His good, but he don't have this thing in his voice who make him special like Kurt Nilsen have :3 If you hear a song by Kurt you can tell by the second, but this could be like... anyone!! :D
Very good performance. Excellent presentation. He's also not hard to look at. Anyplace in Europe, Australia or North America he would have scored very big indeed! And isn't that a sad comment?
This performance is nothing special IMO. There is no range at all and it sounds the same throughout the entire performance. Yes, Aerosmith sings it way better, but David Cook's version was much better than this as well.
I didn't even know that there where white people in Africa until I saw him singing on World Idol. LOL I wanna give a shout out to the american public school system for that one.
I kinda don't understand why Simon didn't like this when most of the talent he finds and funds is based on looks as well as the voice...Leona, Westlife etc. I wanted this guy to win though...
I could listen to Heinz singing the telephone book ;) but I kinda agree with you on this one, However, he did a more acoustic version of this song on his second album, Come Alive, that was absolutely amazing! Check it out if you can and let me know what you think.
omgsh i saw him in ohio last week as roger in rent. he was amazing! plus he's a total hottie.. but yeahh his voice is truly amazing and yeahh i definitly cried when he sang one song glory cuz he had tears in his eyes while he sang. i totally believed he WAS roger. :D
i saw him last week in rent iv seen it before and he is by far the best roger.!! iv never seen anyone so talented!! i wish i could buy his cd's, if they sold them in canada they would fly. i hate having to come on youtube to hear him, it would be nice to have it in my car, if anyone knows if the cds can be bought or are coming to canada let me know!!
i saw rent on the 22nd it was ABSOLUTLY AMAZIN . Heinz wasfantastic .. his voice is so pure . when he was singing what you own .. you could feel the intensity and the power . he haas a true gift .. and i belive you can get his cds on itunes
i saw rent on the 22nd it was ABSOLUTLY AMAZIN . Heinz wasfantastic .. his voice is so pure . when he was singing what you own .. you could feel the intensity and the power . he haas a true gift .. and i belive you can get his cds on itunes
amazing! i saw him in rent last night in hershey, pa and he was fantastic! even though i wish that he got a little angrier during some scenes, he blew my breath away during "i should tell you" and "your eyes"!
Heinz you are the best SA IDOLS winner ever. We were so proud of you at the World Idols Competition. This performance on video here is FABULOUS!!!! Congratulations & best wishes from South Africa. xx
this is what u call a "flat" performance. he sings very well! and looks (if i must say) very hot lol but this was boring. and i love this song! but i would but any cd hes got, just to stare at his picture ;)
nie chciałam nikogo urazić, mi tez się bardzo podobało, ale moim zdaniem byli lepsi od niego (stawiałam na Kelly)Heinz jest świetnym wokalistą, ale moim zdaniem brakuje mu charyzmy... gdyby wygrał prawdopodobnie zapomniano by o nim tak szybko jak o Kurcie.
He's sooo cute and his voice is really nice! Unfortunately he's not really popular in The Netherlands..so can people post more video's from Heinz so I can see and hear more from him...that would be great!
that was so very nice. i've been searching for this performance for a long time now. thanks a lot for posting this. my sister has a big big crush on him. when we watched world idol, my sister was like, "the south african idol is so handsome!" hahah!
Hey exogenous!! Thanx for this video.I am from South Africa, Heinz has grown so much since World Idol...he does have a good voice.Have a good weekend.
Not bad. But for South African talent, refer to Seether. Shaun Morgan is insanely awesome.
disclaimer05 1 month ago
His good, but he don't have this thing in his voice who make him special like Kurt Nilsen have :3 If you hear a song by Kurt you can tell by the second, but this could be like... anyone!! :D
RandomChocolate008 7 months ago
American idol has never had a performance half as good as ths one!!
SuperAndre1411 10 months ago
@SuperAndre1411 hes off key at least 4 times within the 1st minute so get the fuck out.
ballackbeckham 9 months ago
well he's hot... but that doesnt make him a good singer!
inmec 11 months ago
@inmec THANK YOU!
ballackbeckham 9 months ago
I've seen American Idol LOSERS far more talented than this guy. I can appreciate America's superiority when I see the "best" from other countries.
