Added: 1 year ago
From: tcherkin
Views: 185,190
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (280)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @sharpnova2 wow, you've got some issues! why did you suddenly attack suesamlou37 for saying some people are without taste, this is a matter of opinion and not something that has any relevance to 'growing up' or being 'stupid/unintelligent' and i dont know where 'genetics' came into it either?! You must be very lonely and unhappy with your life to react like this and i urge you seek help and aim to as it is commonly phrased 'get a life'.

    @suesamlou37 credit to you for reacting only with sarcasm

  • @giantfish2003 thankyou xxx

  • @giantfish2003 "this is a matter of opinion"

    Exactly he insults other people for disliking the song by saying they are without taste when it's clearly a matter of opinion.

  • 697 people doesn't know real music.. 

  • Comment removed

  • orchestra didn't add much. it wasn't harmful to the original but i don't think it was worth the transposition.

  • lovely.... not sure why there are so many dislikes..... obviously alot of people without taste x

  • @suesamlou37 you mean a lot of people with different taste.

    GROW UP.

  • @sharpnova2 thankyou 4 your kind advise, it is duely noted. just 4 the record growing up is on my to do list!!! have a nice day :-)

  • @suesamlou37 i told you to. it doesn't mean it matters. no one cares about you.

    you think that people who don't like the same music as you have objectively bad taste. you're incapable of admitting their taste is just different.

    that means you are unintelligent, genetically. you'll always be stupid.

  • @sharpnova2 WOW u can tell all that from 2 posts, your intelligence astounds me!!!

  • @suesamlou37 it doesn't take high intelligence to realize that. only reading your first comment where you said that people who don't like this one song have bad taste.

    that told me everything i need to know. everyone read it and saw that you were stupid.

  • guess bieber made 697 accounts and disliked this video using them

  • Very Beautiful :))

  • was there any reason to clap as soon as the guy started playing??? NO!!!

    

  • Y U NO LIKE THE MUSIC?????697 BASTARDS SO FAR.....

  • THIS IS REAL COOL MUSIC

    NOT POOP LIKE JUSTIN BIEBER (POOP)

  • Beautiful video !

    J'ai bien apprécié ce magnifique concert !

    Thank you very much !

  • WTF. DONT CLAP IN THE MIDDLE OF PERFORMING...

  • wonderful..!!!!

    

  • He makes a song for a woman he loves and would do anything for. The chorus is peaceful melody as the way he feels with her. Solo one shows his emotions of giddiness, passion, devotion; its almost as if one is dreaming... The peaceful melody remains but Solo two becomes anger, hatred, betrayal! the best thing that has ever came into his life walks away. His life has spiraled down before his eyes. He is hesitant to return to a peaceful melody but knows the show must go on. It must go on....

  • Just one word to describe this song: wonderful!

  • Really nice and good tempo!

  • I think there is a special team of evil people who search good music on youtube and dislike it. There is no other explanation...

  • @ivannasran - I agree. This is beautiful and they are jealous because this sounds better than theirs, and they wish they had thought of the orchestra with his phenomenal playing.

  • they do xD

  • they could of disliked it because it doesnt show the guy do the hard parts it just looks at everything else lol

  • @xXConSeQuenceZZZZZZZ - You want to see him do the "hard" parts, moron, watch this:

    watch?v=Yw2jV18dO4A&feature=re­lmfu

    Don't hate just because he can play perfect piano and you can't. He's also good looking and you're not.

  • @PianoCriticsKiller wow your are biggest cunt ever i said maybe because they don't show the hard parts because the top comments were saying "why are there so many dislikes" i was just taking a guess i didnt dislike the video nor did i say its fake or he sucks or im better i think its pretty childish of you to pick a fight on YouTube for no reason over nothing everything you said i didnt even say

  • I believe the  orchestra enhances the music.....

  • Wow

  • "The People who pressed the dislike button thought that this was the download button" :D

  • soo nice song :) love it

  • How well in piano do you have to play in order to play this song? This version as well?

  • @mariahcarey50 I play it ill give you a hint im younger then ten

  • this song moves me every single time

  • Im a 27 year old hood nigga that has been through hell and hot water and this song brings tears to my eyes and soul how powerful is that I wish I was there when he created this masterpiece I'm slowly learning how to play it so I can go to a fancy establishment where I don't fit with a hoodie and sagging jeans and then play it to show that even some of the hood got class and also a ear for beautiful music

  • @yzzo84

    More power to you!

  • Comment removed

  • this melody is beautiful

  • what does it means fur elise..please plese

    

  • @incapable84 i think it would be "for Elisabeth"

  • @Thepsicho22 Alice? Alyse? Maybe?

