Not very constructive or helpful. I am sorry you do not like this art, but you are free to your opinion. How does it serve you to knock another person's art? It does not give you any benefit or help serve anyone else. Peace be with you.
Once again, since Hatsumi is Soke, he has the right to make changes on how the test is given. Also he is there witnessing the test. He has said many time he will not leave an heir, but that all the jugodans will inherit the system. Why do you believe that he only has the right to give the test? I suggest to travel to Japan and train with Soke and the Shihans to understand. At least then you can make your opinions known in front of him and the shihan, where it would count for something.
Automatically when i saw this, i knew that i'd be saying this. Hatsumi is Soke and just as gmarquay said, the only one allowed to give the sakki test. It's good that your friend passed but I really do wish that your dojo would respect that it's Hatsumi who should give the test.
The Togakure Ryu scroll supposedly says that only the Soke can give the sakki test, or else the one giving it will feel the wrath of the gods. Soke Hatsumi is allowing his students to violate this premise of the Togakure Ryu. Why is himself violating what the old masters have put forth? Just food for thought.
The scrolls are updated and added to by the Soke of the system. If Soke Hatsumi wishes to make changes to the scrolls he has every right to do it. As far as the wrath of the gods, there is no fear, for there is only one and true God, and he is the God of Mercy and Compassion. More food for thought.
The Soke can break with the tradition. It was also a Japanese tradition not to allow foreigners to learn their martial arts, because they thought they would be cursed if they did. But many asian martial arts have opened up to foreigners.
@gmarquay Coz' if he didn't the art would eventually die. The goal is to make the student better than the master, in all martial arts. The way to do that is to teach your students everything, and hope they will be better than you once was..
@gmarquay one scroll against how many other scrolls and teaching in the many schools that are the basis of the bujinkan. And also with however many thousand bujinkan members now, that would be somewhat impractical
@Blazureokami I believe it would be more practical to limit the Soke as the sole giver of the test. However, he would need to get back to having Yodans with real, hard training, under their belt for many years, prior to administering the test. Its truly a joke these days.
Soke stopped giving Godan tests around 2005. He has been training the jugodans to give the test and emit the sakki feeling. At the 2007 DKMS, Soke had said its time for the jugodans to take over.
Being able to emit a sakki feeling and being able to fight can be two separate things sometimes. Certainly there are people who never trained in the martial arts but are street fighters and able to emit a sakki feeling. Then there are those who train in martial arts for years and can project energy but can not fight. Every situation is different, we must adapt and endure. Thanks for you comments! Have a blessed and prosperous day.
I agree but this is no normal martial art therefore we must be beyond normal and I feel that most are not, maybe I ask too much but then again I think I don't Peace Bro
"sakki" is the intent to do harm. The characters that make it are "satsu" also pronounced "korosu" which means "murder" and "ki" which means "feeling". The sakki test should only be given by someone who is experienced. Ed Lomax has said that when he gives a test he is really trying to kill you. With that intent and as long as the intent and the action are simultaneous it is an effective test.
I don't know him from a bar of soap and I've seen a few shihan and shidoshi who leave a little to be desired but you shouldn't underestimate anyone.
A few years ago I trained with a shihan who was visiting from Italy. At the break I was asked how good he was and I said "a bit to be desired". But during the second half of the class I realised he was close to the best I have ever trained with and my comment just reflected the fact that he was training at my level.
I saw a friend this Christmas, who started training in the Booj with me in 1990,he went on to train with a 10th dan (Lincoln Dojo) in 94, and got to 4th dan. He has now left martial Arts altogether because. 1. Hatsumi doesnt do the test, 2.training with this Shihan , left him with an inability to fight, too much talking and Kata! and not enough Training! he laments. So this shihan (well known BTW) ruined a martial career!
Another Friend (still in the Booj) laments the fact that his students including his son will not feel the awe of Hatsumi doing the test, his son is 13 and I would put him up against any of you guys in a sword fight! (and a real fight when he fills out a bit)(for instance when was the last time you rolled with a live blade? (He does this nearly every lesson!) and did sword cutting in class, (hes been Training since 3years old btw)
I don't mean to be rude, but what was the purpose of you talking about your friend's son's abilities? To brag about it? Did someone talk "crap" and your replying to it? Because, for the most part, putting a person (not taking age into consideration) with 10 ninjutsu training would defeat any average person, any novice fighter, and may pose formidable to average/advanced fighter/swords(wo)man. Point is: Bragging (if that's what your doing) about a 10 year trained 13 year old is ridiculous..