365to173repubsPWNED 11 months ago
@365to173repubsPWNED LOL so true
ballackbeckham 9 months ago
showcase for sa talent
songsforyou1000 1 year ago
Nejlepší !!!!! Best ! in Wolrd
Randos381 1 year ago
sexy Heinz:)
athelka8 1 year ago
i think the song was too "BIG" for him... but still, he did a good job.....
MagnaultiSumus 1 year ago
kind of underwhelming. good song choice though
martialalex 1 year ago
wow.,., the best.,., ever.,.,
Pitboomlyf 1 year ago
what a really really bad version .. no feelings .. no heart in his voice .. just bad
ersechzig 1 year ago
Very good performance. Excellent presentation. He's also not hard to look at. Anyplace in Europe, Australia or North America he would have scored very big indeed! And isn't that a sad comment?
Augie47 1 year ago
This performance is nothing special IMO. There is no range at all and it sounds the same throughout the entire performance. Yes, Aerosmith sings it way better, but David Cook's version was much better than this as well.
Blinkx7 1 year ago
@Blinkx7 Sure, if Heinz had the orchestra backing - he would put shame to David's performance!
roneller1012r 1 year ago
I didn't even know that there where white people in Africa until I saw him singing on World Idol. LOL I wanna give a shout out to the american public school system for that one.
thedurmstrangdelegat 1 year ago
this is the wrong song for him. other songs he sings much better.
asuma51 2 years ago
Steven Tyler sings this MUCH better
MJTMastercp 2 years ago
Steven Tyler is Untouchable Therefore This is not the song for him.....
This sounds good bcuz of the song not becuz he's good @ singing it
heshanck93 2 years ago
your logic is flawed on so many levels!
uChakide 2 years ago
omfg i could listen to this song over and over and over again and never tired of it
Aerosmithfan4484 2 years ago
oo,sexy Heinz:-)
athelka8 2 years ago
this was the wrong song for him
Unscrachable 2 years ago
aw
i didn't hear the high note at the end of bridge
Orter99 2 years ago
it's good but no one can sing this piece better than steven tyler.. its a completed song..
adrianathecook 2 years ago
I kinda don't understand why Simon didn't like this when most of the talent he finds and funds is based on looks as well as the voice...Leona, Westlife etc. I wanted this guy to win though...
Jofishi 2 years ago
sehr schön. sehr schön. *applaus* toll. großartig.
Pluenni 2 years ago
you want to hear I Dont Wanna Miss A Thing sung amazing go listen to Aerosmith, Heinz good but he aint no Steven Tyler
Rearhole431820 3 years ago
I could listen to Heinz singing the telephone book ;) but I kinda agree with you on this one, However, he did a more acoustic version of this song on his second album, Come Alive, that was absolutely amazing! Check it out if you can and let me know what you think.
hottramp 2 years ago
Eee! He's so amazing!
lex91793 3 years ago
how come there's no more world idol??
mamamiya3210 3 years ago 2
David Cook is the best idols winner of all countries and seasons. Heinz is the best out of all the South African shows though
JonoLFC 3 years ago
well said mate
zemogkcin 2 years ago
yup, he's cute & handsome. good boy looks. i remember simon cowell saying he does not look naughty enough for the song...
livestrong1565 3 years ago
South Africa? LAWL.
ShurikenOfLight 3 years ago
He is such a sexy man!!!
britneysprsfan1 3 years ago 9
I remember this, loved it!!!
roeltiesmoeltie 3 years ago 2
yeah david cook is better.haha
wsjzzz 3 years ago
that was a great performance. i remain me i was so young x)
Svennileinchen89 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david cook is better!
chestnutiscute 3 years ago
Omgg, i rememeber watching this when it was on tv,i was so youngg.
i love it.<3
xoJustMyLuck 3 years ago 6
awesome..,,
Pitboomlyf 3 years ago
I LOVE HIM!
best roger in rent if you didnt get to see him in the tour you missed out!
he is amazing and he sings this song great!
bmoran711 3 years ago
Agreed!!!! An amazing singer, actor, etc. He is an awesome Roger!
