Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (430)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • and now thats a singer, not lady gaga and whoever else..

  • @vacmich21 theres no comparison, they are diferent. lady gaga is performer this is an artist.

  • half mimed and live lol

  • i want to know what love is...??? and i know you can show me...!!! <3<3<3

  • Cant stop loving her!!!

  • THE BEST DIVA OF ALL TIME - MARIAH CAREY

  • Comment removed

  • still loving her ~

  • The Whistle was not lipped. But the high chest notes were, unfortunately.

  • @AsherEffendi None of it was, believe me I can tell when Mariah is singing and when she isn't.

  • People are stupid,Yes the whistle was lip synched,But she can really do it,She is in the gueniss book of world records to be the the first person to hit the whistle register,and not falter or crack.She did it live with oprah.She is stunning.So all you haters back off.It was lip synched so it would not be so soft,due to the echo they have on the track.Mariah Carey can float like a fucking quill feather,and land gentle as a softly plucked petunia.She serves genuine pussy,So BACK THE HELL OFF.

  • hmmm i love mariah but i have a feeling she was miming the whistle notes...

  • It's Amazing all the time,I love you Mariah.

  • 2:45-2:47 she looked as if she said to herself like "Fuck I messed up" I LOVE MC!!!

  • @mc1231818 i think it was more like "oh no here it comes" xD

  • Is just me that think or she was lip-sync?

  • @jeancarlosantos1992 is it mind??? nooooooooo cuz she's amazing!!!!!!!!!!

  • @jeancarlosantos1992 JeanC you're right this is what they call miming, she is not singing.

  • Ok i love mimi but:

    1. heartache and pain

    1.lonely live

    1. face it again

    and whole 1st chorsus are lipped...then i think the whistle and the i wanna feeeeeel falsetto at the end is lipped and the "ihhhii wanna knowhowh", rest ist live.

    But she always lipps the same parts...i think that whistle on x factor was live...but i don'T know it...But great performance (:

  • Fantastic! This was one of the best whistle notes of all of her live performances that she did. I love my Mimi!! :)

  • song world.

  • OMG... My speaker broaken after watching this, love u Mariah !!!

  • 3:21 : Cant believe... This note is so high

  • linda lindaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa amo esta musica"!"!!! vc e D++++++++++++

  • This is not prerecorded u idiot!!!

  • Live??? ahaaaaa.... Prerecorded!!

  • Omfg I love when she gets to the duper high notes in the sounds like a bird! Beautiful

  • im the biggest Mariah fan on planet earth but certain parts on this song was lip synched its was very painful to watch her struggle through this song .....but i love her anyway good are bad thats how the real lambs roll!!!

  • @170flyguy you are very funy. how dare you say you are the biggest fan, even say you are a fan also. and then you say this things. plaese stop being fan. and go to be another artist fan.

  • @ratitapanteonera well iam a fan its not an album of Mariah's that i dont own or a song i havent memorized, i roll with her good are bad, i have ears so i know when she aint singing in tune ,i dont like this performance so what i still love her that was all i was saying......now u can go have a seat dont address me cause i aint the one on anyday

  • AMAZIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Whistle note is clearly lip synch

  • that whistle note is wow...

  • She is a diva!

  • WOW !!!

    bows down to a legend

  • LMAO, I adore her, but what happened at 3:09? Sounds funny as hell.

  • @lawlinat0r thats because the lip synch part starts ..... and she almoust missed it -.-

  • @madonnalicious22 No, not that. The part before that where she says "so much love" or whatever. It sounded terrible.

  • Dang. Mariah really nailed it at 3:18

  • SHIVERING !

  • -{ANY REAL LAMbS COULd tELL iT WAS CAUSiNG hER tREMENdOUS PAiN tO GEt tHEM HiGh bELt NOtES OUt dUE tO hER VOCAL NOdULES ACtiNG UP}-

  • Wow her high notes in this song was UNREALLL!!! BEAUTIFUL!