  • @incapable84 fur=für=for elise :) though historicans still argue who elise was.

  • @incapable84 ..Fur elise is like the what you would see on a christmas gift or a note.. " For Elise" only in deutsch I believe..

  • 4 WORDS

    I CANT DESCRIBE IT!!!!!!

  • I.Am.In.Love.With.This.Song!

  • I don't understand why this video has so many dislikes. It's a god-damn classic, played beautifully.

  • Браво ! Чудесна оркестрация и изпълнение !

  • i love it!!!

  • very nice i play it on guitar awesomely

  • 719 wild trolls apeared!

  • 718 retards

  • helvete så fint :)

    

  • kienes son los ignorantes q no les gusta esto??

  • its so beautiful it makes you cry

  • i love this than any others!

  • I like the climax to this piece

  • Likes and dislikes are almost equal, lol.

  • the pianist plays with no feeling exept stick up his butt expression on his face

  • ohh it's so beautiful! it makes you float...so beautiful....I love it when the orchestra comes in!

  • esto es increible¡¡ no puedo creer que vea tanta gente ignorate que piensa que esto no es arte o es algo aburrido.

    De esto se deriva cual quier genero musical, esto lo mas alto de las clases sociales de la musica--- =)

  • Das ist einfach cool

  • Why are there so many dislikes??

  • @nickich95 perhaps because its inauthentic and kitschy

  • @nickich95  - deaf...

  • Comment removed

  • @nickich95

    because they are blind people!!

  • @nickich95 - Deaf? Or rappers. lol This is absolutely beautiful...

  • y so many dislikes?

  • 1:31 does anybody else find that audience member extremely disturbing?!

  • 1:51 "LOL WTF am i doing"

  • 703 dont know what is ART!

  • @Marome8 what art is

  • i dont understand why half the poeple hate this cuz i see no hate comments lol

  • The orchestration on this are wonderful. I do wish the quality of the recording was better.

  • Awesome!

  • how could a normal human being dislike this !!!!

  • i can play this song and i am 13 years old

  • I'm guessing this is a video hack bot. Cause this is amazing.

  • @ThePianooDude I believe it was really done by YouTube bot, that's for sure.

  • I guess (128545 - 702) viewers were so stunned by this magnificent masterpiece that they forgot to hit the like button !

  • what a masterpiece..

  • What's wrong with these 702 people ?

  • More dislikes than likes do some people personally know the pianist or something?

  • HOW CAN PEOPLE DISLIKE THIS???????????? SHAME ON YOU

  • @StijnBF2 - They probably don't like the orchestra. But it's pretty nice...

  • @StijnBF2 - They are either jealous, or they're wearing their ipod headphones and can't hear how beautiful this is. lol

  • why are there so many dislikes ? i'm confused

  • @misswonderfullgenius they probably like justin biber and this is not him:)

    they r idiots thats why!!!

  • @kajzergagi

    i'm still confused..cuz the title does not say Bieber......ugh the world gets more stupid by the minute

  • Love it!!

  • Pra quem acha q Fur Elise é só aquele barulhinho da espera de atendimento ao telefone feito no 8bits

  • Beatiful

  • i love the man in 0:43 - 0:47 holding the flute 2nd Man

  • @harveyalemania I like him too! <3

  • I don't understand why there is more dislikes than likes

  • Откакто я научих като ученик в музикалната школа и аз съм си я представял с оркестър, но явно не съм само аз. БРАВО ГЕОРГИ.

  • Wow, amazing, really amazing .... No commentary's

  • It's not that the people who disliked this video don't like Fue Elise or Beethoven..It's just that it's a cliche played too romantically and the pianist is over doing it..It really annoys and agitates me when people say they like Beethoven just because they like this particular bagatelle,if you want to know what Beethoven is really all about listen to his piano concertos and late piano sonatas ect..(however Fur Elise is often the one piece that ignites an interest in classical music for many. :)

  • Why more half people dont like this??? I cant believe that!!! I Know this music is just for piano but wicth this orquest Jesus very very beatyful...

  • this is amazing!

  • this is amazing lol

  • this is amazing T_T

  • how on earth there are more dislikes than like. wtf !

  • I love it!

  • Excellent

  • This song bring happiness to me.... My 10 month old niece passed away and her middle name was Elise.... So it warms me to know she will live forever through music.. Thank you very much.

  • one who hate this is either deaf or justin bieber....

  • If he touches the piano this way, I can't imagine what he can do with a woman... :P

  • oh god i just found the man i will marry!

  • The video's great... Love the pianist! He played the piano so softly it's awesome

  • I think the video's great... Why would anyone hate it? (I'm not being sarcastic, it's true.) Love the pianist, hoho he played it so softly it's awesome

  • I think the video's great... Why would anyone hate it? (I'm not being sarcastic, it's true.)

