@ferrarimike23 SB 36: Brady drove his team 60 yards in 65 seconds with no timeouts to setup a 48 yard field goal(not "extremely" far")
SB 38: Brady drove his team down the field and threw a TD pass to take a 29-22 lead with 2:50 left, then the other team tied it at 29. Brady once again drove his team down the field to set up a 38 yard field goal(extremely far? no, you're an idiot)
Brady put them in great field position, while Manning threw a pick six to seal a Superbowl loss, nuff said.
@23brokendream It's a possibility, ha ha. After the Cols draft Andrew Luck, poor Peyton(After his years of Good Service) will be thrown out in the cold. I would not be surprised if the Redskins do take Manning. He'll be a hell of lot better than Rex Grossman, who just flat out sucks!
You say Peyton isn't the best ever. Brady and Montana are better because of postseason success. Ask yourselves, how much of a "team" has Peyton ever had? Year in and year out mediocre offensive line, typically one of the worst defenses in the league, (after the prime of Faulk/ Edge) no run game, and recievers that made their name by playing with him... Hmmmmm...
@NewXclusive Peyton has had the top 10 scoring D 6 times. When he did win the Superbowl, his QB rating in the postseason was 70, and he threw 3 TDs and 7 INTs. AKA his defense carried him. so don't give me that whole "his team has been mediocre" because that is false. Manning is a choke artist in the postseason.
The debate for best qb of all time will always be disputed but Peyton Manning is by far my favorite qb to watch, its like watching someone orchestrate a symphony you just can't explain it.
@trapcrew1524 good one. i know you're tryin to make a joke here but its too over the top. it has to be at least possible for your argument to be true before its funny
@ferrarimike23 who drove them down the field for Vinatieri two winning kicks? Vinatieri did not save Brady, Brady was clutch and drove them down the field the first time, when many though they should've have gone to overtime. and Brady had a drive in the 4th Quarter of SB 38 that tied that the game with a TD. you're an idiot. the Rams D was ranked 4th in 2001, the Panthers D was ranked 9th, once again, IDIOT. and Manning won his SB against Grossman in the rain - /watch?v=WrAt2Xzue3U
Fact is vinitari saved bradys ass in 2 superbowls
Bradys good but when you break it down he's lucky he even has 1 superbowl considering all the lucky/corrupt calls they've had go their way hints raiders afc champ game
@DonAdnan123 Adam Vinitari kicked 3 field goals in the colts sb win. Eli won his first sb by 3 points. The giants kicker kicked the game winner in san fran to send the giants to the super bowl. All teams need kickers. Nuff said
If you say Brady, Manning, Montana, Unitas as the best I have no problem...when you start citing Super Bowl wins, which is a team achievement then I have a problem.
Most of you guys here live in indiana probably, i don't live in san francisco and i still think number 16 is the best quarter back ever, its not all about the numbers, get this. have you ever seen montana nervous in a high rated game? no thats why he is cool joe, props to peyton , love the guy i hope he returns
This is the way I look at it, Brady and Manning are both great quaterbacks, But I think Manning is better and I would even say he's the best of all time. Brady has 3 SB's congradulations to you but that's a team stat, Manning has 4 MVP awards which is an individual stat. If you're comparing the colts to the pats the pats have had the better team but if you compare Brady to Manning, Manning is better.
Look at the team Brady brought to the superbowl this year
Imagine having a team that poor defensively basically every year since you came into the league. Without manning the colts wouldn't of had a winning record at all in the last decade
Fact is mannings struggles in the post season are do to a below average team that he brought to the playoffs year in and year out. Manning made Clark Wayne and Harrison good look at them now
If Peyton is so God like, then why does he have a shitty post season record? You'd think with someone who rips up NFL records should have a better postseason record. I do not hate Manning, I have lots of respect for him, but I am just pointing this out.
@BloodFestpwi Shitty postseason record? He's won a Super Bowl and has been to another one where he lost because the Saints were playing out of their minds. Peyton Manning has brought the Colts to the playoffs year after year. He has the most 4th quarter comebacks and as you can tell by this season, the Colts are trash without him. When Brady was injured and out for the season, the Patriots still went 11-5. Brady is an great quarterback but he'll never have the leadership and skill set of Manning
@wirednotice actually, he's had his share of problems in the postseason and everybody knows that. For me, he's one of the greatest of all time, but in the regular season
@nicosfi Yeah his stats for a lot of his playoff games haven't been nearly as good as his regular season games, but again he always played with a Defense that was ranked dead last or close to it (2004, 2005 are perfect examples). You can't put the entire blame on him for a shitty post season record when the entire team is lacking.
I agree with everything you said exept Joe Montana would be 2nd
Peyton manning redefined the qb position
People didn't relize You could dominate the qb position like Peyton has. Montana was good but even he didn't look as good as Peyton did in his prime considering Peyton always threw more Tds every season and set the single season td and qb rating record nobody reads the D like Peyton besides
peyton manning is the best quarterback of all time better than tom brady p:339 tds TOM:300 career wins PEYTON:141 Tom:124 Tom lost to eli manning 3 TIMES twice in the super bowl PEYTON:2-0 against him in 2006 {championship season} 26-21 and blown him out in 2010 38-14 top 10 QBS: 1.Peyton manning 2.Dan marino 3.Steve Young 4.Brett Farve 5.Warren Moon
I'll never see Joe Montana or Terry Bradshaw during their glory days but I'm lucky we have Peyton Manning,Tom Brady,Aaron Rodgers,and I hate to admit it,Eli Manning.
Joe montana is average. He had jerry rice to throw too for years. Peyton had marvin and wayne who are good but not great. Peyton n his offensive mind made them.
Comparing Peyton Manning with Joe Montana is like comparing Derrik Rose with Magic Johnsson. He is great but he is not even close of being Joe Montana. Besides i think Brady is even better Than Peyton.