SacaDitto 3 years ago 4
he has a good voice, good looks but i hate to say this, this does not suite him at all, he should have went for a ballad to really excel his voice.
thelcfkilla 3 years ago
Damn, nice voice and sexy (for a dude)...I'd tap that if I thought my wife would never find out about it.
jleffingwell 3 years ago
i live in germany and i called for him at world idol
desmoil 3 years ago
Southafrica must be very proud... a great singer.. and damn hot!!!!
MARIANOHARRY1980 3 years ago
he is the 2nd best roger after Adam
MrsGerardAWay 3 years ago
Check out his music video - Next Stop Happiness
berlyn21 3 years ago
wow...he is real good
his voice is beautiful<3
Unfaithful7777 3 years ago
Oh man, I saw him in Rent this weekend, and he was absolutely amazing! I met him a couple times over the weekend, it was awesome.
lgfrommk2931 3 years ago
best roger i've ever seen in rent. he was completely amazing. what a voice, and not bad looking either. ;]
buckhoist 3 years ago 3
I agree - best Roger by far!!
amariedavies 3 years ago
omgsh i saw him in ohio last week as roger in rent. he was amazing! plus he's a total hottie.. but yeahh his voice is truly amazing and yeahh i definitly cried when he sang one song glory cuz he had tears in his eyes while he sang. i totally believed he WAS roger. :D
vballcutie003 3 years ago
i saw him last week in rent iv seen it before and he is by far the best roger.!! iv never seen anyone so talented!! i wish i could buy his cd's, if they sold them in canada they would fly. i hate having to come on youtube to hear him, it would be nice to have it in my car, if anyone knows if the cds can be bought or are coming to canada let me know!!
tnx
loveofyourlife69 3 years ago
I'M SEEING HIM RIGHT NOW ON MY SCREEN
nisuputamadreloconoc 4 years ago
Saw him as Roger in RENT here in Toronto last night. He was the BEST VOICE in the show!
He did a WONDERFUL JOB!!!!
Does anyone know if he has any CDs available in Canada?
I looked at HMV but they hadn't even heard of him.
soapfan71 4 years ago 2
I just saw him tonight! So good eh?
julesnoelle 4 years ago
I saw him on Friday! He was AMAZING!!
HarryPotterRENThead 4 years ago
I saw him too... he was amazing
lemonytea 4 years ago
i saw rent on the 22nd it was ABSOLUTLY AMAZIN . Heinz wasfantastic .. his voice is so pure . when he was singing what you own .. you could feel the intensity and the power . he haas a true gift .. and i belive you can get his cds on itunes
lilchemicalprincess 4 years ago
i saw rent on the 22nd it was ABSOLUTLY AMAZIN . Heinz wasfantastic .. his voice is so pure . when he was singing what you own .. you could feel the intensity and the power . he haas a true gift .. and i belive you can get his cds on itunes
lilchemicalprincess 4 years ago
its not available here in North America
its available in England though so if u go over there....
Selena712 3 years ago
i saw him in kansas city on sunday he was awsome
patches4089 4 years ago
i love the way he does this song...it's so beautiful! i just love him! RENT too! th
lmc465 4 years ago
I saw him in rent last night. I his autograph, and a picture. He was amazing in rent! I sat front row, so i saw him perfectly. He is so talented.
ashlicaroline 4 years ago
i saw him in rent. hah i got his autograph and i was talking to him. he's really cool and talented. AMAZING. :]
caitex3babii 4 years ago
i saw Heinz in Rent a few days ago, and his voice is beyond amazing.
chupko23x 4 years ago
I saw him in Chicago two days ago. His voice is so amazing.
clg420 4 years ago
Wow, so did I.
guurah 4 years ago
this is amazing. HE is amazing. i just saw him in rent and it was totally and completely...well, amazing.
