One of best series I've ever seen. Terrific and absolutely fantastic about the eternal fight between evilness and goodness. The composer, Jeff Beal, does an incredible work. I recommend you if you hasn't seen it
Stop the bull crap. Where were all of you when the show was airing. Exactly. Nobody watched then but now all of you talk about how the "mainstream following idiots" ruined the show for you. The truth is that you are part of the mainstream.
this show was simply amazing. as Clancy Brown said, there wasn't enough people who embraced its complexity and subtlety. Carnivale planned to have six seasons. SIX DAMN SEASONS!!! Imagine the possibilities. Another great show canceled because of the dumbed down public.
i think part of the problem was that no one heard of it maybe because of poor advertising of something, i think the best think to do is to rerun the show and try and get it popular to the point HBO can't refuse to fund the rest of the seasons, might be a little too late now though as the actors have gotten older
I love this show to death, but I'm not surprised it was canceled. It might have had great writing and characters, but it also had an incredibly slow pace. One of the most consistent criticisms I hear is that the show is boring because of it. It also placed a huge focus on atmosphere (which not many people can appreciate) and a deep mythology (which made it difficult to get into for new viewers). The show in general is also really strange, and it just seems very niche.
The show was meant to be six seasons, which you'd know. So the slow pace is.. Well the first two seasons are one big intro, would have picked up during 3/4 and been absolutely brilliant 5/6. Too bad it never got that far :(
I want to see if I can get my parents to buy the first season of this tv show for my birthday and since I have not been getting helo frim anywhere else, how much sex and nudity does this tv show have? Does it have less sex and nudity then Rome?
It doesn't have low ratings on imdb.com its pretty high actually, 9.0/10 from a ten. They usually get higher when the show is cut off. People become more interested in things when they get taken off of the air. I'm just hoping this won't happen to True Blood because that is such a great show. And has high ratings, alot of people like it. I'm guessing also because of the sex, too. Lol but HBO does tend to take off such great shows, a lot of the time. Idk why..
@zombiechaos89 I've heard the show was very expensive to produce, and every episode ran over budget. So its cancellation was more of an issue of cost, not popularity.
@athaskreen Yes, I heard that too. What a shame! And to think so much money is wasted on garbage, but when a show that is really worth the expense comes along, whammo. Totally lame.
Andrew Krepiach2 Magee's deal is to inflame not inform. He is a false flag impersonator of ME..KREPLACH. Like a child he gets his jollies from getting attention. Its never acknowledges the other party's opinions so its useless to debate him. What we all need to do to use YouTube help to complain about him and get him deleted.
The troll can be banned I got his previous cloned identity MrJapaneseboy11111 deleted. He is also amagee590
I saw the first episode last year and thought, "This is the show I've been looking for--a fantasy for adults set in a specific historical era." It's now one of my favorite shows. I'm still bitter about it's cancellation (especially considering other shows like Big Brother have had over a dozen seasons thus far), but, in the end, I'd rather have the first third of a great story than no story at all, so I'm happy.
The intro is brilliant. I never skip it when watching the show.
@AvatarYoda I want to start watching it, but since it aparently ended with just two seasons, do you think I will be disappointed much with lots of loose ends or even with that, its great? Just asking for an opinion
There are a few loose ends, but for the most part, things are wrapped up in a satisfactory manner. This is definitely not a series to miss. When you finish it, read the Carnivale pitch document online--it explains the history that the series would have told in later seasons and makes many things (i.e. characters, magic) much clearer. The creators also put out a statement telling what happened to the major characters after the end, so you're not left completely hanging. Enjoy!
@AvatarYoda hey thanks, I got the dvd of first season today. and ignore andrew magee, he is an imposter who was posting anti-semitic statements all over the YT and have resorted to slandering people who are opposing him.!!!
HBO has some damn good intros for all their shows, but this one is the best, without a doubt. I miss Carnivale. The music! Oh god, the music is out of this world.
Best thing ever broadcast from a TV screen.HBO should have cancelled ALL their other shit to keep this on.I guess it was just way too far over the heads of the dumbed-down,MTV watchin bozos the executives are targeting.What a crime.
Because the ratings did not live up to the required minimum if they where going to keep pumping $4 mil into every episode, and the general consesus where that if they can not make the show as good as they possible can, they won't do it at all.