I don't mean to be rude, but==When someone starts with that sentence, I know exactly that you mean to be rude, so then so shall I, go away boy the men were talking, and it was nothing to do with you, you were talking crap anyway, your a ridiculous 19 year old Who doesnt know anything . read my ma history before writing junk, ok
how old for example were Spartan children? 7! and the saying of the Cossacks is that the Cossack child are born with a bullet in it's mouth and a sword in its hand,
shouldn't we train our young as soon as we can to defend themselves? in this harsh world even to kill in self defense
your a slav so act like one mate!
and who told you the bujinkan is legal? ask Brin morgan :) the 15th dan jailbird
Spartan children, cossacks.... Are you aware of the century we live in?
I dont know for other countrys but where I live you cant join a school unless you are legal of age, for obvious reasons. these are mortal techniques after all.
some issues you have no f-ing idea try MS for 15 years, brain damage and other things but I still kick ass see my videos in all of them I have MS even the sakki test!
oh and the kid is called Luke Ramsden you can see his farther on my channel
"a bit to be desired" yes there are many in the martial arts, and a lot find me "a bit to be desired" as well because I speak my mind, but I have Trained with the best and the worst in the Booj, and some people you never heard of as well, but I will tell you how they will fair in a fight by training with them for 5 min, be picky with who you train with, it could end up a mistake, Happy new year to you.
I agree, you cant judge a persons personality from a clip but you can tell their training experience, this person looks to me like he has never used a real sword for cutting, he bends his back at the end of the cut for some reason, and he looks too stiff, in the shoulders, he may be a very nice bloke but he needs to train more, with the sword, imho,
I think you can learn from most people if they are dedicated to something,I learnt more about Martial Arts from a psychologist than any Martial Artist Ive ever met!
"a bit to be desired" yes there are many in the martial arts, and a lot find me "a bit to be desired" as well because I speak my mind, but I have Trained with the best and the worst in the Booj, and some people you never heard of as well, but I will tell you how they will fair in a fight by training with them for 5 min, be picky with who you train with, it could end up a mistake, Happy new year to you.
I think... When I can take that test... will get out in the ambulance with a fractured bone? xD I dont see myself doing that right
porquenoagarra2 1 year ago
congradulations!! his expression makes you know he passed :P
rupin 1 year ago
LARPjutsu
bizitch71717 2 years ago
I like how soke isn't even actually watching when the test happens. Classic!
ginshun 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
OMG BULLSHITKAN!!!
Vladrad 2 years ago
Not very constructive or helpful. I am sorry you do not like this art, but you are free to your opinion. How does it serve you to knock another person's art? It does not give you any benefit or help serve anyone else. Peace be with you.
shinobiryukenden 2 years ago 4
@shinobiryukenden And may the force be with YOU!
TheUltimateGC 1 year ago
Once again, since Hatsumi is Soke, he has the right to make changes on how the test is given. Also he is there witnessing the test. He has said many time he will not leave an heir, but that all the jugodans will inherit the system. Why do you believe that he only has the right to give the test? I suggest to travel to Japan and train with Soke and the Shihans to understand. At least then you can make your opinions known in front of him and the shihan, where it would count for something.
shinobiryukenden 2 years ago
Automatically when i saw this, i knew that i'd be saying this. Hatsumi is Soke and just as gmarquay said, the only one allowed to give the sakki test. It's good that your friend passed but I really do wish that your dojo would respect that it's Hatsumi who should give the test.
7Ronin49 2 years ago
The Togakure Ryu scroll supposedly says that only the Soke can give the sakki test, or else the one giving it will feel the wrath of the gods. Soke Hatsumi is allowing his students to violate this premise of the Togakure Ryu. Why is himself violating what the old masters have put forth? Just food for thought.
gmarquay 2 years ago
The scrolls are updated and added to by the Soke of the system. If Soke Hatsumi wishes to make changes to the scrolls he has every right to do it. As far as the wrath of the gods, there is no fear, for there is only one and true God, and he is the God of Mercy and Compassion. More food for thought.
shinobiryukenden 2 years ago 6
Oh, don't get me wrong. I totally agree with you on your last comment. There is only one God, and his Son paid for all of our transgressions.