This Superbowl, I just saw my sons's fav team defeated by the Giants. I always say, "it's just a game", and so be it. But the Peyton family and legacy is amazing. Good job little bro.
BRADY BETTER THAN PEYTON????? please..... notice how the 3 SB rings he won his team cheated every time SO BEFORE YOU GO RUN YOUR MOUTH ABOUT WHOSE BETTER (remember that.
@TheLarotRobert First of all, Montana only won 4 Superbowls. Secodly, Peyton winning one Superbowl was all he needed to become greatest QB ever. You can safely say that without Jerry rice Montana would have not won as much. He won once without Rice. So Peyton Manning is the greatest ever. Why? Because of the way he controls everything that goes on on the field. He is the Coach. He calls the plays, Executes the plays, and manipulates the defense with his confusing snap count.
@TheLarotRobert No other QB comes close to controlling the game as he does. And to top it off he is dead accurate, quick, and makes nearly any player look good. Greatest ever.
When people say Rodgers or Brady are the best it blows my mind. When Brady was out for the year his back up went 11-5. Peytons back up 2-14. Rodgers back up 6 td over 440 yards in the game against the lion D. All of them have excellent teams but Manning. Brady also plays bad vs. Good teams. For this alone manning should win the MVP
im a huge manning fan i will never turn my back on him until i die if he leaves the colts he needs to go to arizona they are on the rise and he just cant walk away from the game like this and i know he wont
@crockalotadizero How about you try taking a hit from someone like Clay Matthews or one of the Smiths from the 9ers, and then when you wake up, i want you to repeat this same statement
can someone please explain to me what "Receiving Defense" means? was just looking over some of the stats but didn't know exactly what that category was about
@birdo124 he would have twice as many suer bowl as tom if he was on a better team like the pats. look at each teams record the season each was out. Shows how peytons more important to the team and could easily make the pats 10 times better.
fuck u!!!! get off this fuckin channel u bitch!!! go suck your moms dick!!! soccer is fuckin gay.. its for hairy ass lickers like u!!!!! this is american football... and call them fatasses they have way more muscle(skilled positons) than weak ass soccer players... american football is more manly than your dumb ass and soccer...
They see that the colts have moved on and now theyll realize they need to replace Brady soon or they'll be in the same position as the colts but without a #1 pic to save them
I am a patriots fan. And hate the colts. But I hate them in friendly competition. I actually think Payton Manning is one of the best of all time and it shows me what kind of classless organization the colts and there ownership is about!!! Payton Manning Is the Colts period!!! Made them what they are. Good luck Payton where ever you end up. You have a fan in NewEngland!
its actually peyton.. and hes not the whole team... i dont see him playing defense(not trying to be a douche)... but yea he does make a huge impact on the colts... but its sad because he is most likely leaving and the colts are gonna have a whole new team.. im gonna miss those matchups with manning and tom brady... but still let the rivalry begin.. good luck to your patriots...-colts fan
Ill take him over brady any day of the week, people said Payton only did better than brady due to supperior offensive talent, we found out this year just how good that team was without 18
Dont compare Brady with Peyton Manning. Brady's 3 SB wins or the Patriots rather came as a result of a kicker named Adam Vinateri. When Vinateri departed he got his 4th SB with the Colts who tore up a stellar Bears defense with Peyton Manning as the QB. Brady lost against the Giants in the SB and in the famous words of Adam Vinateri, "Tom my boy Brady, u need me if you want another ring and another chance to take the credit of my SUPER BOWL WINS"
@GodlySwagg1 I think Peyton Manning is the greatest QB ever. But to say Tom Brady won 3 super bowls because a kicker is stupid...have you forgot who put Adam in the position to kick those game winners?
@billbb you say that like they are not getting payed millions to catch the ball. Its the Quarterbacks job to put the ball where the Receiver can catch it. Its the Receivers job to make the catch.
How dare people compare Eli to Peyton, and say he's better. When Eli has 4 MVP awards, carried a team on his back for 12 seasons, acted has his own offensive coordinator, called his own plays, created his own plays, directed practices, and made his coaches unnecessary, wins 12+ games for 8 straight seasons, despite a shitty defense, then you can compare the two of them.
everyone can go assume if Peyton had a better offense he would be better than Brady, i dont..., as far as i know, Brady has 3 rings, 2 MVP's, broke Manning's record, Brady is a pure winner, dont get me wrong Manning is a great QB one of the bests, but i don't go by "ifs" or "could haves", Brady is a better QB regardless even if he had better offensive line and receivers.
u must be a patriots fan... its not about the rings, peyton doesnt have more than one ring cuz the colts defense has always sucked... and peyton has 4 mvp's.... peyton manning is better.... oh and its not all bout the stats..
@greenraider28 No im a niner's fan, like i said, one can assume whatever, mvp's are just individual awards, don't matter to me, its about the team, if Manning's team sucked, then too bad, Joe Montana and Brady dont have 4 league mvps and their better because of what they have accomplished,im not talking about stats its about what they have earned as a team, Brady 3 SB, 2 time League mvp, 2 time Sb mvp, 'nuff said
im tlkin bout the qb... manning has the warse team... but when he is there he makes them much better...and how does joe montana come in to this convo.. im not tlkin bout him.... patriots did not do tht bad when brady was injured colts did horrible without manning shows u how he is better than brady....
@greenraider28 nope haters hate on players, i haven't done any hating, i never said he sucks or is one of the worst qb's in the nfl, i simply stated my opinion, this is youtube sonny
@DShodan theyre both the two greatest qbs to ever play, id say their talent is equal except manning is smarter when it comes to calling plays, either way theyre gonna be in canton and be remembered at the greatest rivalry between two quarterbacks
mann, iloveeeeeeeeeeeeeeee peyton manning. he will always be one of my favorite football quarterbacks. he is a beast! and the 2011-2012 season showed how much the colts needed him. go peyton!
