MAC Cleanse Off Oil VS Neutrogena Eye Make Up Remover

[SuPeRBuBbLeYBuBbLeS]

omg the mac one burns like a B**** on my eyes i hate it

[SuPeRBuBbLeYBuBbLeS]

@SuPeRBuBbLeYBuBbLeS ohhhh nvm wrong mac cleanser Nvm sorreh

[shimmerycat]

Yes i have to agree with the previous comments ur doing it all wrong. Do more research.

[Jett1n]

Thank you OohJoy, you are right she is not using the mac cleanse off oil right, you need to pump the product into your fingers and then massage it into your eye makeup until all makeup is liquified, then rinse with water and pat dry. I bet if you use it this way you will have MUCH better results with the cleanse off oil..

[OohJoy]

you're not using the mac cleanse off oil right.. at all.

[CoacoaBean08]

wow some jerky comments on your vid! people need to seriously get it together and learn how to not be assholes. but i guess learning to take off makeup is a bit easier than that...

[anjobonito91]

um..ur wasting product with the mac cleanse of oil do not put it on a cotton ball ur suppose to use it with your fingers and hands im not saying the mac is better than the neutrogena or vice versa..just saying dont waste ur product if use it the right way u'll find it more effective :)

[pillowace]

Mac is just for face and Neutrogena is just for eyes.You cant review 2 different products when they are supposed to do different things.You dont know what you're talking about....jeez

[songsaboutj]

oh my God.....DUH! Learn to read labels please....MAC cleanse off oil is NOT solely an eye make up remover, it is for the whole face, eyes included and you are supposed to apply it with your fingers on your dry face( with the makeup) and then massage with the water.....its actually a pretty good product....oil based cleansers usually are....I wonder how can people actually make review videos about stuff they don't know nothing about!?! That's weird and a total waste of time...lol

[dontpeek88]

with MK's product that will all come off with one swipe, including waterproof mascara

[dontpeek88]

Mary Kay's Oil Free eye make-up remover, try it!

[jepowelldotcom]

If you used the MAC Cleanse Off Oil *properly* you'd find it to be incredibly effective. Put 2-3 FULL pumps into your hands, massage it over your entire face including your eyes, splash a tiny amount of water onto your face and continue to massage. The oil will turn into a milks emulsion. Add a little more water, continue to massage then rinse your face. It will remove everything and very quickly.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thanks for the info. i do love this product now...

[dontpeek88]

why would you put eye make up remover on your entire face though?

[jepowelldotcom]

MAC Cleanse Off Oil is not just an eye makeup remover. It is for the entire face, including eye area.

[dontpeek88]

Oh okay, so how does that work for oily ladies?

[martinezsu2004]

The cleanse off oil works in conjunction with water it has a flash emulsification making it creamy and you use it to remove all your make up not just eye make up. I am sure if you do this the correct way you'll love it.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

i actually started using it that way and it works well! thanks for the info! :-)

[spginsberg1]

Do not use cotton with the MAC...that is why you are getting crappy results!! The oil is not a traditional make up remover, use it as you would a cleanser, rub in on your fingers then your face. That is why it is called "cleanse" off oil. Another great one is Clinique take the day off balm, as with this one as well do not use cotton.

[lawlelizabethxo]

yayy im glad it works well, i just bought the neutrogeno one .

[brookebrooke12345678]

im really good with makeup and removeing makeup i dont have anyvideos but if anybody wants to ask me a questiin ir two i wil answer

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

ok.

[butterflylittlegirl]

Which one do you use? I use the Mary Kay one and after I use it I feel my skin very oily.

[babygurl25392]

im defitiely gona get the neutrogena one thnx so much!!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

you're welcome i'm sure you'll like the it! ;)

[shinenshimmer]

i searched this one at the right tym..i was about to go and buy the MAC one..(so that i can do B2M container...lol)...now i will stick to neutrogen one dat i use..i really wanted to try Lancome Bi-facil one. have heard good thngs...but its pricey...i m waiting for some sale or GWP...btw, how are garnier wipes?? ever tried??

