I'm not a true believer, but if my son will ask me "What is GOD?", i Will make him listen to this live song and i will say "I don't know what is GOD, but i can tell you where you can find him.. in that guitar's phrasing at the end (8:35 - 8:42) , I know for sure that in this 7 seconds there is GOD" (sorry for my bad Eng)
They should have made a studio album with Bruford when Peter left the band... what a great line up it would have been...The true Genesis we all know would have kept its unique, magic sound...
fuck genesis vs pink floyd can we take them for what they are, they are both fucking incredable bands. but Floyd without gilmour is alot like Genesis without gabriel.
Give the gift of rare 70s Classic rock DVDs/CDs this holiday season
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Six of the Best Milton Keynes 1982 reunion CD set and MORE available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
'Supper's Ready' about Christ's Last Supper in the 'City of Eternal Sanctuary', al-Quds, or Jerusalem as it's known in English. The seven trumpets blowing at the apocolypse and guards of Magog swarming around as prohesised in the Bible. Christ is therefore the 'Guaranteed Eternal Sanctuary Man'. What a song!
I'm not the biggest Phil Collins fan, and I dislike the Genesis so called 'pop period', but you can't deny that Phil's performance here is great (its just that Gabriel's was BEYOND GREAT)!
Greatest piece of Rock Music. Period. The quality of Seconds Out Album however is unparalleled. Bruford or Chester Thompson - who cares? Both are the best of the best. You can set your watch on Thompson playing live on Seconds Out. Unbelievable with all these intricate parts. Saw them in 76 in Frankfurt. What a delight. How sad to watch what Collins, Banks and Rutherford later on made out of this. Shame on them. The lure of big money was to great.
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Six of the Best Milton Keynes 1982 reunion CD set and MORE available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
I retract my previous statement actualyl this is pt. VI & VII ie Apocalypse in 9/8 and As Sure As Eggs is Eggs (Aching Man's Feet) in the Peter Gabriel Verson off of the album foxtrot album (I like Phil Collins a bit more because he's not as "out there") if you know what I mean...
Far out the best version ever (seconds out version) So much better when phil sings it. Then the song comes to his full potentional with him. Still to bad there's no full (seconds out) version on YT
Phil Collins uined this band. His vocals cannot not match those of Peter Gabriel--especially when it starts reaching those operatic high spots. Apart a handful of songs post Gabriel they were a mere shadow of the band in their heyday. I like Phil Collins as a drummer, but nothing beyond that.. He emasculated Genesis of that cool strange quality. Thanks.
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Six of the Best Milton Keynes 1982 reunion CD set and MORE available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
I like Pink Floyd, but Genesis does blow them away without question! Every album of theirs kicks butt whereas some of Pink Floyd's music can put you to sleep.
pretty good for a drummer, phil allways sang good back up,peter does peter better and phil does phil. the old songs should stay peter.every thing after lamb is not the same type of music.i just dont like any thing after lamb, sorry but thats just the way it is for me and a lot of others to.
Well, I love both Phil Collins and Peter Gabriel. Peter Gabriel is an AWESOME solo artist since the early 80s, but without Collins on vocals, Genesis probably never would have become that GREAT! :-)
@Hannover1980 there has never been a deeper irony than you telling people to "grow up and become intelligent" while in the same post calling people "fags".
I agree with Hannover, Genesis with Collins singing is absolutely brilliant. I like the Gabriel era, but A trick of the tail, Wind and wuthering and And then there were three, also Duke are stunning pieces of work.Genesis is not good woith Gabriel and bad with Collins, that's stupid reasonement. There's not more authenticity with Gabriel and less with Philou! Music is not like that.
I Like Genesis better with Gabriel, and I don't like the post-Genesis Gabriel as much as I like Genesis with Gabriel. It's too bad in some ways they didn't stay together, but they also made a lotta music with varying degrees of success since. The posters who say get over it are closest to a sane perspective. Its all good.
@jmellopinheiro It is on the 2007 Remastered edition of "Trick of the tail". It comes as a double-disk, with this on a DVD (part of a 45 minute concert)
Can't abituate my ears at the voice of Phil..nothing compared to the original of Peter,Phil is only 1 of the greatest drummer,but leave Supper's Ready for Gabriel..IMHO
i've been sniffing around lots of other progressive bands lately, and there's alot of great stuff, but nothing comes close to this band, and supper's ready especially. a incredibly huge masterpiece
It's a shame...we're not able to see the first part of this great track!
And it's a shame either all that fuss about Gabriel vs. Collins. They are both wonderful performers, and their biggest difference was in the quality of their solo careers... As Genesis frontmen, they were both great!
Look people, I freakin WORSHIP Gabriel era Genesis. But the 76 and 77 tours are absolutely fantastic.
Suppers with Peter was great vocally, he does the vocals better than Phil, but the way they blow out the Apocalypse 9/8 with Bruford and Hackett just going ape shit is SO much better than they were in the Gabriel days.
To deny this shit isn't incredible, period, can only mean to me you worship Peter to the point where you don't actually like old Genesis anymore.
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set plus more rare, vintage Genesis from the 70s available at Tommygun Video please see our Youtube channel for link to web site, video/audio clips, and more info
@Hannover1980: Even as a fan who prefers Gabriel, I agree 100%. In his own way, Collins is just as good and there should be NO issue. Genesis is Genesis.
the only song in the world, except from the rain song by zeppelin, that can make me cry. it's just so incredibly beautiful and genious. thank you for this great upload
I can't stop listening to this song. Just pure power and majesty. Unreal. I'm starting to think that Genesis might have been an even greater band than Pink Floyd. Damn tough call to make... Guess there's no need to play favorites.
