Pia Toscano I'll Stand By You -- American Idol Top 24

[supermonkeyy731]

i regret not voting for her, Thia, and Haley last year... i'm definetly going to vote for Jessica Sanchez. (a friend of Thia'a) :D 

[TheBenjiBang]

IIGHT SCOTTY McCreery deserves that he won! iight country guys needed a country guy to win Idol! im happy he did iight! he was just better than everyone else!

[Fantasynr1]

Now I'm watching season 11 but I still thinking about Pia

[lto9192]

just to remind everyone - Pia's season got off to a TERRIBLE start. The first 23 contestants basically got to the live shows and whiffed. Thankfully, Pia knocked it out of the park on this last performance of the first week. IMO, she saved the season in the last twenty seconds of this song.

[Dulibella01]

what are u talking about she is a talend beautiful girl ur just hating.

[chloewebb01]

To put it simply. That performance was unreal

[z24lm]

I think Jessica Sanchez is going to be this years Pia, where she gains front runner status and everyone neglects to vote for her because they assume she's going to get all the votes

[miroslovah]

TALENT WISE-SHE IS THE REAL AMERICAN.IDOL WINNER, NOT THAT FLOP COUNTRY GUY WHO WON.

[TheBenjiBang]

@miroslovah ah fuck off dick

[jermy1341]

you see the females this year? Wuh, Pia blows all of em out the water. Haley from last year did too. AI is not even close talent wise this year.

[saqafat1]

@jermy1341 i dont think thats entirely true....jessica sanchez and elise tonestine are incredible! ....spacyfoil might be right about why pia got voted out! PIA WAS MY FAV FROM THE PREVIOUS SEAON!

[rich1051414]

@saqafat1 If you follow Pia's twitter, you would know that she is pulling for Jessica Sanchez :) Not that I blame her, Jessica is a POWERHOUSE, and more impressively, has insane control. Tonight Jessica was really in a different league from the rest of the girls. Reminded me of the first season with how Kelly Clarkson was in a different league.

[saqafat1]

@rich1051414 wowdidnt know that......havent heard any thing from pia after that one song she released!whats going on with her

[mcmurryalex]

@jermy1341 Hollie > Pia

[female450]

impressive tit job

[ilovehorses2121]

she should have gone farther in the competition

[animeladdict]

YAY PHILIPPINES!!!

[101lemons]

1:36 HOW THE FUCK IS THAT EVEN POSSIBLE

[ullshootureyeout]

should they hav used the wild card on her instead of casey???

[danieldepaula100]

1:36 *---*

[meninaestrela1]

Canta muitoooooooooooooooooo... Amo sua voz !

[CMARIA1990]

She was way better than most of the people that remained after her

[SoccerFanNBD]

better than carrie underwood like thus please

[SlayerX114]

wow.

[nolan329]

gives me goosies (as j-lo would say) every time =D

[lizrosaful]

i was heated when she left!!! <3 she was the best nd im sure she would've won!!

[mystyle200]

72 carrie underwood fans just visited here ^^

[LouisianaCityboi]

Still, STILL, greatest performance on Idol ever.

[JRAmolo]

I thought it was Pia - Haley on the Top 2. But that's OK 'coz they didn't win and if they then they're like Scotty/Lauren's whose career isn't in the top.

[engine22emt]

@crystalflautii a cat being squashed by a bus!

[mystyle200]

she is so amazing :)

[Crystalflautii]

oh my god, compared to Pia, Carrie Undrwood's version of this song sounds like a cat being squashed.

[dani42596]

amazing <3 one of the best voices ever on American Idol!

[mystyle200]

@dani42596 youre definitely right :) she has an angelic voice effortless in every song

[mystyle200]

she is great :)

[mystyle200]

superb :)

[Allwaswell934]

This was one of those things where I think everyone thought she was so awesome they didn't have to vote because it would be taken care of by everyone else.

[Paybacksoon]

Pia being voted off is one of the reasons that I and others don't watch Idol like we used to !

[IlmaLatansa]

71 dislikes? are you guys kidding me?

[Craigeryden]

Shoulda been the American Idol of season 10..

[DJIvanPang]

can she go x factor?

[trumpetzzz]

i miss pia.. :'(

[LammerLee]

Pia vc já é uma Vencedoraa(Pena q Não Ganhou) = , (

[tarpatful]

I can't get over 1:35

[LouisianaCityboi]

Greatest performance on American Idol ever. Simple as that.