  • Mariah did not nail this song. She whispered the song using a lot of falsetto in the most important part of the song. And at some point, she hardly found her voice. Thanks goodness her back-up was there to rescue her.I think the quality of her voice does not agree with this song. Her voice wasn't powerful enough in the chorus to nail this song. But of course she's Mariah and her whistle at the end of the song made the rendition interesting. I wonder what Simon Cowell would say.

  • @jnet924 hater, try harder next time

  • @hzgg12 You got me wrong. I don't hate Mariah. I have nothing against her. In fact, I'm her fan. But I'm not that impressed with her version of this song. For me, she did not nail this song. I still prefer the original version of this song. You have to realize that people have different opinions about everything. An unfavorable opinion does not necessarily connote hatred. My apologies for hurting your feelings...

  • di mais

  • what a lovely bird!!!

  • mariah carey THE QUEEN OF THE DIVAS IN THE WHOLE WORLD!!!!! I LOVE YOU VERY MUCH YOU MAKE ME VERY VERY VERY INSPIRED!!!!!!ALI

  • I LOVE HER

  • LOVE HER VOICE!

  • i love how she uses gestures to show that she's got feeling into this song, and that she was soul!

  • Something is wrong with the playback!!!!!

  • She is fantastic.

  • Amazing performance by Mariah Carey. I liked the version of it in the composition of this music.

  • WOW the high note was AWESOME ! ! !

  • Go get Mariah Carey's new Album "Merry Christmas II You"! Mariah's back better then ever her voice and music has returned to the perfection of the 90's!

  • She is the most amazing singer in the world her voice is like an angel ! ive never liked this song until mariah sang it, she makes it her own and it sounds magical x

  • give her a break right before she recorded memoirs she had gone through something every woman dreads losing a child to miscarriage so her heart wasn't totally in the project

  • linda

  • @Tonster1998 you suck! she had never said that those songs were written by her. Although, she produced them in a different way. LOOK AT THIS VERSION AND LOOK AT FOREIGNER'S VERSION. stupid.

  • she sucks. always taking other singer's songs and making them her own. This isn't her song. Without You 1993, I'll Be There 1991 was Michael Jackson's song. I Still Believe 1998 was Brenda Star's song, etc.. the list goes on and on. this woman sucks. This woman has no originality or creativity in her songs or music videos. I'll root for Lady Gaga anyday.

  • @Tonster1998

    Yes! She took those songs and made them better! I would never appreciate them so much as i do if it wasn't for her singing them. She's great!

  • @Tonster1998

    she writes and produces her own music except covers...so about 5% of her music over the last 20 years have been covers and maybe less. how does she not have creavity. at least she's not like that whore lady gaga taking other people's fashion and calling it her own. she doesnt even give credit to them.

  • @Tonster1998 You suck major donkey cock, and listening to gaga you know music very well dont you ? NOT you perthetic deaf fuck.

  • que hermosa mujer

  • NOBODY can beat Mariah's whistle register. Fact. :D

  • FLAWLESS performance and then she goes and messes it up by that ANNOYING whistle - GET OVER IT. It's soooooooooooooo 90's!

  • @yokhana You can be the 90's

  • Her voice is just perfect and her whistle is uncomparable ! Love to hear her songs !

  • uncomparable!

  • Do not hate me for saying this, but some parts are lipped the video is also out of sync with the audio, but watching so many performances from her already live for this song, she keeps it 90% live. Chorus ending is lipped but the "lonely life" at 2:26 is not lipped and "I want to know what love is" part is lipped at 2:42 the note is not lipped 3:05 is not lipped 3:12 is 3:15 is not but is beautiful last whistle is lipped Mariah has many prerecord tracks to use on live performances

  • @blackroomfish i feel sorry for you dude. you are obviously deaf & blind.

  • @blackroomfish i feel sorry for you dude. you are obviously deaf & blind. Its like you are trying to say most part is prerecorded and only those timings you mentioned are live.

