Is it me or does it seem like in the movie version of the musicals, the actors in the movie put more feeling into the song than the actors in the musical?
@spiritgirl41192 That's because with film, they can do multiple takes and edit them for the best effect. On stage, you only get one shot to get it right. ;)
Anyone else annoyed at how they keep casting really young actresses to play Griz in the current U.S. National Tour? It's so frustrating, because they always sound so young when they sing "Memory". I'm hoping that they find at least a middle aged woman to play her for the upcoming 2011-2012 show season.
@JemimasMusic No, Prior to its inclusion in Cats, the tune was ear-marked for earlier Lloyd Webber projects, including a ballad for Perón in Evita and as a song for Max in his original 1970s draft of Sunset Boulevard.
my daughter and I both agree that we prefer Elaine Page's version as she is IN character. Poor Grizabella! We cried when she was chosen by Old Deuteronomy to be reborn. It is a sad, dramatic, poignant song and shouldn't be sung frivolously. Too many singers try to sing this while smiling, or shriek it. painful.
Aww when I was small and watched Cats I always felt so sorry for Grizabella and I remember thinking that if she was my cat I would let her sleep in my bed. ^^
i think a version being performed on stage will generally have more emotion(or maybe drama) than one being performed in a recording studio. I think Paige is acting just as much as she's singing.
There isnt much that can top a real show, not just emotions but the fact that everything happens right there, right now and no two show is the same. While the music is fantastic in the video there is nothing off the magic off sitting in the best seat in the theathre. Johan
Maybe the reason Barbara can;t match the emotion because i believe that Elaine Paige is the original Grizebella. So the characters is hers really...if u think about it...
@ember514 I think the difference between Barbra and Elaine is the fact that Elaine wails the song, balls-out. Barbra belts it really well but it's not with as much reckless abandon. Elaine is singing to the limit (at the pinnacle at least)
@ember514 Agreed! I've heard many versions of memory but the Elaine Page version sticks out in my mind every time I hear this song. In my mind, she's goes hand in hand with this song. This is the perfect version
So beautiful but the broadway show and recorded show is very confuzing i found. so can someone tell me what a gelicle cat is?
sugahmama1234 2 days ago
it is a beautiful song.
MichelleY50 1 month ago
EXCELLENT RENDITION.
NANDIKHANNA 2 months ago
Beautiful song! Just a bit sad, as to me, but really beautiful! :)
MusicoCrazia 2 months ago
Bloody brilliant.
lokiforlove 2 months ago
does anybody else see her old coat, the one she had when she was the Glamor Cat? It is very beautiful
animefangirl37 2 months ago in playlist Cats
Kitties should never be sad. I just can't help picturing a sad old cat wandering the streets about to die.... D :
sovermier1 2 months ago in playlist Cats 2
@sovermier1 Picturing that images makes me tear up. =(
thesundaysfan 2 months ago
Elaine Paige is awesome. This song brings back memories of beautiful music lost.
scotlanddays 2 months ago
Elaine Paige is the best Grizabella.
KingdomOfAndy 3 months ago 3
simply fantastic....
TheNellamaria 3 months ago
Is it me or does it seem like in the movie version of the musicals, the actors in the movie put more feeling into the song than the actors in the musical?
spiritgirl41192 4 months ago in playlist Cats 5
@spiritgirl41192 That's because with film, they can do multiple takes and edit them for the best effect. On stage, you only get one shot to get it right. ;)
SednaOfAnterra 2 months ago
I will always cry to this. Always.
awesomesocks15 4 months ago 5
Anyone else annoyed at how they keep casting really young actresses to play Griz in the current U.S. National Tour? It's so frustrating, because they always sound so young when they sing "Memory". I'm hoping that they find at least a middle aged woman to play her for the upcoming 2011-2012 show season.
ValtronW 4 months ago
Comment removed
poptartbrat 4 months ago
you are beautiful now
gdgrlsjstdntgtcght 4 months ago
Musical theater does NOT get better than this.
She is just the consumate joy as a singer!
skbnvacaville 4 months ago 4
This deserves far more views.
TheEpicMusicChannel 4 months ago 2
9 people have never been touched by Grizabella, and they don't know what happiness is...
AriannaSbagliata 5 months ago
Brb , gonna go touch her hand
GIRLSKATER6 5 months ago 2
"CATS" no es una pelicula, es una Opera.
PerBeauty25 5 months ago
Love this so much. <3
Looking at her costume, I can't help but think it looks the way I feel in the mornings.
bluemystic99 5 months ago in playlist 1980's
Oh Elaine Paige, you are glamorous in every way.
businesschic24 6 months ago 2
Simone Simons from Epica...'nuff said.
violentdelights1313 6 months ago
7 people have no heart
Hinnata678 7 months ago
beautiful.
theheartofmyabyss 7 months ago
Whenever she sings i get chills!