I know alot of ppl on the show, and on HBO fought hard to keep it on the air, but, sadly it did not work out. So we are left with 2 extremely well-made seasons of what I consider to be the best show ever aired, but as you said, it left us hanging.
Not sure why Carnivale got low ratings. It had such a haunting, amazing story. The setting (Great Depression, carnival) was perfect and the show had a great balance of character development, plot development, fear factor, and overall entertainment. Plus how ingenius to put Ben, an ex-con as the good guy versus Brother Justin,a man of God, but representing evil.
The shame is that it was the first show that was actually planned out. The seasons weren't just "Yeah, they're wathing it, let's drag it out". Dexter for instance. This show was meant to have six seasons, so the first two were basically just one really big intro.
But HBO couldn't help themselves. Any decent show has to be cut
Is it weird this show reminds me of The X-men Age of Apocalypse X-Man Comic book 1-4. I Love Clea Duval if I had my way I'd but her in everyshow she'd ever wanna be in especially Lost why because we knows where real monsters get their start and she ain't just some paperbag princess she's a M'F'N Dragon Slayer The Girl is The greatest player ever of DragonKnightIV the greatest DragonKnight Game and She was in
that Barry Manilow Movie with Jason Segel and Tara from the Willow and Buffy show...
I LOVED this show.......so fantastic.....so angry when it was cancelled......how stupid is HBO anyway? I mean, what were they thinking? Any chance of this amazing show returning?
I too am very disappointed that HBO chose to cancel something as thought provoking and interesting as this program. We at least could have had a movie to give us an end to the cliff hanger final episode!
Very slow, very quiet, very odd. Too bad HBO didn't give them the six seasons they supposedly promised them. Sometimes too weird for its own good but they had to cram 72 shows into 24!
I'm glad I bought both seasons and I'm thinking about buying a new set of Season One because mine doesn't have the same attractive packaging as my Season Two.
This has been flagged as spam show
the sound coming in the background at 0:11 must be a sample from this: /watch?v=dbkte-RF0Ns&t=0m22s
either that or the other way around, or perhaps that both of them took it from somewhere else :)
Wensby 1 month ago
One of best series I've ever seen. Terrific and absolutely fantastic about the eternal fight between evilness and goodness. The composer, Jeff Beal, does an incredible work. I recommend you if you hasn't seen it
frafa84 3 months ago
I loved this show..alot of people are scared of this type of thing..Io thought it it was great!!
tamilapp 5 months ago
When the little girl's face transforms into Michael the Archangel's -- chills. Every. Single. Time.
Absolutely brilliant show. Such a terrible shame that it's gone. :C
AraireSkance 7 months ago
@AraireSkance Lol, Same with me, I think its the eerie Native American Esque singing in the background that adds to the creep factor XD
XvxBERSERKxvX 2 months ago
Stop the bull crap. Where were all of you when the show was airing. Exactly. Nobody watched then but now all of you talk about how the "mainstream following idiots" ruined the show for you. The truth is that you are part of the mainstream.
raccoongirl100 8 months ago
The first season was an absolute work of genius, amazingly inspired. The second was worked up by a monkey on crack.
althesmith 8 months ago
Amazing opening
limaozito 8 months ago
Simply THE BEST SERIES EVER.
Motherfuckers, we want IT back .
GentlemanDriverWorld 11 months ago
this show was simply amazing. as Clancy Brown said, there wasn't enough people who embraced its complexity and subtlety. Carnivale planned to have six seasons. SIX DAMN SEASONS!!! Imagine the possibilities. Another great show canceled because of the dumbed down public.
SmokinBluntzzz 1 year ago 3
@SmokinBluntzzz
i think part of the problem was that no one heard of it maybe because of poor advertising of something, i think the best think to do is to rerun the show and try and get it popular to the point HBO can't refuse to fund the rest of the seasons, might be a little too late now though as the actors have gotten older
briishspy 1 year ago 2
@SmokinBluntzzz "dumbed down public" yea those stupid bastards would rather watch american idol
Ahmariano 10 months ago
I love this show to death, but I'm not surprised it was canceled. It might have had great writing and characters, but it also had an incredibly slow pace. One of the most consistent criticisms I hear is that the show is boring because of it. It also placed a huge focus on atmosphere (which not many people can appreciate) and a deep mythology (which made it difficult to get into for new viewers). The show in general is also really strange, and it just seems very niche.
thetroybagnell 1 year ago
@thetroybagnell
The show was meant to be six seasons, which you'd know. So the slow pace is.. Well the first two seasons are one big intro, would have picked up during 3/4 and been absolutely brilliant 5/6. Too bad it never got that far :(
FraggingBard 9 months ago
Te best show ever done.