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

i have Lancome Bi-Facil but it doesn't work as great as my Neutrogena...i've never tried the garnier wipes...

[Deseonfire]

Does this work with waterproof makeup?

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

it sure does.. .:)

[flowersugergirl]

OMG what's the name of that song !! i love it!!!

and thnx for the nice video ^^

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

you're welcome and thank YOU for watching it! :) the song is called "Rainbow" by South Border. ;)

[flowersugergirl]

THanKSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!

btw yesterday i bought the neutrogena eye makeup remover OH MY GOSH !! its the best makeup remover i've ever used !! it takes only two minutes to remove everything!!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

hahaha i know! gotta love that stuff!!! ;)

[11StyleGirl11]

i actually think you look good without makeup! Its just that you are used to your eyeshadow! You like nice with makeup and without! I am subscribing to you by the way!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh thanks darlin...you're such a sweetheart! <3

[SFfilipina]

Does this work well with waterproof makeup? Is it good for sensitive eyes? Because I wear contacts, will it irritate my eyes? Thanks. Very helpful video!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

yes ma'am...this works really well...i can't tell you for sure if this is safe for contact lens wearer just coz i don't wear contacts...

[cheryl8311]

The Neutrogena eye makeup remover is the BEST! LOVE IT..I use it before washing my face to take off that oily feel but its still good! :)

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

yeah it's really good...i am inlove with it! :)

[85Auri]

Um you are comparing two items that have different purposes. MAC makes 2 types of "eye" makeup remover. However, MAC's doesn't leave a greasy residue like the Neutrogena. Cleanse off oil is a FACE cleanser.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

ok.. :)

[sweetlittleann]

hi! i love your vids. now, i have to say this and im not pointing fingers so dont get me wrong please. i used the mac the first time in the same way you did- then i read the back coz i wasnt impressed- lol- and your have to wash it off- so first rub all over face gently and eyes - youll get panda eyes here- then wash off well with lukewarm water. i loved this product i have ultra sensitive and this mac cleanse off has become my must have item! thank you for your lovely vids! tc!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

i appreciate the comment! :) thanks for watching! <3

[darkangelic88]

omg thank you so much for this review! really appreciate it! you just made me save some bucks, gonna get the neutrogena one instead of MAC! :D

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh you're welcome and i'm glad the video was helpful to you... ;) you'll love the neutrogena! :)

[fafimack]

i laugh a lot when you say ughh ! when you rubbed off your eye make up. your so funny ! but still pretty :-)))))

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

hhahaha thank you :)

[Philippians4thirteen]

Thanks for the review.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

you're welcome and thanks for watching... :)

[leybi98]

aww you look soo pretty

stay sweet

i love your videos ;)

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thank you so much my dear! :)

[MsSissyLou]

Oh no a black eye :O

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

haha!

[gracesupang]

hi there...i knw this sounds weird but can u pretty pls tell me how do you do that video, how u insert all those caption, the songs, the pictures sliding and stuff?? i reli dont have ANY idea on how to do those stuff... :D

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

i didn't either, until i downloaded windows movie maker... :) it's very easy and self explanatory although it took me couple hours before i got it down...haha! :)

[ANGELFLY39]

Hi! You look soooo pretty without eye makeup! Anyway, love to watch your video like seeing an old friend! Thanks for being so curteous & friendly. Talk to you soon!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh thank you so much that means a lot to me! :) take care sweetie! <3

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

yeah i like it coz it's oil free there's always a BOGO for that hehe! :)

[sudheshnam]

i have a question i think your name is val? right?

okay so when i wear foundation + powder+ blush + lipgloss i have to wear kinda a lot cuz i dont have perfect skin but it looks really, like i actually WORE makeup, you know what i mean? i dont like mineral makeup, becuase idk if it has heavy coverage

can you help me>

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

well i don't know what imperfections you have but if you're tryin to cover uo blemishes or uneven skin tone, you can always use a concealer before applying your foundation. that way you don't need to put a lot to cover it up bec the concealer takes care of that. apply your blush lightly and make it look like it's just a rush of blood on your face. :) just the same with lipgloss, natural looking color is always advisable. :) hope this helps.