  • @blackroomfish I know right, also she has a farting facial expression at the beggining.

  • she know what she really doing!!!

  • Philip Scholfield, who presented it, actually commented on her doing it 100% live after he met her!

  • she's yellow like lemon was she sick !hhhh & wrikles become so apparently !

  • she's yellow like lemon was she sick !hhhh

  • 3:19 - 3:32  ffuuuuuuuuuuuccccccckkkkkkk !!!!!!!!!!!

  • @schlumberger112 Yeah that whistle was lipped.

  • @schlumberger112 that gave me chills that part

  • @schlumberger112 Damn Straight. Fake as hell. Lip synced the entire time. Her breathing is off with it! When she switched to these notes, she didn't even re-breath with it.

  • @HiddNitePRandBSinger Don't really understand why you post negative comments like this one? I mean i doubt you can do it better! So you should just keep your mouth close. But it's understandable, your probably a frustated singer who is never going to accomplish what MC has. Not even in another life. Not mad at you, just kinda feel sorry for you because that's all you have inside of you HATE.

  • @ale5677 The saddes thing is that you think that Mariah's money makes her and you buy into and feed into her conceded self worship. What is even saddest is that you think that I need to measure my self worth to equal that of Mariah Carey to have the best level of self esteem & just because you don't have self worth knowing that you are not Mariah Carey. Mariah's personal sucks, she is an alcoholic that needed to get on progesterone treatements just to have a kid, problems I have never had.

  • @ale5677 I am where I want to be in my life and damn well pleased with it too, and I'm over here in one of the most productive HIGHEST PRAISED country where every Aussie just like you would love to have a dual additonal residence that you cannot just afford u jealous asses. I DON'T NEED TO BE MARIAH CAREY TO FEEL IMPRESSED WITH MY LIFE JUST YOU AND EVERY1 WHO THINKS LIKE YOUR STUPIDEST ASSES. Something else about Mariah and in her life that I would never want is...

  • @ale5677 If u carefully watched Mariah's vidoes of her getting help to vocally arrange & produce music n the studio U WILL NEVER EVER SEE 1 OF U 2 JEALOUS ASS WHITE AUSSIES N THERE EVER HELPING HER OUT DO ANYTHING. She is always, yes always getting her vocal arrangments from ONLY the Blackest Women & her albums are produced and re-produced by ONLY the Blackest Producers priceless things I learned to out do for myself with the help of one of the Blackest Producers.

  • @ale5677 C Mariah OUT NEEDS ME & has 2 many priceless needs that I don't have U Envious Aussies. By the way You Tube was created and based in California over here in the U.S. where U.S. laws apply ignorant asses, so I am minding my U.S.A. business doing very great with understanding our laws and other U.S. cultures that are posting their opinions here on You Tube as well.

  • @ale5677 So just get back to minding your business in Down Under and misreading your Australian Laws b4 I just report your asses 4 harrassment in Australia Bitches. You Tube is in the U.S. and you are transmitting out of Australia so you must obey Austrailian Laws as well as U.S. laws, and since u NOT ME DUMB ASSES are re-transmitting internationally, U must obey international harrassment laws 2 dumb asses. Something else, very very important you needed to know b4 you emailed me dumbest asses

  • @ale5677 Should my ability to out sing Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston both be my whole life? I am as accomplished as I wanted to be then and right now. So you are saying that if I am not being exactly just like Mariah Carey and didn't and don't have every exact thing that she has that I should hate myself? HELL NO!!! JUST U, U JEALOUS ENVIOUS BITCH. U ARE NOT A WELL ROUNDED PERSON AT ALL, SOMETHING THAT AUSTRAILANS CANNOT JUST GET OVER THERE IN DOWN UNDER U WORSOMEST ASS CABRONES!!