You couldn't convince a real colt fan that Brady is better then manning in a million years. Bradys always had a better team with a better coach manning does way more for his team then Brady. Mvps don't lie
i love brady and manning( more so being from indy) but when you rank individuals you rank them for there individual accomplishments and skills so in saying that i think peyton is the best ever. (just my opinion)
To all of you preaching pats D gave brady his rings, he always lacked great receivers. I could easily say no wayne and no harrison no sb for peyton. Goes both ways.
@GotAnEyedea but you must realize football is *thee* ultimate *team* sport i think the world of Brady but ultimately Brady had a better *team* all around so i think thats why the supporting cast arguement comes up
Okay. If your making a dream team, and you have to choose players based on pure skill at each position, and you could choose any player from any time, Peyton Manning would be the quarterback, and there is no close second. In terms of throwing the football, he is the best ever. Brady and Montana are great but they had a little something extra in terms of heart and winning championships that make them great. But, Peyton Manning is the most gifted QB ever.
Sounds like you're the one making excuses because bradys always had a better D to work with and a better coach if manning goes to a different team he will still be great
I doubt Brady could do the same. Bradys a QB that's in a good system
@ferrarimike23 The idea of a "system" QB is absolutely ridiculous. Every QB is in a system, and teams have mimicked the patriots system before with no avail. I won't argue brady vs manning, but to say that brady is the product of things around him and not his own ability is flat out retarded.
STEELERS, CUZ UMM, THEYVE HAD THE BEST OF BOTH SINCE LIKE FOREVER, ALONG WITH GREENBAY. SO STOP MAKING EXCUSES. ITS EITHER UR GOOD OR UR NOT, AND BOTH MANNING AND BRADY R LEGENDS SO I DNT SEE WATS WITH THE EXCUSE MAKING.IN SINCE THE COACHING OF BELICHICK, HOW MANY SEASON HAVE THE PATS GONE WITH THE SAME PLAYERS ON O OR D? NONE. EVERY YEAR THEY ACQUIRE YOUNGER AND NEWER PLAYERS WHILE EVERY1 ELSE STAYS WIT THE OLD. WHOS FAULT IS THAT? GOOD DEFENSE RIGHT?CHECK UR D STATS BEFORE U SAY DA 1 AGAIN
I LOVE HOW EVERY1 SAYS BRADY ALWAYS HAD THE BEST O LINE AND DLINE. IS THAT SO? BEFO THEIR FIRST SB WIN, WHO COULD EVEN NAME THE DLINE OF THE PATS? OR EVEN THEIR DBS? BARELY ANYONE. ALL OF A SUDDEN, BRADY CATCHES FIRE AND OF COURSE PPL GOTTA MAKE EXCUSES. BEFORE WELKER, BRANCH, STALLWORTH, GAFFNEY,GALLOWAY AND SO MANY OTHERS PUT ON A PATS JERSEY, NO 1 EVEN KNEW THEM, BUT BRADY JUST MAKES EVERY1 AROUND HIM GOOD. IF ITS LIKE THAT DEN ALL THESE O AND DLINE COMMENTS SHLD BE DIRECTED AT D RAVENS AND
@Mastrlegacy02 yea everyone says that but Brady never threw a pick 6 to lose a super bowl either. And look at this season and last season, how good was the patriots defense? Brady put up his best numbers besides the 07 season. Ill admit that the three championship years and the 07 season Brady had a great defense but im pretty sure The colts defense played damn good when they won the super bowl. Also how long did Manning have Wayne and Harrison? Patriots let go of guys all the time.
Im a Patriots fan and PERSONALLY i think Brady is better but if Brady wasnt around no qb would touch this guy. True fans of football kno respect and kno when a legend is playing and Manning is the second best qb to ever take a snap.I hope he stays with the colts and comes back next year on fire. This season wasnt the same bc you didnt have a classic shootout between Brady and Manning.
@wasreck1 That's because you're a Patriots fan. I'm a Steelers fan and i definitely pick Manning over Brady. If you remember when Brady went down Matt Cassel came in and went 10-5. Manning goes down it's a 2-14 season. The Patriots have have had a great defense for the majority of Brady's tenure there while Manning has never had a great defense. If you could find the time of possession i could guarantee you that Brady has had the ball in his hands a lot more than Manning.
@Mastrlegacy02 WOOOOOOOOOOA.? THE COLTS NEVER HAD A GRETA DEFENSE? wow. mathis, freeny, beathea, session,bullit, sanders way bak wen, hayden, just to name a few. ALL PROW BOWLERS AND ALL COLTS D PLAYERS. the patriots get rid of like half the team every year. like how many ppl on the patriots d since the superbowl are headline players? or big playmkakers? like 5. they just take players that other teams dnt kno how to use and make em good. dont make excuses for da colts.PEYTON STILL BEAST NO DOUBT
What song is this mixed to???
shearholdt2001 2 days ago
@KoaIalify Since Brady has been the starter at NE, his defense has been in the top ten more times than the Colts D in terms of points given up.
barrys09 2 days ago
Koalalify
Sorry but he didn't have to drive them very far considering the kicks were extremely far
Vinitari saved his ass face it
Brady really didn't even get them in very good field position on top of it
Regardless the pats haven't won since spygate no fluke
ferrarimike23 5 days ago
@ferrarimike23 SB 36: Brady drove his team 60 yards in 65 seconds with no timeouts to setup a 48 yard field goal(not "extremely" far")
SB 38: Brady drove his team down the field and threw a TD pass to take a 29-22 lead with 2:50 left, then the other team tied it at 29. Brady once again drove his team down the field to set up a 38 yard field goal(extremely far? no, you're an idiot)
Brady put them in great field position, while Manning threw a pick six to seal a Superbowl loss, nuff said.
KoaIalify 3 days ago
Peyton's new song: Hail to the Redskins!