@1776Matthew I know, that's a tough call brother! I agree, I am a huge Pink floyd fan too, but Genesis was a powerhouse in the prog-rock era too! Phil was amazing as a drummer, just a long haired drummer, that suddenly had to "take over" as frontman. Jimmy Page didn't have to do that, or did any other band mate of huge bands of the time, Phil did it with pride, talent, and just pure "get r done" attitude!!! He was born for that role! made Genesis one of the greatest bands ever!
@livrafan excellent comment, couldn't have said it better, people harp on phil too much, he did a tremendous job and took them to the next level albeit a bit different but still good,thanks.
oh yaa i remember this concert at long beach bb &pc together on the drums fantastic! ya know phil was rated one of the top ten drummers in the world at the time bruford cant claim that sorry to say as good as he plays. also its a shame both have givin up playin the drums. phil was operated on recently so maybe he can take them up again when he recovers. with bill i think it was just a choice to retire. loved seeing them play together thanks for the viddy well little brother.
@unamax Completely disagree. Even the songs that Gabriel originally sang with Genesis seem to have been written SOLELY for the purpose of what they would later become when delivered by Phil's passionate and majestic vocals. The cohesion of the entire band and the delivery of the songs also seems far smoother with Phil as the frontman.
Gabriel's theatrics were more impressive, but he seemed like the odd man out. His solo material is excellent.
la mujer no esta durmiendo, esta meditando, tio! Que bueno era Bruford que estaba en todas! Y Phil lo sabía, claro. Aunque solo fuera para una temporada de conciertos merecia la pena tenerlo y su participación en el Seconds out lo confirma.
la mujer no esta durmiendo, esta meditando, tio! Que bueno era Bruford que estaba en todas! Y Phil lo sabía, claro. Aunque solo fuera para una temporada de conciertos merecia la pena tenerlo y su participación en el Seconds out lo confirma.
Well part of the problem here is that Phil Collins' vocals are inexplicably mixed pretty low on this particular recording. There are bootlegs from this tour, however, that prove ythat even at this early stage Collins could belt out "Apocalypse" as loud and with almost as much growl and power as Peter Gabriel.
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis Live in Montreal 1974 2CD set, Genesis Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
but whether they were 20 mintues or ten minutes or even five minutes the Genesis songs of that time were not hits you'd put on the radio. They had many dynamic sections in them that did not follow the formula of their 80's hits. Length alone does not define progressive rock. So his comment is really quite true if you don't take it too literally.
Which is an interesting comment because this is the ONLY 20 minute epic song they wrote in their entire history as a group. The only other songs that come even remotely close in terms of length are Cinema Show and The Musical Box which are less than half this length.
Don't get me wrong, I love Peter Gabriel, but Phil does an amazing job singing in this performance. Also I don't understand why everyone blames Phil for the move towards more "pop" music in the 80's. I have seen and read interviews of Tony and Mike who both said it was a band choice to move towards shorter songs because they simply couldn't keep making 20min epic songs anymore. They all wanted to try something new not just Phil.
one of the best live performances of suppers ready , simply stunning. As a drummer for me this is perfection, it has it all in this song. Just wish i could play as good as they do here
Got nothing against collins or his voice, I just prefer the compositions of early genesis. seconds out is one of my fave albums w collins singing(if i'm not mistaken) all gabriel era tunes. I mainly miss phil on drums and gabriel's stage presence/theatricality.
Mr Collins was decent replacement for P. Gabriel... as a singer. GENESIS was still the band we knew, or at least as close as it could be... But when S. Hackett left, only ...Robert Fripp could have replaced him sufficiently and bring new life to the band... but he declined to join... So a great progressive group turned into a mainstream HIT- producing company under the direction of P. C. ...eventually...
this band and this piece in particular is one of the reasons that I opened the Bible and read it...I will be forever grateful to them for that as well as for the remarkable music!!!
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis Live in Montreal 1974 2CD set, Genesis Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
I have seen Genesis 8x . Each one was so amazing. The concert put you in a trance that lasted for days.Watching this again still gives me goose bumps at 57!
I always did like gabriel over collins. and i wish mike rutherford spent moretime on his bass the playing guitar:(. I like two albums where colins was singing Trick of the tail and Wind & wurthering.
bill is a great drummer, but even he had trouble playin the apocalypse check out around 3.35 he seems confused and if you listen to the whole part, he seems to be playing 4/4 over the 9/8 time in many areas. he doesnt play as well with phil as chester did. they really complimented each other even alternating the fills within the same fill...my humble opinion ofcourse.....
@jimmygt4 I don't really see too huge of an issue. It's playing more in straight 8th notes to my ears, which would o'course compliment most any timing.
@jimmygt4 Yeah, I always liked performances with Chester more than with Bill, I listened to a soundboard bootleg from 1986 where they played In The Cage/...In That Quiet Earth/Supper's Ready from Apocalypse and the drumming was flawless
@jimmygt4 trust me ...if Bill is playing 4 over 9 he is doing it intentionally...listen to One Of A Kind...he loves to create that sort of tension...his words not mine
It's agony for my me to say this but I think Collins cuts the mustard here voice wise, but there's no theatrics, no presence, magic etc & he's still a twat
I've said it before and I'll say it again,Genesis just can't be beat! All the centuries of music evolution have led up to this bands 1971-1980 music. I don't think it can ever be surpassed. Gabriel or Collins,it doesn't matter,both have amazing voices. Though,I admit I am a little more partial to Collins voice.