Anubis22bcn 1 year ago 4
I want to see if I can get my parents to buy the first season of this tv show for my birthday and since I have not been getting helo frim anywhere else, how much sex and nudity does this tv show have? Does it have less sex and nudity then Rome?
forestofmyths 1 year ago
The best show always!
Anubis22bcn 1 year ago
Damn I wish this show had not been cancelled. It was soooo great
Trund27 1 year ago
@Trund27 I heard it was cancelled... very dissapointing! I'm in the middle of the first season, and it's fantastic so far!
GetaLyfe2011 1 year ago
At :37, does anyone know what the vocals are / are from? Sounds almost like some Native American chanting, curious if there are any specifics on it.
I generally hate all intros of shows, but i absolutely love this one, if nothing more than for the amazing music.
Mansurus 1 year ago
It doesn't have low ratings on imdb.com its pretty high actually, 9.0/10 from a ten. They usually get higher when the show is cut off. People become more interested in things when they get taken off of the air. I'm just hoping this won't happen to True Blood because that is such a great show. And has high ratings, alot of people like it. I'm guessing also because of the sex, too. Lol but HBO does tend to take off such great shows, a lot of the time. Idk why..
zombiechaos89 1 year ago
@zombiechaos89 I've heard the show was very expensive to produce, and every episode ran over budget. So its cancellation was more of an issue of cost, not popularity.
athaskreen 1 year ago
@athaskreen Yes, I heard that too. What a shame! And to think so much money is wasted on garbage, but when a show that is really worth the expense comes along, whammo. Totally lame.
Trund27 1 year ago
I love Carnivale Best show in the world.
308Rex 1 year ago 4
@308Rex yup
magellanphone 1 year ago
I love Carnivale Best show in the world.
308Rex 1 year ago
Does exist a longer version? It's fantastic.
Sorry for the english, I'm italian.
Carnivàle, by the way, it wasn't absolutely my favorite series, but it's a shame that HBO cancelled it.
LostBrawl 1 year ago
Andrew Krepiach2 Magee's deal is to inflame not inform. He is a false flag impersonator of ME..KREPLACH. Like a child he gets his jollies from getting attention. Its never acknowledges the other party's opinions so its useless to debate him. What we all need to do to use YouTube help to complain about him and get him deleted.
The troll can be banned I got his previous cloned identity MrJapaneseboy11111 deleted. He is also amagee590
kreplach2 1 year ago
I saw the first episode last year and thought, "This is the show I've been looking for--a fantasy for adults set in a specific historical era." It's now one of my favorite shows. I'm still bitter about it's cancellation (especially considering other shows like Big Brother have had over a dozen seasons thus far), but, in the end, I'd rather have the first third of a great story than no story at all, so I'm happy.
The intro is brilliant. I never skip it when watching the show.
AvatarYoda 1 year ago
@AvatarYoda I want to start watching it, but since it aparently ended with just two seasons, do you think I will be disappointed much with lots of loose ends or even with that, its great? Just asking for an opinion
droomerd 1 year ago
@droomerd
There are a few loose ends, but for the most part, things are wrapped up in a satisfactory manner. This is definitely not a series to miss. When you finish it, read the Carnivale pitch document online--it explains the history that the series would have told in later seasons and makes many things (i.e. characters, magic) much clearer. The creators also put out a statement telling what happened to the major characters after the end, so you're not left completely hanging. Enjoy!
AvatarYoda 1 year ago
@AvatarYoda hey thanks, I got the dvd of first season today. and ignore andrew magee, he is an imposter who was posting anti-semitic statements all over the YT and have resorted to slandering people who are opposing him.!!!
droomerd 1 year ago
HBO has some damn good intros for all their shows, but this one is the best, without a doubt. I miss Carnivale. The music! Oh god, the music is out of this world.
somethingswicked 1 year ago
Best thing ever broadcast from a TV screen.HBO should have cancelled ALL their other shit to keep this on.I guess it was just way too far over the heads of the dumbed-down,MTV watchin bozos the executives are targeting.What a crime.
ManyGodz 1 year ago
Awesome show indeed. . Last episode leaves you hanging though.