Jiltedin2007 5 days ago
@Jiltedin2007 hah the redskins won't be stupid enough to take him....they need a long term QB
23brokendream 5 days ago
@23brokendream It's a possibility, ha ha. After the Cols draft Andrew Luck, poor Peyton(After his years of Good Service) will be thrown out in the cold. I would not be surprised if the Redskins do take Manning. He'll be a hell of lot better than Rex Grossman, who just flat out sucks!
Jiltedin2007 5 days ago
You say Peyton isn't the best ever. Brady and Montana are better because of postseason success. Ask yourselves, how much of a "team" has Peyton ever had? Year in and year out mediocre offensive line, typically one of the worst defenses in the league, (after the prime of Faulk/ Edge) no run game, and recievers that made their name by playing with him... Hmmmmm...
NewXclusive 6 days ago
@NewXclusive Peyton has had the top 10 scoring D 6 times. When he did win the Superbowl, his QB rating in the postseason was 70, and he threw 3 TDs and 7 INTs. AKA his defense carried him. so don't give me that whole "his team has been mediocre" because that is false. Manning is a choke artist in the postseason.
KoaIalify 3 days ago
The debate for best qb of all time will always be disputed but Peyton Manning is by far my favorite qb to watch, its like watching someone orchestrate a symphony you just can't explain it.
Sportsguyy18 6 days ago
the "greatest qb ever" is not 9-10 in the postseason. Montana>
/watch?v=WrAt2Xzue3U
KoaIalify 1 week ago
Greatest Quarterback to EVER touch a football, period.
RaexhardAdams 1 week ago
Comment removed
TheLarotRobert 1 week ago
Gotta start getting used to see patron in a seahawks uniform.....
MegaBighead666 1 week ago
Welcome to Washington
controlgroup3 1 week ago
Comment removed
trapcrew1524 1 week ago
who cares how well a person can throw a ball. other things to care about, this is ridiculous.
ronv11 1 week ago
Comment removed
trapcrew1524 1 week ago
@trapcrew1524 good one. i know you're tryin to make a joke here but its too over the top. it has to be at least possible for your argument to be true before its funny
mariomanningfan 1 week ago
@mariomanningfan naw someone else was on my account sayin that, i rep peyton till he dies bro, COLTS FOR LIFE
trapcrew1524 1 week ago
Shabu
It doesn't matter we are talking about superbowls here not playoff games Eli won his by a touchdown pass not a field goal kick
Manning won his by more the a touchdown
Vinitari won to of bradys for him.
And the rams and panther D wasn't really that good
ferrarimike23 1 week ago
@ferrarimike23 who drove them down the field for Vinatieri two winning kicks? Vinatieri did not save Brady, Brady was clutch and drove them down the field the first time, when many though they should've have gone to overtime. and Brady had a drive in the 4th Quarter of SB 38 that tied that the game with a TD. you're an idiot. the Rams D was ranked 4th in 2001, the Panthers D was ranked 9th, once again, IDIOT. and Manning won his SB against Grossman in the rain - /watch?v=WrAt2Xzue3U
KoaIalify 1 week ago
Peyton Manning and Wladimir Klitschko have the exact same birthday of March 25 1976
laaloboyzwestside 1 week ago
Goosebumps man goosebumps
mannshow84 1 week ago
Peyton im my favorite QB of all time ! Go Colts !!!
AllAboutDemGators22 1 week ago
Eli won his first superbowl by a touchdown pass
Peyton won his by more than a touchdown
Fact is vinitari saved bradys ass in 2 superbowls
Bradys good but when you break it down he's lucky he even has 1 superbowl considering all the lucky/corrupt calls they've had go their way hints raiders afc champ game
ferrarimike23 1 week ago
@ferrarimike23 what was the score to eli's first superbowl
How many fg did Adam Vinitair kick to in the Colt;s superbowl
Do you remember how the Giants got to the superbowl after Brett Favre threw a pick back in 2007? You guessed it a field goal
shabuu56 1 week ago
@DonAdnan123 Adam Vinitari kicked 3 field goals in the colts sb win. Eli won his first sb by 3 points. The giants kicker kicked the game winner in san fran to send the giants to the super bowl. All teams need kickers. Nuff said
shabuu56 1 week ago
whoever thinks manning is better than montana should be ashamed of themselves
DonAdnan123 1 week ago
Patriots > Colts, BUT MANNING > BRADY!
mariomanningfan 1 week ago
If you say Brady, Manning, Montana, Unitas as the best I have no problem...when you start citing Super Bowl wins, which is a team achievement then I have a problem.
bissoc14 1 week ago
Manning is the best all time in my book just because he revolutionized the qb position
Dan Marino and manning paved the way for these new QBS by showing the world just how dominate you could be at that position
Even though Montana has 4 rings due to having a great team around him he wasn't as consistent at the qb position until
It came time to be clutch that is
ferrarimike23 2 weeks ago
Most of you guys here live in indiana probably, i don't live in san francisco and i still think number 16 is the best quarter back ever, its not all about the numbers, get this. have you ever seen montana nervous in a high rated game? no thats why he is cool joe, props to peyton , love the guy i hope he returns
cloudchaser07 2 weeks ago
Manning Brother's>Brady
ThePeytonManningFan 2 weeks ago
You know, it's funny that there are no post season highlights in this video......
EmeraldCityAhole 2 weeks ago
This is the way I look at it, Brady and Manning are both great quaterbacks, But I think Manning is better and I would even say he's the best of all time. Brady has 3 SB's congradulations to you but that's a team stat, Manning has 4 MVP awards which is an individual stat. If you're comparing the colts to the pats the pats have had the better team but if you compare Brady to Manning, Manning is better.
iRUSTYZz 2 weeks ago
@iRUSTYZz well said my bro.. let these niggas know whats real.
thekillamc21 2 weeks ago 2
Look at the team Brady brought to the superbowl this year
Imagine having a team that poor defensively basically every year since you came into the league. Without manning the colts wouldn't of had a winning record at all in the last decade
Fact is mannings struggles in the post season are do to a below average team that he brought to the playoffs year in and year out. Manning made Clark Wayne and Harrison good look at them now
ferrarimike23 2 weeks ago
If Peyton is so God like, then why does he have a shitty post season record? You'd think with someone who rips up NFL records should have a better postseason record. I do not hate Manning, I have lots of respect for him, but I am just pointing this out.
