"Can't you see that the pace has fallen behind" wait, so for the past 10 years I thought he was saying "Can't you see that the passengers are fucking behind" Oh well, makes more sense now
You guys are so intelligent, discussing religion. After all, all the world's greatest thinkers discuss their beliefs and the beliefs of others on YouTube.
every equinox there is a new messiah we are now in the image of pisces (jesus) before that was the ram (moses) next is aquarius which will bring forth a new messiah...
@gamemstr98765431 Organized religion is hypocritical, and an oxymoron, but religion itself is an expression of the self reflective element of humanity.
@gamemstr98765431 Fundamentalist Christians say you have to accept the whole Bible w/ their interpretation of it, but its really a set of books you have to look at separately. The virgin birth, his roll as the messiah, the resurrection, his exclusive role as God incarnate, etc were all hotly contested issues by the early church. What I find of value is what they didn't disagree on, and that's his values, his heart, and the holy spirit. PM me if you'd like to discuss more.
A mordern Jesus would have to be in a middle class, they would have been spoiled but not all the time, they would have been stricken but not all the time, not too rich, not to poor, some were in the middle of the dertermind spirial.
@BluePooSonic I'm not sure about that. I think the significance of Jesus was that he could have become an all powerful, earthly king because of his Davidic bloodline. Instead of becoming another tyrant, like Alexander the Great or Atillia the Hun, he decided to spread love, even when the absolute opposite of love was returned. If people really tried to do what he did, as opposed to placing him on this unobtainable pedestal, the world would be a better place.
@joshjh47 If "we" means everyone else on this page, the only reason I wrote about Jesus was to respond to someone else who was writing about Jesus being born today as a modern messiah. My point is we can be the modern messiah by having the kind of love he had for his fellow humanity, We don't need to wait for someone else to do what were capable of doing.
once my legacey is born, i will motor my self, i will speach the unspoken, i will stand for all life. i will be crucified, slain for it, but my effect will last another 2000 years(Era)
i just want to walk through a really suburban park and just grab people's faces and shout the lyrics in their faces. just so that person has a weird story to tell for the rest of their life
Liberate our minds be the messiahs, all of us as one. Bring world peace once and for all! Join the Peaceful Revolution. Bring world peace once and for all.
@FFVII95 Who cares? It's some form of metal/rock, let's just enjoy the song and forget about which hardcore genre it is. Again, agreeing with the pop talk.
@styxinyourneck09 That's got to be the dumbest thing I've ever read. Just because a bunch of mindless morons like something that doesn't make it good. Please do the world a favor and go jump off a bridge. Oh and take your gay ass pop music with you faggot.
Ever since the sickness album, i've fallen in love with these guys....they just did something not alot of people are good at...and their FUCKING AMAZING
You are, enemy You are my hated enemy I am enemy Number one rated enemy I'm a labelled enemy I am your mortal enemy My actions enemy Make me your bitter enemy All the world around enemy They're tearing up the ground enemy They're drawn in by the sound Enemy, enemy I must eliminate my Enemy Your people, enemy My people's hated enemy What are you, enemy Though a created enemy Terminate the, enemy Eradicate the hated enemy I am an enemy My very greatest enemy
@tallyGuRl604 u said hardcore and gruesome then u said my chemical romance and greenday im not putting them bands down but they are not hardcore or gruesome thats punk rock trust me i know alot bout music i was listening to disturbed and slipknot wen u were still in diapers hahaha
@tallyGuRl604 calm down keyboard warrior there is alot of ppl who would agree with what i said im not judging you one bit but u cant put my chemical romance in the same category as disturbed u got alot to learn bout music
One thing I admire in Disturbed is the lyrics...the lack of brain in the songs today is simply absurd, I'm glad there are still people who care about what they say ;)
@m111122 its just strait up heavy. all these sub genres are 2 confusing. (yes i know rock and metal r 2 different genres) but if i had 2 pick one it would be more towards hard rock/alternative metal.
@TaylorKazarian ya most people dont relize it but rocks still pretty damn popular. only about 60% of TEENS listen to rap/pop/rnb and about 30% listen to rock/metal. and thats just teens, also add a shit load of people from the 80s and people in there 20s
@genius13100 I can show you REAL hip hop videos that have less than a thousand views. Shitty mainstream music has the masses enthralled. It's really sad.