In 1976, Genesis needed a hail mary pass to survive. Phil Collins caught that pass and made a touchdown. Gabriel was awesome and so is Phil. Different methods, but the band became one of rock's biggest acts because of both of them.
Collins is shouting into the mic. He cannot sing Gabriel era Genesis songs with any conviction. He does not have the intonation, power, the raw emotion or menace in his vocals conveyed by Gabriel, who fully understood what he was singing about - that is, the inner conflict between good and evil; and how good triumphs in the end.
In my eyes it´s very strange that the only track Bill B. plays on Seconds Out is Cinema Show ! He is so much more better than Chester T. and also Phil C.! Perhaps it´s Phil who don´t like better musicians like himselfe ?! Obviously he has a Gabriel trauma !
Genesis, Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis, Live in Montreal 1974 2CD set, Genesis, Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygun Video, see youtube channel for link, video/audio clips and more info
whichever drummer came in with the china cymbal at 3:49 that was sick, possibly my favorite part of this video. I can't tell who it was but I love both of them already.
Dude -- You are so off-based that as a metaphor I'd like to see you trying to take a lead off first base in baseball -you'd only be too easy to be picked off (if you can understand English -- "mountaine"). Nuf-said. Phil does an AWESOME job on this and showed his stuff on this tour. Not to say I didn't like Peter-- he was great and brought Genesis to the beginning of their pinnacle.
I still find it amazing to return to this and think "How F'n LUCKY was Genesis to have a top notch singer in waiting behind the drums when Pete left?" The fact that he had the vocal abilities, range, and came from within are what saved them. As great as the band were I'm not positive another outside singer would have been welcomed like Phil was.
There's an angel standing in the sun, and he's crying in a loud voice, "this is the supper of the mighty one(s)" aka, Phil, Chester, Bill, Mike, Tony, Steve, Peter. Not all at one time of course, but still.
I imagine that I was that guy holding her in my past life. She wanted to go see Grease in the movie theater and I said we're over unless you come with me to see Genesis.
Genesis has such a history that it sparks debates arguing which singer/drummer/guitarist fits the band the best.... lol..... actually every member Genesis ever had in the band were completely KICK ASS to the max.
I like Phil, and I like Peter. Enough on that note already. I'm sure it's more of an amusement to both of them at this point to see that people are still talking about it.
Ich konnte den Hype um Bill Bruford noch nie nachvollziehen. Chester Thompson spielt vielleicht weniger spektakulär, aber dafür weitaus musikalischer.
I generally steer away from cursing, but when I see this fantastic stuff and compare it to today's complete no-talent hi-hop garbage that is revered as genius, I want to curse. The 70's was a great time for music.
Peter was gone in 74, then began slowly the Collins area, progressiv music didn't last 4-5 years that period, and after Genesis did something else, more commercial, even if I prefer the genius they had in the early times, I must admit they continue to have... in their 80' to 90' period, listening and enjoying remains an affair of moments, anyway
@GuanoApe420 Aww...I prefer Peter, but Phil had a lot of guts to take over for Peter. And he did a good job. Wouldn't you have preferred Phil take over singing than some no-name hire?
@pazzensutra Aww, you know one of the reasons Gabriel left? Jealous band mates! Collins being first in line. I heard a recording where Gabriel was introducing a song and Collins was supposed to start playing when Gabriel stopped the introduction and didn't, he apologized to the crowd and said he was sleeping, totally disrespecting Gabriel and insinuating Gabriel was long winded. F Collins
@Drewper73 - Yes had moments, but fell to repetitve indulgence. Rush had skills, but not bardship or depth. Crimson had dreamspheres but only in a few songs. Genesis kept on "bringing it"! The power of The Apocalypse, tenderness of "The Musical Box", surreal imagery of "Blood on the Rooftops". Coma victims were "Entangled", "Nursery Crymes", visit from a nature god in "One from the Vine", lamentations of drought victims in "Mad Man Moon", lost warriors in "11th Earl" ...I could go on and on.
I'm not a true believer, but if my son will ask me "What is GOD?", i Will make him listen to this live song and i will say "I don't know what is GOD, but i can tell you where you can find him.. in that guitar's phrasing at the end (8:35 - 8:42) , I know for sure that in this 7 seconds there is GOD" (sorry for my bad Eng)
f0ns0r 4 hours ago
i think ive already posted this but: this coems close to orgasm
NeedHeadMusic 2 days ago
They should have made a studio album with Bruford when Peter left the band... what a great line up it would have been...The true Genesis we all know would have kept its unique, magic sound...
GiorgioRocker92 1 week ago
This is incredible footage thank you so much for sharing
Possesssed666 1 week ago
This is Phil at his absolute best. The vocal at the end here is stunning.
sluice 1 week ago
Bill Bruford. Damn,
jibif 3 weeks ago
fuck genesis vs pink floyd can we take them for what they are, they are both fucking incredable bands. but Floyd without gilmour is alot like Genesis without gabriel.