  • @ale5677 BUT YOU'RE VERY EMBARRESSED RIGHT! DON'T SAY THAT YOU ARE NOT BCAUSE YOU ARE NOT GOING TO GET ANYBODY AND I MEANT NOT ANYBODY OVER HERE IN THE U.S. THAT WISHES THAT THEY WERE JUST LIKE MARIAH CAREY AND COULD BE JUST LIKE MARIAH CAREY RIGHT NOW!! NOT ANYWHERE OVER HERE. AS I SAID UP ABOVE BEFORE U ALL HAVE THE LOWEST STANDARDS FOR SINGING, BUT NOW I SEE FOR SINGERS AND THIER LIVES TOO.

  • @HiddNitePRandBSinger WTF? First of all, im not from australia! Im an american citizen. You dump getto bitch! Second of all this is goes to show that you clearly have no sel-respect and respect for each other people. And third you can just keep running your dirty ass mouth all you want cause as you can see i dont have time to reply to all your stupid ignorant comments. GET A LIFE!

  • @ale5677 Your sorry as hell whitest racist mammy is the dumbess whitest ghetto bitch that still out loses her self respoect getting the direst ass insde her mouth, just like she went all out & did getting impregnated with & INbreeding your sorriest asses!! First of all you most ignorant lying S.O.B. who just contradicted himself, and I'm still talking against your whitest racist sorriest mammy, if you really didn't have the time, then u wud have not ever re-bothered a 2nd time at that.

  • @ale5677 You and your sorriest of hell tightest whitest most racist mammy are the idiots without self respect, who inbreed & everyone can just see it with the reflection of her literally dirtiest most jealous ghetto dumpiest ass. She obviously got impregnanted with your out having sex with the worst out of the worst! And you are the proof of that, no body else's grown up adult kid is re-commenting here like you. You and your whitest mammy are the TRASHIEST OF THE MOST RACIST WHITE PEOPLE!

  • @ale5677 You are what we blackest / latino people call The Whitest Trailer Trash!! Now u are probably out on crack too, trying to out sell some food stamps 2 just get more. I don't use drugs & I have never ever needed to go into or have ever been n2 drug or alcohol rehab.

  • @ale5677 I have always gotten self respect and will still get it because of the way that I carried myself. Now I bet u'd find the time to respond 2 my most recent posts to u & about u and / or your White Trailer Trash Racist Jealous Ghetto Dumpiest Dumbess Dirtiest Ass Not Self Respected Mammy whom u only act the dirtiest just like. I'd get respect it's just U that didn't.

  • @ale5677 What bothers me, black, & latino people is that white trashy people just like u, no matter where they lived or now live, and no matter who they live with or leave keep re-trying to act like you and them did and out do the best, but u & your white racist types of people never did out did the best, cannot out do the best & you never will out do the best either. You didn't and you don't know how to you dumbest ass racist white most trashy montegones!!

  • @ale5677 NOW CABRONE, REALLY RE-TRY THIS TIME NOT TO FIND THE TIME TO BOTHER REPLYING TO MY SO CALLED STUPID COMMENTS! YOU WHITEST RACIST TRASH!!! AND I MEANT THAT TO ALSO MEAN, NO MATTER WHERE YOU LIVED OR NOW LIVE!! DAMN,.. IT JUST DID APPLIED AND JUST REAPPLIES TO YOU NO MATTER WHERE YOUR ASS LIVED!!