EraMinkie101 7 months ago 2
Others can try to perform Memory, but nobody will ever sing it with such emotion and feeling as Elaine Paige. Who's with me?
zulu45 7 months ago 4
I've never taken someone dressed as a cat so seriously
OnlyOneTreeHill8 7 months ago 64
the 7 people that disled this probly are followers of mcavity
Hinnata678 7 months ago
Went to see this in the theatre - she got a stannding ovi !
GIRLSKATER6 7 months ago
I swear there is a longer version than this?
EmzLuvzCatz 8 months ago
@EmzLuvzCatz yup. its the reprise with Jemima if you want i can PM you with a link
thebeatles4ever99 6 months ago
No other performer will ever be able to do this song the way Elaine Paige does it!
joshanderson24 8 months ago
Her voice sounds so beautiful and pure in this video, and the emotion she displays is amazing.
awsomesauce7 8 months ago
SAD
WarriorCatsRulestars 8 months ago
Flawless
trancehi 8 months ago
7 personnes n'aiment pas ? Mais ils ont quoi dans les oreilles, du fromage blanc ? Cette chanson est magnifique et magnifiquement interprétée.
Bragance2006 8 months ago
I thought Lea Salonga was Grizabella... Hmm... Guess I was wrong.. :-/
MusicLuver0806 9 months ago
@MusicLuver0806 - She actually does! It was staged on Manila, Philippines for CATS Asian Tour last year
a1x2l3e 8 months ago
Check out Betty Buckley's version!
spsmonktoo 9 months ago
can't stop listening to this song. I love elaine paige for being able to sing this song soo well!!!
lucythebookmonster 9 months ago
was this song written for cats? lol Ive watched this musical since I was a kid, and Im still clueless
JemimasMusic 10 months ago
@JemimasMusic No, Prior to its inclusion in Cats, the tune was ear-marked for earlier Lloyd Webber projects, including a ballad for Perón in Evita and as a song for Max in his original 1970s draft of Sunset Boulevard.
crazychikaboomboom 10 months ago
everytime i listen to this song, i say "this is pure magic"...
missmetalforlife 10 months ago
why 9 people dislike this? sure the costumes are kinda creepy but the song, i mean, seriously? its elaine paige!!!!!!!!!
some people are just deaf.
iluvbroadway15 10 months ago
Jackie Evancho also sang memory.She sang it beautifully!Thumbs up if you've herd and loved it!
tabitharenee13 11 months ago
o my gosh i almost started crying!!!! its so sad when she said "when i USED to know what happiness has" :'(:'(
The2goofygirls 1 year ago 2
@The2goofygirls she doesn't say that.
asthemorningfalls 11 months ago
I have loved this song no matter who sings it. They are all great.
batman12357361 1 year ago 4
5 prehistoric moron watched this video
YIITRL 1 year ago 2
Where is the HD/High Quality youtube video? Had it in my favorites but now it's gone!
Mykosxyz 1 year ago
Bravo
tschuutschuubahn 1 year ago
Does anyone else have an unhealthy obsession with Cats? I do. My family is always asking me to watch somethin else.
animallover2047 1 year ago 43
Goosebump time
MsFanmail 1 year ago 3
Amazing
lalibertyshowtunes 1 year ago
i want to be like her!! check out my videos!
cydneyr 1 year ago
I thought I did ok when I did this, but no one can hold a candle to her performance. Look up mindianna41 for my performance.
Dragonista113 1 year ago
my daughter and I both agree that we prefer Elaine Page's version as she is IN character. Poor Grizabella! We cried when she was chosen by Old Deuteronomy to be reborn. It is a sad, dramatic, poignant song and shouldn't be sung frivolously. Too many singers try to sing this while smiling, or shriek it. painful.
ChctSflwr 1 year ago 4
Aww when I was small and watched Cats I always felt so sorry for Grizabella and I remember thinking that if she was my cat I would let her sleep in my bed. ^^
sparrowcrazy 1 year ago
i love this song so much
21thewiseone 1 year ago
Simone Simmons took this song and made it in to a song for angels. This one is pretty good, but I like Simone's more (Epica)
Stargeek2006 1 year ago
barbara shreds elaine
mistermig 1 year ago
My God! She gives me such goosebumps.
Hmmmm. I can see why Sir Tim Rice had an affair with her!
skbnwinters 1 year ago
i played girzabella andi love to sing this song
swimmolly 1 year ago
She is amazing.
TheMissMikz 1 year ago
She is GREAT!
oscorneylli 1 year ago
Im Guessing Old D Doesn't Know How Much The Cats Dislike Her.
Yaoirocks78 1 year ago
Sounds just like my aunt Midge!!!! (OK - not really - my aunt Midge can't hit the high notes!!!!)