KronikMasterb8r 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Give the gift of rare 70s Classic rock DVDs/CDs this holiday season
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Six of the Best Milton Keynes 1982 reunion CD set and MORE available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
Tommygun1028 1 month ago
'Supper's Ready' about Christ's Last Supper in the 'City of Eternal Sanctuary', al-Quds, or Jerusalem as it's known in English. The seven trumpets blowing at the apocolypse and guards of Magog swarming around as prohesised in the Bible. Christ is therefore the 'Guaranteed Eternal Sanctuary Man'. What a song!
nickhubbardtube 1 month ago
the only thing that burns me is that during Tonys keyboard parts they put the camera on everybody else EXCEPT him
TheCrocBoss 1 month ago
Phil Collins and Bill Bruford 2 of the best drummers, and on stage together, wow.
GregMagDrums 1 month ago
I'm not the biggest Phil Collins fan, and I dislike the Genesis so called 'pop period', but you can't deny that Phil's performance here is great (its just that Gabriel's was BEYOND GREAT)!
FredericoCoelhoNunes 1 month ago
Greatest piece of Rock Music. Period. The quality of Seconds Out Album however is unparalleled. Bruford or Chester Thompson - who cares? Both are the best of the best. You can set your watch on Thompson playing live on Seconds Out. Unbelievable with all these intricate parts. Saw them in 76 in Frankfurt. What a delight. How sad to watch what Collins, Banks and Rutherford later on made out of this. Shame on them. The lure of big money was to great.
gillan5 2 months ago
Where is part one?
kfsfkakf 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Six of the Best Milton Keynes 1982 reunion CD set and MORE available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
ClassicRockDVD 2 months ago
phil collins i god, but peter gabriel is better
diego36871 2 months ago
I retract my previous statement actualyl this is pt. VI & VII ie Apocalypse in 9/8 and As Sure As Eggs is Eggs (Aching Man's Feet) in the Peter Gabriel Verson off of the album foxtrot album (I like Phil Collins a bit more because he's not as "out there") if you know what I mean...
DJD1ed 2 months ago
In the Peter Gabriel version this is actually pt. III
DJD1ed 2 months ago
bill bruford is great. best drummer .check out king crimson,he,s at his best.
jeff42416 3 months ago
Far out the best version ever (seconds out version) So much better when phil sings it. Then the song comes to his full potentional with him. Still to bad there's no full (seconds out) version on YT
Gengske10 3 months ago
Phil Collins uined this band. His vocals cannot not match those of Peter Gabriel--especially when it starts reaching those operatic high spots. Apart a handful of songs post Gabriel they were a mere shadow of the band in their heyday. I like Phil Collins as a drummer, but nothing beyond that.. He emasculated Genesis of that cool strange quality. Thanks.
madahad9 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Six of the Best Milton Keynes 1982 reunion CD set and MORE available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
ClassicRockDVD 3 months ago
I like Pink Floyd, but Genesis does blow them away without question! Every album of theirs kicks butt whereas some of Pink Floyd's music can put you to sleep.
HMan431 3 months ago
wow, realmente disfruté la interpretacion de bruford, excelente!
DanotronKbd 3 months ago
pretty good for a drummer, phil allways sang good back up,peter does peter better and phil does phil. the old songs should stay peter.every thing after lamb is not the same type of music.i just dont like any thing after lamb, sorry but thats just the way it is for me and a lot of others to.
TheStrainers 4 months ago
Well, I love both Phil Collins and Peter Gabriel. Peter Gabriel is an AWESOME solo artist since the early 80s, but without Collins on vocals, Genesis probably never would have become that GREAT! :-)
MrKnopf 4 months ago
Comment removed
TheMistermies 4 months ago
@Hannover1980 there has never been a deeper irony than you telling people to "grow up and become intelligent" while in the same post calling people "fags".
kwakky 4 months ago 7
i love that hair move 2:35 <3
Recorderer94 4 months ago
genesis to revelations
TheMistermies 5 months ago
gabriel was so good though
TheMistermies 5 months ago
4:30 = Baked out of their minds. Talk about stoned. They can't be bored can they?
bkbeban 5 months ago
I agree with Hannover, Genesis with Collins singing is absolutely brilliant. I like the Gabriel era, but A trick of the tail, Wind and wuthering and And then there were three, also Duke are stunning pieces of work.Genesis is not good woith Gabriel and bad with Collins, that's stupid reasonement. There's not more authenticity with Gabriel and less with Philou! Music is not like that.
jeanray3 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
New progressive rock coming out soon band type ''innerspaceband''
Sim2428 5 months ago
I Like Genesis better with Gabriel, and I don't like the post-Genesis Gabriel as much as I like Genesis with Gabriel. It's too bad in some ways they didn't stay together, but they also made a lotta music with varying degrees of success since. The posters who say get over it are closest to a sane perspective. Its all good.
NotoriousAWOL 5 months ago
what is that tone Banks is using in the beginning of the video? it sounds so awesome
mja09006 5 months ago
@mja09006 sounds like the "fuzz Guitar" preset on the Arp
wilecuyote 5 months ago
Great post man! From where did u get this video?
jmellopinheiro 5 months ago
@jmellopinheiro It is on the 2007 Remastered edition of "Trick of the tail". It comes as a double-disk, with this on a DVD (part of a 45 minute concert)
1776Matthew 5 months ago
Anyway amazing MASTERPIECE..