seriously. hes hot, and has an awesome voice. what more can u ask for? lol
lovesdanecook 4 years ago
not only is he amazingly hot, he can sing pretty damn well. He should have won. I have never gotten chills from this song until i heard him sing it.
beckys757 4 years ago 2
dude he did win ;)
gracfllyunnamed 4 years ago
I meant the world Idol comp.
beckys757 4 years ago
i loove him
vonBlubb 4 years ago
omg i just saw him in RENT he was sooo amazing and hes sooo hot!! <3
leximerizzie 4 years ago
He has amazing voice^_^and he's cute!
Danuuuutaa 4 years ago
HEINZ RULES 8DDDD *Fangirl squeel*!! Here's another South African shout-out to the best singer in the world <3 ^0^!!!
44dragonmaster44 4 years ago
amazing! i saw him in rent last night in hershey, pa and he was fantastic! even though i wish that he got a little angrier during some scenes, he blew my breath away during "i should tell you" and "your eyes"!
defyinggravity319 4 years ago
YES!! i saw him tonight in Boston and he made my mom cry during One Song Glory
skatgeek 4 years ago
awesome... love his voice
SolAngelica 4 years ago
Great singer!
Cranny71 4 years ago
Heinz you are the best SA IDOLS winner ever. We were so proud of you at the World Idols Competition. This performance on video here is FABULOUS!!!! Congratulations & best wishes from South Africa. xx
beverleyann7 4 years ago
say what you want, Kurt won!
konge92 4 years ago
where were you seated?! I was around 8 rows back
yangster982000 4 years ago
i just saw him in rent in madison... i was completely shocked i had no idea he was going to be roger... phenomenol
yangster982000 4 years ago
Awesome video! Heinz is amazing!
theebluemartini 4 years ago
if he was ketchup id cover my food with heinz... lol
LexianaFaith 4 years ago
saw him in daytona beach , fl in RENT front row seats- he was WONDERFUL stole the show!!!
orionsky444 4 years ago
I just saw him in Rent!!!
SpeedyBlueDemon 4 years ago
heinz did better than that other idol the one from germany
devagrup 4 years ago
I'm so proud of him! hehe
lepoen 4 years ago
Good Luck on the RENT Tour...Im sure you will make a great Roger...You definately have the voice for it!
JessesAngel 4 years ago 3
wow good job Heinz. You did SA proud!
theocfan2 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What a bunch of kak. He really is crap. I saw more talent at the barnyard a couple months ago.
cougarfanparkingonly 4 years ago
He has such an amazing voice n he's handsome. This waz an amazing performance from Heinz. He should've won :D :D :D
kayla98 4 years ago 4
what a pretty boy
nhumyxxx 4 years ago 2
he cant reach the most important part.if nt maybe it sounds nice but its just an ok performance.nt great
persie31 4 years ago
Okay, but certainly not great. He's off key most of the time!
niklasbarlyng 4 years ago
Heinz Winker is a south afraican champ, his music ic the bom!!!!!!!!!!!! i luv him sooooooooooooo much!!!!!!!
kuzirocks 4 years ago 3
<33
xpinkdoll 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
who the fuck is this
adernosuc 4 years ago
It wasn't great but I would say it was good. Better than most of the others.
o0ber 4 years ago
he has a good voice and the look good
fcdexx44cj99 4 years ago
Wow! Thanks! Do you happen to have any other Heinz Winckler Videos from his Idol performances?
Thanks for the video.
carminae7 4 years ago
this is what u call a "flat" performance. he sings very well! and looks (if i must say) very hot lol but this was boring. and i love this song! but i would but any cd hes got, just to stare at his picture ;)
villain333 4 years ago
I know he's married, but wow he's handsome.
