do you know of Russia's Soviet history?
Ask your parents, people were thrown out of komsomol for the so called "bowing before the west culture", their parents thrown out of work, blacklisted.
And before you call someone degenerate and scum - maybe you should take a look at what you are defending.
serpentu 2 years ago 4
Excellent!!! They captured it perfect!
olgajane 2 years ago 5
Nautilus Pompilus
JeffCreedPeek 2 years ago
And this moment of the film is not hilarious. The leaders of the soviet unon belived in this:"watch?v=-TOG28fDs5I" and i alsow kind'a do ...
ComradPaco 2 years ago 3
The song is awsome! i like it.
ComradPaco 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i don't really like this song.
it scares meD:
litheshadow 2 years ago
Yes =)
I have the mp3, if you want I can send it to you..
DanoontjeePowerrr 2 years ago
what is the text in english??help me ^^
kira790 2 years ago 2
Великий фильм!!!!!Советую всем посмотреть!
Andryxa555 2 years ago 7
Prosto SUper. I film, i osobenno eta pesnia
ArmMermaid 2 years ago 2
luv this song! they made it so dramatic! and the movie is soooooooooo awesome its really hilarious and lively and the music is sweet!
Anna4127 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how the hell did u find that to be a hilarious song? that is history our ancestors lived in that time i was scared that that actually happened and peple did go to the jail for nothing. I mean this is history only less than half of century ago so what did u find hilarious about it it is beyond me. can you explain please.
scobe4life 2 years ago
if u havent noticed throughout the entire movie they were trying to emphasize how stupid the government was back then and they were kinda making of it.
Anna4127 2 years ago 3
THATS WHY ITS SO FUNNY
litheshadow 2 years ago
what is name of this song?
whack666 3 years ago
text after song: He was the Soviet student called Mels (Marx-Engels-Lenin-Stalin).Now-he loves the west. Then, song name:"we bound one chain"
s777allx 3 years ago 2
Vse prosto super. Postanovka, slova, smysl!!!!!!!!!!!!
dusyad 3 years ago 2
Russian cinema is getting better all the time
RNAlovesDNA 3 years ago 7
After all, it's ruins only. :(
Domety 2 years ago
russia movie was great always. Soviet films are perfect. the problem is that the are not for fun, but for soul. they have not the same with holliwood movies
Bu494 2 years ago