BAxitorCH 5 months ago
Can't abituate my ears at the voice of Phil..nothing compared to the original of Peter,Phil is only 1 of the greatest drummer,but leave Supper's Ready for Gabriel..IMHO
BAxitorCH 5 months ago
4:16-4:53
Amazing
timmylikesgenesis 6 months ago
i've been sniffing around lots of other progressive bands lately, and there's alot of great stuff, but nothing comes close to this band, and supper's ready especially. a incredibly huge masterpiece
halflaifjee 6 months ago
It's a shame...we're not able to see the first part of this great track!
And it's a shame either all that fuss about Gabriel vs. Collins. They are both wonderful performers, and their biggest difference was in the quality of their solo careers... As Genesis frontmen, they were both great!
2Slipperman 6 months ago 2
Look people, I freakin WORSHIP Gabriel era Genesis. But the 76 and 77 tours are absolutely fantastic.
Suppers with Peter was great vocally, he does the vocals better than Phil, but the way they blow out the Apocalypse 9/8 with Bruford and Hackett just going ape shit is SO much better than they were in the Gabriel days.
To deny this shit isn't incredible, period, can only mean to me you worship Peter to the point where you don't actually like old Genesis anymore.
harpua13a 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set plus more rare, vintage Genesis from the 70s available at Tommygun Video please see our Youtube channel for link to web site, video/audio clips, and more info
Tommygun1028 6 months ago
@Hannover1980: Even as a fan who prefers Gabriel, I agree 100%. In his own way, Collins is just as good and there should be NO issue. Genesis is Genesis.
mhspiper 6 months ago
This never, ever, EVER gets old.
sinistre 6 months ago
14 people are late for supper.
royism 7 months ago
The true spirit of the Band was Hackett.Stop it.
MoonlightKnight94 7 months ago 2
the only song in the world, except from the rain song by zeppelin, that can make me cry. it's just so incredibly beautiful and genious. thank you for this great upload
halflaifjee 7 months ago
Hands down phil collins blows. Peter gabriel had the true spirit of the band.
cenecasful 7 months ago
I can't stop listening to this song. Just pure power and majesty. Unreal. I'm starting to think that Genesis might have been an even greater band than Pink Floyd. Damn tough call to make... Guess there's no need to play favorites.
1776Matthew 7 months ago 16
@1776Matthew listen to the original too! Both are good
SRNF 5 months ago
@1776Matthew I know, that's a tough call brother! I agree, I am a huge Pink floyd fan too, but Genesis was a powerhouse in the prog-rock era too! Phil was amazing as a drummer, just a long haired drummer, that suddenly had to "take over" as frontman. Jimmy Page didn't have to do that, or did any other band mate of huge bands of the time, Phil did it with pride, talent, and just pure "get r done" attitude!!! He was born for that role! made Genesis one of the greatest bands ever!
livrafan 3 months ago
@livrafan Yessir.
1776Matthew 3 months ago
@livrafan excellent comment, couldn't have said it better, people harp on phil too much, he did a tremendous job and took them to the next level albeit a bit different but still good,thanks.
dntlss 1 month ago
outstanding
ocean686 7 months ago
5:06 -perfectly illustrates how I feel whenever I hear this song---blown away. Peace:-)
binnyman 7 months ago
The boomer generation were spoiled rotten with music. The greatest music of all time was recorded in the 70s.
shackle5 7 months ago
good song to listen to for the end of the rapture today
Trimbler00 8 months ago
oh yaa i remember this concert at long beach bb &pc together on the drums fantastic! ya know phil was rated one of the top ten drummers in the world at the time bruford cant claim that sorry to say as good as he plays. also its a shame both have givin up playin the drums. phil was operated on recently so maybe he can take them up again when he recovers. with bill i think it was just a choice to retire. loved seeing them play together thanks for the viddy well little brother.
maxinedal 8 months ago
poor phill ... light years behind peter gabriel...oooh my God
unamax 8 months ago
@unamax Completely disagree. Even the songs that Gabriel originally sang with Genesis seem to have been written SOLELY for the purpose of what they would later become when delivered by Phil's passionate and majestic vocals. The cohesion of the entire band and the delivery of the songs also seems far smoother with Phil as the frontman.
Gabriel's theatrics were more impressive, but he seemed like the odd man out. His solo material is excellent.
1776Matthew 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
la mujer no esta durmiendo, esta meditando, tio! Que bueno era Bruford que estaba en todas! Y Phil lo sabía, claro. Aunque solo fuera para una temporada de conciertos merecia la pena tenerlo y su participación en el Seconds out lo confirma.
millonety123 9 months ago
la mujer no esta durmiendo, esta meditando, tio! Que bueno era Bruford que estaba en todas! Y Phil lo sabía, claro. Aunque solo fuera para una temporada de conciertos merecia la pena tenerlo y su participación en el Seconds out lo confirma.
millonety123 9 months ago
Blasphemy detected comment. Woman sleeps while Gods are playing. Verrily she must be stoned...but then quite a few of us already were.
MrGrace55 9 months ago
Well part of the problem here is that Phil Collins' vocals are inexplicably mixed pretty low on this particular recording. There are bootlegs from this tour, however, that prove ythat even at this early stage Collins could belt out "Apocalypse" as loud and with almost as much growl and power as Peter Gabriel.