Quoting from Wikipedia: "HBO budgeted approximately US$4 million for each episode, considerably more than what most television series receive"
Wtf were they thinking why did they cancel it????
HighEvolutionary175 2 years ago
Because the ratings did not live up to the required minimum if they where going to keep pumping $4 mil into every episode, and the general consesus where that if they can not make the show as good as they possible can, they won't do it at all.
I know alot of ppl on the show, and on HBO fought hard to keep it on the air, but, sadly it did not work out. So we are left with 2 extremely well-made seasons of what I consider to be the best show ever aired, but as you said, it left us hanging.
TheOdMan 1 year ago
I missed this show!
daphalot 2 years ago
this show was AMAZING!!!
mayaralinda 2 years ago
Definitely
PAP300 2 years ago
best show ever! i wish it was still on!
TinaAldenRees 2 years ago
Not sure why Carnivale got low ratings. It had such a haunting, amazing story. The setting (Great Depression, carnival) was perfect and the show had a great balance of character development, plot development, fear factor, and overall entertainment. Plus how ingenius to put Ben, an ex-con as the good guy versus Brother Justin,a man of God, but representing evil.
psychicriver 2 years ago 45
I woulsnt say ingenius since this kinda of play on evil vs good has been done a million times in literature, but intresting on screen none the less
tara202 2 years ago
@psychicriver in ym opinion this is the best drama series that was ever or ever will be on.I completely agree with everything you said.
ieetemos4breakfast 1 year ago
@psychicriver
'Cause people are afraid of the dark who not means for sure " evil ", but they' re think so !
GentlemanDriverWorld 1 year ago
@psychicriver
I guess it didn't have enough sex scenes for your average joe's entertainment.
SamsButterscotch 1 year ago 4
@psychicriver it got low ratings because it's too good and most people like mediocre or bad stuff.
Oxymorone7 1 year ago
@psychicriver it got low ratings because it's good and most people like mediocre or bad stuff.
Oxymorone7 1 year ago 2
@psychicriver totally... couldn't have put it better myself, lol. shame they cut it at only two seasons. real shame.
utubebgay 10 months ago
@utubebgay
The shame is that it was the first show that was actually planned out. The seasons weren't just "Yeah, they're wathing it, let's drag it out". Dexter for instance. This show was meant to have six seasons, so the first two were basically just one really big intro.
But HBO couldn't help themselves. Any decent show has to be cut
FraggingBard 9 months ago
@psychicriver it was way too smart for an audience.
atomicspatula 8 months ago 2
Is it weird this show reminds me of The X-men Age of Apocalypse X-Man Comic book 1-4. I Love Clea Duval if I had my way I'd but her in everyshow she'd ever wanna be in especially Lost why because we knows where real monsters get their start and she ain't just some paperbag princess she's a M'F'N Dragon Slayer The Girl is The greatest player ever of DragonKnightIV the greatest DragonKnight Game and She was in
that Barry Manilow Movie with Jason Segel and Tara from the Willow and Buffy show...
InvisibleChicken999 2 years ago
I LOVED this show.......so fantastic.....so angry when it was cancelled......how stupid is HBO anyway? I mean, what were they thinking? Any chance of this amazing show returning?
passionateaboutmusic 2 years ago
I too am very disappointed that HBO chose to cancel something as thought provoking and interesting as this program. We at least could have had a movie to give us an end to the cliff hanger final episode!
DyleneC 2 years ago 2
I was SOOOO pissed when i found out they were discontinuing the series because you get so attached to the characters and the crazy story -.-'
MsRachelHalpin 2 years ago
Very slow, very quiet, very odd. Too bad HBO didn't give them the six seasons they supposedly promised them. Sometimes too weird for its own good but they had to cram 72 shows into 24!
I'm glad I bought both seasons and I'm thinking about buying a new set of Season One because mine doesn't have the same attractive packaging as my Season Two.
Love this show!
frankensteinsmermaid 2 years ago
is perfect
rodrigoes123456789 2 years ago
it sso fucking amazing the producer ...oh my god¡¡¡..is a genious¡¡¡***
tatianaflowers 3 years ago
i watch this show and i wonder why would it fail? i just love the show and this is a unique one!
dmitrivalencia 4 years ago 3
one of the best series opening (obb) i ever seen!
bluecrestarts 3 years ago 18
I miss this show so much I could cry..
thebrooke 4 years ago 5