I just wondered why Mr. Hatsumi had decided to break with the tradition of having only the Soke give the test.
It goes against what I had previously understood.
gmarquay 2 years ago
The Soke can break with the tradition. It was also a Japanese tradition not to allow foreigners to learn their martial arts, because they thought they would be cursed if they did. But many asian martial arts have opened up to foreigners.
shinobiryukenden 2 years ago
@gmarquay Coz' if he didn't the art would eventually die. The goal is to make the student better than the master, in all martial arts. The way to do that is to teach your students everything, and hope they will be better than you once was..
shikomunin 1 year ago
@gmarquay one scroll against how many other scrolls and teaching in the many schools that are the basis of the bujinkan. And also with however many thousand bujinkan members now, that would be somewhat impractical
Blazureokami 5 months ago
@Blazureokami I believe it would be more practical to limit the Soke as the sole giver of the test. However, he would need to get back to having Yodans with real, hard training, under their belt for many years, prior to administering the test. Its truly a joke these days.
impcrusher 3 months ago
I thought only soke did these tests?
trolltrumman 3 years ago
Soke stopped giving Godan tests around 2005. He has been training the jugodans to give the test and emit the sakki feeling. At the 2007 DKMS, Soke had said its time for the jugodans to take over.
shinobiryukenden 3 years ago
quoteHe has been training the jugodans to give the test and emit the sakki feeling. At the 2007 DKMS LOL!
I would want to fight the guy first (jugodan) only if He could beat me would I let him test me! I would take out this jugodan in three seconds
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
Being able to emit a sakki feeling and being able to fight can be two separate things sometimes. Certainly there are people who never trained in the martial arts but are street fighters and able to emit a sakki feeling. Then there are those who train in martial arts for years and can project energy but can not fight. Every situation is different, we must adapt and endure. Thanks for you comments! Have a blessed and prosperous day.
shinobiryukenden 3 years ago
I agree but this is no normal martial art therefore we must be beyond normal and I feel that most are not, maybe I ask too much but then again I think I don't Peace Bro
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
Nice answer; btw, is sakki same as intention or shen in Chinese? Or is it ki? Thanks.
tommyboysailor333 3 years ago
I am not familiar with shen in Chinese. As far as I know Saakki is a killing intent and it is a sort of Ki or chi that is being emitted.
shinobiryukenden 3 years ago
"sakki" is the intent to do harm. The characters that make it are "satsu" also pronounced "korosu" which means "murder" and "ki" which means "feeling". The sakki test should only be given by someone who is experienced. Ed Lomax has said that when he gives a test he is really trying to kill you. With that intent and as long as the intent and the action are simultaneous it is an effective test.
mouxou97 3 years ago
"I would take out this jugodan in three seconds" Thats not really the attitude to have is it? No offense, I'm just sayin.
johnm543 3 years ago
no attitude I'm just sayin. a fact.
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
I don't know him from a bar of soap and I've seen a few shihan and shidoshi who leave a little to be desired but you shouldn't underestimate anyone.
A few years ago I trained with a shihan who was visiting from Italy. At the break I was asked how good he was and I said "a bit to be desired". But during the second half of the class I realised he was close to the best I have ever trained with and my comment just reflected the fact that he was training at my level.
mouxou97 3 years ago
I saw a friend this Christmas, who started training in the Booj with me in 1990,he went on to train with a 10th dan (Lincoln Dojo) in 94, and got to 4th dan. He has now left martial Arts altogether because. 1. Hatsumi doesnt do the test, 2.training with this Shihan , left him with an inability to fight, too much talking and Kata! and not enough Training! he laments. So this shihan (well known BTW) ruined a martial career!
