Spanish Guitar - Rumba Flamenca

[dderudito]

Yo no he entiendido una cosa..por que esto es una rumba?

[guitaruleswebsite]

It's hard to play rumba if you haven't been shown properly.... This player has potential ... And when shown what a rumba is he should be able to correct what he is doing... Rumba lesson coming soon ... Google guitarules for more

[smellmyfingure]

this comment page looks like a page in the bible full of random bullshit

[memoerdeselchileno]

hola, no se si me pudieras pasar una pagina o algo asi donde vengan las tablaturas de esa cancion para poder sacarla

[ohorok2]

I am very bored of this flamenco music. Everything stands on F and E accords sometimes G or A.. and again F E. It sounds nice, but after 30 minutes of listening it is unpossible how many songs i just heard.. 5,6,7? I do not know everything sounds very very VERY simmilar..

[XsK5]

Oye muy buena! no parece ser tan dificil! :D

Me podrias pasar algo para que pueda tocarlo? jajaj alguna pista para tocar flamenco, algo de donde pueda aprender?

Esque yo toco clasico, pero el flamenco esta muy guapo. El problema es que no tengo quien me enseñe ni de donde aprender...

Algun consejo?

[em84009]

you've never talk to a gypsy, have you?

There are no science, none, in the way a gypsy grabs a guitar. Not a bit more than the way a gypsy grabs a knife or whatever.

And I bet you ignore the meaning of "traditional". Traditionaly, gypsies do a lot of things. Many of them are wrong. Very wrong. "Traditional posture" is a description. No relation about what is right. Just tourism. Next time you got hill do me a favour: use the gypsy traditional method of treating that ilness. will you, please?

[hamasaful]

does any body know the full name of that piece or maybe give me a link to it on the youtube cuz there r hundreds of rumba flamincas on the youtube just wana find it , plzzzzz people

[em84009]

guitar on left leg. please.

wtf

[wanderatlarge]

@em84009 Wrong. This clip is about Rumba Flamenca, played by gitanos. Gitanos ( gypsy ) most often play with both feet on the floor and the waist of the guitar resting on the right thigh.It is called the gitano posture. Also, some great flamenco players rest the guitar on their right thigh. For example, Manolo Sanlucar. Learn a little bit my friend first and after you can make critical comments. So that is wtf.

[em84009]

@wanderatlarge You're right. But that's not a thing to copy because it's an empirical solution. It's not the 'optimal solution'. Paco de Lucia has a compromised solution, closer to the optimal.

There was a tenist that used both hands. Do you think that we should teach that to a beginner?

There's a blues musician that's blind and lays the guitar on his lap and plays in the horizontal. Do you think that I shoud learn to play guitar that way?

It's the 'eficiency' concept. And not copy errors...

[wanderatlarge]

@em84009 Flamenco, like anything else, evolves over time. At the beginning, the tocaores played only 3-note chords using their thumb (pulgar) only. Even later, when they payed melodies, used their thumb only with techniques like El Ayudado, El Horquilla and El Alzapua. No rasgueo, no picado, no arpegio, no tremolo. These techniques developed later. So if you want to be "purist", only those who play 3-note chords with their thumb are the only flamenco players, right ?

[em84009]

@wanderatlarge you've lost the topic. We're talking about if it is right to imitate those who have learned to play by themselves and play splendidly, althou we know that their technique is faulty. I say no. Why? Because if you talk to them they will tell you how sad they are not to be taught right from the beginning. As you know, one can indeed play well using the thumb only and the guitar in the most awkward position. But we always will ask "imagine what he will do if using the proper technique

[wanderatlarge]

@em84009 Some homework 4 you: Gerhard Graf-Martinez "Flamenco Guitar Method Volume I" page 11 under Posture: Traditional posture both feet on the floor, body of the guitar rests ON THE RIGHT THIGH and the neck/body points upward approx 45 degrees. The Gitano posture is similar, except the the neck/body is almost horizontal. EXACTLY AS SHOWN ABOVE. So he wrote the book. And you ? What is your expertise ? BTW: Paco-de-Lucia crosses his legs and rests the guitar on his RIGHT THIGH . OK, I am done

[UchihaChihiro]

♥i love this song :) ♥

but what is thet

german:♥ich liebe dises lied♥

aber was ist das?