BloodFestpwi 2 weeks ago
@BloodFestpwi Shitty postseason record? He's won a Super Bowl and has been to another one where he lost because the Saints were playing out of their minds. Peyton Manning has brought the Colts to the playoffs year after year. He has the most 4th quarter comebacks and as you can tell by this season, the Colts are trash without him. When Brady was injured and out for the season, the Patriots still went 11-5. Brady is an great quarterback but he'll never have the leadership and skill set of Manning
wirednotice 2 weeks ago
@wirednotice actually, he's had his share of problems in the postseason and everybody knows that. For me, he's one of the greatest of all time, but in the regular season
nicosfi 2 weeks ago
@nicosfi Yeah his stats for a lot of his playoff games haven't been nearly as good as his regular season games, but again he always played with a Defense that was ranked dead last or close to it (2004, 2005 are perfect examples). You can't put the entire blame on him for a shitty post season record when the entire team is lacking.
wirednotice 2 weeks ago
@wirednotice that's true
nicosfi 2 weeks ago
Bret favre and Warren moon don't belong in top 5
ferrarimike23 2 weeks ago
I agree with everything you said exept Joe Montana would be 2nd
Peyton manning redefined the qb position
People didn't relize You could dominate the qb position like Peyton has. Montana was good but even he didn't look as good as Peyton did in his prime considering Peyton always threw more Tds every season and set the single season td and qb rating record nobody reads the D like Peyton besides
Peyton calls his own plays
ferrarimike23 2 weeks ago
peyton manning is the best quarterback of all time better than tom brady p:339 tds TOM:300 career wins PEYTON:141 Tom:124 Tom lost to eli manning 3 TIMES twice in the super bowl PEYTON:2-0 against him in 2006 {championship season} 26-21 and blown him out in 2010 38-14 top 10 QBS: 1.Peyton manning 2.Dan marino 3.Steve Young 4.Brett Farve 5.Warren Moon
bcmartin1000 2 weeks ago
Megariver I'm sorry bro but Peyton is better then Brady
Brady wouldn't be squat without bill beli and the pats franchise
Besides Peyton did lose his last 2 superbowls lol
ferrarimike23 2 weeks ago
I'll never see Joe Montana or Terry Bradshaw during their glory days but I'm lucky we have Peyton Manning,Tom Brady,Aaron Rodgers,and I hate to admit it,Eli Manning.
Silenthunter287 2 weeks ago
Joe montana is average. He had jerry rice to throw too for years. Peyton had marvin and wayne who are good but not great. Peyton n his offensive mind made them.
Geeolm214 2 weeks ago
Peyton was a great QB and he is my favorite QB ever and I'm trying to be as good as him some day. Ilook me up Tate martelll 13 years old quarterback
tmartell18 2 weeks ago
When Peyton retires - whether it's now or in the future - he should become an NFL referee.
Amar7605 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
Michigan18Blue 2 weeks ago
Comparing Peyton Manning with Joe Montana is like comparing Derrik Rose with Magic Johnsson. He is great but he is not even close of being Joe Montana. Besides i think Brady is even better Than Peyton.
MegaRiver97 2 weeks ago
Why the hell do people bring up Terry Bradshaw? Look at his stats first. Very average.
nonebuthelite11 2 weeks ago
Joe Montana is still the best
Torin2015 3 weeks ago
True GOAT
Michigan18Blue 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Michigan18Blue 3 weeks ago
michigan fan here take manning over brady any day of the week.
Michigan18Blue 3 weeks ago
Best QB I've ever seen play
kriscena 3 weeks ago
Manning should go to miami
3
platanoo05 3 weeks ago
He could have had alot.more rings if he didn't have shitty coaches
49ers should consider him a option if he's avaliable
2fast2furious97 3 weeks ago
@2fast2furious97 nah give alex smith some more time
thejanitorssuccess 3 weeks ago
@2fast2furious97 The 49ers arent looking for a QB
WhatssSoFunny 3 weeks ago
@2fast2furious97 I agree 150% with You!!! Bring Peyton To the 49ers please!!!! Alex Smith SUCKS!!!!
elpotopeludo 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Michigan18Blue 3 weeks ago
This Superbowl, I just saw my sons's fav team defeated by the Giants. I always say, "it's just a game", and so be it. But the Peyton family and legacy is amazing. Good job little bro.
DMCoad20 3 weeks ago
BRADY BETTER THAN PEYTON????? please..... notice how the 3 SB rings he won his team cheated every time SO BEFORE YOU GO RUN YOUR MOUTH ABOUT WHOSE BETTER (remember that.
FreshOnMyMind 3 weeks ago
Peyton is the GREATEST, PERIOD.
MrPapus07 3 weeks ago
peyton will never play another snap
JaayPeey 3 weeks ago
I love Peyton Manning
Rvd70a 3 weeks ago
There is the greatest Quarterback of all-time. Montana is numero dos!
skillethead15 3 weeks ago 8
@skillethead15 Montana has 5 super bowls, ¿manning few have? payton is good, great, but not the best
TheLarotRobert 1 week ago
@TheLarotRobert First of all, Montana only won 4 Superbowls. Secodly, Peyton winning one Superbowl was all he needed to become greatest QB ever. You can safely say that without Jerry rice Montana would have not won as much. He won once without Rice. So Peyton Manning is the greatest ever. Why? Because of the way he controls everything that goes on on the field. He is the Coach. He calls the plays, Executes the plays, and manipulates the defense with his confusing snap count.
skillethead15 1 week ago
@TheLarotRobert No other QB comes close to controlling the game as he does. And to top it off he is dead accurate, quick, and makes nearly any player look good. Greatest ever.
skillethead15 1 week ago
yes! peyton manning is healthy.. was on sports center today.. most likely he satys in indy!!
greenraider28 3 weeks ago
Well Rodgers and brees played so good this year that people just ranked them higher then manning
Since mannings been out people forgot exactly how good he really is
Rodgers 1 and done
Brees. 1 and done
That's the differance between them and the truly great QBS like manning Brady and Eli
ferrarimike23 3 weeks ago
When people say Rodgers or Brady are the best it blows my mind. When Brady was out for the year his back up went 11-5. Peytons back up 2-14. Rodgers back up 6 td over 440 yards in the game against the lion D. All of them have excellent teams but Manning. Brady also plays bad vs. Good teams. For this alone manning should win the MVP
TheEroded 3 weeks ago
Dear Peyton,
please go to San Fran. Thank You
antbanks415 3 weeks ago
How do you make/edit these videos?
WhatssSoFunny 3 weeks ago
wobbly passes....
SaintWicked721 3 weeks ago
pretty damn good video...good choice in music!
strutter82 4 weeks ago
im a huge manning fan i will never turn my back on him until i die if he leaves the colts he needs to go to arizona they are on the rise and he just cant walk away from the game like this and i know he wont
blackhorn66 1 month ago
@crockalotadizero How about you try taking a hit from someone like Clay Matthews or one of the Smiths from the 9ers, and then when you wake up, i want you to repeat this same statement
MrPoetistic85 1 month ago
can someone please explain to me what "Receiving Defense" means? was just looking over some of the stats but didn't know exactly what that category was about
bulletproof6113 1 month ago
2:00 i meant...the spaztic kid is what i was trying to show...
MeetTheMentlegen1997 1 month ago
2:02 da fuq lol
MeetTheMentlegen1997 1 month ago
cotes suck
chuteboxe128 1 month ago
@chuteboxe128 learn how to spell fuck face. show some damn respect to peyton manning.
MeetTheMentlegen1997 1 month ago
Peyton manning is a joke.
GO TOM BRADY
birdo124 1 month ago
@birdo124 he would have twice as many suer bowl as tom if he was on a better team like the pats. look at each teams record the season each was out. Shows how peytons more important to the team and could easily make the pats 10 times better.
MeetTheMentlegen1997 1 month ago
if colts trade manning away. i hope luck is a big bust and peyton goes on and win superbowl witha another team
MOMOarabe 1 month ago
I think Peyton is way better then Aaron Rodgers!!!
mividaloc 1 month ago
Even as a Jaguars fan Peyton Manning is a bad ass
NinjaSaiden 1 month ago
lets stop pretending that american football is a manly sport, all that i see is fatasses in tights
football (you dumb yanks know it as soccer) kicks this wannabe crap in the asshole
crockalotadizero 1 month ago
fuck u!!!! get off this fuckin channel u bitch!!! go suck your moms dick!!! soccer is fuckin gay.. its for hairy ass lickers like u!!!!! this is american football... and call them fatasses they have way more muscle(skilled positons) than weak ass soccer players... american football is more manly than your dumb ass and soccer...
greenraider28 1 month ago
Tapout
Brady will be next
Within 2 years he's out of ne
They see that the colts have moved on and now theyll realize they need to replace Brady soon or they'll be in the same position as the colts but without a #1 pic to save them
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
I am a patriots fan. And hate the colts. But I hate them in friendly competition. I actually think Payton Manning is one of the best of all time and it shows me what kind of classless organization the colts and there ownership is about!!! Payton Manning Is the Colts period!!! Made them what they are. Good luck Payton where ever you end up. You have a fan in NewEngland!
tap0ut22 1 month ago
its actually peyton.. and hes not the whole team... i dont see him playing defense(not trying to be a douche)... but yea he does make a huge impact on the colts... but its sad because he is most likely leaving and the colts are gonna have a whole new team.. im gonna miss those matchups with manning and tom brady... but still let the rivalry begin.. good luck to your patriots...-colts fan
greenraider28 1 month ago
@tap0ut22 yes, i realized this season i am more of peyton fan rather than a colts fan
axlrosea675 1 month ago
Cardinal. No
I hope that if they release him he gives the colts the biggest ass whoopen ever.
I'm almost ashamed to be a colts fan right now with the way their doing buissness.
I'm a colts fan but I will forever have mannings back . Whatever team he goes to I hope he wins it all 1 more time before we retire his jersey
Theirs been many Tom bradys but they'll never be another Peyton manning
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
is it wrong if a colts fan want to see Manning destroy his own team if they release him to prove how stupid they are for releasing him?
CardinalStrong5 1 month ago
Ill take him over brady any day of the week, people said Payton only did better than brady due to supperior offensive talent, we found out this year just how good that team was without 18
GoJetsGo90 1 month ago
Dont compare Brady with Peyton Manning. Brady's 3 SB wins or the Patriots rather came as a result of a kicker named Adam Vinateri. When Vinateri departed he got his 4th SB with the Colts who tore up a stellar Bears defense with Peyton Manning as the QB. Brady lost against the Giants in the SB and in the famous words of Adam Vinateri, "Tom my boy Brady, u need me if you want another ring and another chance to take the credit of my SUPER BOWL WINS"
GodlySwagg1 1 month ago 16
@GodlySwagg1 your stupid aren't you.
AMD1080 1 month ago
@GodlySwagg1 Without Brady, the Patriots wouldn't even had made the playoffs those years.
WhatssSoFunny 3 weeks ago
@GodlySwagg1 Held true today once again
dinosaur4 3 weeks ago
@GodlySwagg1 I think Peyton Manning is the greatest QB ever. But to say Tom Brady won 3 super bowls because a kicker is stupid...have you forgot who put Adam in the position to kick those game winners?
shabuu56 3 weeks ago
@shabuu56 eli manning > tom brady! oh and manning scored touchdowns...kickers are not needed if your a great qb. nuff said
DonAdnan123 1 week ago
DONT LET PEYTON GO
RAW2099 1 month ago
watch him go to washington
dominicb222 1 month ago
in front of every great throw the was a great catch
billbb 1 month ago
@billbb you say that like they are not getting payed millions to catch the ball. Its the Quarterbacks job to put the ball where the Receiver can catch it. Its the Receivers job to make the catch.
jobelax16 1 month ago
Fuck ELI.
hunterman823 1 month ago
Miami dolphins new qb
BabyChank25 1 month ago
@BabyChank25 hell no
brasteen1 1 month ago
@BabyChank25 dont think so chief
mriley858 1 month ago
How dare people compare Eli to Peyton, and say he's better. When Eli has 4 MVP awards, carried a team on his back for 12 seasons, acted has his own offensive coordinator, called his own plays, created his own plays, directed practices, and made his coaches unnecessary, wins 12+ games for 8 straight seasons, despite a shitty defense, then you can compare the two of them.
ShadowDog415 1 month ago
go to andystars16
andystars16 1 month ago
like this comment if your a jets fan and watching this, cause you really hope peyton comes to the jets!
TonyFryGuy305 1 month ago
@TonyFryGuy305 god i hope he doesnt go there id rather see him go to the cards or minnesota.
brasteen1 1 month ago
Dshodan
Manning 4 Mvps 1 superbowl
1superbowl MVP
Superbowl is a team award
MVP is an individual award meaning manning is individually better then Brady
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
NFL's GOAT.
regxjin 1 month ago
Not sure if I could say he's the best QB, but he was definitely far and above the smartest. Picked apart a defense like it was nothing.
phaquetoob 1 month ago
peyton is the best he holds the rookie passing record and it isn't about lombardis he is just better than tom brady
JohnCena891000 1 month ago
1. Peyton
2. Warner
3. Brady
coreyownz 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great video man. He is without a doubt one of the best to play the game.
Check out my Doug Flutie highlight video and tell me what you think. If you like it I'll make one for your favourite player next.
youtube.com/watch?v=kHIHF1EwsU Q
keenanmartens 1 month ago
everyone can go assume if Peyton had a better offense he would be better than Brady, i dont..., as far as i know, Brady has 3 rings, 2 MVP's, broke Manning's record, Brady is a pure winner, dont get me wrong Manning is a great QB one of the bests, but i don't go by "ifs" or "could haves", Brady is a better QB regardless even if he had better offensive line and receivers.
DShodan 1 month ago
u must be a patriots fan... its not about the rings, peyton doesnt have more than one ring cuz the colts defense has always sucked... and peyton has 4 mvp's.... peyton manning is better.... oh and its not all bout the stats..
greenraider28 1 month ago
@greenraider28 No im a niner's fan, like i said, one can assume whatever, mvp's are just individual awards, don't matter to me, its about the team, if Manning's team sucked, then too bad, Joe Montana and Brady dont have 4 league mvps and their better because of what they have accomplished,im not talking about stats its about what they have earned as a team, Brady 3 SB, 2 time League mvp, 2 time Sb mvp, 'nuff said
DShodan 1 month ago
im tlkin bout the qb... manning has the warse team... but when he is there he makes them much better...and how does joe montana come in to this convo.. im not tlkin bout him.... patriots did not do tht bad when brady was injured colts did horrible without manning shows u how he is better than brady....
greenraider28 1 month ago
and y would u come on to a peyton manning vid.. and say brady is better... u must juss be a hater..
greenraider28 1 month ago
@greenraider28 nope haters hate on players, i haven't done any hating, i never said he sucks or is one of the worst qb's in the nfl, i simply stated my opinion, this is youtube sonny
DShodan 1 month ago
@DShodan theyre both the two greatest qbs to ever play, id say their talent is equal except manning is smarter when it comes to calling plays, either way theyre gonna be in canton and be remembered at the greatest rivalry between two quarterbacks
Qweeftastic 3 weeks ago
mann, iloveeeeeeeeeeeeeeee peyton manning. he will always be one of my favorite football quarterbacks. he is a beast! and the 2011-2012 season showed how much the colts needed him. go peyton!
chellychellehello 1 month ago 13
Vydeoz
Your not a colts fan jackass
You couldn't convince a real colt fan that Brady is better then manning in a million years. Bradys always had a better team with a better coach manning does way more for his team then Brady. Mvps don't lie
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
@ferrarimike23 who said you could talk?
Vydeoz3 1 month ago
@Vydeoz3 that freedom speech nigga that who said he could talk bitch!!!
GETBIGBITCH1 1 month ago
@GETBIGBITCH1 Learn the concept of grammar and then you can speak.
Vydeoz3 1 month ago
@Vydeoz3 go fuck a couch
GETBIGBITCH1 1 month ago
@GETBIGBITCH1 I was planning to!
Vydeoz3 1 month ago
no QB is batter then Drew Brees!!!
7snowwolf 1 month ago
@7snowwolf ur dumb
itsDylanJohnson 1 month ago
@itsDylanJohnson
and your in idiot
7snowwolf 1 month ago
Lets see his 2011-2012 season highlights ;P
lucasB823 1 month ago
i love brady and manning( more so being from indy) but when you rank individuals you rank them for there individual accomplishments and skills so in saying that i think peyton is the best ever. (just my opinion)
MiskeenPrince 1 month ago
2:25 is a double sluggo on troy polamalu!
C4RNIF3X1986 1 month ago
VARABEL SHOLAX :) on reggie wayne !!!
C4RNIF3X1986 1 month ago
To all of you preaching pats D gave brady his rings, he always lacked great receivers. I could easily say no wayne and no harrison no sb for peyton. Goes both ways.
GotAnEyedea 1 month ago
@GotAnEyedea but you must realize football is *thee* ultimate *team* sport i think the world of Brady but ultimately Brady had a better *team* all around so i think thats why the supporting cast arguement comes up
MiskeenPrince 1 month ago
@MiskeenPrince Maybe overrall, but both had more help at different positions.