[LammerLee]

Pia Toscano s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 ss2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2 s2

[theblondeartist66]

Amazingg...I alwaays thoughht she was gonna win.

[spacyfoil]

Her problem is she is Pretty and girls don't like pretty girls, guys don't vote. Simple.

[brookeharthan01]

@spacyfoil Not true. Haley is beautiful and look how far she got. Its about having a voice thats different.

[gymnastninaa]

@spacyfoil

I have never heard anything so true.

Majority of the winners are the good looking guys that can sing, never the incredibly gorgeous girls that have amazing voices.

[bdubbnm]

@spacyfoil im a guy who vote (Sometimes). but i was voting for haley. sorry pia.

[Italianna99126]

71 people, seriously?? how do you not like this? Are you deaf? Ur probably jealous that you can't sing as good as her. . .

[glennfabian]

While the judges pick on better talents to criticized, Lauren and Scotty’s obviously mediocre performance were unreasonably well-praised. The judges, JLo and Randy turn deaf and blind everytime their favorites perform. Some people just don’t care to lose their basic sense of hearing and vision for money.

[jellosock64]

biggest mistake of 2011 other than rebecca black making a single

[jasonsinanan]

i dont understand ...this is a crime..the best voices did not make it top the top 2...haley reinhart and pia toscan is the best voices i have ever heard...they fit i with the great mariah carey...withney huston... Cristina algularia .and adled...just amazinggggggggggggg

[SuperAsdfghjkl1]

Pia, you are a superstar.

[MidAgeAllisonFan]

Not only is she beautiful she is a very humble person. Come check out everything Pia on PiaFans.net = Home of the Sweet P's. Come celebrate what surely will be a fantastic 2012 for Miss Pia.

[guineaandpolar123]

pffffffftttt how did scotty win?

[izzybug613]

she is one of the best singers i have ever heard. i can not believe that she was voted off...

[jvillar78]

goosebumps at the last part of the song..whew! amazing lady!

[felaipechev]

Pia would do better than Melanie on the X factor

[ItsOnanytime]

@felaipechev Melanie's better range than her haha but she's good too!

[jellysyrup1]

She should've won <3

[rareislebabe]

She's my favorite ever! Very good singer, hot, and beautiful! Perfect!

[RonaldSkerkavich]

INCREDIBLE!



[bradleyy2kaii8]

i wish she was on the xfactor rather than ai, then she would be getting all the credit she deserves and not melanie!

[Fanpire121208]

i think the reason why she didnt go as far as most people, including me, wanted her to go was because she already had such star quality that she wouldn't need a show to make her famous, since she already basically is

[soulsurvivorcrouter]

Is it considered blasphemy that i liked this version more than Carrie's?

[flintybraz]

Pia is amazing. unbelievable performance. but when will u all learn? Jordin will be the LAST girl to ever win Idol. it doesnt matter how good Pia was. My fav was Haley. but the majority of voters are dumb pathetic teenage girls whose lives revolve around Idol. and all they do is vote for the cute boy to win. Chris Allen? Lee DeWyze? SCOTTIE? Really? all u can do is be happy that talent like Haley and Pia and others like them at least can use the show to launch their careers.

[MidAgeAllisonFan]

@flintybraz You are so right about American Idol's voting "system". Even though Pia being voted off in 9TH PLACE has probably been for the best. Any singer not the "cutest boy" has those same teenage girls hating any challenger, including post Idol. AI had better change to a different system if they expect credible results!!!!!

[kathyqz]

Pia is amazing. I hope she'll come out with an album.

[wills2w]

Jennifer Hudson and her are the best singers from all editions of American Idol!! *---*

[crookednub72]

i hardly wanted to watch american idol when she got kicked off...ive watched for 10 years an this was the most disapointing to see her get kicked off!

[danceexoxoo]

look at the like + dislike bar looks like a pencil:)))

[BabyCakess1027]

I still don`t know why she went home.... : ( I loved her !

[luckycharm6541]

how did she not win i love her so much but she will do well i know

[mayapealer]

how didnt she WINNN??????

[louhester]

Amazing.

[meshell86]

boader line opera voice...amazed myself when she didn't make it on idol....but here in america...whatever...in europe/canada/ aussie...world she would have won.////wonderful voice...please sing with ceilon or barbara

[nebrutasen]

Go to: goo.gl\k3U6R and get your own FREE Gears of War 3.

[bballxoxo22]

shoulda won!

[u10ahuskieshockey13]

this is what happens when people just assume that everyones gonna vote for her so they dont vote . ugggh she should have won!

[14heartgirl]

@u10ahuskieshockey13 that was exactly what I was thnking. Everyone assumed that she was going to be voted for so they focused on their other favorite competitiors so that they wouldn't go home. Gotta remember not to the same thing next year or another winner could go home. :/

[kaboey888]

Hey guys this was the season Jordin Sparks won!

Pia should have won

[goldwingdwarrior]

@kaboey888  BZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ wrong answer you don't win the prize

[u10ahuskieshockey13]

@kaboey888 actually its the season when scotty mcreary won .

[chrisdamage83]

@kaboey888 this was just this past season when scotty won

[cheerleaderstar2010]

shes like the best singer in the world!!!!!!!!

[amc7304]

Actually she will be the winner when all is said and done. 3 yrs from now when no one remembers who won season 10 and Pia Toscano has got multiple platinum albums under her belt, then we will all know who the real winner was!!

 :-)

[kenzyny]

amazing!!!! Don't know why she had eliminated the american idol???

[Manners2100]

goosebumps...

[TheFieldy3]

SHE IS FRCKN AMAZINGGG !!! :0

[haileyidaho1]

YOU SHOULD HAVE MADE IT TO THE TOP TWO YOU ARE SO AMAZING GOOD LUCK WITH YOUR CAREER

[ariannaforeverlulu]

70 people who dislike your haters i dare u to go on american idol and show that kind of talent

[puffyheadedfuzzball2]

im here becuz of So Random on Disney Channel lol

[StardollMakeovers13]

Now I'm a crying puddle of goose bumps.

AMAZING.

[srmmarcelo]

good ... Marcelo Brasil

[Northax]

@rrr13rcc Pia Toscano is Italian, Selena is a "Latin" girl, so both basically Mediterranean mixes, both Latin women, no surprise they share physical similarities to a degree - i.e. dark hair, brown eyes, olive skin tone, etc.

Pia is a beautiful woman, I wish to find a woman like her to marry one day. She's family oriented, and she seems to meek and humble, more so than other people I've seen on stage! I love that. :-)

[eminemlover2020]

CARRIE SINGS IT BETTER

[foreverPriscilla]

it's not "screaming" , it's called belting. look it up, son.

[iconicpia13]

@MrEpicSmiles ohh. xD hi caleb. pia is just so amazing idk how anyone could hate on her!

[iconicpia13]

@MrEpicSmiles she is very amazing. I've met her like 8 or 9x she remembered me and she said I'm her number 1 fan :D

[07ladeda]

I STOPED WACHING AI AFTER SHE WAS OFF. WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG . SHE WAS CLEARLY THE BEST.

[LouisDE1]

@07ladeda You are so right ladeda! The only consolation for me would be when Pia Toscano takes on the role of a young Connie Francis in a movie about the legendary singer's life.

[0yannaboo]

@07ladeda me too



[rayrayj888]

i love her and u... down there.. shut up and stop hatin

[1stpKlosr2]

hannabluu = faggot

[hannabluu]

not that special. actually a quite bad singer. and yeah she screamed more than belted.

[2586bryan]

she ruined this songt

[discerdan]

meh..was pretty good,..but screaming at the end is raping the feeling of the song...its meant to be soft and subtle,...almost humble.

[abckoa]

@discerdan Screaming? Where was that at? Obviously you don't know much about music it was called a belted note, that note was a Eb5 and one of the end notes was a G5. Learn your facts. And to answer back to the soft and subtle, that' why she waited almost to the end to belt her notes.

[discerdan]

@abckoa whatever loser,..when you move outta yo mamas basement we can have a grownup conversation. You can not say how the song is supposed to sound ...you lack witted moron....as you did not write it...Chrissie Hynde did,..she also performs the song if you wish to hear what it is SUPPOSED to sound like...who would know better than the person who wrote it? Psuedointellectuals like you are a joke...you dont come across smart or knowing...you come across ass a joke...loser

[RockStarLove211]

How the heck did this woman not win?