[IzzyC91]

Me encanta <3 I love it :)

[aquarius403]

super § jolie magnifique

[thelyko]

ole ole! te falto decir Muchazz graziaz!

[zyrhab]

no es rumba esto!!

[jimimaru87]

can you please tell me where to find this instructional video or if theres a tab? :)

i've searched but no luck, i would very much like to learn this piece!

[jorgesantamaria]

i recomend - spanish guitar- jesus fernandez

[kfjhfieurf]

very cool!!!!thanks

[AntonioE07]

which juan martin video? does it come in one of the books? if it does, whats the name of the video? thanks!

[chsgdss]

***** BEAUTIFUL *****

[voltage051]

pues no es flamenco, no hace abanico ni traba las cuerdas

[runlevel0]

No si tocar toca bien, pero le falta "duende"... y de rumba, ná de ná: Eso es guitarra española clásica, que para los que no entienden puede pasar por flamenco, pero ni la guitarra española clásica es flamenco ni la rumba flamenca se parece a esto.

Yo le recomendaría al payo este que escuchara a los Chichos.

[AntonioE07]

usted lo que es es un envidioso

[tarontube]

hey very nice. I 've just uploaded this one. But your version is better than mine ;)

[jagerhardin]

Bravo!

[champako]

oh wow man that is stunning .......breathtaking...mate do some instrumental stuff with congo drums...... u gonna rock....el bueno,

magnifico

[gemelovalencia]

un saludo desde colombia hombre muy wena la cancion ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡ pero q weno seria si la enseñara un poco mas lento nos vemos ¡¡¡¡

[magocebolinha]

veeeeeeery simple but still interesting!

[bluecrushs16]

this isnt that good at all what are you guys talking about?

[YaoMingbaby]

What tuning is that in?

[654321654321]

standard tuning.

[stavlaft]

OLèè!!!

[cvillemag]

c'est pas mal. merci!

[were2220]

barbant.... c'est pas terrible mais je deteste, c'est tres barbant

[Earthling122]

no yo speako mexicano, pero tocas muy bien!

[perrycostello]

wow that was really good do u have the tabs or sumting

[pel373]

i liked your playing :)

[josegonro84]

HOla, estoy por comprar una guitarra para comenzar, pero no se s CLASICA o FLAMENCA, ¿esa guitarra del video de que tipo es?. a ver si pueden echarme una mano.

Por cierto el video buenisimo, enhorabuena.

[654321654321]

hola!

es una gran duda la que tienes, hace poco pasé por lo mismo. ¿Qué música quieres tocar con esa guitarra?

La guitarra de este video no es clásica ni flamenca, es una guitarra muy básica y antigua.

En mis otros videos uso una guitarra clásica, en el video "alt lys svunnet hen" o "dance of yi" la uso como clásica y en "la feria" la uso para rasgueos flamencos. Una flamenca sonaría con menos "potencia" pero más percusiva y más "cálida".

[mainframezxb]

donde podria conseguir el vidao para practicar la cancion?

[unesx]

vous trop coool !!

good job !! ;)

[nicoo2k]

¡Cómo me gustaría saber tocar así! ¿Cuánto tiempo tarda una persona en aprender a tocar algo similar? Nada profesional, sólo por amor al arte :)

[lomb8]

Lo que toca este chico es sencillito, si realmente te gusta y te lo propones no tardas más de 5 meses (a mi modo de ver y suponiendo que no tengas ni idea)...pero claro, ante todo tener paciencia y ensayar habitualmente.

Saludossss

God job 654321.......

[654321654321]

gracias por los comentarios.

como dice lomb8, esto no es difícil, pero debes tener control y fuerza en la mano derecha para poder hacer sonar los rasgueados como debe ser.

si nunca has tocado guitarra yo creo que con unos 5-6 meses de harta práctica podrías tocar esto.(aunque puede ser más o menos dependiendo de como se adapte tu mano derecha)

[nicoo2k]

Muchas gracias a ambos por sus comentarios :)

[salamiwecken]

great

[stebuson]

ok! You play like Juan Martin but he plays in F diesis

[fafariata]

ma il ponticello dov'è?

[xxy1013]

cool!! well done!! btw, "buena" must be spanish right? :)

[654321654321]

thanks!

yes, "buena" is spanish and means something like "well done"

[wannalearnguitar]

great job man i wanted to play this song but i had some difficulties in the technique but i will try to play it soon

[ARBEJONE]

buena !!