@genius13100 it isnt loosing against rap and pop just cause the new generation like rap and pop think about the hundreds of millions of people from the 60 to preasent day that love rock
@death2160 Yeah for sure. The problem is hip hop is way to easy to trend on, and any clown with a mike and a music program thinks he's a rapper or a DJ. You can't fake talent when it comes to using guitars and drums, relying on raw sound.
@NINJASE7EN yea though it is still very difficult to actualy get a beat to work for a dj my cousin who is one told me that cause you have to have realy good cordination. but you are still very true it is harder for a drummer guitar and vocalist to get in perfect harmony
@death2160 Turntables and wax are the real way to DJ in my opinion. Beat juggling, scratches, and mixing are all manual, which definitely displays musical talent. I respect anything that takes talent to make. Except country. I don't care how much talent is put into that! ;)
@NINJASE7EN heh i only realy like the turntables and jeyboard in industrial music check out rammsteinby rammstein live at volkerball man its fucking epic. heh it explains visualy why they make marilyn manson concerts look like a child daycare
Comment removed
Experiences112 1 day ago
Nation shall not raise sword against nation >:(
0RespectMyAuthority0 1 week ago 3
airsoftmania1000 wat kind of pussy uses airsoft battle to fight hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
o6Slip6knot6o 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Who is liberated? Check your mind to find out...
Tarday 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Who is liberated? Check your mind to find out...
Tarday 2 weeks ago
Who is liberated? Check your mind to find out...
Tarday 2 weeks ago
"Can't you see that the pace has fallen behind" wait, so for the past 10 years I thought he was saying "Can't you see that the passengers are fucking behind" Oh well, makes more sense now
MonsieurJavel 3 weeks ago
I heard this song in NFS most wanted. Great song I'm adicted to it
kamilpk1 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song has exactly my oppinion! fuck narrow minded people!
MrExtremevic101 1 month ago
Comment removed
MrExtremevic101 1 month ago
Hey guys u all suck cock ;)
airsoftmania1000 1 month ago
@airsoftmania1000 No, you suck cock. If you wanna prove me wrong, fight me off in a airsoft battle you stupid pussy.
tdude900 3 weeks ago
You guys are so intelligent, discussing religion. After all, all the world's greatest thinkers discuss their beliefs and the beliefs of others on YouTube.
Gamemasterkf 1 month ago
ok 6 dislikers, so i need revolver only :)
Pecinar55555 1 month ago 2
bestsong for ever
vinyfreestep01 1 month ago
every equinox there is a new messiah we are now in the image of pisces (jesus) before that was the ram (moses) next is aquarius which will bring forth a new messiah...
smokiej89 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Me: Mom im going out
Mom: To kill 6 people?
Me: No i left my phone at Tims.
Blentastic 2 months ago
6 ppl didnt limit their mind
xxxCRAZYLOVExxx 2 months ago
@xxxCRAZYLOVExxx Rather, 6 people limited their mind.
JNathanK2011 2 months ago
@xxxCRAZYLOVExxx its liberate your mind, dumbass, fuck off with that shit that everyone says.
mudvayneLegend 1 month ago
@mudvayneLegend i read "liberate your mind" from a lyrics, congrats for knowing the real lyrics, u must be proud in ur sad life
xxxCRAZYLOVExxx 1 month ago
Best Song in the world
sniper18695 2 months ago
Too afraid...To limit...MIND! :D
AVNGxWarlord 2 months ago
petarb18@gmail.com wow, what a song!!!!!
MegaYoutrube 2 months ago
This song made me see the light... And it made me throw all of my Metalica out the window.
joshjh47 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos 16
@joshjh47 whoa! why not embrace both bands? i listen to both and a host of others....although disturbed is my main :)
dudeguy341 2 months ago
@joshjh47 God have mercy...
JeffreyAgente 2 months ago
@joshjh47 You did the right thing for the wrong reasons
BungeeRooster 1 month ago
Comment removed
rx22289 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@joshjh47 fuck you!! ^
rx22289 3 weeks ago
@joshjh47 man don't do that you could give the Metallica to me at least
MegaJiol 1 week ago in playlist disturbed!