Earthlinked 1 year ago
woww i amazing I wanna sing like her!!!!!!!
Cadymsae 1 year ago
I love Elaine. She is my idol. I hope to be able to sing this song like her one day. I'm close, but not quite good enough yet.
MrVampireLover18 1 year ago
respect x
ukkepek 1 year ago
Her voice is so beautiful. This scene always make me tear up.
stiffkittens101 1 year ago 3
i love tis song
Alischa4Ever 2 years ago
I am going to try to sing this for a talent contest i can get my voice close to hers but this song always makes me cry
SENSAYSIERRA 2 years ago
If you haven't had six years of voice training you should probably stick to something simpler; you might hurt yourself.
Stantzs 1 year ago
@SENSAYSIERRA Don't try to sound like her. Make it your own.
PeaceNdLovee 1 year ago
wow when he sang sound at 0:13 to 0:15 it was so pure and her tone is so bright and PURE....sooo good
steve1rox 2 years ago
This song makes me cry. . I've sung it before. . but it makes me sad every time I listen to it.
SkandranonKiba 2 years ago
My god, Elaine Paige just puts SO MUCH EMOTION into this performance! I LOVE IT!!!!!!!! Brilliant actress and singer!
treehugginmusicluvr 2 years ago 130
I always wondered what exactly could make that 'twanging' sorta sound at the end of this song. I think it's cool. :D
Oh, and the song is heartbreakingly nice too. X3
LeoMidori 2 years ago
when he dies (hopefully not soon) his MUSIC WILL LIVE ON!!!!!!!!!
jelliclechristine 2 years ago
I'm certainly not hoping Andrew dies AT ALL. That man is a legend.
TopGearFanForever 2 years ago 6
andrew lloyd webber is such a genious i swear he composes such beautiful music
stine0225 2 years ago 4
Old Deuteronomy reaches out to Grizzebella at 2:19
xXxbluemidnightxXx 2 years ago
and she reaches back
ickythumpedout 2 years ago
tears brova
demeterfan55556 2 years ago 4
i think a version being performed on stage will generally have more emotion(or maybe drama) than one being performed in a recording studio. I think Paige is acting just as much as she's singing.
iasted 2 years ago 3
There isnt much that can top a real show, not just emotions but the fact that everything happens right there, right now and no two show is the same. While the music is fantastic in the video there is nothing off the magic off sitting in the best seat in the theathre. Johan
MrJohanfromSweden 2 years ago
Maybe the reason Barbara can;t match the emotion because i believe that Elaine Paige is the original Grizebella. So the characters is hers really...if u think about it...
MioEinjeru 2 years ago
actually the original grizabella is betty buckley
TheCoryChannel 2 years ago
Yes on broadway she was. But Elaine paige was the first as it opened in London before broadway.
roth3055 2 years ago 4
No one can sing it quite like Elaine Paige...
Barbra Streisand does a version that's pretty good, but doesn't match the emotion...which is weird...for Barbra...to be outmatched in emotion...:P
ember514 2 years ago 78
You're right, Elaine's emotion is tangible... it comes out of every pore and its a core-shaker... plus she has the character down to a T
rossumrox05 2 years ago
@ember514 I think the difference between Barbra and Elaine is the fact that Elaine wails the song, balls-out. Barbra belts it really well but it's not with as much reckless abandon. Elaine is singing to the limit (at the pinnacle at least)
jtcarey2 1 year ago
@ember514 i stand corrected (kind of)... this isn't the full version... oops. this is the snippet from the end of Act I.
jtcarey2 1 year ago
@ember514 Barbra's emotion is plastic.
Shanniquitie 1 year ago
@ember514 Agreed! I've heard many versions of memory but the Elaine Page version sticks out in my mind every time I hear this song. In my mind, she's goes hand in hand with this song. This is the perfect version
ShortySOM 11 months ago
I always cry when I listen to this ;;
...My mum does too... XD
silent3pitaph 2 years ago 4
I really like playing this on my flute. It is so pretty
16teddybear19 2 years ago 3
best performance
EdensHouse 2 years ago
Funny, it seems that everyone's mum likes this song, i wonder why? mine loves it as well and cries everytime!
frankie385 2 years ago 5
I showed this to one of my friends and her mum cried. And she doesn't like cats (the breed) she loved this musical, though. Haha I converted her...
AriaCloudrunner 3 years ago 4
she is one of the best!
lilasonnenschein 3 years ago 4
Sie ist die beste.
chrissi2810 3 years ago 2
wow s sings so pertty
rudy7203 3 years ago
this is my favorite song of ALL time!!!
ELAINE PAIGE IS MY HERO!!!!!!!!
IceQueenHeiress2012 3 years ago 2
this is my mums favorite song of this show
leoniecocoa1 3 years ago
love this song<3
Beccychan 3 years ago