TheMichaelPeterson 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis Live in Montreal 1974 2CD set, Genesis Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
ClassicRockDVD 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
COME TAKE A LOOK A TOUR BAND : JUST TYPE ‘’OVERHEAD-MUZ’’ ON MYSPACE. THANKS !!! WE ALSO HAVE A FACEBOOK PAGE!!!
Sim2428 10 months ago
Collins, stop singing. Please.
Treqqua57 10 months ago
@Treqqua57 Quite agree, never liked Collins's voice or his choreographics but
still you have to admit that he's the best choice for imitating Gabriel.
BrainStillLife 10 months ago
did they play part 1 as well? or did the just jump right at part 2?
koleola 10 months ago
but whether they were 20 mintues or ten minutes or even five minutes the Genesis songs of that time were not hits you'd put on the radio. They had many dynamic sections in them that did not follow the formula of their 80's hits. Length alone does not define progressive rock. So his comment is really quite true if you don't take it too literally.
MrJesseG123 10 months ago
Which is an interesting comment because this is the ONLY 20 minute epic song they wrote in their entire history as a group. The only other songs that come even remotely close in terms of length are Cinema Show and The Musical Box which are less than half this length.
CalvertdeGrey 10 months ago
Don't get me wrong, I love Peter Gabriel, but Phil does an amazing job singing in this performance. Also I don't understand why everyone blames Phil for the move towards more "pop" music in the 80's. I have seen and read interviews of Tony and Mike who both said it was a band choice to move towards shorter songs because they simply couldn't keep making 20min epic songs anymore. They all wanted to try something new not just Phil.
bluetickgamer 11 months ago
I think Phil does some Gabriel songs just as good as Gabriel did but I think Peter has him beat on this one
Heroiclink1 11 months ago 2
gabriel ever was the best singer and performancer from genesis!!
koboldfranz 11 months ago
brufords cool, but Phil plays from the heart and soul....
rdety 11 months ago
one of the best live performances of suppers ready , simply stunning. As a drummer for me this is perfection, it has it all in this song. Just wish i could play as good as they do here
SuperDaz34 11 months ago
Got nothing against collins or his voice, I just prefer the compositions of early genesis. seconds out is one of my fave albums w collins singing(if i'm not mistaken) all gabriel era tunes. I mainly miss phil on drums and gabriel's stage presence/theatricality.
codebabe 11 months ago 2
O-O-X O-X O-O-O-X (repeat)
ravello99 11 months ago
@ravello99 Apocalypse's structure =D
CoTeCiOtm 11 months ago
Mr Collins was decent replacement for P. Gabriel... as a singer. GENESIS was still the band we knew, or at least as close as it could be... But when S. Hackett left, only ...Robert Fripp could have replaced him sufficiently and bring new life to the band... but he declined to join... So a great progressive group turned into a mainstream HIT- producing company under the direction of P. C. ...eventually...
MrLizardisle 11 months ago
oh my fucking god
this is beyond awsome
koleola 11 months ago 2
Phill = Phill. Gabriel = Gabriel. Both Are insanely talented but not comparable. Discussion end?
papaginseng 11 months ago
Melhor música da humanidade.
Dunhovisques 11 months ago
Ah, the Gabriel/Collins pissing contest continues.
petsounds75 11 months ago
Collins Sucks! Gabriel Rules!
Treqqua57 11 months ago
@Treqqua57 Phil Collins is an awesome drummer,but your right as a far as lead singers go Peter Gabriel rules
blutocampbell 11 months ago
@blutocampbell Yeah, Collins is a great drummer, but as leader Gabriel is better. (I'm Italian, i' don't know if i wrote well)
Treqqua57 11 months ago
Comment removed
blutocampbell 11 months ago
@Treqqua57 lol yeah I can understand it.Phil is one of my influences in my drumming
blutocampbell 11 months ago
@blutocampbell :) Tony Banks is one of my influences as a keyboardist.
SPeacock 11 months ago
@SPeacock Bill Bruford and Phil Collins are both my influences in my drumming.
blutocampbell 11 months ago
this band and this piece in particular is one of the reasons that I opened the Bible and read it...I will be forever grateful to them for that as well as for the remarkable music!!!
puppylover7117 1 year ago
brufford played with 3 best prog rock bands...with this tour the mission was complete!
Hrci04 1 year ago
@Hrci04 Don't forget UK (the band)
jossy2112 1 year ago
@jossy2112 yes i know and the rest of albums and projects i have
Hrci04 11 months ago
My motherfucking heroes right here.
ANOMTOfficial 1 year ago
4:28 "man i thought gabriel was gonna be singing"
tranthu02 1 year ago
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb Live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis Live in Montreal 1974 2CD set, Genesis Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygunvideo, see our channel info for link video/audio clips and more info
ClassicRockDVD 1 year ago
I have seen Genesis 8x . Each one was so amazing. The concert put you in a trance that lasted for days.Watching this again still gives me goose bumps at 57!
headman1953 1 year ago
I always did like gabriel over collins. and i wish mike rutherford spent moretime on his bass the playing guitar:(. I like two albums where colins was singing Trick of the tail and Wind & wurthering.
MrRush1974 1 year ago
bill is a great drummer, but even he had trouble playin the apocalypse check out around 3.35 he seems confused and if you listen to the whole part, he seems to be playing 4/4 over the 9/8 time in many areas. he doesnt play as well with phil as chester did. they really complimented each other even alternating the fills within the same fill...my humble opinion ofcourse.....
jimmygt4 1 year ago
@jimmygt4 I don't really see too huge of an issue. It's playing more in straight 8th notes to my ears, which would o'course compliment most any key.
Again, just my opinion though!
MasterYumyums 1 year ago
@jimmygt4 I don't really see too huge of an issue. It's playing more in straight 8th notes to my ears, which would o'course compliment most any timing.
Again, just my opinion though!
MasterYumyums 1 year ago
@jimmygt4 Yeah, I always liked performances with Chester more than with Bill, I listened to a soundboard bootleg from 1986 where they played In The Cage/...In That Quiet Earth/Supper's Ready from Apocalypse and the drumming was flawless
CoTeCiOtm 11 months ago
@jimmygt4 trust me ...if Bill is playing 4 over 9 he is doing it intentionally...listen to One Of A Kind...he loves to create that sort of tension...his words not mine
poodleenvy 3 weeks ago
It's agony for my me to say this but I think Collins cuts the mustard here voice wise, but there's no theatrics, no presence, magic etc & he's still a twat
66hoopick66 1 year ago
I've said it before and I'll say it again,Genesis just can't be beat! All the centuries of music evolution have led up to this bands 1971-1980 music. I don't think it can ever be surpassed. Gabriel or Collins,it doesn't matter,both have amazing voices. Though,I admit I am a little more partial to Collins voice.
RalfsLab 1 year ago
@RalfsLab yes and genesis will always be the greatest to me
nintendo64isking 1 year ago
In 1976, Genesis needed a hail mary pass to survive. Phil Collins caught that pass and made a touchdown. Gabriel was awesome and so is Phil. Different methods, but the band became one of rock's biggest acts because of both of them.
Raughwe 1 year ago
@Hannover1980
apart from you unintellegent remark about roman sex slaves I agree,
curemeoflove 1 year ago
This song just loses its magic without Gabriel
Timbarwell 1 year ago
grandi genesis ormai siete IMMORTALI
pirrupain1 1 year ago 6
I think Bill should of have been a pernament member of Genesis when Phil became frontman.
blutocampbell 1 year ago 3
Collins is shouting into the mic. He cannot sing Gabriel era Genesis songs with any conviction. He does not have the intonation, power, the raw emotion or menace in his vocals conveyed by Gabriel, who fully understood what he was singing about - that is, the inner conflict between good and evil; and how good triumphs in the end.
ThefightingCelt 1 year ago
@Hannover1980 German opinions don't count so feck off
ThefightingCelt 1 year ago
I hope somehow the Full Footage will appear... This would be so great
illegalalien2 1 year ago
Not even close to Peter Gabriel's Version!!
VoooooooDooooooo 1 year ago
@blutocampbell Um that would be Phil Collins.
kitchensj 1 year ago
Who's playing drums at 3;25 along with Bill Bruford
blutocampbell 1 year ago
In my eyes it´s very strange that the only track Bill B. plays on Seconds Out is Cinema Show ! He is so much more better than Chester T. and also Phil C.! Perhaps it´s Phil who don´t like better musicians like himselfe ?! Obviously he has a Gabriel trauma !
drjekyll66 1 year ago
Genesis, Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set, Genesis, The Lamb live at the Shrine 1975 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Genesis, Live in Montreal 1974 2CD set, Genesis, Live in Zurich 1977 2CD set available at Tommygun Video, see youtube channel for link, video/audio clips and more info
Tommygun1028 1 year ago
NOTHING without PETER!!!!!!
boz6969123 1 year ago
whichever drummer came in with the china cymbal at 3:49 that was sick, possibly my favorite part of this video. I can't tell who it was but I love both of them already.
MrJesseG123 1 year ago
Bring back the beard Collins. Bring back the beard.
FredMalm 1 year ago
bruford absolutly bright ! ....
jazzharmonie 1 year ago
Comment removed
Kristopful 1 year ago
@Kristopful
Dude -- You are so off-based that as a metaphor I'd like to see you trying to take a lead off first base in baseball -you'd only be too easy to be picked off (if you can understand English -- "mountaine"). Nuf-said. Phil does an AWESOME job on this and showed his stuff on this tour. Not to say I didn't like Peter-- he was great and brought Genesis to the beginning of their pinnacle.
BruceS1111 1 year ago
The audience looked like that because they were shell shocked
runntum 1 year ago
I still find it amazing to return to this and think "How F'n LUCKY was Genesis to have a top notch singer in waiting behind the drums when Pete left?" The fact that he had the vocal abilities, range, and came from within are what saved them. As great as the band were I'm not positive another outside singer would have been welcomed like Phil was.
cranie4 1 year ago
This video was hearing this song for the first time again.
all the way down to the shivers.
stuffedsonic 1 year ago
The faces at 4:21 say one thing.....WHERE IS GABRIEL??!!
gowestward1 1 year ago
This was Gabriel's baby
gowestward1 1 year ago
There's an angel standing in the sun, and he's crying in a loud voice, "this is the supper of the mighty one(s)" aka, Phil, Chester, Bill, Mike, Tony, Steve, Peter. Not all at one time of course, but still.
rozeem6 1 year ago
4:27 - Blasphemy detected. Woman sleeps while Gods are playing.
natethegreat1985 1 year ago 68
@natethegreat1985
I imagine that I was that guy holding her in my past life. She wanted to go see Grease in the movie theater and I said we're over unless you come with me to see Genesis.