@joshjh47 you asshole >:(
Gunner164o 4 days ago
Those are some bold motherfuckers that dislike this...
swordslasher299 3 months ago
@swordslasher299 Yah, not to sound like a dick, but I feel pity and sorrow for their souls.
JNathanK2011 2 months ago
Heard this over the weekend at a rave....God I love this song.
Sxeybodygirlz 3 months ago
Religon is so hypocritical. LIBERATE YOUR MIND!
gamemstr98765431 3 months ago
@gamemstr98765431 Organized religion is hypocritical, and an oxymoron, but religion itself is an expression of the self reflective element of humanity.
JNathanK2011 2 months ago
@JNathanK2011 Yes you are completely right, but after taking a closer look at the religion more ive come very close to renouncing my beliefs.
gamemstr98765431 2 months ago
@gamemstr98765431 Fundamentalist Christians say you have to accept the whole Bible w/ their interpretation of it, but its really a set of books you have to look at separately. The virgin birth, his roll as the messiah, the resurrection, his exclusive role as God incarnate, etc were all hotly contested issues by the early church. What I find of value is what they didn't disagree on, and that's his values, his heart, and the holy spirit. PM me if you'd like to discuss more.
JNathanK2011 2 months ago
LIBERATE YOUR MIND, YOU MOTHERFUCKER
YOUR SO NARROW MINDED, SO NARROW MINDED!
KDawgha 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 9
@KDawgha yes thanks you, we all heard the song...
pavelic24 3 weeks ago
A mordern Jesus would have to be in a middle class, they would have been spoiled but not all the time, they would have been stricken but not all the time, not too rich, not to poor, some were in the middle of the dertermind spirial.
BluePooSonic 3 months ago
@BluePooSonic I'm not sure about that. I think the significance of Jesus was that he could have become an all powerful, earthly king because of his Davidic bloodline. Instead of becoming another tyrant, like Alexander the Great or Atillia the Hun, he decided to spread love, even when the absolute opposite of love was returned. If people really tried to do what he did, as opposed to placing him on this unobtainable pedestal, the world would be a better place.
JNathanK2011 2 months ago
Comment removed
joshjh47 2 months ago
@joshjh47 If "we" means everyone else on this page, the only reason I wrote about Jesus was to respond to someone else who was writing about Jesus being born today as a modern messiah. My point is we can be the modern messiah by having the kind of love he had for his fellow humanity, We don't need to wait for someone else to do what were capable of doing.
JNathanK2011 2 months ago
@JNathanK2011 well thats what the song is about so ya
TheExodious 2 months ago
once my legacey is born, i will motor my self, i will speach the unspoken, i will stand for all life. i will be crucified, slain for it, but my effect will last another 2000 years(Era)
BluePooSonic 3 months ago
LIBERATE IS A SLIPKNOT SONG!!! IT WAS ON THEIR FIRST ALBUM BACK IN '99, still like it though xD
person5598 3 months ago
@person5598 They're two completely different songs...
ChooseCheese127 3 months ago
@ChooseCheese127 well i know that...
person5598 3 months ago
@person5598 just because it has the same title doesnt mean its the same song dude, completely differenttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
thclifted 3 months ago
this and slipknot liberate is such a sick metal combo of songs to listen to
GamerMovieMaker7 4 months ago
WOAHH mother fucker bitch aunt jamimaaaaaa. lol that's what it sonunds like he's saying in the begininng...
bobbyepin 4 months ago
please dont lagh but only now iv noticed that the cover is all the religion symbols...
62dankar 4 months ago
Eargasm
Jethro95rocks 4 months ago
yeah disturbed
m1c4b4 4 months ago
heard it on thug2 niguh!
EvincentDavis73 4 months ago
The start where he sings is just adrenaline pumping! :D
Twizzle2056 4 months ago in playlist Disturbed Moosic :3
This song rocks!
Gammer01fluffy 4 months ago
thug2 anyone???
668bonecrush 5 months ago
i just want to walk through a really suburban park and just grab people's faces and shout the lyrics in their faces. just so that person has a weird story to tell for the rest of their life
supermanjack7 5 months ago
liberate your mind, fuck your god :)
goreziad 5 months ago
and not the pace, its the message
fifi85100 5 months ago
for the lyrics, its not Don't limit your mind, but Liberate your mind
fifi85100 5 months ago
OH MY GOD DISTURBED BREAKING UP? ! WHERE IS THE MEANING OF LIFE WITH OUT DISTURBED?!
