yes and no. the prelude and fugue eventually became the 545, but they are even slightly different here, and it is a different trio movement (not the same as the c-moll trio movement in 545a) - cf. the Weinberger I uploaded, where the P+F are practically the same as in 545.
In fact, though all the PT+F are by Bach it is thought the combination originates with an organist in London who also wrote the link passages.
The trio here is a transcription from a viola da gamba sonata.
and yes, 545b *is* meant to be in B flat, though 545 and 545a are in C (it's a lot harder to pedal in B flat!) despite my cornet-ton recording of 545a which sounds in what's now our concert D (apart from when the organ sags).
isnt this the C major?
organstudent 2 years ago
yes and no. the prelude and fugue eventually became the 545, but they are even slightly different here, and it is a different trio movement (not the same as the c-moll trio movement in 545a) - cf. the Weinberger I uploaded, where the P+F are practically the same as in 545.
In fact, though all the PT+F are by Bach it is thought the combination originates with an organist in London who also wrote the link passages.
The trio here is a transcription from a viola da gamba sonata.
ForestChav 2 years ago
and yes, 545b *is* meant to be in B flat, though 545 and 545a are in C (it's a lot harder to pedal in B flat!) despite my cornet-ton recording of 545a which sounds in what's now our concert D (apart from when the organ sags).
ForestChav 2 years ago
Wonderful.
Nice to hear notes connected.
Also enjoyed the photos.
Thank you, ForestChav.
robertgift 2 years ago