ANOMTOfficial 1 year ago
@natethegreat1985 wrong...... he is referring to men.
RockinRealtorVegas 11 months ago
@natethegreat1985 She was probably totally wasted
onilvehs 10 months ago
@natethegreat1985 best comment ever!!! lol
Laminateddeffect 6 months ago
The Good old days
jimthedrummer1963 1 year ago
during this tour i have never seen Rutheford more into it thn this!!!!
44hornet 1 year ago
I Hope that someday the Complete Concert will appear like with Lyceum 80... This would be soo great
illegalalien2 1 year ago
If this music is heaven, then i wanna be in heaven.
If this music is hell, then i wanna goto hell.
Regardless what it is, it is unique and out of this world.
vfrmilco 1 year ago 2
14 people need to born again... =/
xthixx 1 year ago
Only a snippet of Supper's Ready, but one of the best. That 9/8 time signature blows my mind.
adamtzsch 1 year ago
Genesis has such a history that it sparks debates arguing which singer/drummer/guitarist fits the band the best.... lol..... actually every member Genesis ever had in the band were completely KICK ASS to the max.
lastertower 1 year ago 4
I´ve seen them several times. But Bill Brufor on Drums was simply the greatest! And he still is....
deirfgeisllots 1 year ago 4
I always wonder why the video skips the laser parts and shows the film footage. It was the first concert to ever use a laser in the show.
KDawgJamz 1 year ago
Bill Brufford ¡¡¡MASTER!!!
Cascabel40 1 year ago 11
this is the meaning of magic
erik8666 1 year ago 3
Phil Collins just can't do this. Wasted.
chrisguygeezer 1 year ago
@chrisguygeezer have you heard the seconds out verson? it is much better
grevgnu 1 year ago
Sorry Phil, you cant sing that song well, althrough you are awesome
flyingsayon 1 year ago
I like Phil, and I like Peter. Enough on that note already. I'm sure it's more of an amusement to both of them at this point to see that people are still talking about it.
capth00k 1 year ago
second`s out album?
peruman2009 1 year ago
Can you imagine Phil Collins and Jon Anderson of Yes singing together? It would be amazing!
saarnoldbhm 1 year ago 2
@saarnoldbhm lol YES that would be awesome; throw in John Wetton as well and it would be more awesome than before. And Ian Anderson too haha
MrJesseG123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Genesis Six Hours Live 1972-1980 2DVD set available at Tommygunvideo see our channel for link and details
Tommygun1028 1 year ago
Ich konnte den Hype um Bill Bruford noch nie nachvollziehen. Chester Thompson spielt vielleicht weniger spektakulär, aber dafür weitaus musikalischer.
hochi81 1 year ago
They don't make 'em like this any more.. sadly.
nickhubbardtube 1 year ago 4
I generally steer away from cursing, but when I see this fantastic stuff and compare it to today's complete no-talent hi-hop garbage that is revered as genius, I want to curse. The 70's was a great time for music.
pazzensutra 1 year ago
i love the fact that where Keith Emerson would have a wine bottle by his keyboard, Tony Banks has a glass of orange juice! :P
remnrone 1 year ago
Anything out there like this today?
I don't think so...
wjf1950 1 year ago
infreakincredible! Thanks so much for sharing!
dawnmarieb 1 year ago
Peter was gone in 74, then began slowly the Collins area, progressiv music didn't last 4-5 years that period, and after Genesis did something else, more commercial, even if I prefer the genius they had in the early times, I must admit they continue to have... in their 80' to 90' period, listening and enjoying remains an affair of moments, anyway
markusmala 1 year ago
wtf. where's pete?
was he gone in 76?
firefly666x 1 year ago
@firefly666x 1975
PeterMayer 1 year ago
Collins looks like a bald Jesus. "A new Jerusalem" indeed..
simonyricools 1 year ago
F*ck phil collins, I'll take Gabriel any day doing these classics.
GuanoApe420 1 year ago
@GuanoApe420 Aww...I prefer Peter, but Phil had a lot of guts to take over for Peter. And he did a good job. Wouldn't you have preferred Phil take over singing than some no-name hire?
pazzensutra 1 year ago
@pazzensutra Aww, you know one of the reasons Gabriel left? Jealous band mates! Collins being first in line. I heard a recording where Gabriel was introducing a song and Collins was supposed to start playing when Gabriel stopped the introduction and didn't, he apologized to the crowd and said he was sleeping, totally disrespecting Gabriel and insinuating Gabriel was long winded. F Collins
GuanoApe420 1 year ago
@GuanoApe420 I believe that was a planned comedy routine worked out between Gabriel and Collins.
TheMichaelPeterson 1 year ago
I can see why they got rid of Bruford. Flash twat. Long live Chester Thompson!!
Penguinarmy69 1 year ago
@Penguinarmy69 totally agree on this one, though he's "usually" very good
simonyricools 1 year ago
@Drewper73 - Yes had moments, but fell to repetitve indulgence. Rush had skills, but not bardship or depth. Crimson had dreamspheres but only in a few songs. Genesis kept on "bringing it"! The power of The Apocalypse, tenderness of "The Musical Box", surreal imagery of "Blood on the Rooftops". Coma victims were "Entangled", "Nursery Crymes", visit from a nature god in "One from the Vine", lamentations of drought victims in "Mad Man Moon", lost warriors in "11th Earl" ...I could go on and on.
jeffteach