TheDYNILE 6 months ago
@TheDYNILE there is, as you said a song called THE MEANING OF LIFE by disturbed, so your wright ;)
fifi85100 5 months ago
@TheDYNILE that better be bullshit
sonofmysorrow 5 months ago
wh
TheDYNILE 6 months ago
6 ppl dont know how to Liberate
gible08 6 months ago
Liberate our minds be the messiahs, all of us as one. Bring world peace once and for all! Join the Peaceful Revolution. Bring world peace once and for all.
worldpeace2011able 6 months ago
awesome song thumbs if you agree
albertlikesnerf 7 months ago 2
5 Motherfuckers have not Liberated their minds ..
GROWNassK1D 7 months ago
@GROWNassK1D 6
BradyGoldie 7 months ago
this song doesn't go loud enough
monkeyzrule86 7 months ago in playlist disturbed believe
THUG 2 hells yeah when u graffitti the billboards
richiehernandez59 7 months ago
4 dislikes - Nice try mother !
Mistify73 7 months ago
why are people talking about pop music on a metal video?? doesnt make any sense!
footballkidooooooooo 7 months ago 46
@footballkidooooooooo Because people in general are fucking stupid.
CapnRumple 7 months ago 2
@footballkidooooooooo >Implying Disturbed is metal
IrishGuitarist 7 months ago
@footballkidooooooooo yeah cause Disturbed is obscure
redl3ss 4 months ago
@footballkidooooooooo it aint metal its heavy rock [however i agree with u about people talking about pop here
FFVII95 3 months ago
@FFVII95 Who cares? It's some form of metal/rock, let's just enjoy the song and forget about which hardcore genre it is. Again, agreeing with the pop talk.
ClOuDsTaR159 3 months ago
@footballkidooooooooo I have an idea: It's because Nu Metal is a kind of popular music (POP-Popular).
JeffreyAgente 2 months ago
does anybody know what pop music is? its music thats popular! ao if disturbed became more popular it would be pop music!
styxinyourneck09 7 months ago
@styxinyourneck09
metallicarulz12345 7 months ago
@styxinyourneck09 That's got to be the dumbest thing I've ever read. Just because a bunch of mindless morons like something that doesn't make it good. Please do the world a favor and go jump off a bridge. Oh and take your gay ass pop music with you faggot.
CapnRumple 7 months ago
@CapnRumple your r the dumbest person to ever send me back a comment! u do u know the meaning of pop music?
styxinyourneck09 7 months ago
@styxinyourneck09 Pop "music" is shit just like your face!
CapnRumple 7 months ago
@CapnRumple nice talking with a moron
styxinyourneck09 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song is TRUTH!!!
V1993ful 7 months ago
I need to take my purity ring off cause im tired of ear rape.
thewarlord333 7 months ago
Can't sop replaying that opening!!
TheMaskedInsomniac 7 months ago
Liberate by Disturbed is one of my favorite songs!
ZAFT103 7 months ago
"waiting for your modern messiah, to take away all the hatred, it darkens the light in you eye, still awaiting i." fucking amazing lyrics
Jimmy9298 7 months ago
Liberate
Zykris 8 months ago
2 people are not disturbed.
zakkgames 8 months ago
I find when my religion teacher makes me pissed off I sing thiss.......
deiseblu 8 months ago
@deiseblu y
death2160 8 months ago
I don't know what 'ear rapping' is, but it sounds pretty bad! Hahaha!
NINJASE7EN 8 months ago
I have a better idea. Just don't listen to what you don't like. I don't know if that crossed that small mind of yours.
NINJASE7EN 8 months ago
heh i raped the shit outa the replay buttun... i think i screwed it up lol
death2160 9 months ago
Ever since the sickness album, i've fallen in love with these guys....they just did something not alot of people are good at...and their FUCKING AMAZING
VersionOfToxicity666 9 months ago
Marcus31699 9 months ago
just seen them in milwaukee concert they were amazing have a few videos on my channel
prettypaine 9 months ago
one person has not hit puberty yet.
kickaturd2 9 months ago
Bold motherfucker won't you limit your mind
can't you see that the pace has fallen behind
all the hate in your heart is leaving you blind
so bold motherfucker won't you limit your mind
this time
texasproof 9 months ago
for every One dislike there should be 181 likes.
