Added: 4 years ago
From: Vostorgina01
Views: 86,385
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (46)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • very nice *****

  • Does anyone know on which Mireille album this originally appeared??

  • Hat lange gedauert aber jetzt am 10. Dezember sieht man endlich schnee auch bei uns

  • Erinnert mich an meine Schwester die vor 50 Jahren nach Canada ging

  • Bin alles andere als ein Schlagerfan, aber das Lied hat absolut was.

  • einfach schön!

  • Hört euch das Lied bei 35 Grad Celsius an.

  • Ist doch ein schönes Lied und Mimi ist sowieso die Beste.

  • Sooo ergreifen schön

  • Toller Song, danke für's online stellen!

  • @entdeckeKanada da ich eine schwester in canada  habe liebe ich das lied

  • mirelle ist für mich immer noch ergreifend.

    ich wünsche ihr alles Gute.

    lang lebe Mirelle !!!

  • very nice. I like the version by Elissa Gabbai too.

    The paintings are wonderful. There is a Canadian painter by the name of Cornelius Krieghoff who has a similar style and subject matter. If you wanted a more authentic Canadian ambience, Krieghoff would do, but the Russian painter is fine. The winter scenes are much the same in both countries.

  • Thanks for the tip, dear!

    Ciao,

    r. b. Vostorgina

  • @ironpirites

    Some of the group of 7 would have been fitting too, they did some great winter scenes... but then again it would be overly stereotypical.

  • Also wenn ich die version von Elissa Gabbai höre krieg ich Stress, die singt vieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeel zu schnell!!!!

    unerträglich!!!!

    Mireille Matthieu dagegen ruhig und schön, da kann man träumen!!!

  • Indeed! And why not? It adds to the fun, nicht wahr? BTW, are you an English Quebecker or a full-blooded Canuck Quebecois? If the latter, you could add, "as noticed by a smiling and sly Quebecois".

    Cheers! Do pass the jug, it is on your right!

    r. b. Vostorgina

  • Its a French singer, singing in German, about Russian pictures, with a Canadian title?

  • wunderbar,- soo viel gefühl

  • Krankhafter Ehrgeiz??? Immer nur vergleichen und kritisieren???

  • Ich geb dir wirklich Recht! Diese scheiß Vergleiche! Es ist so ein tolles Lied, von beiden Interpreten toll gesungen. Es erinnert mich an meine Kindheit und macht mich etwas traurig. L.G.

  • Elissa Gabbai macht das besser

  • Mirelle das besser

  • Mireille is too slow

  • Vive Mirelle. Elle chante mieux qu'Elissa Gabbai. Quelle pureté cette voix.

  • Russische Trojkas als Bilder...

  • Wunderbare Version!

  • Wunderbare Version!

  • M.M. Fassung ist um längen besser und viel gefühlvoller wie die Version von E.G. @Schusterlehrling: Du hast keine Ahnung!

  • Sie kommt nicht hoch genug im Refrain.

    Schade. netter Versuch.

  • Elle chante beaucoup mieux qu'Elissa Gabbai.

  • Eine ganz tolle Version, aber das Original von Elisa Gabbai ist natürlich unerreicht.

  • Die Fassung von Elissa Gabba ist viel zu hektisch!

    M. M.'s Fassung passt viel besser zum Text!

  • stimme voll zu!

  • Na ja, Mireille knödelt (voooookaaaaal) so ziemlich und kann auch nicht hoch genug singen für den Refrain.

    Schade.

    Auch das Tempo ist für die Leidenschaft, die Mireille anspricht typisch, aber nicht für die Frau, die es leidenschaftlich sigen kann.

    Mireille singt eben auch wie eine Matrone.

  • Elissa 5/10

    Mireille 10/10

  • Elissa 100

    Mireille 2

  • Thanks. Mireille Mathieu bears an unique and attractive French accent. The song is very nice....but, first class are the background with Russian inspiration.

  • I have placed the original version by Elissa Gabbai as a video response above. It is matched with photographs of the Russian countryside in winter.

    raba bozhiya Vostorgina01

  • MM has loyal fans all over the world. Her voice is unforgettable - even in the United States, where we rarely hear anything about MM on our silly TV networks, those of us that have traveled abroad, and have heard MM, are forever her fans. Thank God for the Internet that keeps us in the loop. Thanks for posting this.

  • I DO agree! MM just did a special concert in St Petersburg to honour the victims of the siege in the 2nd Great Patriotic War. Her fans in Russia are legion!

  • I want to thank all of you who have watched this video. I thought that I was the ONLY Mireille Matthieu fan left! I DO remember the other version, but, I have not been able to find it on the internet. Thank you for bringing joy to me by watching my vid.

    Vostrogina01

  • Dear Vostorgina01: First, let me thank you for posting this charming video. I think the Russian winter scenes go quite well with the "Winter in Canada" theme. Let me assure you that her fans are legion, and from all over the world! Her songs are optimistic and uplifting, which resonates with people everywhere. Even her French patriotic songs manage not to be chauvinistic, but, rather, to appeal to every healthy individual's love of country. Again, thank you.

  • Elisa please record again.

  • I remember this song as a kid living in Germany when my dad was in the RCAF. No one in Canada has ever heard of the song I think! Too bad.

  • Es war Winter in Kanada... :-) nettes Lied

  • Ein Klassiker zur Weihnachtszeit.

  • do you also have the original version of the song (by elisa gabbai)?

  • This is the only version I have at present, I am afraid.

  • You might insert some fleeting Canadian images such as Royal Canadian Mounties,lumberjacks, maple syrup, and mgagnificent mountains and lakes. Fool the audience better.

  • I wasn't trying to fool the audience. It is the title of the song! I didn't write it! All my vids have a Russian tie-in... and you have to admit, winter in Canada... winter in Russia... what's the difference?

    Thank you for the comment. It means you watched the vid! Shall we crack open an adult beverage? (I suggest the real thing... not Coke! Vodka!)

    raba bozhiya Vostorgina

  • ach liebe den song !!! ohhhhhhhhhh....einfach nur süß; danke für den song!

    VW Golf 4EVER

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more