Judy Hsu plays La capricieuse by Edward Elgar

[1910th]

delete this shit, practice at home...who wants to see your crap??

[jameshoffnung]

There is no need to be nice and diplomatic about the things which I have to say about her playing. When one stands on a stage and post the video on You Tube, he or she expects to be judged. There is no need to sugar coat my comments just because they do not sound nice although it is nothing but the truth. A performer standing on the stage owes it to the audience to play decently so that he/she could embrace the audience into the music. She was obviously making a fool of herself on stage!!!

[TonicMike]

This is not bad. It's a little under-tempo and a couple spots could do with a little polishing but in general the intonation is not bad. Don't be discouraged by James. I don't think he was taking into account that this was a casual performance, not a major professional appearance.

[jameshoffnung]

Terribe!!!!!!!!!! If you have not mastered your up bow staccato, please do not play this piece.This is the worst performance of this piece which I have heard so far...Terrible...and your bow hand...looks so ugly.

[ItzhakRoxMySox]

There's a way to say these things and not be an ass about it.

[Bratsche2000]

i completely. This person was incredibly insensitive.

[heifetz87]

@jameshoffnung At least she is giving it a try music is about giving its not about perfection yes this piece requires a good up bow staccato technique but i give her credit for her playing this piece as its challenging

[DesiFuyuko]

@jameshoffnung lol at you, let's see you playing this perfectly, where's YOUR video? :P I bet you don't want comments of your kind in your videos.

おまえバカだなあぁ.. <.<

As for me, I think she's really brave for playing this live and she seems like a nice person too :)

[kamhandel2008]

連續的頓弓做得很干淨，左右手配合good.