Rico8406 9 months ago
@tallyGuRl604 how old are u O.o
amoogashane 10 months ago
@tallyGuRl604 u said hardcore and gruesome then u said my chemical romance and greenday im not putting them bands down but they are not hardcore or gruesome thats punk rock trust me i know alot bout music i was listening to disturbed and slipknot wen u were still in diapers hahaha
bigboy14100 10 months ago
@tallyGuRl604 calm down keyboard warrior there is alot of ppl who would agree with what i said im not judging you one bit but u cant put my chemical romance in the same category as disturbed u got alot to learn bout music
bigboy14100 10 months ago
@tallyGuRl604 take out my chemical romance and green day and ur good thats not hardcore thats emo
bigboy14100 10 months ago
Bible and metal can be combined!
AverageAnimators 10 months ago
David Draiman and Jamey Jasta need to collab on a bad ass, driving, anthemic industrial NYHC metal song. That shit would beast.
n00bb00ts 10 months ago 2
One thing I admire in Disturbed is the lyrics...the lack of brain in the songs today is simply absurd, I'm glad there are still people who care about what they say ;)
JohnPrestonZero 10 months ago 7
THUG2
kabal5000 10 months ago
1 Person will be sodomized and the rest will have high respect for this fucking awswome song
TheMrmetalhead666 10 months ago
salute! all hail disturbed!
9mmboobgun 10 months ago
Gotta love the classics babyy. lol
XxUndeaDxX2009 10 months ago
39,000 people are disturbed and counting
oxymoronicish 10 months ago 2
Who in the hell could not love this song.
caminoty 10 months ago
1:18 is the best part
Ghostmarine554 10 months ago
someone probally thought dislike meant dis i like
Ghostmarine554 10 months ago
1 person was so awesafied from this song they shook and hit the dislike butten
mrcrowelydr 11 months ago
Damn try listening to this song, at full blast with turtle beaches. HOLY SHIT!!
zZTrickShotZz 11 months ago
Remember when you could watch a video without commercial?
Remember when music videos were uploaded by user and not VEVO
Remember when all the info was to the right of the video?
Remember you could rate a video 1-5 stars?
Remember the famous yellow subscribe button?
Remember when the users controlled the site and not corporations?
WE MISS THE OLD YOUTUBE!
Post this in every video and lets start a youtube revolution!
Thumbs up to keep at the top of the page
zZTrickShotZz 11 months ago 4
he says the same thing like 2,000 times in one verce
bigboom24times 11 months ago
lol at the beginning it sounds like he says "Bold Mutha Fucker Dont Touch My Vegemite"
Reaperules30210 11 months ago
@Reaperules30210 hahah
bigboom24times 11 months ago
this song is the best i think from disturbed its beast
bigboom24times 11 months ago
Liberate your mind! \m/
Plaguebob 11 months ago
1 person needs to be librated
kickaturd2 11 months ago
OH YEAH LIBERATE JUSTINFAGBIEBER
WolfLinkRules 11 months ago
@WolfLinkRules
Would you shut the hell up about him? Every time you aknowledge his existence he earns another dollar.
MiamiTom1 11 months ago
1 person sucks dick for busfare and still has to walk home.`nuff said.
killbill37601 11 months ago
Disturbed is awsome Yeah!!!!!
AnimeRules53 1 year ago
@ThunderStrike764 yeah, what? ahh yes i get it it took pretty long to hear it (exactly 2 yrs for me:))
MarchuxProductions 1 year ago
Ni they are good and I hella love this song!!!!!!!!!!1
ravensfire67 1 year ago
DISTURBED 4 LIFE!
Spartan0895 1 year ago
the dislke button is useless... please youtube, would you fix that?
