It is a great book. Very well thought out, and the characters are almost like real people because they have developed emotional issues and thoughts. It is exciting and a knuckle biter as well. Wonderful book!
I loved this book I wish there was a sequal of when aud and halli go on an adventure and seek out what is found beyond the vallley. the book never answered a few of the mysteries and i hope it is answered in the 2nd if ever possible to be one!
I am currently halfway through the book and it's great. It's not as good as the Bartimaeus trilogy, but it's still a wonderful novel. I do hope it gets better - Jonathan Stroud can totally turn the readers' expectations around.
if there was ever a movie of it I wish i could play Aud.
mickeymousepokaspot3 1 week ago
I have the book
whoohoo
but it really looks different then the copy from 2009...
MsKATHYZ1 1 month ago
50 pages into it I couldnt stop reading it...this is probably my favorite book
BonJovilover10000 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i liked this book
CruelMaple 4 months ago
i liked this book
CruelMaple 4 months ago
this book is awesome, i really want a squel for it :D soon hopefully
LivingOrJustLife 5 months ago
i wish he made a sequel for this book
tipapus 6 months ago
I wish it would be made into a movie.
mickeymousepokaspot3 6 months ago
Awesome book loved reading it
RobotronicRaptor 7 months ago
the ending kind of disapointed me. hope there is a sequal tht would ovr take the ending...
StreetKing996 1 year ago
@StreetKing996 I thought the ending was great. Unusual, but great.
wjww1166 1 year ago
It is a great book. Very well thought out, and the characters are almost like real people because they have developed emotional issues and thoughts. It is exciting and a knuckle biter as well. Wonderful book!
Lindsaymwaters 1 year ago
Magnificent book! I read it in like two sittings. I never knew what was going to happen. Yeah Halli and Aud!
ladyhart21 1 year ago
awesome
pmattson 2 years ago
I loved this book I wish there was a sequal of when aud and halli go on an adventure and seek out what is found beyond the vallley. the book never answered a few of the mysteries and i hope it is answered in the 2nd if ever possible to be one!
shikalover678 2 years ago 3
I read the book. It was pretty good :) it was good enough that I did my ISP project on it for english.
ashtreeh 2 years ago
I am currently halfway through the book and it's great. It's not as good as the Bartimaeus trilogy, but it's still a wonderful novel. I do hope it gets better - Jonathan Stroud can totally turn the readers' expectations around.
Quibre 2 years ago
luv the german cover but probably going to get the english version, looks good.
Nikkimond 3 years ago
I'm dying to read this book!!!!!!!
Quibre 3 years ago 2
It's seriously good! a little complex but you'll just have to wait and see!
shikalover678 2 years ago