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
Another Friend (still in the Booj) laments the fact that his students including his son will not feel the awe of Hatsumi doing the test, his son is 13 and I would put him up against any of you guys in a sword fight! (and a real fight when he fills out a bit)(for instance when was the last time you rolled with a live blade? (He does this nearly every lesson!) and did sword cutting in class, (hes been Training since 3years old btw)
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
I don't mean to be rude, but what was the purpose of you talking about your friend's son's abilities? To brag about it? Did someone talk "crap" and your replying to it? Because, for the most part, putting a person (not taking age into consideration) with 10 ninjutsu training would defeat any average person, any novice fighter, and may pose formidable to average/advanced fighter/swords(wo)man. Point is: Bragging (if that's what your doing) about a 10 year trained 13 year old is ridiculous..
Reaper8989 2 years ago
I don't mean to be rude, but==When someone starts with that sentence, I know exactly that you mean to be rude, so then so shall I, go away boy the men were talking, and it was nothing to do with you, you were talking crap anyway, your a ridiculous 19 year old Who doesnt know anything . read my ma history before writing junk, ok
gekiryudojo 2 years ago
Since when are children legally allowed to learn mortal techniques?
zlobronex 2 years ago
how old for example were Spartan children? 7! and the saying of the Cossacks is that the Cossack child are born with a bullet in it's mouth and a sword in its hand,
shouldn't we train our young as soon as we can to defend themselves? in this harsh world even to kill in self defense
your a slav so act like one mate!
and who told you the bujinkan is legal? ask Brin morgan :) the 15th dan jailbird
gekiryudojo 2 years ago
Spartan children, cossacks.... Are you aware of the century we live in?
I dont know for other countrys but where I live you cant join a school unless you are legal of age, for obvious reasons. these are mortal techniques after all.
zlobronex 2 years ago
What year are you in
OK you asked for it!
You are trying to lure me into a internet fight.
That is like competing in the special Olympics,
Even if you win you are still a retard,
You Win!
gekiryudojo 2 years ago
I was just asking a question mate, I have no intent to fight with anyone over teh intertubes, my point was that the kid story was fake.
Wimp like me? Geez you have some issues man.
You cant generalize people like that especially when you dont have any point at all.
I feel sorry for you :(
good day sir
zlobronex 2 years ago
some issues you have no f-ing idea try MS for 15 years, brain damage and other things but I still kick ass see my videos in all of them I have MS even the sakki test!
oh and the kid is called Luke Ramsden you can see his farther on my channel
on this video
/watch?v=7kMet9CFC7o good day
gekiryudojo 2 years ago
Guess brain damage explains why you are acting like a 15 year old and not 49 that you are.
Blocked.
zlobronex 2 years ago
what is your excuse then LOL! it's not that bad that cant deal with you chum, oh and good luck with your fan-base
gekiryudojo 2 years ago
What do slavs act like btw? :/
zlobronex 2 years ago
not like a wimp like you, now shut your face hole.
gekiryudojo 2 years ago
"a bit to be desired" yes there are many in the martial arts, and a lot find me "a bit to be desired" as well because I speak my mind, but I have Trained with the best and the worst in the Booj, and some people you never heard of as well, but I will tell you how they will fair in a fight by training with them for 5 min, be picky with who you train with, it could end up a mistake, Happy new year to you.
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
I can usually get the measure of a person in a
few minutes, but I've been wrong about people
before. I guess the point is you can't really
judge someone from a 10 second youtube clip.
As far as training goes I'm getting a lot more
picky...I'll train with anyone but I'm very choosy about who I'll learn from.
mouxou97 3 years ago
I agree, you cant judge a persons personality from a clip but you can tell their training experience, this person looks to me like he has never used a real sword for cutting, he bends his back at the end of the cut for some reason, and he looks too stiff, in the shoulders, he may be a very nice bloke but he needs to train more, with the sword, imho,
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
I think you can learn from most people if they are dedicated to something,I learnt more about Martial Arts from a psychologist than any Martial Artist Ive ever met!
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
"a bit to be desired" yes there are many in the martial arts, and a lot find me "a bit to be desired" as well because I speak my mind, but I have Trained with the best and the worst in the Booj, and some people you never heard of as well, but I will tell you how they will fair in a fight by training with them for 5 min, be picky with who you train with, it could end up a mistake, Happy new year to you.
gekiryudojo 3 years ago
soke did godan test in 2006 for my sensei
Shingitaishinoby 3 years ago