  • @ale5677 NOW CABRONE, REALLY RE-TRY THIS TIME NOT 2 FIND THE TIME 2 BOTHER REPLYING 2 MY SO CALLED STUPID COMMENTS! U WHITEST RACIST TRASH!!! & I MEANT THAT 2 ALSO MEAN, NO MATTER WHERE U LIVED OR NOW LIVE!! DAMN,.. IT JUST DID APPLIED & JUST REAPPLIES TO YOU NO MATTER WHERE YOUR ASS LIVED!! BUT IT IS MOST OBVIOUS THAT MY LIFE IS 1 OF THE BEST LIVES TO HAVE OF THE BLACKS AND LATINS, BCAUSE YOUR SORRIEST RACIST WHITEST MOST TRASHY ASS & THE OTHERS JUS LIKE U AREN'T RE-NVOLVED IN IT! YEAAAAAH!:-)

  • @schlumberger112 your fuck jerk

  • Hatter hi .. You go far to get there .. I do not like it at Hatter Mariah Carey

  • @schlumberger112 Hatter hi .. You go far to get there .. I do not like it at Hatter Mariah Carey

  • i like her voice and the whistle, amazing!

  • @sodaw222 what whistle??

  • @sarahsoriano17

    Listen good to the highest notes... It really sounds like a whistle sometimes...

  • @cool058 oh snap i never thought of that. well i guess i expected that bc its mariah lol

  • amazing....she needs a "little" more rest but her voice is deff coming back...i didnt think she REALLY showed it off on MC2 and her new ablum...but if she rest her voice for her next album...maybe she can go back to singing like on Butterfly and Day Dream album

  • tje best singer =)

  • she's screaming

  • boxgames.webnode.com.br/

  • Perfect whistle

  • The introduction of vocals is quite good and has a good beat that suits her.

    BUT! .. Overall ..

    1)she and the performance were fake (whats with the fist :s)

    2) HOW ANNOYING! What is the point in that squeek at the end !

    doesnt she realise how annoying it is! it ruins the performance and to be honest is pathetic! just as on the X factor!

    I would never buy her cds, i have all of Whitneys! and mariah is in general not a patch on Whitney, her voice, her presence, looks, likeability, EVERYTHING!

  • @dudleyowl

    I'm sure she's absolutely devastated! With her 5 octave vocal range, hundreds of millions of records sold and international career, who wouldn't be!

  • @dudleyowl

    1) there was nothing fake about the perfomance mariah is known famously for the passion and heart she puts into her ballads.

    2) that squeek is the highest note their is, and shows off her suprior range, somthing she is famous for

    3) its not annoying to most people espically her fans, and its her fans that she is singing. pathetic? take a look in the mirror sweetie

  • @dudleyowl

    hahahaha

    so funny how you say it!!

  • @dudleyowl well well well. what do you know about vocal range? she possesses a five-octave vocal range which whitney dosn't have. that so called "squeek" you mentioned is called the whistle register. And its not annoying. and when you ask whats the point. the point is how many singers you can name that hit the whistle register. Not even Whitney Houston or Celine Dion. so please don't say that the whistle register is pathetic.

  • @NiiC you are right , just mariah carey , georgia brown and another woman who i forgetthe name :) can whistle

  • @harajukuboi88 yea you are right to. so far i only know 3. the 2 you mentioned and another male singer from taiwan.

  • @harajukuboi88 ciao conosco un cantante che ha più estensione di lei...ma lei è superiore xD si chiama nicola sedda ascolta delle canzoni sue e poi fammi sapere ;) ps:l estensione di nicola sedda è si 8 ottave xD

  • what she got on is cute:)

  • ewww :( what happened.

  • waaaaaaaaaauh she is the best, love her

  • this is one of the best live performance evah of MIMI..^^ love love love

  • I love you Mariah!

  • She"s actually a SONG KILLER!

    THE BEST!

  • She looks great here. And here singing is outstanding <3

  • i very much like and love her whistle regsters....

  • clearly her peak performance of this tune!

  • i love mariah carey!!

  • she's so lovely

  • ---> MC pkt. 1

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Good interpretation of FOREIGNER's song. Good job, Mariah.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • the music is out of sync

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • yes MARIAH CAREY IS THE BEST ARTIST OF ALL TIME..........

    LOVE U MARIAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH, HOPE TO WATCH UR CONCERT HERE AGAIN IN MANILA, PHILS........ SOON..... TAKE CARE LOVE U ALWAYSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed