Superbe ! Reste gracieuse dans ses aigus ! et la plupart des amateurs lui pardonnent sans doute la petite erreur qu'ils n'ont pas repérée sans la partition.
L'enregistrement est cependant assez médiocre das les aigus.
@123belgian I was thinking the same thing. Lucia is absolutely wonderful, like Kiri. Like so many of these top singers, they bring their own styles. For the singing heart and floating sensation, go for Kiri. Her voice floats along like a balloon in the sky or a bubble in the water. Lucia has unmatched purity, cleanliness and perfection in her delivery. Both wonderful wonderful singers. I love them both.
Voice of pure velvet and beauty to dream of. I make more mistakes in a day than Kiri makes in a whole career. Solti and Levine handle it without blinking. Brava!
Pardon me for being slow (I really don't know)...but could someone tell me what her mistake was? I could see from her face during the 4:35-4:40 part that something's wrong - she had this 'oops' look on her face. But I still haven't figured out what. I'm sort of guessing that she forgot to sing the 2nd C before going off on the melisma?
She just lost few sixteenth notes before the phrase goes high......very well made-up. It didn't really break the construction of this piece. I think that's why they still published it.
Lol I wouldn't have noticed it unless I had the score in front of me! I always love her Mozart interpretations...she seems made for them. I wish I could sing Mozart as well as she does.
@damekirilover -- I love her too, but she made the same mistake TWICE! And both times she beat the orchestra and had to wait for them to catch up to her.
She confused the text in the two measures right before the melisma and then droopped a measure in the run. I'm impressed the orchestra and she kept it together by the next entrance!
She's so wonderful! ... but... 4:35-4:40... oups... ! A real soprano mistake ! Not a hint in her face! hahaha! Sounds like the OBOE made a mistake but NO it's her!
One of the most beautiful arias ever. Dame te Kanawa excells in vocal agility, pureness of voice, intelligence in approaching the piece that easily becomes too ornamental. Te Kanawa has all the discipline and carachter to hold back when bravura tempts in this bravura aria.
Superbe ! Reste gracieuse dans ses aigus ! et la plupart des amateurs lui pardonnent sans doute la petite erreur qu'ils n'ont pas repérée sans la partition.
L'enregistrement est cependant assez médiocre das les aigus.
gercat11 5 months ago
@gercat11
Merci de respecter la correction du texte français : reste gracieuse dans ses aigus ! la plupart de ses amateurs etc.
gercat11 5 months ago
I LOVE KIRI .BUT I THINK THE MAESTRO GOES TO FAST-FOR A MELODY THATS HAVE TO DO DO WITH CALM ,REST SLEEP!!
sikeirosdocarmo 7 months ago
Un timbre qui se prête bien à cet air,mais les aigus ne sont assez légers.
abracadabranque 8 months ago
ok rendition
not very sweet or virtuous
but still very nice
jradetzky 11 months ago
Kiri is Kiri. Wonderful
Alexmeister25 1 year ago
Coincido, hay que escuchar a Lucia Popp, el aria está escrita para ella.
rodhuss 2 years ago
please listen to Lucia Popp for this aria!
123belgian 2 years ago 3
@123belgian I was thinking the same thing. Lucia is absolutely wonderful, like Kiri. Like so many of these top singers, they bring their own styles. For the singing heart and floating sensation, go for Kiri. Her voice floats along like a balloon in the sky or a bubble in the water. Lucia has unmatched purity, cleanliness and perfection in her delivery. Both wonderful wonderful singers. I love them both.
swanningaround 1 year ago
mein gott! this is really painful, one has the feeling that he is going to hit her anytime! poor kiri, she is just perfect so that kept singing...
yomisma77 3 years ago
i don't get all of this analysis - lol - by such standards Dessay or Fleming should not be singing at all ... ok, maybe they shouldn't ...
still, why dissect a TV recording of a live performance to such detail ...?
branko1b 3 years ago
what a pretty voice long live mozart
beethomozart 3 years ago 4
feels rushed.
assclown2k6 3 years ago
WHat a treasure she's for Mozart and R Strauss..
eppurs1muove 3 years ago
i mean, besides stating the obvious, such as her voice, but whole her being and approach.
eppurs1muove 3 years ago
Voice of pure velvet and beauty to dream of. I make more mistakes in a day than Kiri makes in a whole career. Solti and Levine handle it without blinking. Brava!
Glenmed 3 years ago 2
Nice but listen to Lucia Popp!
lagnaha 3 years ago
Absolutely,
Nobody sings this music like Lucia Popp.
Arkadiusz
Timberfell123 3 years ago 2
Yes I agree absolutely
Klassikfan2008 3 years ago
this was my answer to Timberfell123 (see below)
Klassikfan2008 3 years ago
Pardon me for being slow (I really don't know)...but could someone tell me what her mistake was? I could see from her face during the 4:35-4:40 part that something's wrong - she had this 'oops' look on her face. But I still haven't figured out what. I'm sort of guessing that she forgot to sing the 2nd C before going off on the melisma?
musicyh 3 years ago
She just lost few sixteenth notes before the phrase goes high......very well made-up. It didn't really break the construction of this piece. I think that's why they still published it.
dame-KITI-lover
damekirilover 3 years ago
Lol I wouldn't have noticed it unless I had the score in front of me! I always love her Mozart interpretations...she seems made for them. I wish I could sing Mozart as well as she does.
musicyh 3 years ago
@damekirilover -- I love her too, but she made the same mistake TWICE! And both times she beat the orchestra and had to wait for them to catch up to her.
Rosalind80 1 year ago
She confused the text in the two measures right before the melisma and then droopped a measure in the run. I'm impressed the orchestra and she kept it together by the next entrance!
Beseda99 3 years ago
She's so wonderful! ... but... 4:35-4:40... oups... ! A real soprano mistake ! Not a hint in her face! hahaha! Sounds like the OBOE made a mistake but NO it's her!
presto208 3 years ago
Look at her face right at the end, though. She was well aware of her mistake. I guarantee though, that nobody in the audience noticed.
LizN90 3 years ago
Haha yes I know, we can see soprano terror in her eyes!
presto208 3 years ago
She recorded this a few years back in a compilation of Mozart arias...the recording has one fabulous performance after another.
nessie96 3 years ago
I'm always amazed by her interpretation in Mozart's music! What a voice and what a magical atmospere.....so charming....
damekirilover 3 years ago
OMG the voice is just beautiful - so is the opening melody! =D
I absolutely adore this performance!
DeMaulwurfn 4 years ago
wah, beautiful! Mozart!
stevtomato 4 years ago
One of the most beautiful arias ever. Dame te Kanawa excells in vocal agility, pureness of voice, intelligence in approaching the piece that easily becomes too ornamental. Te Kanawa has all the discipline and carachter to hold back when bravura tempts in this bravura aria.
swe50 4 years ago 2
amazing...
SMMHELDENTENOR 4 years ago