FridaysChild713 4 years ago
i think he is soo soo i think alexander is more cool and handsome,and alexander singing well
anakunj 4 years ago
moim skromnym zdaniem.. powinien wygrać..:)
kiniakubika 4 years ago
nie przesadzajmy... i tak zajął wysokie miejsce :)
nonetheless219 4 years ago
przecież napisałam, że to moje zdanie..:)
podobno o gustach się nie dyskutuje - nie to ładne, co ładne, ale to, co się komu podoba..;)
prawda..?
kiniakubika 4 years ago
oczywiście ze prawda =]
nie chciałam nikogo urazić, mi tez się bardzo podobało, ale moim zdaniem byli lepsi od niego (stawiałam na Kelly)Heinz jest świetnym wokalistą, ale moim zdaniem brakuje mu charyzmy... gdyby wygrał prawdopodobnie zapomniano by o nim tak szybko jak o Kurcie.
nonetheless219 4 years ago
nie no, OK..:)to był mój subiektywny typ..;)
obiektywnie rzecz biorąc najbardziej liczyłam na Willa i Kelly, w końcu Young był u siebie, a Clarkson z nich wszystkich była najbardziej pop-ularna..
kiniakubika 4 years ago
nie no śliczniutko... :)
I love this performance. I wish there was more his videos here. He's so gorgeous :)
nonetheless219 4 years ago
He's married now...
Titanic02h20 4 years ago
Heinz should have won World Idol cause he is so HOT!!
shelbydivine 4 years ago
this guy's voice is so smooth..
4/11, not bad i think...
thx for uploaded this.
Kusnadi 4 years ago
nice performance! i was betting on either him or kell to win the world idol and not that kurt nilsen whose performance really sucks
pajodaep 4 years ago
please don't ever delete this!
TSichaleun 4 years ago
He's sooo cute and his voice is really nice! Unfortunately he's not really popular in The Netherlands..so can people post more video's from Heinz so I can see and hear more from him...that would be great!
butterbellyNGT 4 years ago
that was so very nice. i've been searching for this performance for a long time now. thanks a lot for posting this. my sister has a big big crush on him. when we watched world idol, my sister was like, "the south african idol is so handsome!" hahah!
sherwin76502 4 years ago
Really nice!
dannimama 4 years ago
pięknie poprostu pięknie
oleczqa18 4 years ago
well done beautiful!
pjazpjaz 4 years ago
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!
cutietrio 4 years ago
Great song, Great voice.
I prefer his version over the original ;)
Thanks for posting this.
Exne 5 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
paste this message onto 3 commentsand press ALTF4 and your crushes name will appear!! not joking!
SERIOUSLY IT FREAKINGW WORKS!!! !!!
cutietrio 5 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
paste this message onto 3 commentsand press ALTF4 and your crushes name will appear!! not joking!
SERIOUSLY IT FREAKINGW WORKS!!! !!!
cutietrio 5 years ago
is he really african? i kno there are white africans but dus he have an accent?
killahkrush 5 years ago
Heinz was born in South Africa, yes he has an accent. He's of German descent.
FridaysChild713 4 years ago
Hey exogenous!! Thanx for this video.I am from South Africa, Heinz has grown so much since World Idol...he does have a good voice.Have a good weekend.
sashnaidu 5 years ago
<dEaNtArNaTe>
sorry, but i dont have the judges comments, just the performance.
exogenous 5 years ago
Imma replay this over and over again.
cyay7 5 years ago
OMG. I LOVE YOU. I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS FOREVER! HEINZ IS GORGEOUS! HIS VOICE COMPLIMENTS THIS SONG PERFECTLY! CAN YOU TELL I'M EXCITED?!
Thanks again.=]
cyay7 5 years ago
He came in 4th out of 11. Not bad...
MasterWarlord3000 5 years ago 2
thank u buddy...this guy's voice is gold
quanguyen 5 years ago
I've had it in my computer for so long,I dont even remember where and when I got it from lol. but ur welcome anyway!
exogenous 5 years ago
Hey there!!! it would be much better if we also have the comments from the judges portion on this video, just a comment...Have a great day!!!
dEaNtArNaTe 5 years ago
I've been looking for this video..Thanks so much...
dEaNtArNaTe 5 years ago