BlackandBlue1993Jc 1 year ago 33
This has been flagged as spam show
@BlackandBlue1993Jc i used it on this comment thumb whore
LLschoolJ2 11 months ago
@BlackandBlue1993Jc its not useless it was probably there for rebecca black =)
m4g3fir3 9 months ago
@BlackandBlue1993Jc yea so you couldnt disslike the videos you didnt like?
death2160 9 months ago
Comment removed
death2160 9 months ago
@BlackandBlue1993Jc i know its unbelivibel
123456612lk 8 months ago
@BlackandBlue1993Jc it only has one use though, hating bieber. for the better of the world
nikkonolascobigfan 8 months ago
Great song love this album and I'm cool
Metallica96121 1 year ago
fuckin rocks
thelastdemon130 1 year ago
my mind has been liberated
RIPdimeRIP101 1 year ago 2
It should be a crime that rock is losing to pop and rap.
genius13100 1 year ago 39
@genius13100 rap and pop sucks
wwedisturbedfan 1 year ago 3
@genius13100 is this song Rock or Metal??
cuze my friend tells me its Metal.....
m111122 1 year ago
@m111122 its just strait up heavy. all these sub genres are 2 confusing. (yes i know rock and metal r 2 different genres) but if i had 2 pick one it would be more towards hard rock/alternative metal.
RipXrevXA7X 1 year ago
@RipXrevXA7X anyways, the song is pretty cool.... :D
m111122 1 year ago
@RipXrevXA7X Dude, it doesn't matter if it's rock or metal...either way, it's not losing to rap or pop...it's just our own taste...
TaylorKazarian 1 year ago
@TaylorKazarian ya most people dont relize it but rocks still pretty damn popular. only about 60% of TEENS listen to rap/pop/rnb and about 30% listen to rock/metal. and thats just teens, also add a shit load of people from the 80s and people in there 20s
crazeyboii678 11 months ago
@genius13100 I can show you REAL hip hop videos that have less than a thousand views. Shitty mainstream music has the masses enthralled. It's really sad.
NINJASE7EN 9 months ago
Comment removed
NINJASE7EN 9 months ago
@genius13100 it isnt loosing against rap and pop just cause the new generation like rap and pop think about the hundreds of millions of people from the 60 to preasent day that love rock
death2160 9 months ago
@death2160 Yup.
NINJASE7EN 9 months ago
@NINJASE7EN especialy considering the hop is newer than rock
death2160 9 months ago
@death2160 Yeah for sure. The problem is hip hop is way to easy to trend on, and any clown with a mike and a music program thinks he's a rapper or a DJ. You can't fake talent when it comes to using guitars and drums, relying on raw sound.
NINJASE7EN 9 months ago 2
@NINJASE7EN yea though it is still very difficult to actualy get a beat to work for a dj my cousin who is one told me that cause you have to have realy good cordination. but you are still very true it is harder for a drummer guitar and vocalist to get in perfect harmony
death2160 9 months ago
@death2160 Turntables and wax are the real way to DJ in my opinion. Beat juggling, scratches, and mixing are all manual, which definitely displays musical talent. I respect anything that takes talent to make. Except country. I don't care how much talent is put into that! ;)
NINJASE7EN 9 months ago
@NINJASE7EN heh i only realy like the turntables and jeyboard in industrial music check out rammsteinby rammstein live at volkerball man its fucking epic. heh it explains visualy why they make marilyn manson concerts look like a child daycare
death2160 9 months ago
@death2160 keybaord**
death2160 9 months ago
@NINJASE7EN
turntables?
can you give me earplugs THEN play that whickwhickwhicka ear rapping shit?
NurseNekoNeko 8 months ago
@genius13100 this aint rock dumb ass
Marcus31699 9 months ago
@genius13100 new rap is shit but i like old school listin to bring the noise by anthrax and public enemey
styxinyourneck09 9 months ago
@genius13100 Pop and Rap beating Rock? pfft...it goes along the same lines of "whatever helps them sleep at night"...Rock will never be beaten!
NXNaraku 8 months ago
@genius13100 Bold motherfucker, don't limit your mind.
boj4ngles1 8 months ago 39
@genius13100
Even rap is losing. It should be a crime that bland, monotone sounds are what's gotten popular.
laughingfurry 8 months ago
@genius13100 I'd say it's a unfair handicap but your opinion is as good as mine.
soulessphilosopher 7 months ago
im awsome
wwedisturbedfan 1 year ago