[tinkerbellax30]

i loovee this song rainbow by southborder right lol =)

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

yes ma'am! :)

[EppyBaBe]

Hi Val do u have the pig golden olive?? 'cause I have it is amazing and has I said my hair its kinda like yours and I think it shows off really good the dark hair :D could u try a tutorial with that or if u don't have it, with any other greens? thankzy *

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

hi darlin, unfortunately i don't have that pigment. i'm not really a pigment user and i only buy pressed pigments coz i feel like they're so messy... :( but i can do more greens soon... ;)

[ladyvdesignz]

I have the neutrogena eye makeup remover and I agree it is great!! It doesn't sting nor is it drying on my eyes. Just feels soothing after using it. I want to try the makeup wipes from mac as well as the cleanse off oil. Thanks for the review!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

you know what i've tried the MAC wipes and i didn't like it. i mean it's very moist and there's just so much product in there to get rid of the make up but it has a funny after smell...i dunno, maybe that's just me...lol! :)

oh and you're welcome and thanks for watching! <3

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thanks! :)

[jessijoy67]

i use the clinique brand and it's awesome, next time i'll try the neutrogena it must be cheaper in price too, and i like saving money, thanks for this video.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

you're welcome and thanks for watching! :)

[dimples262207]

i never tried the mac oil,,but i do like the neutrogena one and the price is good for me..lol

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

yeah i think it's still pricey but good thing it always comes in buy one get one free... :) at cvs though, i don't know about the others...

[shylockkishey]

rainbow!!!!!!!! great song!!!!!!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

one of my favorites!!! <3

[shylockkishey]

ahahahahah Galing!!!! Galing!!!!!!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thank you po! :) hehe!

[ChelyLovesMakeup]

great videos!!!!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thank you! :)

[sanamabhi]

you dont look funny , you are so pretty even without makeup.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

aww darlin you are so sweet thank you! :)

[jkay88]

I thought the MAC Cleanse-Off Oil is supposed to be for face makeup, not eyes? Am I wrong?

I use the Neutrogena for eyes.... looooove the stuff!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh no no i just tried it on my eyes to see if it's gonna work as an eye make up remover as well so i can stick to using less products...but yeah neutrogena is really great! :)

[sweetayez]

I use neutrogena and recently switched from Loreal. Loreal stings my eyes, but Neutrogena has been great, and it also removes mascara and all of fluidline.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh my god i did use loreal too but yeah it doesn't even work haha! and yes it did sting my eyes as well! :( neutrogena is good... :)

[1moremacfan]

I use neutrogena, it works very well for me.

Thanks for the vids...Have a Great Day :o)

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh you're welcome hun and thanks for watching! you have a great day too! <3

[rileyXXS]

good comparison. the neutrogena performs better because it's made specifically for eye makeup.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

exactly!!! :) thanks for watching! <3

[macface2adore]

The Mac Cleanse Off Oil received a chance from me for one week. It didn't remove my makeup and I was a zit factory for a month to come. I do not have bad acne, but I had to get an acne kit to help with my face after this stuff.

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

oh my dear god i'm so sorry to hear that! :(

[mia2108]

Neutrogena seems to be the winner!!!!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

hell yeah! :) lovin it!

[noracism11]

i love these comparison videos!

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thanks... :) i'm glad you liked it...

[whywouldit]

the neutrogena seem good. does it take off mascara too?

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

yes it does... :)

[pinkpornstar1]

Wow! this is a awsome review and I been trying to find something for my eyemakeup..Thank you

[MakeUpVideosAndMore]

thanks for watching! :) i'm glad you find the video helpful... :)