[nooneveryimportant]

@RockStarLove211 because there were better, more unique and musically talented contestants .

[KRene922]

@RockStarLove211 i know right i LOVED HER!!!!! nice comment

[carriecrazed]

@RockStarLove211 Well, Simple really..... America did not vote her through. Common sense...

[RockStarLove211]

@carriecrazed No reason to be rude.

[carriecrazed]

@RockStarLove211 Lol. sorry. wasn't trying to be rude. just a smartass remark on my part :)

[nash18able]

@RockStarLove211 Cuz she's worth more than American idol's title

[nightrodspeciallover]

@RockStarLove211 she didnt win? wtf how the heck dose a girl with a voice like this not win that. it would be like carrie underwood not wining it bc carrie has an awsome voice to but she did win.

[TraumaER]

@RockStarLove211 70% of America is obese and ugly and are haters by default

[vanillateakiss]

my favorite performance in AI ever !!!

[M0NT4N4TR3Y]

<3 i love her!

[harforeva123]

@KingxofxRedxLions she is amazing, you know it, the ending is boring? really? lets see you do this.

[KingxofxRedxLions]

not the best version, this is pretty plain and generic compared to The Pretenders.

[morganrachelidol]

LAUREN.PIA.SCOTTY.JAMES.<3 

[harforeva123]

WOW.

[KatharineMcPheeFan7]

My god. <3

[icantbetamedd]

SHE SHOULDVE WONNNNNNN!!!!!!

[RBbulldogs5]

People need to remember that if you don't vote, the person yu want to win wont win... you cant rely on others to vote because they are doing the same thing.

[syrocc]

Haley and Pia were divine. By far the best performers on AI.

[felaipechev]

Pia,Haley and Casey ;)

[rgordon002]

Really, when you watch this performance by Pia Toscano, can you say anything other than WOW!!! She is a superstar folks!!!

[allisandrojhonifer]

she supposed to win. they should change the format. vote is 50% and the judges vote is 50% to prevent this.we lose a very talented singer cuase of the stupid voting

[FluffyMonsterr]

Shes a boring person, that's why she got voted off. She has a single out now that is barely in the charts. She didnt deseve to win. Just my opinion

[tdigirl101]

@FluffyMonsterr its a about singing -____- not about personality

[FluffyMonsterr]

@tdigirl101 Then why is the show called American IDOL the whole point is to have the whole package.

[tdigirl101]

@FluffyMonsterr its about singing not personality

[FluffyMonsterr]

@tdigirl101 If its so about singing, why didn't she win? :|

[tdigirl101]

America is dumb! I can`t belive Haley made it farher than her thats like say there was celebrity idol saying that Rebecca Black made it to the top three and Lea Michelle made it to like the top 8!

[chuggggggy]

@tdigirl101 America is dumb because Haley didn't win

[XdemonX1532]

Well American Idol is corrupted people just vote for the best looking person now The X Factor is alot less corrupted and alot better.

[MrYu2316]

she's good i thought this one will be the winner

[TheHaterz411]

She put Carrie Underwho to shame with this. WOW FLAWLESS

[MyCANDYMONKEY]

Scotty who?

[MrYu2316]

@MyCANDYMONKEY scotty pippen?

[MyCANDYMONKEY]

why did america have to be so boy crazy and not see the AMAZING TALENT that pia and lauren had! It should have been pia and lauren in the finale not scotty

[harforeva123]

578,033? WHY ARE THEY ONLY COUNTING MY VIEWS???

[MyCANDYMONKEY]

@harforeva123 lol laughed at that me 2

[kingofheartsdrake]

you should have won!!!...keep going ...the kid that won was so plain!

[Yozah321]

Whats up with the dislikez peopleZ!!!!

[1997gymnastic]

her and lauren were my absolute favorite!!!!

[ggordy6]

Pia, Pia, Pia!! you are just a blessing. I love you girl!!!

[99024bfp]

i lost my appetite when Pia was eliminated... she should have won the competition...

[toocuteeee]

I just love her to this day.. I don't care what anybody says she should have won hands down..

[Manners2100]

best voice in american idol history..

[MsDominic20]

Pia version of I'll Stand By You is the best version of the song I have ever heard.

[klrfan]

Wow O.O amazing

[suicidecoaster]

i wanna cry. so good.

[johaliee]

she is selena`s growed