  • this is great music..tyvm 

  • I don't even bother going into the browse section. I just search for what I want to see. The piece sounded fine. I don't think the pianist is doing the smart thing by contending with an enemy on the comments section. Just set your comments section for reviewing and delete him if he's bothering you too much. Frankly anyone that has to piss on someone else's program that much is a loser. I have my favorites, that doesn't mean I go around trying to find those I don't like.

  • WHAT A WONDERFUL MUSIC PIECE. AMAZING. NO WORDS TO DESCRIBE. I believe music is above all man made rules. If Mr. cherkin adapts fur Elise to is soul version what is wrong with it. To the pompous guy `classicalmusic63', beethoven will not laugh at cherkin but will laugh at you for your insensitive ears which could not catch the wonderful music in his version.

  • Love this melody, love the pianist :D

  • @classicalmusic63 : Before talk about YANNI, please clean your mouth !!! Beside, this is a good creation.-

  • ust like a thief, they come uninvited and do a lot of harm. There are a lot of HATERS who go around on "YouTube" for nothing but to randomly pour their venomous comments on everybody and every video regardless of any thing.

    I wish those would remember their daddy (if they know who he is) told them “If you don’t have any thing nice to say, KEEP YOUR YAP SHUT”, otherwise, stay away dumb asses; your opinion is just as useless as a mule’s balls.

  • oh c'mon people! don't you appreciate this anymore? oh and i've notice there is an increase in dislikes for videos like this. at least for the ones i've viewed.

  • Why no praise? :'(

  • dear classicalmusic63, clearly you dont know classical music fur elise is not just a simple recital piece and could you even compose such a beautiful piece?NO i dont think you can so please dont hate on mr.cherkin and at least he is tryin to contribute to music but you just hate whole day long!!!!

  • @tcherkin When you began playing classical music professionally, I will bet you that you never dreamed of having your performances on YouTube. Why, because you were catering to a more intellectual audience. Fur Elise is a simple recital piece, not classical art. How would you feel about being the opening act for Brittany Spears? How do you think your music would be recieved by her fans? You would be booed off the stage. Why do you expect of different result from YouTube?

  • @classicalmusic63 For some reason you got fooled into thinking you could reach a wider audience through YouTube. There is a reason why nearly all Brittany Spears fans don't go to Carnegie Hall. Because they wouldn't understand and appreciate the high art of classical music. You should stick with the venues that respect classical art. Pandering to the masses with your cheap adaptation of Fur Elise will get you nothing but grief. Just accept your mistake and move on.

  • @classicalmusic63 pardon my french, but i do believe you are acting like a BOS.(witch on a stick, replase "w" with "b")insted of doing pointless fighting and causing nothing but greif to others, get your butt out of the chair and LEAVE YOUTUBE. i happen to love this version. your opinion has been stated. GET OUT!

    (you other people that happen to read this then tell us your opinion)

  • @classicalmusic63 Of course, a guitarist would have 500,000 views. This is not Carnegie Hall, you idiot. This is YouTube. This is the real world, where your elitism is not protected from the masses. If you want to be applauded for every little thing you do, then go back to your protective concert halls.

  • @classicalmusic63 The fact that you have 2 videos of Fur Elise just verifies the fact that you are pandering to the masses like Yanni. In Classical music circles, Fur Elise is considered to be pop art, yet clearly that is what you are promoting the most on your channel. And the fact that you are promoting your precious orchestration of it just exacerbates its pop art status. Are you a serious musician or a pop musician?

  • This may be one of the best versions I have ever heard. Incredible. Thanks for the post. Down with the Haters!

  • wtf wen i saw this video it had no dislikes and only likes and wtf happened now???

  • 630+ People are probably Teenagers who have no taste in music and listen to mostly cRAP.

    I on the other hand am 17 and love this!

  • I don't like fur elise with the orchestra, piano itself is better.

  • I really don't understand the amount of dislikes?

  • all those people that disliked it are just jealous that they cant play the piano as good as him!

  • The 253 that disliked this video are undoubtedly deaf, this is absolutely amazing.

  • @jerem0988 so was Beethoven...

  • You play so beautifully. The only thing more beautiful than piano music to me, is to watch professionals play piano passionately....

  • HAH i cud totally imagine one of those old ladies getin up n starts rockin shop suey xD

  • beautiful!!!!!!! ........

  • I did not dislike it, but I would, because those uncultured plebs ruined the music with early applause. You wait till the piece is over before you applaud... geez

  • this is the music that stands the test of time. even when i was young i loved this song and still to this day.

  • u r great! :D im learning this song now :D keep on doing what u do best :D