GotAnEyedea 1 month ago
Okay. If your making a dream team, and you have to choose players based on pure skill at each position, and you could choose any player from any time, Peyton Manning would be the quarterback, and there is no close second. In terms of throwing the football, he is the best ever. Brady and Montana are great but they had a little something extra in terms of heart and winning championships that make them great. But, Peyton Manning is the most gifted QB ever.
FeebleNosemanny 1 month ago
I think the colts are planning on keeping manning because they want him to be apart of the colts organization when he retires
And if they trade him hes not coming back as a player or anything else
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
Fuck Luck.
EveryNameIsTakenFFS2 1 month ago
have we seen the last of manning in a colts jersey? (maybe)
22s22a 1 month ago
Eyering
Yeah this music is only fit for Tim tebow
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
peyton manning is the greatest but this dramatic music is way over the top. he ain't the pope
EyeRing100 1 month ago
Apex
Sounds like you're the one making excuses because bradys always had a better D to work with and a better coach if manning goes to a different team he will still be great
I doubt Brady could do the same. Bradys a QB that's in a good system
Manning is the system.
ferrarimike23 1 month ago
@ferrarimike23 The idea of a "system" QB is absolutely ridiculous. Every QB is in a system, and teams have mimicked the patriots system before with no avail. I won't argue brady vs manning, but to say that brady is the product of things around him and not his own ability is flat out retarded.
GotAnEyedea 1 month ago
STEELERS, CUZ UMM, THEYVE HAD THE BEST OF BOTH SINCE LIKE FOREVER, ALONG WITH GREENBAY. SO STOP MAKING EXCUSES. ITS EITHER UR GOOD OR UR NOT, AND BOTH MANNING AND BRADY R LEGENDS SO I DNT SEE WATS WITH THE EXCUSE MAKING.IN SINCE THE COACHING OF BELICHICK, HOW MANY SEASON HAVE THE PATS GONE WITH THE SAME PLAYERS ON O OR D? NONE. EVERY YEAR THEY ACQUIRE YOUNGER AND NEWER PLAYERS WHILE EVERY1 ELSE STAYS WIT THE OLD. WHOS FAULT IS THAT? GOOD DEFENSE RIGHT?CHECK UR D STATS BEFORE U SAY DA 1 AGAIN
ApexPredator95 1 month ago
I LOVE HOW EVERY1 SAYS BRADY ALWAYS HAD THE BEST O LINE AND DLINE. IS THAT SO? BEFO THEIR FIRST SB WIN, WHO COULD EVEN NAME THE DLINE OF THE PATS? OR EVEN THEIR DBS? BARELY ANYONE. ALL OF A SUDDEN, BRADY CATCHES FIRE AND OF COURSE PPL GOTTA MAKE EXCUSES. BEFORE WELKER, BRANCH, STALLWORTH, GAFFNEY,GALLOWAY AND SO MANY OTHERS PUT ON A PATS JERSEY, NO 1 EVEN KNEW THEM, BUT BRADY JUST MAKES EVERY1 AROUND HIM GOOD. IF ITS LIKE THAT DEN ALL THESE O AND DLINE COMMENTS SHLD BE DIRECTED AT D RAVENS AND
ApexPredator95 1 month ago
fuck brady shit the patriots cheated anyways lol
voddy100truth 1 month ago
Football without 18 doesn't seem right...it also didnt feel right when Brady went down........
flyboiiyayo123 1 month ago
@Mastrlegacy02 yea everyone says that but Brady never threw a pick 6 to lose a super bowl either. And look at this season and last season, how good was the patriots defense? Brady put up his best numbers besides the 07 season. Ill admit that the three championship years and the 07 season Brady had a great defense but im pretty sure The colts defense played damn good when they won the super bowl. Also how long did Manning have Wayne and Harrison? Patriots let go of guys all the time.
wasreck1 1 month ago
@wasreck1 atleats sum1 understands.
ApexPredator95 1 month ago
Im a Patriots fan and PERSONALLY i think Brady is better but if Brady wasnt around no qb would touch this guy. True fans of football kno respect and kno when a legend is playing and Manning is the second best qb to ever take a snap.I hope he stays with the colts and comes back next year on fire. This season wasnt the same bc you didnt have a classic shootout between Brady and Manning.
wasreck1 1 month ago
@wasreck1 That's because you're a Patriots fan. I'm a Steelers fan and i definitely pick Manning over Brady. If you remember when Brady went down Matt Cassel came in and went 10-5. Manning goes down it's a 2-14 season. The Patriots have have had a great defense for the majority of Brady's tenure there while Manning has never had a great defense. If you could find the time of possession i could guarantee you that Brady has had the ball in his hands a lot more than Manning.
Mastrlegacy02 1 month ago
@Mastrlegacy02 WOOOOOOOOOOA.? THE COLTS NEVER HAD A GRETA DEFENSE? wow. mathis, freeny, beathea, session,bullit, sanders way bak wen, hayden, just to name a few. ALL PROW BOWLERS AND ALL COLTS D PLAYERS. the patriots get rid of like half the team every year. like how many ppl on the patriots d since the superbowl are headline players? or big playmkakers? like 5. they just take players that other teams dnt kno how to use and make em good. dont make excuses for da colts.PEYTON STILL BEAST NO DOUBT
ApexPredator95 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
psh please. check this kid out yall! Seminole Ridge football Kevin jerome
pittsteel24 1 month ago
backround music...so annoying!!!!
j23sj 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tom Brady a Patriot? 3 rings
Peyton Manning a Colt? 1 ring
Tom Brady a Colt? 0 rings
Peyton Manning a Patriot? 4+rings
marvinowns1234 1 month ago
Tom Brady a Patriot? 3 rings
Peyton Manning a Colt? 1 ring
Tom Brady a Colt? 0 rings
Peyton Manning a Patriot? 4+rings
marvinowns1234 1 month ago